I*T?rCo N I A N I N S T I T>^?^ I O N Ou the rover: Aiuistasio Leon, an itinerant craftsmnu. finishes the edge on a framecontaining the holy image ofSan Xavier, a patron saint of the Arizona-Sonora borderlandsregion. Don Anastasio learned this craft, luhich combines reverse-painting on glass luith tinframe-making, from- his father. He usually sells his frames with a variety of holy images at theFiesta de San Xavier in Magdalena, Sonora. Photo by Doctor Felippe deJesus Valenzuela SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION1993 Festival ofAmerican FolklifeJuly 1 -July 5 Co-sponsored by the National Park Service Festival of American Folklife ? 1993 by the Smithsonian InstitutionISSN 1056-6805Editor: Peter SeitelStyle Editor: Arlene ReinigerDesigner:]oan WolbierAssistant Designers: Rebecca Lepkowski, Carmina .'\nguloTypesetter: Harlowe Typograph)'Printer: Schneidereith & SonsTypeface: New BaskervillePaper: LOE DullInsert: Cross Pointe Genesis Milkweed Contents America's Reunion on the Mall, Bill isf Hillary Clinton, Al & Tipper Gore 4The 1993 Festival, Robert McC. Adams 6Cultural Conversation on the Mall, Bruce Babbitt 8Culture on the 1990s Agenda, Richard Kiirin 9The Festival of American Folklife; Doing More with Less, Diana Parker 15 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDSUnited States - Mexico Borderlands/ La Frontera, Olivia Cadaval 1 7Living on the Border: A Wound That Will Not Heal, Norma E. Cantil 26Cultiual Identities on the Mexico- United States ^ordei, Jose Manuel Valenzuela Arce 30The Problem of Identity in a Changing Cultine: Popular Expressions of CultureConflict Along the Lower Rio Grande Border, Americo Paredes 33The Arizona-Sonora Border: Line, Region, Magnet, and Filter, fames S. Griffith 37The Epic Tradition of the Foiuiding of Nuevo Laredo, Manuel Ceballos-Ramirez 42Border, Culture, and Maquiladoras: Testimonies ofWomen Workers, Maria Eugenia de la O 44The Mixteco Presence in Tijuana, FranciscoJavier Moreno B. 47Mixteco Women on the Migration Route, Laura Velasco Ortiz 49The Texas-Mexican (jonjiuito, Manuel Pefia 53La Onda Bajita: Lowriding in the Borderlands, Michael C. Stone 56Mortars and Metates, Alice Fay Lozano as told to Ian Hancock 59The Chinese in Baja California, Maricela Gonzcilez Felix 61AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCESharing Common Groimd: Social Dancing in the U.S.A,Vivien Chen luith Magaly E.Janad & Chan Moly Sam 63Generations of African American Social Dance in Washington, D.C.:Hand Dancing, Hip-Hop, and Go-Go, LeeEllen Friedland 69Hip-Hop Dance, Anthony Hovington 73Iroquois Social Dances: The Life of Dance in the Dance of Life, Linley Logan 74 "Circle Lip Four on the Old Dance Floor": Old-Time Dancing inChilhowie, Virginia, Susan Eike Spalding 77METRO MUSICMusic in Metropolitan Washington, Phyllis M. May-Machunda 80The Music Performance Trust Fimds 82 KIDS' STUFFKids' Stuff: Children's Traditions of Play andPerformance in Metropolitan D.C., Diana Baird NDiaye 84City Play, Amanda Dargan Csf Steven Zeitlin 86 FESTIVAL RESEARCH REPORTThe Jerusalem Festival Project, Amy Horoiuitz 90 Reprinted from the program book for America's Reunion on the Mall,held for the Presidential Inaugural, fanuary 17-18, 1993.America's Reunionon the MallBill Cjf Hillary ClintonAl Csf Tipper Gore From Kamuela, Hawai'i, and Ketchikan,Alaska; from Ponce, Puerto Rico, and Rangeley,Maine; from the rural heartland of Kansas, Mis-souri, and Tennessee; from our major cities ofLos Angeles, New York, and Chicago, they havecome to our Nation's capital. From the glam-orous world of popular entertainment and fromthe neighborhoods of local communities theyhave come to the Nation's front lawn. Craftspeo-ple representing the long-lived arts of America'scultural past have come, along with new immi-grants whose artistic and cultural traditions willmake their place in the history now being writ-ten. Cooks and stoiytellers, musicians, dancers,and artisans have come to this Festival on theMall to tell, to sing, and to weave the stoiy ofAmerica. Their artistiy, skill, and talent, asimmense as it is, is but a sample of the culturaldiversity that exists throughout our land. Thatthis diversity can be imited, together, in the sym-bolic center of our nation, tells us much aboutwho we are and what we dream.The enlightened founders of this counti7conceived of a new nation in which the manycould be united. We have always thrived as anation of nations. This has not been easy toachieve. We have overcome manv travails to forge ideals of tolerance, mutual respect, andhuman dignity. We are still engaged in the pur-suit of these ideals, yet, America stands as a bea-con of hope. Here, cultural difference can be asomxe of strength not weakness, hope notdespair, joy not sorrow.A nation comprised of a diversity of people,communities, and cultiual groups is a flexibleand adaptable one. Ideas, inventions, songs, arts,even foods developed by some can be enjoyed byall. Never before in the histoiy of humankindhave so many different people from so many dif-ferent places joined together in one nation. Andnever before has a nation accomplished so muchpolitically, economically, socially, and culturallyas ours. Ovu^ form of democracy, our freedom ofexpression, our concern for hiunan rights andfor the rights of the minority grow from ourrecognition of a diversity of origins, perspectives,and interests. The diversity of American lives hasenriched our souls, oiu' minds, our institutions,and even oiu" senses.We Americans are proud of wlio we are. Wetake pride in our own regional, ethnic, religious,and family identities, for these give us a sense of .self. But we are all Americans first. Being Ameri-can means bridging differences, not stamping them out. It means learning from each other. Itmeans including everyone as "us," rather thanexcluding some as "them." It means we can singour own song, enjoy the singing of others, singtogether, and even make up new songs. Some ofthe distinctly American forms ofjazz, blues,gospel, and rock-and-roll heard at the Festivalarose from just such a creative combination ofcultural styles. Just as our recognition of theuniqueness of each and every individual does notdetract from our sense of a common humanity,so, too, the recognition of our diversity need notstand in opposition to national unit}- and identi-ty. Indeed, just as the creativity, genius, and gen-erosity of individuals enlarge our sense ofhumanity, so, too, can an appreciation of ourdiversity increase our sense of national accom-plishment. It is fitting that we rededicate ourselves tojoining together at this time and in this place.The Mall is the place where Americans talk toeach other. It is where we celebrate and enshrineour national understandings. It is the placewhere soine 30 years ago the Reverend MartinLiuher King, Jr., informed the nation of hisdream? of a nation in which children of differ-ent backgrounds, races, and creeds could walkhand in hand. Wlrere the differences that dividecould one day be used to unite. It is thus fittingthat in the same place on this Day, and on Mar-tin Luther King Day, for the inaugural and forthe first public event celebrating a new adminis-tration, the American people gather here, toreunite with each other, to reunite with anAinerican ideal, and to reunite with a nationaldream that all of us can help realize. The 1993 FestivalRobert McC. AdamsSecretary, Smithsonian Institution This is, in a sense, the second Festival on theMall this year, the first having taken place somesix months ago for the Presidential hiaugural.The America's Reunion on the Mall broughttogether performing musicians, artists, craftspeo-ple, and cooks from all across the country in acelebration of our nation's strength in diversity.The inaugmal festival was wonderfully successful. "We were happy to play a role in celebrating ourdemocracy, and all the more so because thatevent reinforced what the Smith.sonian's Festivalhas been doing and saying about American cul-ture for the past 26 years.Through the Festival of American Folklifewe have learned that to represent truly the cul-ture of our nation, one must represent the diver-sity of its people, its commimities, its regions,and its genres of cultural expression. We havelearned that such representations? whether inthe form of cultiual performances, skill demcjn-strations, expository talks, or museum exhibits?must result from intimate collaboration withthose being represented; they too have roles toplay as researchers, curators, presenters, andartists. We have also learned that cultiual repre-sentation is a vehicle for affirmation of self-worth, especially when it is done in a highly visi-ble, centrally symbolic place like the NationalMall. And we have learned that people ? thoserepresented at the Festival as well as visitors to it ? can understand, appreciate, and learn fromeach other when culture is presented in an open. respectful setting. Indeed, the Festival hasproved to be a forum where the confluences anddivergences of culture can be engaged in apeaceful and sometimes even enlightening way.At the Festival, the interaction of visitors, partici-pants, and Smithsonian staff has often resultedin new cultiual awareness and in syntheses ofnew ideas and cultural forms.This summer, the Festival includes programson U.S. - Mexico borderlands, American socialdance, music in the Washington Metropolitanarea, and urban children's culture. All point tohow people creatively use the resources of com-munity culture to shape life experiences in waysthat celebrate and affirm social values.The Festival's featured program, U.S. - Mexi-co Borderlands, is the latest in a series developedfor the Columbus Quincentenan' which hassought to expand public knowledge about thecultural histoi"y of our heiuisphere and to fortifythe Smithsonian's engagement of colleagues andcommunities in Latin America and theCaribbean. These programs, including Creoliza-tion in the Caribbean, Land and Power in NativeAmerican Cultures, New Mexico, Maroons in theAmericas, and American Indian Soundscapes,have directly reached some 5 million Festival visi-tors. Brought to fruition with the cooperation ofscores of academic, cultural, and educationalinstitutions in 18 nations, these programs haveengaged the efforts of some 250 different schol-ars and over 1,000 exemplaiy culture bearers from across the Americas. These Festival pro-grams have generated rich documentaryarchives, copies of which reside both at theSmithsonian and at collaborating institutions.Additionally, these programs have generated twodocumentaiy films, several books, and even thepassage of cultural legislation.Our consideration of cultiual borderlandscomes at an important time, socially and intellec-tually. The migrations and movements of peoplechallenge prior notions of boimded, localizednational cultures. Borderlands are generallyregarded as the edges of a nation, marginal andperipheral to its cultural life. Yet what happenswhen the border region of two nations achievesits own sense of identity, its own idea of cidturalcentrality? The borderlands are characterized bycultural dynamism, liminality, and contention.And the U.S.- Mexico cultural border is quitepermeable, with flows of people, goods, andideas that extend not only geographically deepinto each country, but also deep into their sociallives. No doubt, in a continent whose patterns ofexchange may be refashioned by the NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement or like arrange-ments, we will continue to witness the culturalevolution of this important region. And so toowill our thinking aboiU the relationship betweenculture and nation deepen. The examination ofthe borderlands makes it possible for us to seeculture not as a static accumulation of things, but as flows of meanings, styles, and values con-tinually reshaped and revalidated by use.Finding such phenomena as cultural border-lands represented at the Festival signals the factthat over the past decade, museums and theirprograms have increasingly become forums foraddressing the cultural realities of contemporaiylife. These cultural realities are complex, andoften intimately tied to important social andpolitical issues. The involvement of the Smith-sonian and other such institutions with issues ofcontemporaiT cultural concern is part of ourpublic trust. We have the responsibility to con-tribute our knowledge and perspective to publicdialogue and debate ? imderstanding of coursethat oiu" voice is only one, and not necessarilythe definitive one, in that discussion.The Festival has historically been a leader inthis area. This was especially true during the pastyear as its staff engaged colleagues from Hebrewand Bir Zeit Universities in researching the grass-roots cultural traditions ofJerusalem. No placeon earth is perhaps as culturally rich, nor as con-tentious, as Jerusalem. Yet working with localresearchers and scholars, community artists andleaders, and members ofJerusalem's diversecommunities, excellent work was accomplished.We hope that this lesearch, the understandingsand substantive practices that animate the cultur-al life of that great city, will emerge as a Festivalprogram in the near future. Cultural Conversationon the MallBruce BabbittSecretary, Department of the Interior Tlic National Mall is our countiy's symboliccenter, where we celebrate our national civicrites? the inauguration of a president, ourindependence day, oiu" bicentennial. The Mall isour national showcase where we enshrine, in ournational museums, our understandings of histo-ry, culture, science, and the arts. And it is ournational town square where generations ofAmericans have gathered to speak to each other,to represent themselves and their concerns totheir fellow citizens.Since 1967, the Festival of American Folklifehas presented the grassroots culture of ournation, bringing together musicians, craftspeo-ple, cooks, stoiytellers, workers, and other cultur-al exemplars from eveiy region of our country.People from various states, ethnic and NativeAmerican groups, occupations, and cultureshave brought their wisdom, knowledge, art, andskill to the Mall and have shared it with their fel-low citizens.For some 20 years, the Department of Interi-or through the National Park Sendee and withthe cooperation of its other Bureaus, has been aproud partner in the Festival. The Smithsonianand the Park Sendee share a commitment to thepreservadon of our national heritage? culturaland natural. Over the years, the Festival's workhas been guided by research done by folklorists,anthropologists, and historians from both agen-cies in communities across the countiy. The Fes-tival has been a forum for discussions about cul-ture conservation, environmental presenation,and local economic development. The Festivalhas provided a training ground for developingskills and techniques for the presentation ofgrassroots culture. Most of all, the Festival hasfunctioned as a combined outdoor museum andinterpretive park, where people from around thecountiy can speak directly to their fellow citizensabout their history, their culture, and their lives. This type of cultural conversation, in whichcultural traditions can be respectfully presented,discussed, and even exchanged, is vital to ourcontinued health as a whole nation. As PresidentClinton has affirmed, our cultural diversity is asource of national strength. Oiu- educationalprograms and public institutions need to encoin-age the study and broadest dissemination ofknowledge about our history, and about thevalue and flow of ideas between people of variedbackgrounds. Sometimes our cultural conversa-tions will be celebratoiy, and sometimes sober-ing. But to appreciate their importance, oneneed only look around the globe to places wherethe cultural conversadon has stopped, and wheredifference has led to intolerance, to the abuse ofhuman rights, and even to endemic violence.We continually engage the American publicin eveiy state and territoiy in cultural conversa-tions. The Yaqui, represented this year at the Fes-tival, have regidarly participated in the Fiesta atTumacacori National Monument in Arizona;musicians, craftspeople, and working cowboyslike those here at the Festival from Texas havedisplayed their culture at Chamizal NationalMemorial Park in El Paso; and local Washingtonarea musicians like those at the Fesdval have reg-idarly performed in National Park venues atGlen Echo and Wolf Trap. The cultmal dialoguegoes on at historical sites such as America'sIndustrial Heritage Park in Johnstown, Pennsyl-vania, at interpretive exhibits in urban parks likeLowell National Historical Park, at natural siteslike Hawaii's Volcanoes National Park, at culturalcenters being developed in Maine and West Vir-ginia, and in programs such as Keepers of theTreasures. Our work, and oiu" partnerships withthe Smithsonian and with many others at thenational, state, and local level, help Americansunderstand their national heritage, and we fer-vently hope, each other. Culture onthe 1990s AgendaRichard Kurin Who would have thought that cultiue, as asign of group identit)', would play a prominentand sometimes deadly role in world politics?Who would have thought that culture, as com-modified knowledge, art, and image, would bethe world's largest industry? In one form oranother, culture has become central to politicsand economics. Culture is on the agenda for the1990s. Wliat role is to be played by institutionsconcerned with understanding culture and edu-cating large and broad publics?The Politics of CultureTalk to a politician about cultural issues afew years ago, and before the eyes glazed over,you'd likely get a reaction that placed culture inthe realm of the frivolous, the romantic, or theobvious. No more. From ethnic cleansing inYugoslavia, to family values in the United States,and a distinct society vote in Canada, culture ison the battlefield, in the news, and on the ballot.Culture has come to be seen as values, worldviews, and identities that may move world events,shatter states and forge new ones. This is not the "culture" of high society, the elite arts or com-mercial media. It is rather the culture of ordi-nary people as expressed in daily life, in thestreets, the workplace, and the school yard.As a political issue culture has emerged inpublic consciousness under the rubric of "multi-culturalism," a term which has been used todescribe 1) a demographic situation? a culturallydiverse population; 2) a policy? equity inresource accessibility for different cultures and Richard Kurin is Director of the Smithsonian Institution Cen-terfor Folklife Programs & Cultural Studies and a Professor-ial Lecturer at TheJohns Hopkins University Nitze School ofAdvanced International Studies. He is a cultural anthropolo-gist with a Ph.D. from the University of Chicago who hasdone most of his research work in India and Pakistan. Hefirst worked on the Festival ofAmerican Folklife in 1976. their bearers; 3) an ethic? the comparable valueof every culture; and 4) a process? the ways inwhich cultures interact within pluralistic societiesand complex individual lives.Debates over multiculturalism in all of thesesenses have defined a number of issues. Thepolitical question of the decade will be whether amulticultural state is possible, and if so, how? Forpublic institiuions the question is how to makemulticultiualism part of institutional practice.And for students of society and civilization, thequestion is to what extent multicultiualismencourages or precludes larger sociocultiual syn-theses and unities. Each of these sets of issues?the political, the educational, and the evolution-aiy have their own histoi7, and their own prob-lems and tensions.Culture and the Modern State. Modern Europearticulated the idea of nation in the mid-1 9thcentui7 by binding it to ideas of race, language,and land. Definitions of singular national cultin-al identities were attempted through scholarshipin folklore, physical and cultural anthropology,philolog)'. and other disciplines. Debates overthe characteristics of these unicultural or mono-cultural national identities, from their costiuiiesto their customs to the question of who is to beincluded in them, have never ceased.Many Third World countries, emerging fromcolonial rule after World War II, knew they hadto construct culturally diverse states? nationswith different languages, different religions, andmany ethnic and regional backgrounds. India,Indonesia, Kenya, and others had to face theissue of forging political imity from cultiualdiversity. As we know, the maintenance of a cen-tral government with a core civic culture hasbeen difficult in these societies. Ethnic, religious,tribal, linguistic, and regional differences contin-ue to challenge national civic cultures.The industrialized nations, because of theirhistories, traditions of governance, and levels of literacy and education, were thought to beimmune to pressiues arising from cultural differ-ence. Their stability was thought to result fromtheir having made the transition from traditionaland cultiue-bound societies to modern ones.Indeed, many political scientists have seen theculture of the folk as a sunival, a kind of primor-dial identity subsumed by the modern state andthe rise of the individual. When cultural identit)'figures in politics, it is often seen as an irrational,unpredictable force.Yet this idea of progress is challenged by thefact that some of the societies most successful inmaking this modernizing and industrializingtransition have experienced a strong surge ofpolitical conflicts apparently based upon reli-gious, ethnic, and regional cultmal identity. Arecent study sponsored by the American Acade-my of Sciences (Fundamentalisms and Society:Reclaiming the Sciences, the Family and Education)found that religious fundamentalism has tended,worldwide, to emerge as a cultin al reaction tomodernism, not as a survival of long held andcherished folkways. But even the most modern ofnations have not been spared from such conflict.Movements of immigrant and colonized popula-tions, the resistance of previously subjugatedpeoples, and persistence of internal cultural andregional differences have challenged receivedideas of nationhood. Efforts to redefine the stateas multicultiual have in some cases resulted indissension, conflict, bigoti7, and violence. Manynations seem to be under a cultmal siege, threat-ened by the unreconstructed cultmal diversity oftheir people. And thus, more and more the ques-tion is being asked ? is a multicultural state pos-sible?According to the former ministers of cultureof the republics in the former Soviet Union, theanswer is no. On the eve of the dissolution of theSoviet Union, those ministers warned about thepitfalls of cultural diversity lest it weaken the U.S.in the same way it had undermined the Sovietstate.It was at about the same time that debate onmulticulturalism heated up in American publiclife. The so-called "culture wars" erupted in themedia, in national institiuions, and eventually inpresidential politics. To consenative detractors,multiculturalism is a highly problematic ideolo-gy, ethically relativistic and ahistorical. In thiscritical \aew. Western, European, andjudeo-Christian culture have crystallized in the Ameri-can historical experience to form a national cul-ture characterized by civic pride, political stabili- ty, economic success, and high moral ideals.They argue that "politically correct" history,bilingualism, ethnic particularism, fimding ofthe national arts endowment, Hollywood portray-als of the family, and other activities were imder-mining the cultural unity and foundations of thenation. Some suggested that the way to deal withAmerican cultural diversity would be to elimi-nate it, generally through the type of culturalassimilation associated with mainstream econom-ic success. Others suggested that elimination ofcultmal diversity would involve a more coercivestrategy of excluding people and ideas.Cultural wars became an election issue. Onthe eve of the presidential election the celebrat-ing crowd in Washington was told, "no more cul-tural wars. No more religious wars. No more cul-tiual cleansing." And in accepting the results.Bill Clinton interpreted his victory as amongother things, a call "to bring oiu' people togetheras never before so that our diversity can be asource of strength." The Presidential Inauguralwas termed "America's Reunion" to explicitly cel-ebrate the relationship between imity and diver-sity. And so the question, at least in the UnitedStates, would appear to turn away from whetheror not the multicultural state is possible to thequestion of how to make it so.Cultural Representation. Debates over multi-culturalism often grow quickly around the publicevents and institutions through which a societ)'"sculture is represented. Contending interpreta-tions of histoiy, luiderstandings of the present,and visions of the futiue have been subjects fordebate in these arenas. The bicentennial of Aus-tralian settlement in 1988 was a harbinger of the1992 American (and Iberian) Columbus Quin-centenary, as issues of the "discoverers" and "thediscovered," the glory and the gore, the celebra-tion and the commemoradon emerged inexhibits, programs, speeches, television pro-grams, demonstrations, and coiuiter-demonstra-tions. Japan's ceremonials smrounding theinstallation of the Emperor and the commemo-ration of Pearl Harbor are also recent contextsfor stud)'ing what Geoff White calls "the politicsof remembering. " The ways in which different cultural groupsare remembered and presented is also beingfought oiU in museimi exhibits, textbooks, televi-sion programs, and magazine advertisements.Simply piu, many cultural groups are upset withtheir lack of representation, or the skewed orprejudicial way in which they are represented,and they are using techniques of political persua- 10 Forums for multiculturalencounters will continueto be invented as a wayof grappling with socialrealities. Here at the 1992Festival of American Folk-life, New Mexican partici-pants from variousPueblo and Plains Indian,Hispanic, Anglo, AfricanAmerican, and otherbackgrounds develop amulticultural way ofexpressing a new-foundcommunity spirit.Photo by Jeff Tinsley,Smithsonian Institution sion to do something about it. Public institutionsare under increased scrutiny to be inclusive andpositively value cultural diversity in hiring, pro-gramming, and audience outreach.While generally accepting the ethic of multi-culturalism many scholars in cultural studieshave criticized the way its arguments are framed.According to some critics, proponents of multi-culturalism endorse simplistic and essentialisdcnotions of cultural groups. Too often, advocatesof culturally articulated groups argue as thoughthey believe themselves to be naturally constitut-ed? as discrete, unchanging species. Hence,they unwittinglv accept and replicate scientifical-ly unsupportable ideas of race and racial classifi-cation. As a social consciousness, this atomisticsort of multiculturalism avoids attention to socialsystems (such as capitalism and colonialism) andsocial identities (such as those based upon class,gender, region, occupation, and religion) whichcrosscut ethnic groups. It also ignores how indi-viduals and communities have juggled, juxta-posed, synthesized, and compartmentalized vari-ous identities in daily contexts and over thecourse of histoiy.New Syntheses and Alternatives. In spite ofinternal difficulties, divisions, and debates, glob-al institutions like the U.N. have moved in anunprecedented way to define new global consen-sus on standards for ethical conduct, himianrights, and environmental policy. These are notmerely agreements among nation-states, but to an unprecedented degree seem to represent theopinion of people across the planet. A moreimited Europe, whatever the fate of the Maas-tricht Treaty, has emerged, and has subsumedaspects of sovereignty and national identity infavor of shared economic interest. New freetrade zones proposed in North America and inother parts of the world are based not on similar-ities in cultural identities, but on participation inregional and global markets. Indeed, there is, asEmile Durkheim predicted almost a century ago,the emergence of a global culture tied to theindustrial and post-industrial world. Made possi-ble by telecommunication technologies, this newculture defines distinct codes, networks, andcommunities of individuals and institutions,many, as Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett hasargued, with a shared folklore.But these new, emergent forms of globalpolitical and economic culture are not so univer-sal or so entrenched as to preclude opposition.Often characterized as nativistic though not nec-essarily home grown, some of multiculturalism'sopponents proclaim their own form of universal-ism. In the United States and in parts of Einopesome analysts see new forms of Islamic transna-tionalism as alternative global visions and athreat to the new world order. Domestically,some Christian fimdamentalist groups are seenin the same way, and indeed, they explicitly chal-lenge the very notion of a new world order basedupon secular economics. How much multicultur- 11 alism Clin the new global framework stand whenfaced with ahernative, inimical systems? Does theacceptance of a mvUticnIturalist ethic meanbringing systems opposed to its ideology into thetent?The Economics of CultureAs culture has become a political problem, ithas also been turned into an economic treasure.Cultural knowledge, artifacts, songs, stories,images, and representations are rapidly andincreasingly being transformed into commodi-ties. Culture, as such, is at the forefront of theglobal economy. Who is consuming whose cul-ture for whose economic benefit and at whatcost?Culture as Tourist Industry. Counting toiuism,or at least a good part of it, together with the artsand entertainment, culture is the largest industn-in the world. Trillions of dollars a year are spentrepresenting and selling culture.Perhaps the largest cultiual enterprise in theUnited States is the Disney Corporation. Millionsof Americans learn about world cultiues at Dis-neyland and Disneyworld where they see thepirate-like people of the Caribbean drinking,and pygmies of Africa rising out of a river to aimtheir spears at your body? with knives and forkspresumably to follow. Only slightly less dismay-ing is Disney's "Its a Small World After All," atableaux of cute, little, formulaically but differen-tially costimied doll-figures meant to representall the world's people singing the same song ?each in its own language. Ersatz and fakeloreabound. One French intellectual, intei^viewedabout Euro-Disney, aptly summarized, "theyclaim to present our folklore and culture, biuthey have taken it and returned it to us in anunrecognizable form." Similarly, cultural themeparks, costing millions of dollars, are proliferat-ing? in Japan, hidonesia, China, WesternAfrica, the Caribbean, the U.S., and Europe.Can touristic cultural theme parks be orga-nized so that their representations do justice tothose represented; so that the material benefitsof tourism are not just exported or used to buildmore luxury high rise hotels but actually reachthe people represented; so that such activities donot destroy local environments and communityculture? Strategies to meet these goals have beendeveloping under the rubrics of eco-toiuism andcultural toiuism. Increased efforts to achieve andbalance three broadly desirable goals? culturalconsei"vation, economic development, and envi-ronmental preservation ? will define key cultur- al policy concerns aroiuid the world over thenext decade.Indigenous Creations. Another aspect of thecultural economy is the international trade inthe creations of folk and traditional communitiesthe world over. Popular musicians make millionsof dollars mining the music of South Africans,Cajuns, Latin Americans, and others. A contem-porary cosmetic company bases its multi-milliondollar business on folk potions and ethnoaesthet-ics. Pharmaceiuical companies work withshamans and healers to develop new drugs andtreatments. Scholars, writers, and artists make ahealthy living by writing about or appropriatingthe wisdom and knowledge of "their" people.Increasingly, folk cultiual knowledge, wisdom,and art are going to be repackaged, made andmarketed for profit, and distributed far beyondtheir traditional audiences. The issues invohingthe kinds and uses of property? intangible andtangible, individual and community, ownershipand usufruct? continue to emerge as the indus-trial and post-industrial economy appropriatesthe creativity of traditional cultiues. If the tech-nology, knowledge, and networks are made avail-able, some of this may occur under the controlof the communities that produce this culture.Cultural Markets. Mass production and massmarketing are designed for products that are thesame for all consumers. Making everyone mod-ern through advertising, propaganda, and otherdiscursive forms has been a long term goal ofindustrial economics? whether capitalist orsocialist. But mass producers are increasinglyaware of cultural diversity in the marketplace.More salsa than ketchup is now eaten in U.S.households; Hindi film rentals in New York are abig business; a /;?/?/ grocery and butchery arenecessaiy institutions in several Detroit-area com-mimities. In their search for new markets, pro-ducers have realized they have to be responsiveto local needs. And they may have to competewith local producers whose niche in the localmarket is cai^ved out by attention to culturalneeds and aesthetics. The market has at oncebecome more homogeneous? penetrated byinternationally produced goods available every-where, and at the same time increasingly cus-tomized for local consumption. Apple and IBMcan sell their computers everywhere, but need avariety of script and language packages. Market-ing research, needs assessment, and ethnograph-ic fieldwork are likely to become increasinglyentwined, as the interpenetration of local andglobal goods brings cultiually diverse popula- 12 tions together in complex patterns of cultural-economic exchange. Global businesses will haveto become more aware of the culture of theirproducts, their markets, and their audiences;local producers will become increasingly sophis-ticated about creating new products and pene-trating new markets.The Challenge for Cultural InstitutionsWhat role can public cultural institutionsconcerned with the study, documentation, andconservation of culture play in this political andeconomic context?We face several problems. One concerns oiu^own standing and expertise as professionals.Eveiyone knows something about culture, espe-cially one's own. This makes public understand-ing of cultural expertise problematic. In Ameri-can public discourse it is difficult to separate outfolk sociology, folk folklore, and folk anthropolo-gy from their disciplinaiy varieties. Key terms?such as "'society," culture," "tradition," and "com-munity"? are used by much of the population,journalists, politicians, and experts with consid-erable slippage of meaning.Wliile scholarly and scientific studies havemuch to contribute, they have generally failed topenetrate public luiderstandings. Popularly, soci-ology is often reduced to psychology, histoi^y tobiography, culture to human nature. The socialsciences, the humanities, and the arts are largelymarginalized and trivialized in our educationalsystems, which contintie to be informed by aresilient anti-intellectualism. Disciplinaiy imder-standings, which once held hope of escaping eth-nocentrism, have been shown to be heavily influ-enced by it. The idea of race in the UnitedStates, for example, which should have beendrastically reformulated in light of social andnatural science findings, nonetheless persistsamong the public and its leaders in its 19th cen-tury form.This is not just a commimication problem.The human studies disciplines have in a reflexivemoment undercut some of their own legitimacy.They have generally remained aloof from nation-al and international debates on fimdamental cul-tural issues. They have failed to work closely withthe commimities they study on matters of press-ing political and economic concern.Scholars and museum curators face a fimda-mental challenge. We claim a special empathyfor, imderstanding of, and ethical relationshipwith the people we study and represent. But if weare so intimately and meaningfully involved. those petiple should be flocking to us for knowl-edge and insight. They, the studied and repre-sented, should be coming to our museinns,attending our professional meetings, enrollingtheir children in our courses, reading our books,and becoming professionals in oiu^ fields. In theU.S. this is not happening. The participation ofAfrican Americans, American Indians, Hispanics,and Asian Americans in the cultiual studies andmuseimi fields is stunningly low.Emerging Cultural Policy NeedsWhat are we going to need for a world inwhich increasing weight is put on culture?I think the future of the cultural field is tobe foimd in a clearer focus on situated scholar-ship. Research and analysis need to be situatedin contexts? historical and contemporaiy, localand global ? and presented to affected politiesand institutions. We need research work onissues that crosscut disciplines, populations, andgenres as we have traditionally defined them.And we need the active involvement and engage-ment of commimity and lay scholars in this effort ? people who can bring to the field new under-standings, assumptions, approaches, and associa-tions.We need research on the midticultiual state,on comparative cultural politics, on cultural eco-nomics, on multicultural lives, on transnationalcultural flows, on cultural processes associatedwith immigration, acculturation, urbanization,and the relationship between culture, environ-mental preservation, and development. We needstronger scholarship if it is to stand the scrutinyof the audiences who can actually think aboutand use our work. This means students and pro-fessionals trained in several fields and method-ologies. And it also means the penetration of cul-tural work into other disciplines? lawyers whowork on intellectual and cultural property rightsLssues need ethnomusicological research toimderstand the creation and ownership of songs;pharmacologists who will work with rainforesthealers and shamans need folklore research toimderstand ethnobotanical knowledge, and soon. We have to combine research more closelywith education and public service. We havemajor work to do in developing teaching materi-als and upgrading teacher training to reflect thecomplexity' of cultural issues students will face.We have to use the full range of new media andcommunicative forms to transmit our ideas sothat younger and broader publics can entertain 13 Maroon leaders from Jamaica, Suriname, French Guiana, Colombia, and Texas met each other for the first time at the 1992Festival. Joined here by Rev. Jesse Jackson, the opportunity provided an occasion to discuss the cultural history and conti-nuity of these communities, and their common concerns. Photo by Jeff Tinsley, Smithsonian Institution them. If kids can sit for hours in front of a videogame tiying to get Mario to save the princessfrom the dragon, we have to figure out ways toengage them with the same intensity in questsfor cultiual linowledge, understanding, andappreciation.We need to be more creative aboiU how adiversity of understandings are shared, discussed,and debated. Grassroots communities through-out the world cannot afford to communicatethrougli Ph.D. dissertations, the meetings of pro-fessional organizations, or documentaiy films?the time lag is too long and the audiences toosmall and insignificant. Increasingly public cul-tural institiuions themselves will have to becomeforums for cultural conversations. Museums,libraries, and universities? in their currentform, as well as in electronically networked, "vir-tual" forms? will have to serve town, national,and global conversations, if they are to continueto merit public support. The conversations them- selves will need to become less of an authorita-tive monologue, as central institiuions enabledialogue and the increase of knowledge by thoseformerly seen as peripheral.The federal investment in this process hasnot been made. The resources put toward multi-culturalism are minute. Public institiuions havefailed to connect enshrined ideas of culture?what it is and whose it is? to an increasinglymulticultiual America. Funds and commitmentsfor training people and supporting professionalsin the cultiual studies areas are lacking. And yet,in a changing world, where culture looms largerand larger in political and economic life, theneed for this investment is greater. DevelopingAmerica's cultiual economy in a just way anddeveloping public understanding of the nation'scultural life seem not only worthwhile goals, buturgent ones that require swift and decisiveaction. 14 The Festival ofAmerican Folklife:Doing More with LessDiana Parker This year's Festival of American Folklife isthe 27th since the Smithsonian's annual livingcultural exhibition began in 1967. We havelearned much in these years about how to pre-sent traditional cultures respectfully and under-standably to a broad audience. We have learnedabout the products besides the Festival that cancome from the research done to produce theevent. .And we have learned about the ways thelabor and the money the event requires can beused to maximimi effect.Walking through the Festival, you see theculmination of more than a year of hard work.Before a Festival can happen, themes and cura-tors must be selected, research plans formulatedand researchers identified, funds raised, fieldresearch documentation reviewed, participantsselected and in\'ited, visas, transportation, hous-ing, and meals procured, sites and programsdesigned and produced, signs and programbook articles written, supplies located, and more.Upwards of 100 people have worked closelytogether to create the program on the Mall, andover 100 vohmteers a day will add their laborduring the Festival's span.The annual Festival requires a tremendousconcentration and commitment of intellectual,emotional, spiritual, and physical energ)-. It alsotakes a lot of money. Considering salaries, fees,transportation, and everything it takes to pro-duce the event. Festivals typically cost betweenone and two million dollars, depending on thesize, length, and complexity of the program.In the recent past, the Festival, like the restof the Smithsonian, has had to learn to make dowith less. Traditionally, about 25% of the cost ofthe Festival has come from Federal funds, 25% Diana Parker is the Director of the Festival ofAmerican Folk-life. She has worked on the Festival in a variety of capacitiessince 1975. from Smithsonian trust funds, 20%) from corpo-rate and foundation sources, and 30% fromother governments. The sale of traditional crafts,foods, publications, and beverages at the Festival.which do much to bring the intimate aestheticsand taste of folk culture to a broad audience,also help in a limited way to offset the cost ofproduction. But the current economic climatehas limited the a\ailability of Federal and Smith-sonian fimds, and also made it more difficult toraise fimds from the outside.More than 1.2 million people visited the1992 Festival. That makes the cost of the Fesdvalabout $1.50 per visitor? less than the cost of aconcert or a movie ticket and much less than thecost of maintaining an artifact-based museum.But the economy of the Festival is even greaterwhen you consider the ways it reaches beyondthe Mall.Perhaps the most direct way that the Festivalstretches beyond its temporal and physicalboundaries is through the media. It is estimatedthat some 40 million people learn about theevent and the people and themes it presentsfrom sources as varied as 'The Today Show," fea-ture stories in national and local newspapers,and "Nadonal Public Radio" inteniews with Fes-tival participants. Public television has producedseveral documentaries about our programs andFestival participants, and aired others made byindependent producers. Perhaps the best knownis The Stone Carvers, produced by Marjorie Huntand Paul Wagner which won the 1985 AcademyAward for best docvmientary.Remounting sections of the Festival of Amer-ican Folklife "back home" has proved an effec-tive way of multiphing the value of the moneyspent for research and planning by sharing theresources of the Smithsonian with non-Washing-ton audiences. The Fesdval's second life reusesits research, design, and its museimi-qualitysigns, banners, and publications; it trains people 15 in various parts of the counti'y in the art of pre-senting traditional culture to a broad publicaudience; and it increases the much desei"vedhonor tradition bearers receive in their ownhome regions.Recent Festival of American Folklife pro-grams remoimted back home include Michigan(1987), Massachusetts (1988), Hawai'i (1989),and the U.S. Virgin Islands (1990). Althoughthere was no state or territoiy program at the1991 Festival, a portion of the Family Farm pro-gram of that year was remounted in the Festivalof Michigan Folklife in the fall of 1991. The leg-islature of the state of New Mexico has recentlyappropriated fimds to remount the successful1992 program back home in Las Cruces. Some ofthese Festival restagings, as in Michigan, haveprovided the impetus for year-roimd culturalresearch, educational, and public programs.Other restagings, like the one in the U.S. VirginIslands, have led to legislation and the establish-ment of local cultural institiuions. Generally, theSmithsonian provides in-kind staff support tothese efforts, which are funded largely by statesand private sources.States and territories participating in the Fes-tival receive complete archival copies of theresearch done in preparation for the Festival.The Festival has generated significant dociunen-taiy collections, which are now housed in manystate archives and universities. This culturalinformation provides material for books, policystudies, and public programs.Festival research materials have also beenused to prepare educational packets for use inpublic schools. Smithsonian and U.S. VirginIslands scholars compiled audio, video, and wiit-ten materials from the 1990 Festival to createteachers' kits. The kits were used to teach tradi-tional culture in Senegal and the U.S. VirginIslands? comparing and contrasting story-telling, foodways, music, and other expressiveforms, and introducing students to the skillsrequired to research folk culture in their ownfamilies and communities.Other ways have been foimd to share theresearch done for the Festival with people out-side the Washington area. Numerous Smithson-ian/Folkways recordings accompanied by exten-sive documentary notes have been producedfrom eveiy Festival since 1988, beginning with the critically acclaimed Musics of the Soviet Union.These recordings have proved valuable tools inthe classroom for teaching about traditional cul-tiue. Their quality is reflected in a GrammyAward and several nominations. The most recentFestival recording. Roots ofRhythm and Blues: ATribute to the Robert Johnson Era, was nominatedfor a Grammy in the category of best traditionalblues.Eveiy year the Festival generates ancillaiyprojects that capitalize on the energy and fimdsput into it. For instance, the 1984 Black UrbanExpressive Culture from Philadelphia programled to a traveling exhibit, an exhibit catalog, aNational Geographic article, and a training pro-gram for young African American documentaryphotographers. A 1992 program on White HouseWorkers is being developed into a film and atraveling exhibit for the presidential libraries;another 1992 program on Native Americanmusic is being transformed into an exhibit forthe National Museimi of the American Indian;and yet another, on Maroon cultural histoiy, willtour the nation as a future exhibit in the Smith-sonian Institiuion Traveling Exhibition Sei"vice.Numerous interns, undergraduate, and post-doctoral fellows have used the Festival and itsarchives for research and publication. Addition-ally, the Center originated a Folklore SummerInstitute which brings together selected lay schol-ars from commimities around the countiy fortraining in research, documentation, and pre-sentation of traditional culture, as well as propos-al and grant writing. Coinciding with the Festival,the Institute allows students to use the event as alaboratoiy and an opportunity to meet other tra-dition bearers and professionals in the field oftraditional culture. The National Park Semcehas held its training program for Native Ameri-cans, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians inWashington during the Festival for the last twoyears for the same reason.Proud as we are of the Festival on the Mallcreated by the tradition bearers it honors, wethink of the event as just the tip of an iceberg.The effect of the Federal funds expended on it isamplified many times over by private, state, andincome-generated fimds that support Festival-inspired cultural education projects around thecountiy and even around the world. 16 U.S. -MEXICO BORDERLANDSUnited States-MexicoBorderlands/La FronteraOlivia CadavalDedicationWe dedicate the Borderlands program to Don Americo Parades whoselifelong intellectual, artistic, and social engagement with the border has ledthe way in imderstanding borders as distinctive cultural regions. Borders,and in particular the area he has called the Lower Rio Grande Border andfiom which he came, create complex and turbulent environments. Thesegenerate what Don Americo has rightly understood as a culture of conflict,struggle, and resistance. For Don Americo, it is precisely the generativepower of the struggle that makes border folklore distinctive. La frontera inarca I'l sitio doiide dos paises sobera-nos colindan, creando un drnbito de acercamiento perotambien de separacion entre culturas y jurisdiccionesnacionales. La frontera trazada de acuerdo al tratadode Guadalupe Hidalgo de 1848 entre Mexico y losEstados Unidos invadio tierras indigenas, dividiocomunidades rnexicanas, y creo una dindmica de opo-rtunidad, explotacion, y conflicto que ha engendradouna cultura propia fronteriza.Basado en la investigadon, este programa nosofrece una muestra de esta adtura fronteriza? sushistorias, sus diversas comunidades, identidadeslocales y regionales, y de su musica, su arte, su arte-sania, sus costumbres, su comida y su nanativa. Elprograma se ha realizado gracias a la colaboracion deEl Cokgio de la Frontera Norte, Texas FolklifeResources, Western Folklife Center de la Biblioleca de laUniversidad de Arizona, el Centra de EstudiosRegionales de la Universidad Autonoma de NuevoLeon, la Universidad Autonoma de Baja California yde investigadores individuals y miembros de variascomunidades de ambos lados. Este articulo es unaintroduccion a los ensayos de investigadores partici- pantes que aportan diferentes perspectivas y tocandiversos temas.Finalmente este articulo es una introduccion a losparticipantes del programa en elfestival, a esas vocesindividuales que viven y crean la cultura de la fron-tera. A traves de sus historias y la presentacion de sushabilidades artisticas y creadoras, esperamos apreciarla vitalidady riqueza propia de la cultura fronteriza, yentrar en un didlogo con los fronterizos mismos paramejor entender los problemas y los procesos culturaks ysociales que se dan en este drnbito transnacional.IntroductionBorderlands have often been the locale ofmajor folk cultural achievements, from the out-law ballads of the Scots-English border to theheroic corridas oi ionth Texas. Energized by thelives of heroes and others, borderlands continueto spark themes of frontier lawlessness, nationalpride, rebellion against injustice, and a commu-nity hero's stand against all odds. What is itabout a border that triggers these cultural formsand others, such as souvenirs, duty-free liquors. "United States-Mexico Borderlands " has been made possible with the support and collaboration of the Consejo Nacional para la Cultura y las Artes -El Programa Cultural de las Fronteras, El Colegio de la Frontera Norte, Texas Commission on the Arts, Cerveza Tecate - Imported Beer, Texas Folk-life Resources, University ofArizona Library 's Western Foltilore Center, Universidad Autonoma de Nuevo Leon - Centro de Informacion de HistoriaRe^onal, Universidad Autonoma de Baja California, Gobiemo del Estado de Nuevo Leon, Mexican Cultural Institute, and the recording industriesMusic Perfonnnnre Trust Funds. U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS 17 retaining walls made of automobile tires, andmaquiladora assembly plants? Is the border a par-ticular kind of region or social environment? Ifso, does the border tend to produce a particularkind of culture? And what is the relationshipbetween this environment and its culture? In thisessay and in this Festival program we exploreanswers to these questions.A line drawn in various ways, a border marksthe place where adjacent jurisdictions meet. Thiscombined conjunction-and-separation of nationallaws and customs creates a zone in which move-ments of people and goods are greatly regulated,examined, discussed, and hidden. Commerceattains a higher importance in border society asdoes dialogue about the identities of its peoples.Smuggling, the myriad signs in border towns,legal and illegal immigration, and the use ofunneighborly names between neighbors are partsof this picture of accentuated concern with thetrade in goods and the flow of people.The border is an environment of opportuni-ty . Individuals find work enforcing or avoidingthe laws that regulate movement. Companies usenational differences in labor and euNaronmentalregulations to pursue their advantage. Bordersociety thrives on difference, and people andinstitutions come there to exploit niches in itsenvironment.Borders are artifacts of histoiy and are subjectto change over time. Wlien borders shift, landsand peoples are subjected to different sets ofrules; this creates opportunities for exploitation,conditions of hardship, and motivations for revolt. An approach to describing a society con-structed by difference is necessarily many voiced.Rather than a central, authoritative perspective,we strive for a de-centered point of view, onewith many authoritative speakers. Of course, thisis more easily achieved in the Festival, where citi-zens of the border region speak and perform forthemselves and their communities. But even inthis printed mediiun, through translation andtranscription, a varietv of authorities are repre-sented.Border society is an abstract concept com-poimded of ideas about the sovereignty ofnation-states, the intensification of commerceand social discourse, and strategies of culturalrepresentation. The U.S.-Mexico border can beunderstood in these terms; and in this it is simi-lar to borders like those between the U.S. andCanada, East and West Germany, or Kenya andTanzania. But a particular history of the U.S.-Mexico bcjrder is expressed in the images,soimds, discourse genres, and social fcjrmationsdiscussed below. This particidar historical devel-opment has made the border the planet's longestbetween a coimtiy characterized by economicpractices and achievements sometimes known asTirst world" and a countiT whose economv is Olivia Cadaval is curator of the Festival's United States-Mexico Borderlands program. She has conducted researchand collaborated in public programming with the Washing-ton, D.C. Latino, Latin American, and Caribbean commu-nities/or over a decade. .She received her Ph.D. from GeorgeWashington University. 18 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS sometimes characterized as 'third world'. Thegrowth of a capitalist world economy providedthe context for the development not only ofU.S.-Mexico border culture, but also of othertypes of cultural processes that incorporate dif-ference ? acculturation, creolization, and thegrowth of various cultural diasporas.Cultural processes which may be opaque andelusive elsewhere become clear at the border.This is the case, as Dr. Valenzuela points out, inthe formation of cultural identitw The borderoffers a stark context of cultural difference,social inequality, and ever present reminders ofgovernmental power to limit individual opportu-nity by ascribing national identity. The dominantdiscourse that assigns low social value to particu-lar sectors of the population is answered by a cre-ative flood of expressions of identity in music,graphic arts, poetry, and styles of clothing andself presentation.People speak passionately and often artisti-cally about themselves and others; they regulateexchange and avoid regulation; they struggle tosurvive in an environment often shaped by thepractices of nation-states and a global economv.These human acts are not luiique to borders, butthey occur there with a claritv and an urgencythat commands our concern.People at the BorderThe region between the Gulf of Mexico andBaja California has been inhabited by manyNative ^\merican societies, which first settled andused the land. Spaniards took ownership of theselands in grants made by the Spanish crownaccording to a perceived divine right. Mestizos,whose practices, like their ancestiy, combinedhidian and Hispanic heritage, inhabited theregion. And English-speaking citizens of theU.S., whose land acquiring and owning practiceswere informed by principles of commercial capi-tal and manifest destiny also settled here. Theborder region is usually thought of as composedof these principal groups of landowners, fcjrmerlandowners, and workers, but its environment ofopportunity has attracted many others, whosesuccessive arrivals continue to transform thesociocultural life of the region.On the Gulf coast, Jewish families from cen-tral Mexico sought refuge from religious perse-cudon in the 18th century and established busi-nesses in Matamoros and along the valley. In thelatter part of the 19th centui^, a Mexican govern-ment concerned by U.S. expansionism encour-aged settlement and in some cases granted land When her paralysis was cured, Josefina Ollervidez builta shrine in her yard in San Antonio, Texas, to NuestraSenora de los Lagos, a patron saint she brought with herfrom Jalisco in central Mexico. Photo by Kathy Vargasin the western region of the border to groups asdiverse as Chinese, Mennonites, Molokan Rus-sians, Black Seminoles, and Kickapoo Indians.Black Seminoles and Kickapoo were welcomedwith the stipulation that they defend the territoryagainst the Apache and Comanche raids.As Maricela Gonzalez describes in her arti-cle, Chinese managers and laborers establishedresidence in the towns of Mexicali and Calexicoat the beginning of the 20th century. Thedamming of the Colorado River converted thisarea in the Imperial Valley along the ColoradoRiver into fertile agricultural land. Anglolandowners leased this land to Chinese entrepre-neurs from California, who smuggled agricultur-al laborers into Mexico from China.The Bracero Program of 1942-1964, firstnegotiated by the U.S. and Mexico as an emer-gency measiue during World War II, encouragedlarge migrations of Mexican workers to the U.S.Under its terms, Ameiican agricidtural enterpris-es could legally bring Mexican contract laborers U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS 19 for seasonal work. In the off-season many did notreturn home but settled on the border, oftenselecting a place where people from their homestate were already established.The Mixtecos are one of 16 indigenousgroups from Oaxaca who, for at least 30 years,have been migrating to urban and agriculturalareas in Mexico and in the U.S. As FranciscoMoreno's article points out, they are not a mono-lithic group but have regional linguistic and cul-tural differences. For them, as for other indige-nous migrants in Mexico, the sale of traditionaland tourist crafts has been an economic main-stay. Today, some of the most popular touristitems sold throughout Mexico are the rag dollsdressed in archetypal peasant garb with nostrong regional identity. Mixteco women vendorssell them in Tijuana. They formerly made thedolls but now buy them, along with other tradi-tional crafts, from other migrants in Tijuana,who come from the western Mexican states ofJalisco and Guanajuato, and from Guatemala.The traditional and tourist crafts displayed on aMixteco vendor's cart represent the labor ofmany cultural groups on the border and theentrepreneiuial skill of Mixtecos who make a liv-ing in this market i reatcfi b\ short-distancetourism.Mexican immigrants continue to seek eco-nomic opportunities. Workers have been attract-ed to the border area by the 19til-1965 MexicanNational Border Economic Development Pro-gram followed in 1965 by the IndustrializationProgram of the Border, which introduced themaquiladora assemblv plants to the region. Inher article, Maria Eugenia de la O records testi-monies of several inac|uiia workers in CiudadJuarez.From the 1980s onward, economic and polit-ical refugees from Central America have swelledpopulations at the border and migrations acrossit. Individuals, groups, and corporate bodies con-tinue to be attracted to the border to exploitniches in an environment created by differenceand marginality. Wliat they have constructed,appropriated, abandoned, and re-constructed fillthe social landscape of the border region.Regions of the BorderWhile border cultiues share an environmeiUcreated by adjacent jurisdictions and socioeco-nomic marginality and difference, culturalexpressions do vaiy from one border town orregion to another. Older, established communi-ties populate the string of small towns on both sides of the river along the Rio Grande/RioBravo valley to Laredo/Nuevo Laredo. EaglePass/Piedras Negras and Del Rio/Ciudad Acmiabegan as coalmining towns in the 1800s. In DelRfo, the San Felipe spring feeds a network ofcanals, creating a lushness not othei"wise seen insouth Texas and inviting the establishment ofItalian vineyards. Here regional cultiual tradi-tit:)ns are shaped by agriculture, cattle ranching,and mining as much as by the early conflictsbetween the Mexican land-grant settlements andthe northern land-grabbers. Labor unions ofMexican farmers, semce employees, and oilworkers now organize maquila workers at theassembly plants that are replacing those olderindustries on the Mexican side.The border follows the river through therough terrain of the Big Bend and through theonce busy trading posts of Presidio/Ojinaga andon to the El Paso/Ciudad Juarez twins estab-lished as the "Pas.sage to the North" between themountain ranges, "the border's fulcrum, wherethe river gives way to the fence and where Northand South have been horsetrading for centuries"(Weisman 1986:85). El Paso/Ciudad Juarez is acrucible of cultmal identities, in which sharedborder personas are created, exported, re-imported, and transformed. Here the pnrhuco, aMexican American, neighorhood identity of the1940s and '50s was reforged as the cholo Mexicanand Mexican American yoiuh of today.West of the river a series of straight lines, notthe topography, define the boundai"y. Here theSonoran Desert border is home to Yaqui andO'odham Indians. As noted by Dr. Griffith, thereis in this region a unique cultural interdepen-dence between Native Americans and Mexicans,exemplified by the shared celebration of thepatron saint, Francisco Xavier, and of the mis-sionar)' Francisco de Kino (often merged into acomposite St. Francis along with St. Francis ofAssisi). Members of these groups share eachother's crafts and food at the feast in Magdalena,20 miles south of Ambos Nogales (the TwoNogales). In this area, the socioeconomic strug-gle of the Rio Grande/Rio Bravo region is not asdominant a feature of life. Wliereas lower bordercorridos praise the valor of men who fight fortheir rights, corridos in this area celebrate famedhorses that win epic races.The westernmost border area between theCaliiornias is veiy different. The original NativeAmerican populations are surroimded and for-gotten by the growing urbanization of the early20th cell tun'. Many have migrated to San Diego 20 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS Most Mixtecos in Tijuana live in the neigborhood l4:7()-74.Valdez, Luis. "Once Again, Meet the ZootSuhers." Los Angeles Times, 13 August 1978.Villareal, Jose Antonio. 1959. Pocho. Garden City,New ^'ork: Anchor Books.Weisman, .\lan. 198(i. La Frontera: The U.S. Borderwith Mexico. .San Diego: Harcourt. Brace,Jovano\'ich. 58 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS Mortars and MetatesAlice Fay Lozanoas told to Ian Hancock Alice Fay Lozano is one oftlie Mexican Afro-Semi-noles. The Seminoles originally came westfrom Florida,first to Indian Territory in what is now Oklahoma inthe 1830s, and then to Nacimiento in norihem Mexicosome 12 years later. In both instances, they were dis-tancing themselvesfrom slave raids into their settle-ments. In 1870, some of the Nadmiento people camenorth again into Texas to serve as Scoutsfor the U.S.Ar)ny, settling in Brackettvilk after' they were dis-charged in 1914. The word seminole is a Creek Indi-an reinteipretation of the Spanish cimarron, mean-ing, among other things, 'fugitive. " When the Britishwere using Africans and Native Americans as slavesin the Crown Colonies during the 1 7th and early 18thcenturies, a number of those people threw off their yokeof bondage and escaped south into Spanish Florida.Indian Cimarrones, or Seminoles, were not subject tothe same harassment as the African Seminoles, and notall of them left Florida, though almost all of theAfrican Seminoles did. In Oklahoma, nearly all of theIndian Seminoles remained, while the African Semi-noles continued on to Mexico, and subsequently toTexas.Today, the Seminoles in Mexico (known locally asMuscogosj arefewer than 200, and a similar numberlive in and around Brackettville 30 miles north of theTexas border. Although there are Afro-Seminole com-munities elsewhere? in Oklahoma, Florida, and theBahamas? the Border Seminoles are differejit. Wliileretaining their language and many of their traditions. Alice Fay Lozarw is a Black Seminole from Nacimiento de losNegros, Coahuila. Ian Hancock is Professor of Linguistics and English at theLhuversily of Texas at Austin. His major work has been jiiiththe English-related Creoles and Roniani. His pioneering luorkin Brackettville, Texas, brought to light thefact that theSeminole Maroons of this community have maintained a dis-tinct language, Afro-Seminole Creole, closely related to Gut-lah. He earned his Ph.D. from the School of Oriental andAfrican Studies at the University ofLondon. both groups have adopted newer elements of culture:those of the hontera. norteiia. Ms. Lozano lives mostof the time in Nacimiento, sometimes spending timewith relatives in Del Rio, but prefening the peace andspirituality of her home at thefoot of the Mexicanynountains. During an afternoon, talking in heryardabout an African-looking mortar, which sat on theground notfarfrom a Mexican grindstone, she com-mented that the two really represented the Indian andAfrican heritage of her people. I asked hei' to elaborate. From the yard around my hacienda in ElNacimiento de los Negros I can look down acrossthe valley to some other homesteads and seemen tending their goats and cows, and womenhanging their washing out to diy. Here at thefoot of the Sierra Madre range, an hour's drivefrom Melchor Miisquiz, Coahuila State's capitalcity, everything is hushed and peaceful. Only thewind, and the noise of the animals pushingthrough the brush, break the silence.In my yard you'll find a mortar and pestle,which we call maata en maatastick in oiu' ownspeech, and you'll find a grinding stone, in Span-ish called a metate y tejolole. More than anythingelse, these two tools for preparing food symbol-ize the dual heritage of our Black Seminole peo-ple, for one is African, and the other Indian.The mortar is far too hea\'y for me to lift; itconsists of an upright oak log about a foot acrossand two or three feet high, with a depression cutinto the top several inches deep. The pestle isaboiU five feet long, and is also ciU from oak. It isabout three inches in diameter except for thelast foot on each end, which is wider, and round-ed so that it can crush the dried corn kernelsand other things we use it for. The metate isabout a foot square with four small feet, and iscarved out of one piece of stone. It has a flat topwhich cuiTes inward slightly, and the tejolote, orgrinder, looks like a fat stone cigar and is used .S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS 59 Alice "Nina" FayLozano enjoys thetranquility of theSierra Madre moun-tains that surroundthe Muscogo com-munity of Nacimien-to de los Negros innorthern Coahuila,Mexico. Photo byDavid Bosserman with both hands to mash peppers and otherthings on the surface. Sometimes we also use amolcajete, which is like a small stone mortar andpestle, and is used with just one hand.Things are different now, because some ofthe homes in Nacimiento have electricity andelectric blenders, but food processed that waydoesn't come out the same, and it sure doesn'ttaste as good. Another sign of the changingtimes can be seen inside the panti^; pro\'isionsfrom Musquiz, or even from Del Rio across theborder, are our staples now, but it wasn't alwayslike that. In the early days, everything we ate wegrew and prepared ourselves. In leaner times wewould go up into the Sierra Madre to cut downthe royal palms growing there, from which wecould make a floin" called kunteh. We'd mash andsoak the fibers, strain them through a fine sieve,and use their starchy sediment to make tortillas.We don't need to do that any more, but peoplein Nacimiento still use the nattiral medicinesthat grow all around. Plants in the area arebrewed into teas to remedy all kinds of ailments.Even the yerba loca is boiled with water as a painreliever, especially during childbirth.Much of our daily fare is Indian in origin.Some dishes, like suffki (a kind of cornnieal por-ridge) we brought with us from Florida; its nameis from the Creek language. Others, like toli(sweetened and spiced cornmeal pudding) or frybread probably come from Mexican Indians. We also make and eat chorizo, tamales, and all kindsof other regional foods, which are not exclusiveto the Seminoles. One popular African dish issweet potato pudding, which we call tettiih-poon.Some of these we make at any time, while othersare for special occasions, such as birthdays orftmerals or the New Year.The Border Seminoles differ in some waysfrom Seminole commimities elsewhere, becauseof our special connection with Mexico. Semi-noles in Oklahoma or Florida or the Bahamasfor example, don't share that histoiy, and wouldfind some of the things we eat untistial.Some people think we already spoke Spanishbefore we reached Mexico, having learned it firstin Florida. But one thing is certain, wherever welearned it: Spanish has taken over as our mainlanguage in Nacimiento. Only a handful of olderfolk still speak Seminole. The settlement evenhas more oiUsiders living there today than Semi-noles themselves, who have moved out to othertowns, or up to Texas, especially to Brackett\ille.With the new interest in our people, and theestablishment of the Seminole Center and Muse-imi in Del Rio, and the attention the Folklife Fes-tival has brought us, our own grandchildren arebeginning to take a renewed interest in their spe-cial histoiy. Our language and culture, our ownunique blend of African and Native Americanand Mexican, may yet suivive to be enjoyed bythe generations to come. 60 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERtANDS The Chinese inBaja CaUforniaMaricela Gonzalez FelixTranslated by Hector Antonio Corpordn Las incursiom's iniciales de la jwblacion china aBaja California se suscitaron entre 1860 -y 1880,cuando los chinos de California inaugiiraron la Bahiade San Diego con la industria de la pesca del abulon.Posteriormente los chinos arribaron en mayor numerocon la apertura de las tienas a la agticultura en elValle de Mexicali en los primeros anos de este siglo.Luego de haberse iniciado la expropiacion de las tierrasy las dotaciones ejidales a fines de la decada de lostreintas, los chinos quedaron excluidos delproceso decolonizacion y explotacion de la tierra. Con ello los chi-nos empezawn a concentrarse en las actividades comer-dales y de servidos hasta ese momenta poco desarrol-ladas, al liempo que sus asentamientos se empezawn aubicar en la dudad.The (Chinese played an important role in the19th centui7 development of the California andBaja California coast and border region. Theycreated the first abalone fishing industry alongthe coast and were a major part of the work forcethat transformed the border region into the pro-ductive Imperial Valley on the California sideand the Mexicali Valley on the Baja Californiaside. Chinese have always lived in separate com-mimities, but their presence has greatly con-tribiued to defining the culture of the region,particularly that of Mexicali.Chinese were attracted to C>alifornia in themiddle of the 19th centuiy by the discovery ofgold and the territorial expansion of the UnitedStates, which offered job opportimities, highsalaries, and possibilities of acquiring farm land.The majorit)' of the migrants were poor farmers Maricela Gonzalez received her B.A. in Sodology at the Uni-versidad Autonoma de Baja California in Mexicali and is aresearcher at the Museo Regional at the Universidad. In 1977,she Tvorked in a maquiladora in Mexicali. She is author ofEAproceso de aculturacion de la poblacion de origenchino en la cuidad de Mexicali, xohich examines the accul-turation process of the Chinese community in Mexicali. from the pro\ance of Canton, who were fleeingpoverty and war.Chinese first came to Baja Californiabetween 1860 and 1880. They extended the SanDiego Bay abalone industiy along the Baja Cali-fornia coast down to Bahia de Tortugas. Chinesemigration from the U.S. to the northern borderstates of Mexico was accelerated by a series ofanti-Chinese movements in the United States,culminating in the first Chinese exclusion law in1882. Chinese settled primarily in Baja Califor-nia, Sonora, Sinaloa, and Tamaulipas.Chinese later arrived in greater nimibers,drawn by the land and employment promotionsof various foreign companies during the lastdecades of the 19th centui^, which were aimedat attracting tenant farmers to this scarcely popu-lated region. At the turn of the centui^y, the Col-orado River Land Company built irrigationworks and opened the Mexicali Valley for agri-cultural development.Chinese contractors from California provid-ed the company with the necessary labor to workthe xdrgin lands of the Mexicali Valley at a lowcost. The Colorado River Land Company leasedthe land to independent Chinese contractors,who in tiun sub-leased it to Chinese farmers, hithis way, the company indirectly controlled thedifferent phases of farming production, makingthe Chinese intermediaries for LJnited Statesbusinessmen in the exploitation of Mexicanresources.The relationship between United Statesinvestors, Chinese contractors, and Chineseworkers substantially changed after the Mexicangovernment stopped Chinese immigrauon in192L Other factors contributing to the changewere the government's 1936 expropriation ofland owned by foreign companies in Baja Cali-fornia and the growth of the Mexican popula-tion in the peninsula. Chinese and other foreigngroups?Japanese and East Indians? were U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS 61 excluded from the subsequent redistribution ofthese lands. As a result, they began to concen-trate on commercial and service activities mainlyin Mexicali, leaNang their earlier, rural agricultur-al pattern of settlement.Another important movement of Chinese tothe region occurred dining the 1930s anti-Chi-nese movement in Mexico. After the Mexicangovernment cancelled Chinese immigration in1921, various state congresses approved discrimi-natoiy legislation prohibiting marriages betweenChinese and Mexicans, creating special zones toisolate the Chinese, and deporting illegal Chi-nese immigrants.Part of the life histoi"y of an elder Chineseman from Mexicali illuminates those years ofconflict:We left Mexico when I was 12 or 13 yearsold, more or less in 1931 or 1932. We leftMexico City due to the anti-Chinese cam-paign. In those days almost all the Chi-nese were discriminated against andinsulted by Mexicans. I remember thatwhen we went to school other kids threwstones and called us chaks.Although there were many peoplewho tried to prevent those kids frombothering us, there were always othersready to insult us. So that when somedidn't offend us, others were devoted todoing so. They would insult us withoiUreason, only because we looked Chinese.Almost daily we were attacked withstones, and unfortimately, we lived inthat situation for more than two years.The government at that time clearlysought to get the Chinese out of thecounti7, one way or another. As a result,many mixed families were broken. A hus-band would not be allowed to take hiswife with him, much less his children whowere born in Mexico. These things tookplace in various states of the Republic.One could not live in that constantharassment. The government of that timedid not want the Chinese in Mexico. It seems that at that time a group ofpeople with vei7 strong interests hadcome together, and were devoted toharassing the Chinese. That group, if 1remember correctly, was named the Anti-Chinese Party or something like that ? 1don't remember the name exactly. Andin spite of the government's knowing oftheir activities, it did nothing to stoptheir cruelties, like those that are said tohave happened in the state of Coahuila,where dozens of Chinese lost their livesin confrontations with Mexicans. And inEnsenada we know that some Chineseconnnitted suicide because of that.Today the Mexican Chinese community sup-ports itself through small- and medium-sizedcommercial activities like restaurants, real estatebrokerages, money exchange centers, hotels,and a variety of retail stores. Recently arrivedChinese usually come with six month residencepermits to work in these establishments. Chinesein this western border region have lived for along time in a contradictoiy situation of eco-nomic integration and sociocultmal segregation,a condition which continues today, as exchangesbetween Chinese and Mexican populations inthe region remain predominantly economic. Further ReadingsCrighton Miller, Stuart. 1969. The Ameriran Imageof the Chinese, 1785-1882. Berkeley and LosAngeles: University of California Press.Gonzalez Felix, Maricela. 1990. Elproceso deacidturacion de la poblacion de origen rhino en lacuidad de Mexicali. Mexicali: Universidad deBaja California, Instituto de InvestigacionesSociales.Hu de Hart, Evelyn. 1985-1986. The Chinese ofBaja California Norte 1910-1934. InProceedings of Pacific Coast Council onLatin American Studies. Volume 12. SanDiego: San Diego State University Press. 62 U.S. - MEXICO BORDERLANDS AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCESharing Common Ground:Social Dancing in the U.S.A.Vivien Chenwith Magaly E.Janad and Chan Moly SamDancing is sheer pleasure for socializing,exercise, and self-expression. Dancing means cel-ebration ? people gathering together, with foodand drink, at weddings, birthdays, graduations,anniversaries, holidays, block parties, forfundraisers, or just at end-of-the-week get-togeth-er parties. These social events take place in a vari-ety' of settings, from private homes to publicparks. Dancing brings people together and con-tinues to play a role in courtship.Most of us learned to dance by going to par-ties, by observing our elders or peers, or by study-ing the technique of particularly good dancers.More recendy, young people get a lot of their "moves" from videos and television. From theseresources and experiences, we each develop ourown style. Music is almost inseparable from socialdancing and, for most of us, provides the inspira-tion to dance.As an open and adaptive communicative sys-tem, social dance is alwavs up-to-date and reflec-tive of its times. Looking closer, one finds thatdances are also stronglv shaped by their commu-nity expressive traditions and social structures.Most dance steps and styles derive their movesfrom those of earlier dances and movementrepertoires.Dancing brings members of a community'together and strengthens cohesiveness by empha-sizing shared ethical and aesthetic values. Per-forming a common vocabulaiy of movement, intime to a shared repertoire of music, one partici-pates in a culture.The United States is blessed with a diversityof communit)' dance traditions and new danceforms that have developed from interactionsbetween commimities. This exciting Americanmix has had a profound impact on the popular "American Social Dance" has been made possible with sup-portfrom the recording industries Music Peifoitnance TrustFunds. cultiues of nations across the world. The danceprogram at this year's Festival explores socialdancing traditions in five communities? anAppalachian communitv' in soiuhwest Virginia,hoquois communities in upstate New York, andAfrican American, Bolivian, and Cambodian .American communities of Washington, D.C. Tra-dition-bearers will teach dances in workshops,participate in conversations on a variet)' ofthemes, and demonstrate skills, repertoires, andperformance styles from their communities. Ineach of these communities, dance is centrallyimportant in the expression of cultural identity.Consider the interplay of dance, community, andidentity among two Washington area communi-ties, Bolivian and Cambodian Americans. Bolivian Dance in Washington, D.C.For recent immigrant communities such asBolivians in Washington, D.C, dance sustains animportant part of their cultural heritage, reaf-firming shared values in a new and rapidly chang-ing environment. Music and dance also bringreminiscences of youth, courtship, and the cultur-ally familiar. When away from "home," peopledevelop an increased awareness of cultural dis-tinctiveness, and actively embrace what was oncetaken for granted. Cultural activities may becomecrucial in expressing one's group identity' and inpresenting it to the greater American public.The Bolivian commimity is one of the largestLatino communities in the Washington, D.C.area. A majority of the commimitv' came from thecities of La Paz, Cochabamba, Santa Cruz, andOrin'o, and are of middle class mestizo back-groimd. In Bolivia, the population is comprisedof 60% indigenous Aymara and Quechua peo-ples, 30% mixed Indian and Spanish (mestizo),and 10% European (primarily Spanish). Boliviawas under Spanish colonial rule from 1544 to1824 when a republic was established. Boliviabecame a democratic republic with a constitution AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE 63 Men perform the caporalesdance at Elena and AndresPuna's wedding in Virginia.Photo by Marlon Vasquez in 1967. There has been ongoing immigration tothe U.S. for more than 30 years, as well as fre-quent comnumication between Washington, D.C.and Bolivia as himdreds of families retiun eachFebruaiy to take part in two-week long Carnivalcelebrations in Oriiro.Cultural organizations in the Washingtoncommunity engage Bolivian youth and families infolkloric dances and other social activitiesthroughout the year. Weekend practice sessionsprovide opportimities for socializing, and July4th, Hispanic, and Chern' Blossom parades downConstitution Avenue provide public recognitionof the Bolivian community and its cultme.During the past 20 years Washington's Boli-vian community has come to include "revived"folk traditions as part of its social dance reper-toire to a greater extent than before. Dora Castel-lon, president of Comite Pro Bolivia, an unil^relhi Vivien T.Y. Chen, curalor o) the Ai?ietican Social Dance pro-gram at the Festival ofAmerican Folklife, has researched, per-formed, and taught dancefor several years. She received aMasters degree in Dance and Dance Education from NeiuYork University.Magaly E. Jarrad is a dancer, choreogap/ier, scholar, andteacherfrom Oruro, Bolivia. She has received prizesfor herchoreographies at the Carnival in Oruro. Ms. Jarrad currentlydirects a children 's ballet theater in Glen Bumie, Maryland.Chan Moly Sam is a Cambodian master dancer, choreograph-er, and scholar. Her publications include Vl^mer FolkDance (1987), Khmer Court Dance: A CoiTiprehen,siveStudy of Movements, Gestures, and Postures as AppliedTechniques (J 987), and Khmer Court Dance: A Perfor-mance Manual (1989). cultural organization, obser\'es how social life wasa few decades ago:Growing up in Bolivia I loved to watchmy father doing the cueca, but I wasn'tallowed to dance it. These dances werelooked down upon because theybelonged to the middle and lower class-es. The upper class would go to the ballsand dance to music from outside thecountiy, from the United States, likewaltzes and rock-and-roll.As a result of the nationalization of mines in1952 and agrarian reform in 1953, indigenouscommimities that were previously kept immobileh\ a feudal-like political economy inigrated tocities and abroad. They introduced their musicand dance traditions to a wider society, andindigenous styles of dances such as the huaynowere infused into the social dance repertoire.Huayno and other mestizo dances have sincebecome part of the repertoire in the Washington,D.C. community.Sixteen-year-old Andy Lopez participates indancing as a way of maintaining his Bolivianroots: In the United States, there are so many dif-ferent cultures, and everybody seems toknow where they come from. So sinceschool doesn't deal with any part of ourculture, the only way for us to really findout what our culture is, or just keep ourculture, is for us to dance and stick with it. 64 AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE Angel Quinteros, who devotes his Sundays toperforming and teaching Bohvian dance,explains, "I love doing dances like ca/ximlcs; itmakes me feel very powerful."For many members of the Bolivian communi-ty, dancing is a passion and an essential ingredi-ent at weddings, birthday parties, sweet 15 parties(quinceanera), baptisms. Carnival, and Virgin Maiycelebrations. At house parties all generations par-ticipate. Seniors are often energetic and talenteddancers, while children experience dancerhythms from infancy. Three clubs in northernVirginia feature live bands, while social dancingat smaller parties is inspired by record-playingdeejays.Dancing at social fimctions includes coupleand group dances: the cumbia, cueca, morenada,caporales, diablada, taquirari, huayno, camivalito,salsa, merengue, disco, and slow dances. Thisdance repertoire is an artifact of the complex cul-tural and social interactions that have taken placeover the past 500 years in Bolivia and now in Boli-vian communities in the U.S. It is a record of theinter-relationship of indigenous communities,Einopean immigrants (Spanish, English, French,and Germans), enslaved Africans (brought towork in mines and plantations) , nationals ofneighboring countries and of the United States,and the international entertainment industiy.Traditionally, indigenous dances such asthose of the Aymara and Quechua feature sepa-rate lines and circles ofwomen and men, andsmall rimning steps moving from side to side thattrace small semicircles, recalling agriculturalplanting movements. Mestizo dances have beeninfluenced by European spatial patterns, dancesteps such as skips, hops, and jumps, and the phe-nomenon of dancing in couples.Most Bolivian parties start with a pan-Latindance like the cumbia, a Colombian dance with astrong African-derived rhythm. In cumbia,dancers tiun waists, hips, and shoulders as theystep from side to side. Next come livelier dances ? morenada, diablada, and caporales? that arefeatiued at the pre-Lenten festivity of Carnival.Although dances for the actual Carnival proces-sion require much practice, their basic steps canbe fairly easily done as social dances.The diablada dance represents the symbolicstruggle between good and evil. According to tra-ditional belief, the mines in cities like Oruro andPotosi, where much of the popidation earns a liv-ing, are inhabited by Supay, owner of the miner-als. Supay was later interpreted by Evnopeans asthe diablo, or devil. The commimity prays to the Virgin Mary and Archangel Michael to keep thedevils in their place and to prevent them fromharming its miners. The diablada featiues a timein 2/4 marching time and boimcy steps, jumps,and kicks while the dancer turns from side toside.Two dances recall the exploitation ofenslaved Africans brought by Spaniards to workin the mines and plantations dining the colonialperiod. According to some, the morenada repre-sents the forced march of slaves toward the minesof Potosi in the Andes. According to others, itrepresents the movements of slaves crushinggrapes in vineyards in the Xingas tropical planta-tion area. The dance is said to have been first per-formed by the descendants of slaves. Morenada isoften danced in a circle, with small, slow, sidesteps and occasional turns, and is accompaniedmusically by the matracas, which simulate thesound of chains or of cranks turning the winepresses.The caporales, a dance created within the last20 years, borrows features from the indigenousAymaran cullaguada (turning steps from one sideto the other with frontal jumps and kicks), has adriving rhythm from negrilos del patador (an Afro-Bolivdan regional dance), and combines shouldermovements from the Brazilian samba. Borrowinga personage from the morenada dance, thedance depicts the harsh treatment of slaves by thecaporale (foreman) and his wife on plantationsduring the colonial period. Caporales has gainedenormous popularity in recent years and is espe-cially attractive to teenagers, who enjoy the chal-lenge of learning and performing it. Genderroles are very defined in this dynamic dance. Boysand men perform stomping, strong, percussivemovements while girls and women perform small-er, flirtatious, and swinging hip movements.The cueca is a popular courting dance forcouples. Influenced by the Spanish snnllanes in itsspatial pattern, the cueca is done with a polka-likestep. It has four parts. After an introduction andsaliUe, the man dances behind the woman as theytravel in a small circle, he pursuing, she teasing,both twirling handkerchiefs. They meet anddance side by side in the quimba section, and fin-ish together in the zapateo with fast tapping foot-work. Drinks are often offered to the dancersbefore the dance is repeated.In internationally popular dances such asmerengue and lambada, couples dance apart orin a closed position. Originally from the Domini-can Republic, the merengue seems to have result-ed from a confluence of European contra dance AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE 65 and an African style of movement. Its rhythm isfast, and when danced in a closed position, part-ners move as one by taking little side steps as theyturn.After a few slow dances like bolero, partiestraditionally close with a carnivalito or hiiayno,during which everyone joins in or is pulled fromtheir seats. These are joyous dances in fast, 2/4time featuring small rimning, stomping, hopping,and jumping movements. The hiiayiio begins as acouple dance with partners holding hands orlinking arms. As momentum gathers lines areformed, and dancers wind around the room incircular, zig-zag, or intersecting patterns. Oftenthe bandleader or deejay will give directions suchas "pull the ears" or "hands on hips," "do turns," "dance on one foot," or "slow down." It is notimcommon for women to dance with each otherin these dances. Using a variety of culturalresources, Bolivians in the D.C. area enjoy eachother's company and dance out rich identities tothemselves, to each other, and to their neighbors.Cambodian American Dancein Washington, D.C.Among the Cambodian communirv in theWashington area, social dancing helps to bringindividuals and families together at weddings.New Year's, birthdays, graduations, and fundrais-ers. The selection of dances and the way they aredanced at parties reflect distinctive cultinal histo- r-y, aesthetics, and ethical ideas as well as recentinfluences of an American context.The roots of Cambodian dance span milleniain Southeast Asia. Throughout its 2,000-year his-tory, Cambodian culture has had a fertile inter-change with the cultures of India, China, andIndonesia. From the 9th to the 1 5th centuries,the Angkor Empire fostered a subtle intermin-gling of Indian and indigenous elements to pro-duce a culture regarded by many scholars asamong the richest and most creative in SoutheastAsia. At its largest, the Pilimer Empire rangedfrom the border of China into present-day Thai-land, Laos, and southern Vietnam. Cambodiabecame a French protectorate in 1863 andgained independence in 1953. Since 1975, afterthe fall of Cambodia to Khmer Rouge forces, theCambodian commimity in Washington, D.C. hassteadily grown to about 15,000. While many immi-grated from urban Phnom Penh, a significantnumber also caine from more riual areas in theprovinces of Battambang, Siem Reap, and Ki\m-pong Thom.Cambodian social dance uses leaf and flower hand movements, two of the four basic gesturesof classical dance: tendril (chanol), leaf (/crtrj,flower (chip), and fruit (kuong). These representthe cycle of fertility and were performed rituallyto visualize the creative spirit of plants and flow-ers. Vuthy Kheav, 30, who grew up on a farm inSiem Reap province, remembers dancing the ramvoug, raw kbaih, and lam lean in the rice fields atthe completion of planting and hai-vest, to theaccompaniment of the tro, a two-string fiddle, andskordai, a hand drum. Sochietah Ung, 35, learnedto dance at seasonal festivals that featured freemovies and social dancing in the evenings. ChanMoly Sam recalls that "Evei"y New Year celebra-tion in Phnom Penh, you heard the pattern ofthe drum from dust to dawn, or sometimesthroughout the night, for three days."Ram \'ong is always the first dance at anysocial event, often followed by ram kbach andlam leav. These are all circle dances done in cou-ples in a coiniterclockwise direction in 4/4 time.In ram vong the female leads while the male pur-sues her, traveling from side to side, seeking eyecontact. Ram kbach, a slow, graceful dance thatconveys harmony, is performed with one legcrossing in front of the other as the body inclinesdiagonally from one side to the other. In lamleav, a courtship dance from Stung Trengprovince, the partners move in intenvoven pat-terns. fJimer leu, from the northern provinces,features a three-count wiist movement. In sara- x'tiiiu, partners face each other, moving their armsriivthmically, raising and lowering them, openingand closing them like the wings of a bird. Thedances allow participants the freedom to do varia-tions and improvisations. For example, in time tothe rhythmic pattern of saravann music, a skillfulcouple can travel foi'wards, backwards, or side-wards to elaborate on the image of a bird risinginto the air, soaring, and landing. These dancesembody the value of attentiveness in male andfemale relationships, and they are an importantpart of courtship.The dances also express the value of balanceand harmony. Dancers cultivate internal balanceas their gestures flow rhythmically with the music.Symmetrical movements alternate from one sideto the other. Moderation is valued; one shouldnot overdo or neglect movements.Many Cambodians are equally at ease withEuropean-derived dances. Popular western musicand social dances were introduced to Cambodi-ans by Filipinos and the French. In the early1900s, the Cambodian court received the gift of alarge band in residence from the Philippines. 66 AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE Nara and Sambonn Lekand friends dance the ramvong, a traditionalCambodian circle dance.Photo by Sambonn Lek The Filipino musicians taught marching music toCambodian royal and symphonic bands, partici-pated in court ensembles, and performed in jazzbands at nightclubs. The musicians introducedLatin rhythms into Cambodian dance, foundingbig bands that played at ballroom dances. Theydeveloped a kind of music that came to be calledphkng manila, or Filipino ensemble music. Thismusical innovation greatly expanded the Cambo-dian repertoire.Mr. Lek Chhan, a distinguished dancer nowin his seventies, learned European dances? thetango, Boston, cha-cha-cha, rumba, foxtrot, waltz ? from his French professor in Phnom Penh.Fellow students also taught each other withrecordings and attended nightclubs and bars.Western music was also disseminated by Frenchhigh school teachers; and in some militaiy acade-mies, high ranking officers received formal train-ing in European-derived dances. The madisonwas in vogue by the 1950s, and the twist intro-duced by the popular entertainer Chum Kemupon his return from France in the early 1960s.At parties in the Washington area, musiciansusually play dances in pairs, juxtaposing fast andslow tempos. Contemporai-y bands usually featmemale and female vocalists, lead, rhythm, and bassguitars, and a drimi set or synthesizer. In adopt-ing European-derived dance music such as cha-cha-cha or tango, Cambodians retained therhythms and composed Klimer melodies andlyrics to each song; they simplified the dance steps. Dances like the cha-cha-cha and madisonare interpreted with deft and subtle hip, back,and foot movements.At social events in Cambodia, danceexpressed social relationships and values, and thedance floor often became an arena of gesturaleloquence. Traditionally, yoimg men and womenwere only allowed to socialize with each other atNew Year's, which provided a rare and importantopportunity to meet, dance, and talk. Womenwould sit together on one side of the room whilethe men sat on the other. A man would offer sam-peah, a greeting of respect performed to invite ayoung woman to dance and to take his leave onparting. There was no physical contact in tradi-tional Cambodian dances.Traditionally, yoimg women were kept closeto the family. As they reached their middle teensthey entered c/iaul mlob, or "went into shadow,"meaning they were not to be seen in public, espe-cially by young men. Young men were freer incomparison and were encouraged to explore theoutside world and society.Wliile women were encoinaged to showinterest in the court dance traditions, men weregroomed to be good social dancers. In an oldergeneradon, men danced a flamboyant expressiverole compared with women's modest one. Herexecution of social dances was not expected to beas creative or as varied as her partner's. Membersof older generations expected that at socialevents, behavior was performed and evaluated AMERICAN SOCIAt DANCE 67 and everyone was watching. A young man seekinga young lady chose his movements carefully, withan eye to impressing her family members presentat the event. Moderation and attentiveness werehighly valued, while wild and self-involved move-ments were looked upon with disfavor. While theseparation of the sexes is no longer practiced inthe AjTierican context, the connotations of move-ment still persist.At wedding receptions, the bride and groomand their parents initiate the celebration with theram vong. As revered elders, the parents are thefirst to give blessings to the new couple throughdance. At other functions, the host or anotherprominent person leads the circle dances.In the Washington cominunity, seniors par-ticipate in social dancing but only minimally infast genres like the twist, disco, and rock. Young-sters have free range of the floor, often dancingin separate groupings of boys and of girls.Community members note that while dancemovements have remained essentially the same,there have been changes in gender roles. Influ-enced by the role ofwomen in Ainerican society,Cambodian women have become less confined,more assertive, and more nearly equal as dancepartners. Many people feel that the dancing isbetter now with opportunity for more fun.Phavann Chhuan talks about the importanceof dance and commiuiity for young people sort-ing out their identity:We get the kids to social functions asoften as we can, to expose them toKhmer cultiue, to give them both views.Maybe through peer pressure or groupparticipation they'll see that it's accept-able to do Cambodian dance as well asinclude other dances with it. We want tobring them up in an environment wherepeople accept different cultures, wherethe kids will not forget their heritage.Shaped by traditional ideas of beaiUv, order,and the individual, social dance is a rich anddeep language for communicating ideas andidentities. Like a language it is a formal set of cat-egories and transformaUons that keeps us intouch with centuries of meaning. Yet it is alwaysopen to change to serve the needs of themoment. It is a tool for living that enables us tocomprehend the voices and actions of others,respond to them, and make them our own.Washington social dance repertoires contin-ue to evolve and grow as new dances are taught by relatives, friends, and home videos. MarcoCastellon added some football moves to caporalesand brought it down to Oriuo, Bolivia, where hetraded steps and videos with students there.(They showed him a new version of caporalesthat incorporates a freeze, taking inspirationfrom hip-hop.) Lashmi Sam brought the newestCambodian American dance "Hai-vesting theShrimp" from Seattle and is teaching it to neigh-bors in Reston.Thr iiiilliiiy. ii'niil In lliinik muiix dinuns /mm ihe Bolivian amiCambodia II lommuiiiliesjut \lianng llieir knowledge and wisdomwith us, including Adela Baldarrama, Hugo Carillo, Phavann andNatalie Chhuan, Gonzalo Gutierrez, Katherine Guzman, JhaninaHerbas, Vuthy Kheav, Leh Chhan, Sambonn and Nara Lek, AndyLopez, Maria Lopez, Melina Mendez, Jhonny Meneses, Sesane Ouk,Shirley Pena, Nelson Perez, Angel Quinteros, Sam-Ang Sam, RithySok, Sokhon Soum, Samnang Sun, Sody Teh, Rady and SaroeumTes, Sochietnh Ung, Chinary Ung, Jugo and Alex Urresty, LuisVillarroel. Maria Villrgas, and Danett Zepeda. Furlher Ri'tidingsHeredia, Augusto Beltran. 1962. The Histoiy of theCamivale. Oruro, Boli\ia: The Department ofFolklore.Nash, June. 1979. We Eat the Mines and the MinesEat Us: Dependency and Exploitation in BolivianTin Mines. New York: C'olumbia UniversityPress.Pin, Chap. 1962. Danses Populaire au Cambodge.Phnom Penh: Institut Bouddhique.Prado, Benjamin Torrico. 1971. Indigenous in theHeart ofAmerica. La Paz, Bolivia: Los Aniigosdel Libro.Sam, Sam-Ang, and Patricia Campbell. 1991.Silent Temples, Songful Hearts: Traditional Musicof Cambodia. DanbiuT, ConnecticiU: WorldMusic Press. Suggested ListeningCambodian Traditional Music, Vo\. 1.Smithsonian/Folkways 4081.Cambodian Traditional Music, Vol. 2.Smithsonian/Folkways 4082.Instruments and Music of Bolivia.Smithsonian/Folkways 4012.Word of Love. Sann Huy Film 'Video Production,CD 2.Souvenirs Klimer Air Lines. Chlangden Productions,CD 034.Dream of You. Preah Vihear Production, CD 2. 68 AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE Generations of African AmericanSocial Dance in Washington, D.C.:Hand Dancing, Hip-Hop, and Go-GoLeeEllen Friedland Wliat do the Motown sound and hip-hopmusic have in common? Each is the musicalinspiration for a vital dance tradition that thrivesin the African American communitv of Washing-ton, D.C.And these two st)les of Black dance? thesmooth partner coordination and intricate turnsof "hand dancing" performed to Motown clas-sics, and the rhythmic steps and weight shiftswith elaborate, syncopated arm and torso ges-tures done to the rhythmic polyphony of hip-hopmusic? what do they have in comnion? Eachserves as a generation's prime marker of identityand vehicle for artistic expression. Together witha third style, go-go, they provide artistic alterna-tives to people of different ages and aestheticsensibilities.Hand DancingHand dancing was born and bred in Wash-ington, D.C, during the Motown era, whichbegan in the late 1950s. It is essentially a smoothversion of the Lindy Hop that features almostconstant hand holding and tinning betweenpartners, and several step patterns used to keeptime.' As musical tempos increased through the1960s, with successive Motown hits by groupssuch as the Supremes, Foin- Tops, and Tempta-tions, hand dancing stsle developed to suit thefast beat and new rhythms. - Like popular dance styles before and after it,hand dancing soon became a favorite pastimefor teenagers and young adults. It largelyeclipsed the older st)'les at house parties,cabarets, and clubs in Washington's Black com-mimity. Deejays provided the music for danceevents and built reputations on the breadth oftheir record collections and their skill in craftingsong sequences.Local television shows such as the "Teenara-ma Dance Show," which ran from 1963-67, fea-tured local teenagers and put hand dancing inthe spotlight. Indiwdual dancers cultivated dis-tinctive styles, often incorporating regional varia-tions that developed within the cit). Just by theway they danced, hand dancers could be recog-nized as hailing from Southeast, Southwest, orNortheast Washington. This intra-city variation,and the markedly contrasting dance styles seenon nationally broadcast shows like "AmericanBandstand," helped to fortifS' local opinion thathand dancing was imique to Washington, D.C.^As the Motown era faded into funk and discoin the 1970s, however, hand dancing was largelyreplaced by "free dancing" styles, in which part-ners do not hold hands. Most of the Blackteenagers who had grown up hand dancing inWashington made an easy transition to the newfree dancing st)ies, and kept pace as youngadidts with the new trends in popular Black cu\- Some version of tlie Lindy Hop. also known as swing or the Jitterbug, was popular from the 1920s through most of the 1950s.Dance historians consider African American dancers t]ie primary innovators of the Lindy form. See Stearns (1964) . Arthur Murray's1954 dance manual describes single, double, and triple Lindy Hop steps. Variations of these steps are among those performed byWashington-area hand dancers. ~ I am indebted to Washington deejay Robert Frye. "Captain Fly," for insight into tlie relationship between Motown music and handdancing. Captain Fly chronicles the progression of popular musical style through the 1950s and 1960s on his radio show, "OldiesHouse Party," every Saturday on Washington-area station WPFW (89.3 FM). Along with otlier deejays devoted to the "oldies butgoodies" format, he is a dedicated historian of oldies music and an inveterate record collector. ^ I am grateful to many veteran hand dancers for sharing their knowledge with me, including Florence Barber, Jerome Bettis. PhilClark. Bobby L. Conwav. Lewis Fountain, Althia Harris. Ron Patterson, Preston Walker, and Wayiie Williams. AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE 69 Hand dancing partners improvise an elaboratearm gesture between turns. Photo by LeeEllenFriedland Veteran deejay CaptainFly (Robert Frye) is hostof the "Oldies HouseParty" radio programon WPFW-FM. Photoby LeeEllen Friedland 70 AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE ture. Sometime in the mid-1980s, however, asrap became more commonly heard on the radioand hip-hop grew into a major cultiual move-ment, hand dancers? by this time mostly intheir forties and fifties? began to revive theirgeneration's "own" music and dance. Thisreturn to artistic roots planted firmly in theMotown era led to a revival of "oldies but good-ies" music at Washington-area clubs, cabarets,and radio stations that is still going strong.Hip-HopHip-hop is not just a dance style; it is a multi-faceted world of expression that includes dance,music, a deejay's skilled mix of live and recordedsounds, verbal art (including rapping and otherforms), visual arts (such as graffiti), clothing,body adornment, and social attitude. Hip-hop isshared by yoimg people of different culturalbackgroiuids throughout the United States, binits basic aesthetic ideas are deeply rooted inAfrican American culture.In Washington's Black commimity, hip-hopincludes social dancing, done by couples (whodo not hold hands); and exhibition dancing,done by individuals or sets of dancers who dotheir most impressive moves and choreographedroutines to demonstrate their prowess.Hip-hop dancing is done to any type of hip-hop music ? rapping, singing, or instrumental ? with an appropriate beat and tempo. This canalso be imadorned rhythm playing, such as a syn-thesized drum track or an impromptu beatpoimded out by hands or with sticks. Socialdancing is most often based on relatively simplepatterns of stepping and weight shifting, whichare overlaid with multiple rhythmic layers of ges-tures done with the arms, head, and segments ofthe torso.Exhibition dancing can include any moveused in social dancing, biu it features a widerrepertoire of fancy stepping patterns; body wavesand isolated movements of body parts (as in "popping"); gestures, facial expressions, andother forms of mimicry; acrobatic tumbling,splits, jiuTips, and spins; and choreographed rou-tines that combine any niunber of different ele-ments. Not all dancers choose to develop theextraordinary skills of exhibition dancing, but Folklorist LeeEllen Friedland has studied European- andAfrican-derived social dance traditions in the United Stalessince 1975. She is director ofEthnologica. a Washington,D.C., consultingfirm that specializes infolklife and culturalheritage research. nearly eveiyone that participates in hip-hop doessocial dancing.Dancing generally happens at clubs,cabarets, and parties that featiue hip-hop music.But it can also erupt spontaneously in responseto music in schoolyards, neighborhood streets,and homes. Often these informal performancesare interspersed with mimicry and acrobatics.Deejays are the favored source of music forhip-hop dance events. Like those in older gener-ations in the Black commvmity, hip-hop deejaysare valued for their skill in gauging the fitbetween the music and the dancers" mood, fortheir ability to string together inspiring musicalsequences, and for their collections of soimdrecordings and equipment that allows the great-est range of musical creativity. Most hip-hop dee-jays are also adept at "mixing," a range of music-making skills including such techniques as "cut-ting" and "scratching" that involves the manualmanipulation of discs on multiple turntables andthe interpolation of additional soimds generatedby synthesizers, electronic rhythm machines,pre-recorded tapes, verbal art performed by thedeejay or others, and a variety of percussioninstruments.Go-GoThough hip-hop culture proxddes the frame-work for much of the music and dance amongyoimg people in the Black community, anotherstyle, one unique to Washington, D.C., providesan artistic alternative for many teenagers: go-go.Unlike hip-hop, which except for a deejay's mix-ing uses pre-recorded music, go-go is danced tolive bands that generally include multiple per-cussionists (playing a trap set, congas, and a vari-ety of small, hand-held instruments) and a mixof keyboard synthesizers, bass, horns, guitars,and vocalists. This "big band" sound is especiallywell-suited for large public venues such as clubs.The music is fimk-derived and incorporates ele-ments of Afro-Cuban and jazz styles.'*Go-go dancing has the same basic structureas hip-hop social dancing? stepping and weightshift patterns overlaid with multi-rhythmic arm. * My thanks to Michael Licht of the D.C. Commission on theAlts and Humanities for an overview of go-go activities inWashington, D.C. The Arts Commission regularly includesgo-go in its cultural programming and currently co-sponsors(with the Malcolm X Cultural Educauon Center) a Cio-goHoUine that lists local go-go events {202 543-GOGO). TheArts Commission has also published a pamphlet on go-go, "What's the Time?" AMERICAN SOCIAL DANCE 71 V SI r\i ^ *?? ft ^ Kim, Tyrone, Brian, and iVlil