Pelagic Studies of Seabirds in the Central and Eastern Pacific Ocean WARREN B. KING, EDITOR m wtu. SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY • NUMBER 158 SERIAL PUBLICATIONS OF THE SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION The emphasis upon publications as a means of diffusing knowledge was expressed by the first Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution. In his formal plan for the Insti- tution, Joseph Henry articulated a program that included the following statement: "It is proposed to publish a series of reports, giving an account of the new discoveries in science, and of the changes made from year to year in all branches of knowledge." This keynote of basic research has been adhered to over the years in the issuance of thousands of titles in serial publications under the Smithsonian imprint, com- mencing with Smithsonian Contributions to Knowledge in 1848 and continuing with the following active series: Smithsonian Annals of Flight Smithsonian Contributions to Anthropology Smithsonian Contributions to Astrophysics Smithsonian Contributions to Botany Smithsonian Contributions to the Earth Sciences Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology Smithsonian Studies in History and Technology In these series, the Institution publishes original articles and monographs dealing with the research and collections of its several museums and offices and of professional colleagues at other institutions of learning. These papers report newly acquired facts, synoptic interpretations of data, or original theory in specialized fields. These pub- lications are distributed by mailing lists to libraries, laboratories, and other interested institutions and specialists throughout the world. Individual copies may be obtained from the Smithsonian Institution Press as long as stocks are available. S. DILLON RIPLEY Secretary Smithsonian Institution S M I T H S O N I A N C O N T R I B U T I O N S T O Z O O L O G Y • N U M B E R 1 5 8 Pelagic Studies of Seabirds in the Central and Eastern Pacific Ocean Warren B. King, Editor SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION PRESS City of Washington 1974 ABSTRACT King, Warren B., Editor. Pelagic Studies of Seabirds in the Central and Eastern Pacific Ocean. Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology, number 158, 277 pages, 170 figures, 1974.—Seven papers by various authors on the pelagic distribution of sev- eral seabirds in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean based largely on the re- searches of the Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Program, 1963-1968. "Introduc- tion," by Patrick J. Gould, introduces these and future papers in this series. He discusses the methods and procedures used by the POBSP in gathering and recording data on observations of seabirds, outlines the areas under surveillance, and pro- vides a general account of the oceanography and marine biology of the areas under discussion as a background to understanding the movements of seabirds in relation to their environment. "Sooty Tern (Sterna fuscata)," by Patrick J. Gould, presents the POBSP'S records of this most abundant tropical and subtropical Pacific species. Its distribution at sea depends on erratic food availability, location of breeding islands, breeding schedule, and postbreeding dispersal patterns. "Wedge-tailed Shearwater (Puffinus pacificus)," by Warren B. King, gives data on the distribu- tion of the northern, predominantly white-breasted and the southern, dark- breasted morphs of this species. Subtropical populations migrate extensively, for example between the Hawaiian Islands and the Pacific coast of Middle America; tropical populations are apparently nonmigratory. "Black-footed Albatross (Diomedea nigripes)," by Gerald A. Sanger, discusses the distribution and fre- quency of sightings on a seasonal basis of this ship-following seabird, both in gen- eral terms throughout its range and in detail in certain areas, for example, the CalCOFI study covering an eight year period oft California and Baja California. Its winter range overlaps largely with, but lies slightly to the south of, its summer range. "Laysan Albatross (Diomedea immutabilis)," by Gerald A. Sanger, analyzes observations of this species and relates its seasonal distribution and abundance to its oceanographic environment. This species is more abundant in the western and central Pacific, whereas the Black-footed Albatross is more abundant in the central and eastern Pacific. "The Storm Petrels (Hydrobatidae)," by Richard S. Crossin, summarizes the POBSP'S data on eighteen species or subspecies of storm petrels based on sightings and collected specimens. Pelagic distribution is related to breeding cycles, location of breeding sites, and marine environment. "Red-tailed Tropicbird (Phaethon rubricauda)," by Patrick J. Gould, Warren B. King, and Gerald A. Sanger, discusses seasonal distribution and abundance of this species relative to its breeding cycle. This species disperses widely from its breeding is- lands, for example, from the Hawaiian Islands to the Pacific coast of Middle America. "Recoveries of Banded Laysan Albatrosses (Diomedea immutabilis) and Black-footed Albatrosses (D. nigripes) in the Pacific Ocean," by Chandler S. Rob- bins and Dale W. Rice, summarizes the seasonal distribution of pelagic recoveries of 324 banded Laysan Albatrosses and 399 banded Black-footed Albatrosses. Dif- ferent age groups of each species concentrate in somewhat different areas, and, al- though range overlap between species is almost complete, each has its own distinc- tive seasonal distribution pattern. OFFICIAL PUBLICATION DATE is handstamped in a limited number of initial copies and is recorded in the Institution's annual report, Smithsonian Year. SI PRESS NUMBER 4901. SERIES COVER DE- SIGN: The coral Montastrea cavernosa (Linnaeus) . Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Main entry under title: Pelagic studies of seabirds in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean. (Smithsonian contributions to zoology, no. 158) "Seven papers by various authors . . . based largely on the researches of the Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Program, 1963-1968." Bibliography: p. 1. Sea birds—Pacific Ocean. 2. Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Program. I. King, Warren B., ed. II. Series: Smithsonian Institution. Smithsonian contributions to zoology, no. 158. QL1.S54 no. 158 [QL694] 591'.08s [598.4'09164] 73-10383 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Washington, D.C. 20402 - Price $3.70 Contents Page INTRODUCTION, by Patrick J. Gould 1 Survey Areas 2 Methods and Procedures 4 Acknowledgments 4 SOOTY TERN {Sterna fuscata), by Patrick J. Gould 6 Introduction . 6 Behavior 8 Distribution and Abundance 13 Summary and Conclusions . 33 Appendix: Tables A C 46 WEDCE-TAILED SHEARWATER (Puffinus pacificus), by Warren B. King 53 Introduction 53 Distribution and Abundance . 56 Density and Distribution within Equatorial Currents . 56 Range of Sea Surface Temperatures and Salinities at Which Wedge- tailed Shearwaters Were Observed 59 Specimen Records, Molt, and Band Recoveries 59 Discussion 62 Behavior 63 Summary 67 Appendix: Summary of Published Data on Wedge-tailed Shearwater Distribution 92 BLACK-FOOTED ALBATROSS (Diomedea nigripes), by Gerald A. Sanger 96 Introduction 96 Distribution and Abundance 98 Specimen Records 98 Sighting Records 98 Band Return Information 103 Distribution off California and Baja California, 1951-1959 103 Abundance at Weather Station Victor 107 Analysis of Distribution . 107 General Considerations 107 Seasonal and Monthly Variations 109 Distribution in Relation to the Environment 110 Addendum 113 Appendix: Summary of Published Data on Black-footed Albatross Distribution 126 LAYSAN ALBATROSS (Diomedea immutabilis), by Gerald A. Sanger 129 Introduction 129 Distribution and Abundance . 130 Specimen Records 130 Sighting Records 130 Annual Pelagic Cycle 134 iii Page Abundance at Weather Station Victor 134 Band Return Information 134 Analysis of Distribution 134 General Considerations 134 Distribution in Relation to the Environment 138 Addendum 139 Appendix: Summary of Published Data on Laysan Albatross Distribution 152 THE STORM PETRELS (Hydrobatidae), by Richard S. Crossin 154 Introduction 154 Pelagodroma marina (Latham) 157 Oceanodroma furcata (Gmelin) 158 Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa (Vieillot) 158 Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali Emerson 165 Oceanodroma leucorhoa chapmani Berlepsch 169 Oceanodroma leucorhoa socorroensis Townsend 170 Oceanodroma homochroa (Coues) 176 Oceanodroma castro (Harcourt) 177 Oceanodroma tethys (Bonaparte) 179 Oceanodroma hornbyi (Gray) 183 Oceanodroma melania (Bonaparte) 183 Oceanodroma markhami (Salvin) 187 Oceanodroma tristrami Salvin 187 Halocyptena microsoma Coues 189 Oceanites oceanicus (Kuhl) 190 Oceanites gracilis (Elliot) 190 Fregetta grallaria (Vieillot) 190 Nesofregetta albigularis (Finsch) 193 Discussion 200 Appendix: Tables A-E 203 RED-TAILED TROPICBIRD (Phaethon rubricauda), by Patrick J. Gould, Warren B. King, and Gerald A. Sanger 206 Introduction 206 Behavior 207 Specimen Records 210 Molt 212 Distribution and Abundance 213 Environmental Factors 216 Discussion 216 Appendix: Summary of Published Data on Red-tailed Tropicbird Distribution 230 RECOVERIES OF BANDED LAYSAN ALBATROSSES (Diomedea immutabilis) AND BLACK-FOOTED ALBATROSSES (£>. nigripes), by Chandler S. Robbins and Dale W. Rice 232 Introduction 232 General Patterns of Distribution 236 Concentration Areas 238 Statistical Analysis of Geographic Range 238 Comparison of Distribution of Laysan and Black-footed Albatrosses 241 Discussion 242 LITERATURE CITED 272 iv Pelagic Studies of Seabirds in the Central and Eastern Pacific Ocean Introduction* Patrick J. Gould In 1963 the Smithsonian Institution initiated a research project to study the ecology of certain areas of the Pacific Ocean. The activities and ob- jectives of this project, called the Pacific Ocean Bio- logical Survey Program (POBSP) , have been sum- marized by Humphrey (1965). The present paper is the first in a series summarizing at-sea bird ob- servations made by the POBSP, although a number of papers have already been published incorporat- ing some POBSP at-sea observations (Amerson, 1969; Gould, 1967; Gould and King, 1967; King, 1967; King, 1970; King and Gould, 1967). The following introduction is rather lengthy so that subsequent papers herein and elsewhere may avoid needless repetition of material relevant to all of them. POBSP efforts were concentrated primarily on a 4ys million-square-mile area of the central Pacific between 10°S and 30°N, and 148°W and 180°. The birds of this area have received the greatest atten- tion, although plants, arthropods, mammals, fishes, reptiles, and other forms have figured in the re- search as well. The energies of the POBSP were di- vided between periodic visits to the islands of the Leeward Hawaiian chain, the Line group, the Patrick J. Gould, Department of Zoology, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona 85721. •Paper Number 100, Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Pro- gram, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. Phoenix group, and observations in the open ocean. Peripheral island groups such as the Tokelaus, Marshalls, Gilberts, Wake, and the Pribilofs were visited less frequently. On island surveys POBSP personnel estimated the breeding and roosting populations of each seabird species, described the breeding status of each, made representative collections of the plants and animals (with special attention to vagrants), and marked large numbers of as many species of birds and mam- mals as possible. In the course of this work, POBSP personnel have banded over 1,800,000 birds of 56 species. On two atolls, Johnston and Kure, POBSP maintained continuous surveillance. A large pro- portion of the birds on these islands was banded, and uninterrupted breeding biology studies were conducted. Late in 1966, field work was expanded eastward to include a survey area off southern California and northern Baja California. Observers also ac- companied many cruises (south to as far as 20°S and east to as far as 135°W) of project EASTROPAC. This latter project was an intensive oceanographic investigation of the eastern tropical Pacific Ocean by Chile, Ecuador, Mexico, Peru, and the United States, sponsored and coordinated by the U.S. Bu- reau of Commercial Fisheries. Observations at sea have been made in the cen- tral and eastern Pacific to determine the identity, SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY occurrence, and abundance of seabirds. Data on atmospheric and oceanographic conditions were collected concurrently on some cruises to provide a broad ecological foundation. POBSP personnel made continuous observations, normally from sunrise to sunset, but sometimes around the clock, on cruises along replicate tracks and straight-line transects in all months of the year. On most island survey cruises, personnel made observations en route to, from, and between the islands. Furthermore, data on the population and breeding phenology of sea- birds from island surveys added to the understand- ing of the distribution and densities of birds at sea. In addition, the use of plastic leg streamers and feather dye applied by island workers increased the chances of assigning an island of origin to marked birds observed or collected at sea. SURVEY AREAS Data were gathered systematically from the north-central, south-central, and eastern Pacific dur- ing all months of the year. In these areas, ships fol- lowed replicate cruise tracks or concentrated their efforts within a small area of ocean so that the abundance and distribution of birds could be docu- mented seasonally in great detail. Cruises also went into peripheral areas but less regularly (Figure 1). Although the seasonal movements of birds in these peripheral areas cannot be shown in as much de- tail, the resulting data broaden the total coverage. The north-central Pacific is defined herein as the area between 10°N and 30°N, and between 148°W and 180°. The only islands within this predomi- nantly tropical oceanic area are the Hawaiian group and Johnston Atoll. This area is within the North Pacific Trade Wind Zone which is characterized by mild temperatures and remarkably constant winds from the northeast, normally between 10 and 25 knots. Anticyclonic high pressure cells move from west to east between 35°N and 50°N and generate the trade winds. These cells break down occasion- ally,, more frequently in winter than in summer, at which times southerly and westerly winds bring warm moist air and increased rainfall. The north-central Pacific is within the large North Pacific Central water mass. This is bounded on the east by the southward flowing California Current, the westward extension of which flows into the North Equatorial Current. The southern border of the North Equatorial Current forms a di- vergence with the Equatorial Countercurrent be- tween 9°N and 12°N depending on the season. The Kuroshio Current and the North Pacific Current border the water mass on the west and north, re- spectively. The North Pacific Central water mass in the Hawaiian Islands area has a high surface salinity, up to 35.3 parts per thousand, decreasing toward the south to 34.1 parts per thousand. Sur- face water temperatures range in summer from 25°C in the north (26°N) to 27°C in the south (10°N), and in winter from 20°C in the north to 25°C in the south. A summary of north-central Pa- cific oceanography is found in Seckel (1962). The flow of water through the Hawaiian Islands is to the southwest. The large submerged bases of the islands deflect the water and cause eddies to form in the lee of the islands, which result in local areas of nutrient turnover and enrichment (Sette, 1955). Seabirds are often associated with such areas. The leeward Hawaiian Islands, Johnston Atoll, and, to a lesser extent, the main Hawaiian Islands, have large seabird breeding colonies. In the spring and summer, when most of the species of this area are breeding, high densities of seabirds are found at sea near the islands. The oceanic areas within 100 miles of these islands provide most of the food resources that make possible the large col- onies. The south-central Pacific, as herein defined, ex- tends from 10°N to 10°S and from 150°W to 180°. Within this area are the Line Islands, the Phoenix Islands including Howland and Baker, and the Tokelau Islands. Northeast trade winds predomi- nate in the northern part of this area, and southeast trade winds predominate in the south. The narrow zone of light, variable wind between the two trade wind systems is called the doldrums. It is charac- terized by low atmospheric pressure, warm, humid air, and more abundant rainfall than in the trade wind zones. In January the doldrums are farthest south, being found at 5°N at 150°W and 5°S at 170°W. In July they are found between 5°N and 9°N (Riehl, 1954:13, fig. 1.9). The belt of high rainfall (up to 118 inches per year) moves north and south seasonally with the doldrums. The oceanographic conditions of the south-cen- tral Pacific are dominated by the equatorial cur- rent system which includes the easterly setting Equatorial Countercurrent, and the westerly setting NUMBER 158 North Equatorial and South Equatorial currents. The boundaries of these currents change seasonally and annually (Barkley, 1962). They are strongest in summer as the result of stronger and more constant trade winds. In winter the width of the currents de- creases and the surface flow is weaker. In general the North Equatorial Current is north of 9°N, the Countercurrent lies between 4°N and 9°N, and the South Equatorial Current is south of 4°N. Surface temperatures range between 26° and 29°C, and sur- face salinities between 34.4 and 35.8 parts per thou- sand. For a more thorough treatment of the ocean- ography of the area see Barkley (1962). Ashmole and Ashmole (1967) present an excellent review of the general biology of birds and their food organ- isms in the equatorial current system. The uninhabited islands of the south-central Pa- cific support large breeding seabird populations, and pelagic areas close to islands maintain high seabird densities. In addition, high seabird densi- ties are normally found along the southern bound- ary of the Equatorial Countercurrent where local 140"E 150' WO' 170'W 160" 150" 140' 130' 120' 1K>' t00 ' FIGURE 1.—Area covered by POBSP observations. 80' 70'W SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY concentrations of food organisms are caused by convergence of that current with the South Equa- torial Current (Ashmole and Ashmole, 1967:57). The eastern Pacific is herein defined as the ex- panse of ocean between 35°N and 20°S, and be- tween the American Continental coast and 135°W. Most of the islands in this area occur within 100 miles of the coast but a few are oceanic. The sur- face water conditions of this area are dominated by the California Current in the north and the Peru Current in the south. These currents, especially the latter, carry relatively low temperature surface wa- ters toward the equator. This results in cooler sur- face temperatures in this area than are found farther west at the same latitudes. METHODS AND PROCEDURES Observers maintained daily watches on ships mov- ing through areas of interest. When two or more observers were available, watches began before sun- rise and alternated every two to four hours until sunset. If only one observer was present, one- or two-hour rest periods were taken occasionally. Noc- turnal observations were made whenever possible. In no case was an inexperienced observer expected to make identifications without the supervision of an experienced observer. However, in 1963 all ob- servers were relatively inexperienced and for this reason the 1963 data (8 cruises) are included only as supplemental material in this report. All birds seen were recorded in a daily field log. The following information was included: time of sighting, identification (to species or subspecies when possible), number of birds, direction of flight, behavior, and special comments (e.g., de- scription, association with other species, fish activ- ity) . When weather conditions and ship schedules permitted, specimens were collected to verify sight identifications and to show the range of individual birds and, by inference, of whole populations. All specimens are in the collection of the National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institu- tion, Washington, D.C. Records were kept of all position fixes and of interpolated hourly positions. On a few cruises bathythermograph and other oceanographic recordings were also taken. Prelimi- nary reports were made of each trip and these, along with the raw data obtained, are on file at the National Museum of Natural History. Line transects provide the basis for data collec- tion and analysis. Densities were calculated in birds per mile (BPM) or birds per hour (BPH) . In this report only the former value is used. Since the majority of observations were made at a speed of approximately 10 knots, it is necessary only to mul- tiply all BPM figures by 10 to get an idea of BPH values. In order to store and analyze data, an electronic data processing system was designed (King, Wat- son, and Gould, 1967). This system can simultane- ously analyze data pertaining to sighting, environ- ment, and location and duration of observation. The system was programmed to calculate and list the abundance of each species. For each day of each cruise, the total diurnal miles traveled and the total number of a species seen were used to calcu- late relative densities for the entire day. All sight- ings were tied to the noon position of the ship. The BPM units were plotted by month on maps, one per month, for all data from January 1964 through April 1968. Contour lines were drawn on the maps, connecting points of equal bird density. In most cases a linear gradation of bird density was assumed between any two points (i.e., noon posi- tions) . Exceptions to this were when several posi- tions with significantly different densities (greater or less than the next contour increment) occurred within a relatively small area. This may have been because of different densities noted during a given month or a given year, or because of different den- sities noted among the four years for a given month. In such cases, the contours were drawn ac- cording to the arithmetic mean of the densities within the area. Thus, the maps represent the monthly average distribution and density for all four years. All midday positions are indicated by dots, and varying density is indicated by degrees of shading. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The following POBSP personnel and collaborators contributed observations during the course of the Program: Kenneth E. Amerman, A. Binion Amer- son, Jr., Alan H. Anderson, J. Phillip Angle, Ken- neth C. Balcomb, Frederick A. Blagden, David A. Bratley, Robert L. Brownell, Jr., Walter Buhner, David L. Burckhalter, Richard D. Chandler, Jane P. Church, Roger B. Clapp, Richard S. Crossin, NUMBER 158 Robert L. DeLong, Paul G. DuMont, Robert P. Elliott, Charles A. Ely, John H. Fitch, Robert R. Fleet, Douglas E. Gill, Patrick J. Gould, C. Doug- las Hackman, Brian A. Harrington, Richard Heiden, Norman N. Heryford, the late J. Vincent Hoeman, David I. Hoff, Lawrence N. Huber, Dayle N. Husted, Raymond R. Jillson, Cameron B. Kepler, Warren B. King, Ralph D. Kirkpatrick, Vernon M. Kleen, Philip N. Lehner, T. James Lewis, Charles R. Long, James P. Ludwig, Peter Marshall, Richard L. Maze, Robert W. McFarlane, Richard W. Merrill, David L. Pearson, Robert L. Pyle, Gerald A. Sanger, Ralph W. Schreiber, Philip C. Shelton, Fred C. Sibley, Frank H. Smith, Jr., Dennis L. Stadel, Robert S. Standen, Robert A. Sundell, F. Christian Thompson, Max C. Thomp- son, Jeffrey P. Tordoff, Michael N. Trevor, Robert Tuxson, George E. Watson, J. Douglas Whitman, Kenneth J. Wilz, William O. Wirtz, II, George S. Wislocki, and Paul W. Woodward. Reginald Creighton and Warren Minami devel- oped and operated the automatic data processing program. Anne K. Poulson prepared most of the illustrations. Mae H. Esterline gave editorial ad- vice. All work was under the direction of Philip S. Humphrey. All the observations to be presented were made by POBSP personnel as well as by many other collab- orators. On innumerable occasions logistic and technical support has been generously provided by the United States Coast Guard, the United States Navy, the Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife and Bureau of Commercial Fisheries of the U. S. Department of Interior, the State of California De- partment of Fish and Game, the State of Hawaii Division of Fish and Game, the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, and the institutions and coun- tries involved in the EASTROPAC investigations. We are grateful to all the participants who have made this series of papers possible. Sooty Tern (Sterna fuscata)* Patrick J. Gould Introduction SUMMARY OF PUBLISHED PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.— The Sooty Tern is one of the most numerous and characteristic seabirds of the tropical and subtrop- ical Pacific Ocean, occurring widely at sea during all times of the year. Birds have been recorded south to 40°S on both sides of the Pacific, and north to southern Japan and southern Baja Cali- fornia. Population estimates of breeding colonies for mid-central Pacific Islands visited by the POBSP indicate total numbers in that area to be in excess of 30 million birds (Table 1). Data from the east- ern Pacific are fewer and less precise but indicate many thousands of birds are present. Vast numbers occur throughout the Atlantic and Indian Oceans as well. Appendix Table A is a summary of published in- formation on Sooty Tern distribution in the Pa- cific Ocean. It can be seen that at-sea records are spotty, both with respect to time of year and to geographical area. It is apparent, however, that Sooty Terns range widely at sea throughout the tropical and subtropical Pacific. Morzer Bruyns (1965) found them common to abundant in No- vember within the Equatorial Countercurrent (6°- 8°N) across most of the Pacific. Although he re- corded the largest numbers near islands and coastal areas, he found them most consistently, on a day- to-day basis, across the large open stretch between 145°W and 115°W. King and Pyle (1957) found these terns most abundant near islands and coastal areas. They observed birds only sporadically along the northern edge of the Equatorial Countercur- Palrick J. Gould, Department of Zoology, University of Ari- zona, Tucson, Arizona 85721. • Paper Number 68, Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Pro- gram, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. rent (ca. 10° N) in November between 156°W and 120°W, and from mid-October to mid-November between Manzanillo, Mexico, and the Marquesas Islands. In early December they recorded Sooty Terns every day between the Marquesas and the Line Islands. Distributional extremes in the south Pacific are represented by one specimen from Rio Valdivia, Chile, ca. 40°S (Murphy, 1936:1132) and three records along the Wellington coast of New Zealand, ca. 40°S (Falla, et al., 1967:165). In the north Pa- cific extreme records are from: the Alijos Rocks, ca. 25°N (McLellan, 1926:283), north of the leeward Hawaiian Islands, ca. 33°N (POBSP) , and Japan, 35° N (Austin and Kuroda, 1953:450-451). Factors influencing Sooty Tern distribution (e.g., feeding habits) have been studied by Ashmole (1963a), and Ashmole and Ashmole (1967). In the latter study they found that these terns fed mainly on fish and squid between 2 and 8 centi- meters in length. They suggest that Sooty Terns are capable of utilizing food sources up to 700 miles from breeding islands, and that Christmas Island birds often feed at great distances from land during the breeding season. Nocturnal feeding has been documented by Morzer Bruyns and Voous (1965) and by Gould (1967). BREEDING PHENOLOGY.—At-sea distribution and densities of Sooty Terns are greatly influenced by the timing of breeding activities. A brief summary of these activities is thus necessary to the under- standing of data presented later in this paper. Sooty Terns breed, or have bred, on almost all islands in the tropical and subtropical Pacific be- tween latitudes 29°N and 32°S. The timing of the breeding cycle is apparently quite variable (Hutch- inson, 1950; Chapin, 1954; Ashmole, 1963a). For colonies within the Hawaiian Islands the breeding NUMBER 158 TABLE 1.— Maximum number of Sooty Terns recorded on islands in the central and eastern Pacific Island CENTRAL PACIFIC Hawaiian-Leeward Kure Midway Number 48,000 353,000 Pearl and Hermes Reef 40,110 Lisianski Laysan Gardner Pinnacles French Frigate Shoals Necker N'ihoa Moku Manu Manana Johnston Atoll Line Islands Palmyra Fanning Christmas Jan is Maiden Starbuck Caroline Phoenix Islands Canton Enderbury McKean Phoenix Birnie Hull Howland Wake Marshall Islands Taongi Bikar Taka Eniwetok Ailinginae Jaluit EASTERN PACIFIC Isabel Revilla Gigedos Clipperton IslasFrailesdelSur Cocos Culpepper 1,000,000 2,000,000 1,000 250,000 50,000 100,000 20,000 200,000 600,000 750,000 thousands 15,000,000 1,900,000 10,000 3,000,000 500,000 100 400,000 250,000 250,000 1300 3,000,000 375,000 1,750,000 20,000 7300 60,000 16,000 5,000 30 thousands thousands 2,000 200 30 thousands San Felix large numbers Source POBSP •• " *• " •• " " Amerson, 1969:23 Amerson, 1969:37 Amerson, 1969:50-51 Amerson, 1969:116 Amerson, 1969:141 Amerson, 1969:196 McLellan, 1926:283 Gifford, 1913:20 Stager, 1964:365 Wetmore, 1965:457 Hundley, 1962:114 Leveque, 1964a:39-40 Millie, 1963:566 cycle is annual and regular, the dates of peak lay- ing generally falling within the same four-week period in most years. Dates of egg-laying, however, occur progressively later on the chain from Oahu northwestward to Kure Atoll. On Manana, close to Oahu, the peak of egg-laying occurs during the last week in March or the first week in April. On Kure, at the northwestern end of the leeward Hawaiian chain, egg-laying begins in May. On Johnston Atoll the peak of egg-laying comes in the middle of March. Birds first appear over the island at night, nearly three months prior to the time of laying. Numbers swirling over the island at night build up gradually to the time of egg-laying, when birds are present throughout the day as well. Maximum numbers on, or over, the island coincide with the hatching peak in the middle of April. Most fledging takes place in June. Fledglings gen- erally leave the island by the first of August, and most adults leave by the end of August. The John- ston population is composed of approximately 300,000 breeding birds, and a roughly equivalent number of subadults and nonbreeding adults. The relative proportion of subadults and nonbreeders to breeding adults increases from June to the end of the cycle. Sooty Terns are virtually absent from Johnston Atoll from mid-September to the end of December (Shdton, in. prep.). In the Line island group, the breeding cycle ap- pears to be semiannual. Birds that successfully rear a chick breed again in 12 months, but those that fail nest again in only 6 months. The egg-laying peaks are in December and June. This cycle has been documented on Christmas Island by Ashmole (1965) and appears to hold true for other islands of that chain as well, although there may be excep- tions or complicating factors in some populations. The timing of the breeding cycles of Sooty Terns on Wake Island, and in the Phoenix, Marshall, and Gilbert chains, and on islands in the eastern Pa- cific is not understood. Some islands may have two or more individual colonies, each breeding at dif- ferent times. Many may have a non-annual cycle. A discussion of breeding cycles and associated prob- lems may be found in Ashmole (1963a). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.—I would like to give special credit to Warren B. King and Gerald A. Sanger who have worked with me in analyzing all at-sea bird data obtained by the POBSP and Philip C. Shelton who has provided data and comments on the popu- lation dynamics of Sooty Terns on breeding islands. Charles A. Sklar plotted the majority of the noon positions on the maps, and Helen H. Quinn typed the final draft. SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY TABLE 2.—Sample size of POBSP Sooty Tern observations Observation Sightings Birds 1964 1965 1966 Total 1,547 19,070 1,665 20,738 782 11,287 3,994 51,095 I am indebted to William B. Robertson, Jr., and George E. Watson for their critical reading of the manuscript and their many helpful suggestions. The many POBSP personnel and various cooperat- ors without whose observations and help this paper could not have been written have already been ac- knowledged in the Introduction. Behavior In this section all data, except when specifically stated otherwise, were collected within the follow- ing parameters: (1) at sea over 50 miles from land, (2) within approximately three-fourths mile of the ship, (3) in the north-central Pacific Ocean, (4) from 1964 through 1966, (5) from diurnal observa- tions (sunrise to sunset). These parameters have been purposely chosen. Observations near land have been excluded because it was often impossible to get a clear idea of what was happening when birds were "too numerous to count": birds seem to be everywhere, moving in all directions, joining groups, leaving groups, flying high, flying low, etc. In such situations it was impossible to follow indi- vidual birds or flocks, or to understand behavioral patterns and interactions. The parameter of three- fourths mile from the ship was chosen because, al- though Sooty Tern flocks could be seen at greater distances, they could not be counted accurately, nor could they be observed well enough for behavioral studies beyond that distance. Moreover, single birds cannot be observed at greater distances so that the inclusion of distant birds would over-emphasize ef- lects created by flocking. The north-central Pacific was the most uniformly covered large area, and had by far the largest number of observations made within it; also, Sooty Terns breeding in this area have an annual rather than semiannual cycle. Only the years 1964, 1965, and 1966 were included be- cause of the spottiness of coverage in the north- central Pacific during other years. Within these parameters a total of 51,095 birds in 3994 sightings was recorded (Table 2). At this point it seems advisable to define a few special terms which will be used in the following discussion. A "sighting" refers to a single bird or two or more birds acting as a unit. A "flock" is con- sidered to be the association of five or more indi- viduals, "BPS" (birds/sighting) is a good index of the gregariousness or flocking tendency of a species. A "mixed" flock or sighting is one that contains more than one species, while a "pure" flock or sighting is one which contains only one species. "Searching" birds are those actively hunting for food, while "traveling" birds appear to be moving towards a specific goal. FEEDING.—Ashmole and Ashmole (1967) have discussed the feeding ecology of Sooty Terns, con- sidering particularly the kind of food taken and how it is captured. Our observations are in general agreement with theirs. Sooty Terns, searching for food, generally remain from 10 to 20 meters above the water surface. When the food source appears, they descend, simultaneously, and begin wheeling rapidly and erratically in circles. At this time there does not appear to be any coordination between individuals within a flock, although small groups may act in unison for short periods. When the food source descends, the flock rises to its original posi- tion and follows until the food returns to the sur- face or until it disappears. In a feeding flock work- ing over a large area, terns in one section may be flying high, following locally deep food, while those in another section may be low and actively feeding. "Air dipping" and "contact dipping" (Ashmole and Ashmole, 1967) appear to be the preferred feeding techniques, although "plunge to surface" is frequently used if the food source remains near but under the surface. The latter technique has been recorded only once in the Sooty Tern literature (Watson and Lashley, 1915). In POBSP observa- tions, the "plunge to surface," although actually causing the water to splash up and obscure the bird momentarily, is never powerful, nor is it made from any great height. It never results in complete submergence of the bird, nor do the wings ever ap- pear to cease beating. The feet do not seem to be utilized. FLOCKING.—Sooty Terns were recorded in sight- ings of from 1 to 3000 individuals. The overall BPS ratio was 13, the highest value for any seabird NUMBER 158 TABLE 3.—Percent of sightings and numbers of Sooty Terns in different sighting classes Birds per sighting 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10+ 1-4 5-55 56-105 106+ Percent of all sightings 1964 36 20 9 4 3 3 1 1 1 22 69 25 4 2 1965 15 21 9 5 4 2 1 1 1 21 70 ?4 4 2 1966 1? 21 10 6 4 3 1 ? 1 20 69 3 1 mean 35 21 9 5 4 2 1 1 1 21 70 25 4 2 Percent of all birds 1964 3 3 2 0.5 86.5 9 37 27 26 1965 1 3 2 2 ? 1 1 1 1 84 10 3"> 27 28 1966 ? 3 2 2 86 9 in 16 45 mean 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 85 10 15 24 31 species regularly feeding over 50 miles from land. Although 90 percent of all individuals were found in flocks, flocks comprised only 30 percent of the sightings in all years. Indeed, sightings of single birds (35 percent) far outnumbered sightings of any other group size. Singles and groups of two ac- 120 100 80 60 40 20 counted for 56 percent of all sightings (Table 3). The POBSP data agree with Ashmole and Ash- mole's (1967:97) statement that "most tropical sea birds depend partly or entirely on schools of preda- tory fish (mainly tunas) to drive their prey close to the surface and so make it available." Although Sooty Terns have been observed feeding in the absence of predatory fish, many actively feeding flocks were directly associated with such schools. The sudden, and often relatively short-term, ap- pearance of feeding tuna apparently places a pre- mium on the ability of Sooty Terns to join feeding flocks containing other species. Seventy-seven per- cent of all Sooty Terns, and 24 percent of all Sooty Tern sightings, were associated with one or more seabird species (Table 4) . Almost all species nor- mally occurring in the area were involved, but the degree of their involvement was related to their gregariousness and their status within the area. For example, 70.6 percent of all mixed flocks containing Sooty Terns also contained Wedge-tailed Shear- waters (Puffinus pacificus). Conversely, King (p. 65, herein) found that 77 percent of all mixed flocks containing Wedge-tails contained Sooty Terns. Wedge-tails are the next most abundant species in the area and have a high BPS ratio (King, p. 64 herein). On the other hand, Sooty Shearwa- V VV — V V V i , . ^ VV V VV VV rfV VV VV £/ > r" ^ FIGURE 2.—Schematic representation of a mixed feeding flock showing the general stratification of selected species and their general pattern of movement while feeding. 10 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY TABLE 4.—Percent of association of Sooty Terns zoith other seabird species, 1964-1966 Species Puffinus pacificus Pterodroma externa . . . . Gygis alba Pterodroma nigripennis.. Fregata minor Puffinus griseus Anous stolidus Puffinus puffinus Sula sula Bulweria bulwerii Pterodroma neglecta . . . . Sula dactylatra Puffinus nativitatis Phaethon rubricauda ... Oceanodroma leucorhoa . Sterna lunata Stercorarius pomarinus .. Puffinus carneipes Pterodroma alba Pterodroma phaeopygia.. Stercorarius longicaudus. Fregata oriel Pterodroma hypoleuca .. Phaethon lepturus Puffinus bulleri Puffinus Iherminieri Puffinus tenuirostris . . . . Pterodroma inexpectata . Sula leucogaster Catharacta species Anous tenuirostris All sightings 16.4 7.4 4.8 S.9 3.3 1.1 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 Mixed Sightings 70.6 32.0 20.8 16.8 14.2 4.5 4.4 4.3 4.1 2.8 2.8 2.5 2.3 2.2 1.8 1.5 1.2 1.0 1.0 0.6 0.6 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2 General at-sea status abundant most of the year common summer and fall uncommon throughout year common summer and fall uncommon throughout year abundant spring and fall migrant rare throughout year uncommon spring, summer and fall common winter uncommon spring, summer and fall uncommon throughout year common winter uncommon spring, summer and fall common throughout year abundant winter uncommon spring, summer, and fall uncommon spring and fall migrant rare spring and fall migrant rare throughout year rare summer and fall rare spring and fall migrant rare throughout year rare throughout year uncommon throughout year rare spring and fall migrant rare throughout year abundant fall migrant uncommon spring and fall migrant rare throughout year rare spring and fall migrant rare throughout year ters (Puffinus griseus) were abundant at certain seasons and had a high BPS ratio, but were found in •only 4.5 percent of all mixed flocks containing Sooty Terns. This difference between two highly flocking and abundant species is explained by the fact that Wedge-tails are resident in the area while Sooty Shearwaters are primarily passing through on migration and rarely stop to feed. The association of Sooty Terns with other sea- bird species appears to be mainly one of a common interest in the same food source. While within mixed feeding flocks, Sooty Terns maintain a defi- nite spatial position in accord with the feeding abilities and techniques of all species involved. (Figure 2) . We have a number of records of Sooty Terns be- ing harrassed by Pomarine Jaegers (Stercorarius pomarinus), Long-tailed Jaegers (Stercorarius longicaudus), Great Frigatebirds (Fregata minor), and Lesser Frigatebirds (Fregata ariel). The largest Sooty Tern flock ever recorded by the POBSP occurred on 20 May 1966, some 200 miles south of Oahu. On this day a feeding flock of 4300+ birds, including Wedge-tailed Shearwaters, Pale-footed Shearwaters (Puffinus carneipes), Christmas Shearwaters (Puffinus nativitatis), Manx Shearwaters (Puffinus puffinus), Bulwer's Petrels (Bulweria bulwerii), Great Frigatebirds, Brown Noddy Terns (Anous stolidus), Black Noddy Terns (Anous tenuirostris), and 3000+ Sooty Terns was observed. The birds were concentrated over eight to twelve Fin-backed Whales (Balaenoptera physalus) and about 200 porpoises. The fringes of the flock stretched for approximately three miles. NUMBER 158 11 Although we have no direct information on how much time individual birds spend feeding, search- ing, or traveling, the fact that the great majority of all birds observed were in mixed flocks, usually an indication of current or recent feeding, suggests that the greatest percent of their time is spent feed- ing or actively searching for food, with the former outweighing the latter. There is certainly a tend- ency for Sooty Terns to occur in larger flocks while feeding (Table 5) . Our observations indi- cate that mixed, nonfeeding groups are composed mostly of searching birds. Pure, nonfeeding groups may be either searching or traveling; the activity cannot always be determined. Pure flocks of up to 140 birds and mixed flocks of up to 125 birds have been recorded traveling. Single birds and small groups have been observed both searching (moving slowly, dropping occasionally to the water surface, and investigating other birds in the water), and traveling. The distinction between searching and traveling, however, sometimes breaks down (trav- eling birds may stop to feed if the stimulus is strong enough), or it is sometimes even meaningless (many traveling birds may be headed for a distant feeding flock). It was difficult to obtain direct evidence on how flocks form, how long they are maintained, and what happens when the food source being utilized disappears. In discussing the feeding behavior of Brown Noddies and Sooty Terns, Watson (1908: 193) wrote: "The birds feed singly or in groups, usually in groups. The group may be composed of both noddies and sooties and may contain some- times as many as 50 to 100 individuals. All during the day groups of noddies and sooties may be seen at work. As the minnows cease to jump above the surface of the water, the group disbands and scat- ters in every direction. An instant later, as an at- tack is made upon the minnows in some other lo- cality, the birds immediately rush there and renew their feeding." POBSP observations include a num- ber of isolated observations documenting various stages in this process. The following entries, with annotations enclosed in brackets, are abstracted from the POBSP original daily log sheets. They are arranged in a subjective order from "searching" birds through "feeding" birds (including birds trav- eling toward already formed feeding flocks), to flocks "breaking up." TABLE 5.—Total Sooty Tern sightings and numbers in mixed and pure, feeding and nonfeeding, situ- ations Situation Mixed Feeding .. Nonfeeding Pure Feeding .. Nonfeeding Mixed Feeding . . Nonfeeding Pure Feeding .. Nonfeeding Mixed Feeding .. Nonfeeding Pure Feeding .. Nonfeeding 1964 1965 1966 Mean Percentage of sightings 14 8 2 14 10 2 14 8 5 14 9 3 75 74 74 74 PerCe«»=><*** nt total numtv»r* 58 16 6 18 51 24 33 3 54 24 3 19 BPS 48 30 22 3 69 8 10 13 ratio 70 16 28 3 59 18 6 18 53 25 28 3 SEARCHING 05 March 1964. 0700 Hours. 16°48'N, 169°06'W. 3 ST [Sooty Terns], [flying at] ca. 30-40 feet. One bird separated and circled a dead albatross in the water, then joined other two. 08 March 1964. 1103 Hours. 14°50'N, 169°40/W. 1 ST. Investigated downed [dead in water] albatross and continued NE. 07 June 1964. 1441 Hours. 18°11'N, 166°10'W. 2 ST. One shot [ship circled to retrieve downed bird]. At 1450 Hrs. 12 ST circled and looked over downed bird. 02 April 1964. 1612 Hours. 20°41'N, 159°ITW. 2 ST flying SW joined and drded with 6 ST circling at 1615 Hrs., then all 8 departed SW. No feeding was ob- served. 04 July 1964. 0600 Hours. 16°40'N, 169° 1 8 ^ . Hock of 26 ST and 1 WTS [Wedge-tailed Shearwater]. Original group of 14 joined by 6 then 6 more. Birds were not actively feeding but flew around as if food were near by. FEEDING 10 May 1964. 1900 Hours. 15°04'N, 170°37'W. 30 ± ST. Very high, maybe 1000 feet up. Some of them seem to be gathering to move on, but then descend sud- 12 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY denly as feeding flock. Big fish, probably tuna 5' or more long and some about 3' long jump at least 6' clear of water. 22 July 1964. 1110 Hours. 18°46'N, 150°59'W. Feeding flock containing 90± ST, 2 WTS, 8 JFP [Juan Fernandez Petrel, Pterodroma externa], 1 W'T [White Tern, Gygis alba]. Three separate groups joined up, each with about 30 ST. 11 March 1964. 1656 Hours. Near Johnston Atoll. Feeding flock in formation started with 4 birds on their way south starting to circle and dive. Within minutes, 8 other Sooties came in, seemingly from all directions to join them. No fish action noted and feeding over area of about 14 mile length (or diameter). [Ship continuing to move at ca. 8 knots.] 1700 Hours: 25+ ST moving low towards above flock. 1702 Hours: 40 ± ST at ca. 50' mov- ing to join above? 1702 Hours: 10 ± ST low, moving right under above. 1705 Hours: 2 ST moving low toward above flock. 18 May 1965. 1500 Hours. 20°14'N, 154°02'W. Feeding flock of 50 ST, 8 WTS, and two unidentified shearwaters or petrels. Original flock of 20 joined by 10 individuals and then by group of 25 or so. 06 September 1964. 1645 Hours. 17°34'N, 167°03'W. 30 ± ST, 8 WTS, 1 GFB [Great Frigatebird]. Feeding over fish jumping out of water. 1640 Hours: 13 ST at 50' going to above flock. 1646 Hours: 10 ST, 1 GFB, circling. 1648 Hours: 11 ST flying towards 1645 flock. 1656 Hours: 8 ST flying towards 1645 flock. 12 May 1964. 0715 Hours. 15°30'N, 171°33'W. Flock of 55 ±1 ST and 3 WTS. Actively feeding. Large tuna-type fish jumping under flock. Flock was originally only of about 30 birds but soon increased to final num- ber. At one point flock broke up into two groups, one of about 25, the other about 30. One group was soaring around high on port side of ship, the other was low, flying on starboard. BREAKING UP 11 April 1964. 0825 Hours. 15°07'N, 171°24'W. 16±2 ST feeding. 3 birds left flock as we approached. 18 July 1964. 0905 Hours. 21°48'N, 162°27'W. Flock of 50 ±10 ST, 6 WTS, 2 BFB [Blue-faced Booby, Sula dactylatra], 1 WT, 1 GFB, feeding—but breaking up into small groups. 091") Hours: flock of 30 ST, 10 WTS, 1 RFB [Red-footed Booby, Sula sula], 2 CIS [Christmas Shearwater], and 1 WT, undoubtedly was once part of last flock; we saw birds from last flock join this one. 13 May 1964. 1705 Hours. 16°25'N, 17O°51'W. 17 ST, 5 to 50' [above water]. Not feeding, but appar- ently looking for food source—group tended to split up but constant movement was to E[ast]. Most shearwaters and gadfly petrels tend to sit on the water in either compact or loose aggrega- tions after heavy feeding. It is well known, how- ever, that Sooty Terns are incapable of spending long periods in such a fashion (Watson and Lash- ley, 1915:39-41). Sooty Terns do, however, alight occasionally at sea, either on a floating object or actually on the water. All such POBSP records are listed below. Omitting the bird knocked down by shot and the three sitting on turtles or flotsam, 0.3 percent of all sightings and 0.16 percent of all individuals recorded by the POBSP were on the water. These estimates, however, are undoubtedly low since most birds tend to rise before they can be detected. 19 August 1965. 0920 Hours. 13°53'N, 173°01'W. One Sooty Tern was knocked down by shotgun blast and sat in the water for 12 minutes then flew at the approach of the ship. 23 October 1965. 0940 Hours. 01°16'S, 173°38'W. One adult and one immature Sooty together on water, immature being fed by the adult. 23 October 1965. 1730 Hours. 02°00'S, 172°52'W. One adult, one immature were collected while sitting on the water. 10 November 1965. 17°5rN, 164°09'W. In a feeding flock containing ca. 15 Sooty Terns (at least four being immature), one adult and one young were noted as "on water together." September-October 1964. "Three different times during the trip I saw Sooty Terns sitting on the water. A total of 6 birds were observed, always in twos. Each pair contained an immature bird and an adult. In one case both the immature and the adult were observed on the water. In the other two cases just the immature was on the water with the adult hov- ering overhead. In all cases the birds flew off as the ship approached. I never saw them land on the water so I can't say how long they stayed there. The longest I ob- served them was about 5 seconds." (POBSP, Robert Standen) 12 May 1965. 0744 Hours. 16°44'N, 162°16'W. 10 and 25 Sooty Terns. "Two separate flocks sitting on the water. They were gliding around and at first ap- peared to be Wedge-tails from their flight pattern. Birds were flying and then sitting down again. They were not feeding." 01 September 1967. 0930 Hours. 01°44'N, 98°04'W. 75 ± ST. All adults, seemed to have fresh plumage. Most circling high 200'±, some close to water. About 8 of them were sitting on the water. 14 June 1967. 1425 Hours. (Atlantic Ocean) 12°42'N, 81°06'W. 2 adult ST sitting on water with wings closed—quite happy 10-15 seconds that I saw. (POBSP, Richard Chan- dler) February 1968. "On February 13 both shipboard observers saw a single flock of 22 adult Sooty Terns resting on the water about 10 miles south of Johnston. When first seen all were to- gether on the water spaced two to six feet apart. As the ship aproached two or three birds rose off the water and NUMBER 158 began hovering over the remaining 20. These remained on the water for at least another minute before the ship scared them into flight. The time lapse between the lust sighting and flushing was about two minutes, but it was obvious that the birds had been there quite a bit longer." (POBSI\ Brian Harrington) 07 July 1967. 0955 Hours. 18°35'N, 104°53'W. One Sooty Tern sitting on a turtle. 10 July 1967. 1433 Hours. 17°O8'N, 101°05'VV. One Sooty Tern standing on head of turtle. 18 August 1966. 1713 Hours. 32°06'N, 163°42'W. One adult Sooty Tern sitting on fish ball [float]. DISCUSSION.—Sooty Terns occur over the entire pelagic area of the north-central Pacific. They are distributed primarily as singles and small groups interspersed with a few small flocks and even fewer large flocks. Over 90 percent of all individuals, however, are found in flocks. The degree of flock- ing is probably greatest in areas of food abundance. Single birds and small groups generally appear to be searching. Their flight is usually slow, indirect, and often high above the water. They frequently drop to just above the surface, apparently investi- gating possible food items. When available food is spotted the bird or birds descend and begin feed- ing. This change in behavior pattern is distinct and easily recognizable to the human eye. Other birds within visual range probably can detect and identify the new pattern and are attracted to it. Birds heading towards a feeding flock fly in a rela- tively fast and direct manner distinct from that of searching birds. It is possible that this type of flight may provide a clue to other birds which were not aware of the newly formed feeding flock. Similar behavioral differences are also found in other flock- ing seabirds (e.g., Wedge-tailed Shearwaters) and it seems probable that Sooty Terns could recognize such behavioral changes in other species and act accordingly. As a feeding flock grows it becomes visible to more distant birds. The eventual size of the flock would thus be controlled, primarily, by the length of time that food is available. The total number of terns within range of the food supply would, however, have a restricting effect, since distant birds might be hard put to detect the presence of food and to reach it before it disappeared. When the food source disappears, Sooty Terns rise high into the air and disperse, either by fragmenting into two or more smaller groups each going in a separate direction, or by all going in the same direction but becoming widely separated. Subse- quent fragmentation of groups or continued sepa- ration of individuals may eventually result in the dispersal of all birds over the ocean as individuals. If another food source is discovered before a flock has fragmented or separated completely, the group, whatever size it has been reduced to, becomes the nucleus of a new feeding flock. As the length of time between feedings increases, sightings of single birds should increase since flocks would have had more time to disperse. The relative frequency of sightings of single birds, as opposed to sightings of groups, should thus provide an estimate of food availability and tuna school density in a given pelagic area. Distribution and Abundance Figures 17-28 (pp. 34-45) summarize monthly POBSP Sooty Tern sightings in the Pacific Ocean. They attempt to show gross distributional patterns and in most cases tend to de-emphasize local or short-term variations. Only at-sea sightings are in- cluded, although these may include sightings within a few miles of land. Sightings cover the period January 1964 through April 1968, and con- tour lines are drawn without regard to year. Den- sities are recorded in BPM units. NORTH-CENTRAL PACIFIC.—Sooty Terns are pres- ent in the north-central Pacific throughout the year. At least one bird was recorded during 74.5 percent of all days of observation from 1964 through 1966. Only during January 1964, Decem- ber 1965, and August 1966, were birds seen on fewer than 50 percent of all observation days (Figure 3). Densities throughout the year ranged from a low of 0.0 BPM to a high of 54.5 BPM. Densities greater than 10.0 BPM were uncommon and, with one ex- ception, always occurred within 50 miles of land. This exception, however, was the second highest density ever recorded within the study area (27.1 BPM). The highest density figure, 54.5 BPM, is some- what unreliable since observations on that day covered only four miles and lasted somewhat less than one hour (Table 6). With the fledging of chicks in August, Sooty Tern numbers near islands decrease markedly. Lowest maximum densities near the Hawaiian Is- lands and Johnston Atoll occurred in October 14 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 100 90 80 70 60 t 8 50 I 40 30 20 10 Average J F M A M J J A S O N D 63 59 83 115 77 99 66 76 58 72 79 77 Days of Observation FIGURE 3.—Percent of observation days on which one or more Sooty Terns were recorded in the north-central Pacific during 1964-1966. (Table 7). In the area as a whole, however, den- sities were lowest in November and December, even though densities near the Hawaiian Islands and Johnston Atoll increased slightly. Densities over 50 miles from land began increasing in June with an influx of newly fledged birds. From June through November, immature birds became in- creasingly abundant and wide-spread throughout the north Pacific. We have a few records which indicate that newly fledged birds accompany their parents when they leave the breeding colony, i.e., the six sightings of an adult and immature sitting on the water listed in the behavior section. The record of an adult feeding an immature over 100 miles from land on 23 October 1965 is certainly conclusive. Increasing densities in January and February, particularly near breeding islands, were the result of birds returning to these islands for the next breeding season. From September through Decem- ber, and especially during September and October, densities in areas over 50 miles from land were generally greater than those within 50 miles. This was particularly noticeable in two widely separated areas where at-sea densities reached as high as 9.0 BPM. The first area was 200-300 miles west-south- west of Oahu. This is apparently a rich feeding area favored by many species of seabirds, particu- NUMBER 158 15 TABLE 6.—Date and location of all Sooty Tern densities of 10.0 or greater BPM recorded within the north-central Pacific, 1964-1966 (Observation = within 50 miles of "Location") TABLE 7.—Maximum Sooty Tern densities (BPM) in the north-central Pacific Density (BPM) 10.0 10.2 10.4 10.9 11.0 11.5 11.8 12.4 12.8 12.9 14.5 16.1 23.2 26.9 27.1 54.5 Location Oahu Johnston Atoll Oahu Oahu French Frigate Shoals Oahu Laysan Johnston Atoll Oahu Johnston A toil Laysan Johnston Atoll Lisianski Oahu at-sea, 17°54'N, 158°48'W Oahu Date 6 Jun 5 Jun 5 Jul 5 Jun 17 Jun 4 May 20 Jun 13 Apr 13 Jul 31 Jan 5 Aug 5 Jul 14 Jul 31 May 20 May 2 Jul 66 66 66 64 64 65 66 65 64 66 65 65 65 65 66 65 Miles of observation 28 141 23 73 108 40 39 117 51 22 80 127 33 104 117 4 larly those breeding in the leeward and main Hawaiian Islands. The second was 700-800 miles south-southeast of Oahu. This area may be occu- pied by birds from more southerly breeding locali- ties (e.g., Line Islands) as suggested by King (1970:54), although it is somewhat north of the Equatorial Gountercurrent which Ashmole and Ashmole (1967:66) considered a likely feeding ground for Christmas Island birds. During this winter period, a strange pattern of occurrence was found in the area between 50 and 300 miles southwest of Johnston Atoll. During the day, Sooty Tern densities decreased through No- vember and December to a low of 0.0 BPM in January, and then increased again in February. Nocturnal observations in the same area, on the other hand, revealed few terns in November and December, but large numbers in January and February. This occurred in all three successive years of our investigations in this area (Table 8). Nocturnal counts were primarily of birds heard near the ship. Densities listed in Table 8 are con- servative, particularly with respect to diurnal sight- ings, since birds can be seen at greater distances than they can be heard. Although Sooty Terns are often attracted to the ship's lights, particularly on Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Near Near 50+ miles Hawaiian I. Johnston Atoll from land 4.8 6.7 6.9 5.6 26.9 11.8 54.5 14.5 1.0 0.1 1.0 1.5 12.9 5.0 7.9 12.4 7.2 10.2 16.1 2.8 3.5 02 1.3 2.3 4.9 6.7 8.0 6.4 27.1 3.9 9.4 8.0 9.0 7.1 2.6 5.0 TABLE 8.—Winter Sooty Tern densities 50-300 miles southwest of Johnston Atoll, 1963—1967 Year 1963-1964 1964-1965 1965-1966 1966-1967 Mean 1963-1964 1964-1965 1965-1966 1966-1967 Mean Nov Dec Jan Feb Birds per 100 miles of diurnal observations 23 1 0 1 1 17 0 0 32 3 14 1 10 8 0 0 0 8 41 20 Birds per 100 miles of nocturnal observations 2 0* 2 # 0# 13 9 1 2 » 2 0 5 3 62 5 32 30 23 47 40 •Months in which less than 100 miles of observations were made. stormy nights, they are still difficult to observe. The chances of counting the same birds twice are much greater at night than during the day. In this case, however, most of the nocturnal birds appeared to be traveling in a specific direction, rather than circling the ship, thus reducing the chances of duplicate recording. Two additional features were also apparent. First, there was a definite nocturnal activity cycle. Sooty Terns were first heard about an hour after sunset and increased in numbers to maximum 16 6 5 r u s IEi3 2 1 - - - - - m Ii m11n1 II i1 1I1 sXXS I ii1i I i I !iIi g j JAN. - FEB. [ | NOV. - DEC. SUNRISE-0617-0790 SUNSET -1749 1912 I I1 IIi w I1m1 1100 19-20 20 21 21-22 22-23 23-24 24-01 01-02 02 03 03-04 04-05 OJ-04 0600 to to 1 9 0 0 HOURLY PERIODS 0700 FIGURE 4.—Nocturnal abundance cycle for Sooty Terns from 50 to 300 miles southwest of Johnston Atoll during 1963- 1967. densities between 2200 and 0200 hours. Numbers then declined to zero about an hour before sun- rise (Figure 4). This was especially noticeable in January and February, but was also true in No- vember and December. Second, a majority of the nocturnal terns heard south and west of Johnston Atoll was apparently moving north and northwest towards the atoll, or towards other breeding islands farther north and northwest in the Leewards. The number moving in southerly directions was almost nil. Unfortunately, adequate records for nocturnal direction of movement are available only for Jan- uary and February of 1966 (Figure 5). A similar nocturnal-diurnal pattern occurred on the breeding island at Johnston Atoll. Lowest numbers of Sooty Terns occurred in October and November when only a few individuals and small flocks visited the island briefly and irregularly. These were probably wandering pelagic birds that happened to pass the island and were temporarily attracted to it, primarily at night or just at dusk. They rarely landed on the island. Potential breed- ing birds were first observed at the island between late November (1964—1965) and late December SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY (1963). In 1966 flocks first occurred near the island during the first two weeks of December. These birds first gathered offshore at night, then began settling on the island in small groups. These groups grew until much of the land was occupied. This development took several weeks, generally lasting through mid-February, during which no more than a few wandering birds were over the island during the day. All of those on the ground at night left shortly before dawn. Finally, the birds began to stay on the island during the day, after which courtship and egg laying followed in quick succes- sion (POBSP, Philip Shelton). Sooty Terns occurred within 50 miles of the atoll in fair numbers during the day throughout this period, especially in Jan- uary and February. Several causative and perhaps interrelated factors have been suggested to explain the day-night differ- ences in January-February densities. Although none of these explanations is complete in itself, one or more may provide part of the answer. 1. At this time of year Johnston birds are known to avoid land during the day, and to be attracted to it at night. Birds may react toward ships in the same way, thus avoiding diurnal detection at sea. 2. Sooty Tern migration may be rapid and noc- turnal. Birds may "pile up" in preferred feeding areas during the day and complete the last leg of their migration in a single night. 3. Most Sooty Terns may remain within 50 miles of Johnston during the day even though they avoid close approach to land. 4. The area southwest of Johnston is probably very poor in available food. Terns leaving John- ston before dawn may pass through the area before sunrise and return through the area after sunset. A lack of food would deter them from pausing within the area. 5. The January and February nocturnal aggre- gations may represent prebreeding swirls from Johnston Atoll. W. B. Robertson of the National Park Service (pers. comm.) informs me that early prebreeding swirls at the Tortugas often do not seem to be oriented toward the colony site. Instead they may occur anywhere around the general area and, quite possibly, well outside the area. Although egg-laying commences in late February on Johnston Atoll, at-sea densities of Sooty Terns continued to increase through March in the sur- rounding waters. This was consistent with a con- NUMBER 158 17 169°3O' 16°45' •Jr ^ 9 Johnston A Atoll WIND Total °h for 271 bird* . = 24OO position Avg. 16 knots 5 1 2 7 8 1 FIGURE 5.—Nocturnal flight directions for Sooty Terns southwest of Johnston Atoll during Janu- ary-February 1966. (Arrows indicate direction in percent, numbers indicate sample size.) tinued increase of birds on the island. Maximum island and at-sea densities were generally main- tained through July, although some terns began leaving Johnston Atoll in early June. During the northern summer, densities in the 1-5 BPM range were common over 50 miles from land, and ranged from 0.0-8.0 BPM. Densities up to at least 26.9 BPM were recorded within 50 miles of the breeding islands at this time. The largest single concentration of Sooty Terns recorded by the POBSP north of the equator, however, occurred on 20 May 1966, at 17°54'N, 158°48'W, some 200 miles south of Oahu. Repeated observations to the northeast of the Hawaiian Islands illustrate the seasonal expansion and contraction of Sooty Tern distributional limits in the north central Pacific (Figure 6). During the nonbreeding season, in particular November-De- cember, birds were rarely recorded over 100 miles northeast of Hawaii. With the return of the birds and the beginning of nesting activities (March- April), distributional limits were extended, and by July-August, when chicks were being fed, birds were found up to 600 miles northeast of Hawaii. The northernmost sighting in the central Pacific was of two adult-plumaged birds recorded at 33° 06'N, 164°08/W on 9 August 1966. To summarize, at-sea densities of Sooty Terns in the north-central Pacific Ocean are reflections of breeding island densities. The annual cycle is repre- sented by a fairly smooth curve, with lowest den- sity in November-December and highest density in June (Figure 7). To clarify the distributional patterns of birds 18 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 160' FIGURE 6.—Seasonal variation in the distributional limits of Sooty Terns northeast of the Hawaiian Islands. within the central Pacific, the POBSP initiated an intensive banding program. Since March 1963, over 1,200,000 Sooty Terns have been banded. These include birds from nearly all major breeding col- onies on the main and leeward Hawaiian, Line, and Phoenix (including Howland) island groups, as well as on Johnston and Wake atolls. Greatest numbers have been banded on Johnston (over 250,000), Laysan (over 130,000), and Howland (over 100,000). Colored vinyl leg streamers were also placed on birds from Johnston (orange) and How- land (blue). A special effort was made on all POBSP field trips, both at sea and on islands, to look for streamered and banded birds. In addition, a pro- gram of intensive advertisement of our efforts, including appeals for help in locating banded and streamered birds, was made throughout the in- habitated areas of the tropical and subtropical Pacific. As of December 1968, we have processed 1027 interisland and at-sea recoveries and 339 at-sea streamer sightings of Sooty Terns. These represent WEST 170° 160° M A M J MONTHS, 1964-1966 N FICURE 7.—Annual at-sea density cycle for Sooty Terns in the north-central Pacific. NUMBER 158 19 CENTRAL PACIFIC OCEAN \SLANOjs »NUKUNONOt mryyD IQO 20ST 355 «oo FIGURE 8.—Distribution of banded and streamered Sooty Tern sightings. 20 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 110° IJ0° 130* 140° ISO* 160* 170° t»0° 130° 110° 110* 100* 90* to' 70* FIGURE 9.—Interisland movements of Sooty Terns banded in the north-central Pacific. less than 0.01 percent of the total number banded. Over one-half of the interisland recoveries repre- sent elapsed times greater than one year and 68 percent were short-distance movements within island groups (e.g., between Kure and Midway atolls). It is thus too early to attempt a detailed analysis of the banding data. Since some of these records provide insight into the confusing pelagic dispersal of Sooty Terns, however, a brief summary is presented here. Two hundred and thirty-five orange-streamered birds have been observed at sea (Appendix Table B). All were in the central Pacific north of 11°N. Similarly, orange-streamered birds have been seen and handled on most islands in the same area, but none have been observed on islands farther south. No blue-streamered birds have been recorded north of 02°N. Ninety-six percent of all orange-stream- ered birds were recorded during the breeding sea- son (March-August). Of these, 70 percent were within fifty miles of Johnston Atoll even though over 80 percent of all observation time in that gen- eral area was spent over 50 miles from the atoll. During the breeding season, four streamered birds were sighted over 275 miles from Johnston (one adult in August, 278 miles SE; one immature in August, 287 miles SW; one adult in August, 392 miles SW; and one adult in March, 392 miles SW). We have 10 records of 13 streamered birds feeding at distances up to 225 miles from Johnston (April- June). Recently fledged streamered birds have been found over 100 miles from the breeding colony only during August (3 birds: 180, 226, and 287 miles SW). During the nonbreeding season (September- NUMBER 158 21 February), three of a total of eight orange-streamer sightings were over 50 miles from Johnston (two in September, 394 and 481 miles NE; and one in December, 299 miles ENE). The remaining five were found in September, January, and February, and were probably late departing or early arriving birds. Twelve banded birds (10 from Johnston, 1 from Oahu, and 1 from Laysan) have been recovered at sea (Appendix Table C). As with the streamer sightings, all were from the central Pacific north of 11°N. All but three were recovered over 100 miles from the site of banding. One immature banded on Laysan in August was recovered four months later 1170 miles to the southeast. Another, banded on Johnston in July, was recovered four months later 460 miles to the southwest. Figure 8 is a spatial summary of all at-sea streamer sightings and band recoveries. The above data suggest that during the breeding season, Johnston-based Sooty Terns may forage up to 300 miles from the breeding colony, but that the greatest numbers remain within 50 miles. At the end of the breeding season, adults and immatures disperse widely at sea and many disappear from the north-central Pacific. Four late fall and early winter orange-streamer sightings show dispersal from John- ston of birds to the northeast (three) and to the southwest (one). The one late fall record from Laysan was to the southeast. Figure 9 summarizes interisland movements of Sooty Terns involving the main and leeward Hawaiian, Johnston, and Wake islands. Unfortu- nately, few of these recoveries involve known status birds (e.g., breeding, nonbreeding), or elapsed times less than the length of one breeding season. It is thus impossible to connect the islands of banding and recovery with meaningful directional arrows. TABLE 9.—Interisland Sooty Tern movements occurring within six months of banding Banding and recovery locations Hawaiian banded : Hawaiians Leeward banded: Leewards Johnston Japan Philippines Johnston banded: Leewards Japan Philippines Wake banded: Johnston Carolines Japan Phoenix banded: Phoenix Leewards Line banded: Leewards North Pacific banded: North Pacific Western Pacific . . . South Pacific banded: South Pacific North Pacific Recovery month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 2 - 1 _ 2 1 - 3 !• 9 1 - 16 _ - - 2 1 + 1 1 - 3 1 5 9 28 - - 1 1 4 - 3 - 2 1 1 1 •Banded as locals or immatures. 22 Table 9 summarizes all recoveries made less than 6 months after time of banding. It is apparent, however, that there is considerable interisland movement between islands of the north-central Pacific. Birds banded on Johnston regularly occur on Wake and in the main and leeward Hawaiians and vice versa. Similarly, much movement occurs between islands of the south-central Pacific. A cer- tain amount of interchange between these two areas has been recorded, but our eighteen records probably exaggerate its amount. The lack of orange-streamer sightings in the southern islands, and blue-streamer sightings in the northern islands, particularly on frequently surveyed islands such as Howland and Johnston, indicate that some of the north-south band recoveries may be due to misread band numbers. Unfortunately, none of the north- south band recoveries have been substantiated by the collection of the bird or the removal of its band. The relatively large number of these north- south records, however, indicate that such move- ments may occur. Twenty-eight poBSP-banded birds have been re- SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY covered in the western Pacific. Ten were reported as being associated with typhoons, and three with stormy weather. Another three were reported ex- hausted when found. By comparing the dates and localities of recapture with typhoon and tropical storm tracks in the western Pacific (Joint Typhoon Warning Center, 1965, 1966, 1967; DeAngelis, 1968, 1969), a total of 20 can be directly associated with typhoons and tropical storms (Table 10). This indicates that at least a majority of banded birds recovered in Japan and the Philippines was driven there by storms. By analyzing the origin and path- way of these storms, it is possible to make assump- tions as to the area these Sooty Terns were carried from and thus determine at least part of their non- breeding range. Typhoons in the northwest Pacific appear to originate in the area between 5°N and 20°N, and between 170°E and the Philippines. The United States Naval Oceanographic Office (1964:42) de- scribes the typhoon tracks in this area as follows: . . . the greater number of typhoons conform to the usual tropical cyclone track pattern and move initially westward or 100 E 20 10 FIGURE 10.—Tracks of typhoons which blew banded Sooty Terns to the western Pacific. NUMBER 158 23 TABLE 10.—Sooty Tern recoveries from the western Pacific Recovery location Leyte, Philippines (ca. 11°N, 126°E) Southern Honshu, Japan (34°4O'N, 135°56'E) Honshu, Japan (37°4O'N, 139°J0'E) Southern Leyte, Philippines (ca. 10°N, 125°E) Masbate, Philippines (ca. 12°N, 122°E) Isabela, Philippines (prob. 1O°35'N, 124°E) Near Ticao, Philippines (12°3O'N, 123°5O'E) Tarlac, Luzon, Philippines (ca. 15°S0'N, 125°E) Southern Honshu, Japan (34°5O'N, 138°20'E) Honshu, Japan (35°I9'N, 139°22'E) Honshu, Japan (35°00'N, 1S8°2O'E) Southern Luzon, Philippines (ca. 15°N, 121°E) Eastern Samar, Philippines (12°N, 125°20'E) Mawmawan, Philippines (ca. 10°N, 124°E) Philippines (no location specilicd) Southern Leyte, Philippines (ca. 10°N, 126°E) Toledo City, Philippines (ca. 10°20'N, 124°E) Negros Island, Philippines (09°10'N, 123°10'E) Southeast Luzon, Philippines (13°3O'N, 123°10'E) Northern Luzon, Philippines (ca. 15°40'N, 121 °E) Southeast Luzon, Philippines (ca. 13°2O'N, 123°2O'E) Southern Luzon, Philippines (ca. 14°15'N, 121°15'E) Eastern Samar, Philippines (ll°40'N, 125°20'E) Honshu, Japan (35°20'N, 139°35'E) Shikoku, Japan (ca. 33°3O'N, 133°3O'E) Shikoku, Japan (ca. 33°3O'N, 133°3O'E) Shikoku, Japan (ca. 33°3O'N, 133°3O'E) Negros, Philippines (ca. 10°N, 123°E) Date Remarks Banding location Date Age 7 Mar 65 tropical storm Vera off Leyte on 7 Mar 65; bird exhausted by "typhoon" winds 7 Aug 65 typhoon Jean moved north over Kyushu 5 Aug 65; birds "typhoon-driven" 18 Sjp 65 typhoon Trix over eastern Honshu on 17 Sep 65 before typhoon Faye passed about 250 mi NE of islands 17 Dec 65 on 23 Nov 65 before as above; bird exhausted 22 Dec 63 before no typhoons or tropical storms since Faye passed 10 Mar 66 250 mi NE on 23 Nov 65 20 Mar 66 as above 20 May 66 typhoon Irma over SW Luzon on 18 May 66; bird in wake of typhoon Irma 25 Sep 66 typhoon Ida passed over Honshu on 24 Sep 66; birds "typhoon-driven" 25 Sep 66 as above; no recapture data 25 Sep 66 as above; bird "typhoon-driven" 4 Jan 67 no typhoons or tropical storms since Pamela on 27 Dec 66; raining 11 Jan 67 as above; bird exhausted 4 Feb 67 as above; bird in heavy rain in front of "ty- phoon" ? Feb 67 as above; bird "storm-driven" 3 Mar 67 typhoon Sally passed over central islands on 3 Mar 67 4 Mar 67 as above; bird at height of typhoon Sally 4 Mar 67 as above; male bird 6 Mar 67 as above; bird weak 17 Oct 67 typhoon Carla passed over northern Luzon on 17 Oct 67; after typhoon Trining 3 Xov 67 typhoon Emma passed over southern Luzon on 3 Nov 67; stormy 4 Nov 67 as above; "typhoon-driven" 4 Nov 67 as above; bird after typhoon Welling 26 Apr 68 cannot be accounted for by typhoons or tropical storms 3 Jul 68 last stages of typhoon Lucy passed about 250 miles S of Shikoku on 2 Jul 68 28 Jul 68 typhoon Mary passed over Shikoku on 28 Jul 68 29 Jul 68 as above 25 Nov 68 typhoon Nina passed over Negros on 24 Nov 68 Johnston 8 May 64 local Wake 1 May 65 nestling Johnston II May 65 local Laysan 9 Aug 65 adult Johnston 26 May 65 local Johnston 28 May 65 local Johnston 7 Jun 65 local Midway 27 Jul 65 nestling Johnston 22 Mar 66 adult Midway 12 Jun 66 breeding adult Lisianski 17 Jun 66 adult Johnston 13 Mar 66 adult McKean 19 Jul 64 adult Johnston 15 Jun 66 adult Wake 15 Jun 66 nestling Howland 19 Jul 66 adult Christmas 12 Mar 66 nestling McKean 21 Sep 65 local Howland 16 Aug 66 local Midway 27 Jul 65 nestling Johnston 14 Jun 67 local Midway 22 Jul 64 local Midway 8 Sep 64 immature Laysan 6 Aug 65 adult Johnston 8 Mar 64 adult Johnston 20 May 68 local Johnston 2 May 66 adult Midway 13 Jun 66 adult 24 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY west-northwestward from the source region. Those that reach higher latitudes, normally north of 15°N, have a tendency to recurve and move in a northeasterly direction over or to the east of Japan. A considerable number, however, travel almost due westward and eventually dissipate over the Philippines or the China coast. At the height of the typhoon season over the western Pacific (July through October) the majority of these storms passes to the north of the Philippines moving toward Taiwan, the Japanese Islands, and the China coast. . . . During the so-called slack season (December through February) many continue on a westward course and enter the South China Sea. Figure 10 shows the typhoon and tropical storm tracks that can be associated with POBSP band re- coveries in the western Pacific. All originate in, or immediately southeast of, the Philippine Sea, and all pass through it. Thus, the Philippine Sea must constitute at least part of the nonbreeding range of north-central Pacific Sooty Terns. The only typhoon that can be associated with birds from the Line and Phoenix islands was Sally in 1967. This was the most southern of all Sooty Tern-bearing typhoons, and had the southwesternmost point of origin. No northern birds were reported as a result of this storm. Lane (1967), however, reports the recovery of a Sooty Tern originally banded on Roach Islet, Lord Howe, New South Wales, 28 November 1962, from southern Leyte, Philippines, on 4 March 1967. This is the same recovery date and area as two of our recoveries associated with typhoon Sally. This suggests that the nonbreeding ranges of south-central and north-central Pacific terns are essentially allopatric. Unfortunately, literature records from this area are scarce. Brink- ley (in Bourne and Radford, 1961) recorded seven birds in August at 22°N, 124°E. In late October, Morzer Bruyns (1965) recorded two groups of 50 birds each at approximately 9°N, 131°E, three groups of 40, 10, and 3, near 7°N, 142°E, and possibly two birds at 7°N, 150°E. He did not, how- ever, find any terns in late October or early No- vember near the Palau, western Caroline, or Marshall islands. Records for the timing of the breeding cycle in the Carolines are lacking so that we do not know whether the birds he observed were of that population. EQUATORIAL CENTRAL PACIFIC.—Sverdrup, et al. (1942:709) point out that the Equatorial Counter- current is remarkably well developed in the Pacific Ocean, present at all seasons, lies always in the northern hemisphere, and is farther north in the northern summer. Barkley (1962:5) shows that the borders of this current generally lie between 4°- 5°N and 9°-10°N. North of the Countercurrent is the westward flowing North Equatorial Current, while south is the westward flowing South Equa- torial Current. Data from the Carnegie Expedition (Sverdrup, et al., 1942:711) state that within the Equatorial Countercurrent descending motion takes place at the southern boundary and ascending motion at the northern boundary, and between the Equator and the Countercurrent descending motion takes place at the bound- ary of the Countercurrent and ascending motion at the Equa- tor. Thus, two cells appear with divergence at the northern limit of the Counlercurrent and at the Equator, and with a convergence at the southern boundary of the Countercurrent. Ashmole and Ashmole (1967) have discussed the distribution of seabirds with relation to the equa- torial currents in the central Pacific. They make several points which are relevant to the following discussion: (1) Most tropical seabirds depend, at least in part, on schools of fish to drive their prey close to the surface. (2) Upwelling waters are gen- erally rich in nutrients and zooplankton. (3) As water moves away from divergence areas, phosphate and zooplankton decrease and forage animals in- crease. (4) In the equatorial current area fish schools are generally most abundant within the Counter- current. They (1967:107) conclude that "localized concentrations of plankton and nekton produced by convergence and sinking of surface waters at 'fronts' which have been suggested as exerting im- portant effects on the distribution of surface schools of tunas in the open ocean, may also provide favor- able feeding grounds for many oceanic birds." Other authors, among them King and Pyle (1957) and Morzer Bruyns (1965) have shown some of the effects of oceanic currents in the central Pacific on the density and distribution of seabirds. From January 1964 through 1967 twenty cruises were made by the POBSP across the equatorial cur- rents (0°-13°N) between 148°W and 180°. Surface water temperatures ranged between 25.5° and 30.6°C with the majority falling between 27.0° and 29.5°C. Barkley (1962) presented averaged temperatures for this area of 27° to 28°C, and averaged salinities of 34.30 to 35.40 ppt. FIGURE 11.—Sooty Tern density in relation to equatorial cur- rents in the central Pacific between longitudes 148°W and 180°. IT: 70 J 110 a 130 J - Q 210 230 250 H Q D -> I j" 0 z id 5 0 • i • _ - - - - - O 180" • i • • • o o© o Mo-Hod 1 * . o a© • • 0 • 170" 0 'ob ' 0 -i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—i—r- - - '•"""1 * • 160' IS WEST LONGITUDE U D E < _ l r 5" X 0 z 0" - - _ - — H 1 1 1 1 1 'ffl ' o o 0 o o o •0o® 0 • | 8 J U | 1 1 1 1 1 o • <» • t , • ® # * © a 0 0 • NaiftmftM • ''"""• I ^ Clui \\mt\ — 1 t 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 WEST LONSITUDE I I i^«J- DECEMBER JANUARY FEBRUARY 12* 11" 10" 9" 8" 7" 6" 5" 4" 3* 2" 1" 0" NORTH LATITUDE 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 S 4 3 2 1 0 T U O E < N O R T H _ O '. ffl Htwla* . -1—1 1— 1 1 1 1 1 1 ' ' ' ' » ' o cf . , , 1 1 o c • -1 i i , Q , o - • " 0 0 mm 1 > 1 I l l 170" 160' WEST LONSITUDE I f JUNE QTJ JULY • AUGUST ^ 11 10" 9" 8" 7* 6" 5* 4' 3" 2' I* 0' NORTH LATITUDE 111 0 - A T I rK X. 0 z 10 5 0' i i i i i i i i i i m i « • © • %° • • o — # — MowiMd '•B."« 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 180" 170" »l 1 1 1 * O l 1 l 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 • • © 0 • ramm •fMninf , f I 1 1 "l 1 1 1 160" 1 M l 1 | G 0 O O o M M 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 O - _ _ - — z1 1 150" WEST LONGITUDE 1 4 [J] SEPTEMBER [|]| OCTOBER • NOVEMBER I 12 11 10 9" 8" T 6" 5" 4" 3" 2" 1" 0" NORTH LATITUDE NUMBER 158 27 Figure 11 shows latitudinal variation of Sooty Tern densities plotted against the depth of the 20°C isotherm for five 1966 cruises. The slope of this isotherm can be used as a rough indication of the position of major currents. Figure 12 presents density data for all 20 cruises on a seasonal and monthly basis, while Figure 13 shows a composite of all 1965-1966 densities and an average density per each degree of latitude. Ignoring areas under the immediate influence of islands (i.e., areas within 50 miles of Howland, Christmas, and Palmyra) Sooty Terns are more abundant within the Equatorial Countercurrent than in either the North or South Equatorial cur- rents. The South Equatorial Current has greater Sooty Tern densities than the North Equatorial Current, possibly because of the more direct in- fluence of islands and/or the convergence at its northern border. It is within the convergence area that greatest over-all densities have been recorded (Figure 13). Our data thus support the assump- tions reached by the Ashmoles. Our data also sug- gest, but are too few to prove, a seasonal shift in high densities from the convergence area (4°N- 5°N) in the fall, to the northern Countercurrent area (7°N-9°N) in the spring. Intervening seasons are intermediate, with greatest winter densities re- corded in the area of 5°N to 6°N, and greatest sum- mer densities in the area of 6°N to 7°N. The more northerly position of high density in spring and summer might be explained if many of the terns in the Countercurrent area were part of the north- ern islands' (e.g., Johnston Atoll) breeding popu- lation. Unfortunately, there have been no band returns or color-streamer sightings from this area. It seems quite probable that Sooty Terns in the equatorial currents are from islands in both the north and south central Pacific and that the in- fluence of each area varies with the season and with the local breeding schedule. Within the equatorial currents lie a number of islands, most of which support large Sooty Tern colonies. These include the Line Islands: Kingman Reef (06°24'N), Palmyra (05°52'N), Washington (04°43'N), Fanning (03°52'N), Christmas (01°51'N) and Jarvis (00°23'S), and two islands often consid- FIGI'RE 12.—Sooty Tern density across the equatorial central Pacific. ered part of the Phoenix group: Howland (00° 45'N), and Baker (00°13'N). The latter two islands have been intensively investigated by the POBSP with respect both to island and at-sea bird popula- tions. The POBSP observations show a very close rela- tionship between the breeding schedule and den- sities on Howland Island, and at-sea densities within a 100-mile radius of it (Figure 14). Peak at-sea densities occurred during each of the two major egg-laying periods in 1966-1967. The large numbers of birds at sea during September and October 1965 while island populations were at their lowest are thought to be due to birds from other populations moving into or through the area. The only evidence for this was the collection within the area in October of three immature and one adult Sooty Terns originally banded on Hull Is- land three to eight weeks earlier. At-sea collections and sightings of banded or color-tagged birds dur- ing all other surveys were of Howland-marked birds. SOUTH-CENTRAL PACIFIC.—Pelagic observations were conducted on 13 POBSP surveys to the south- central Pacific from March 1964 through February 1967. During most of these trips many days were spent in the Phoenix Islands. Twelve trips con- tinued south to eastern Samoa and one to the Fiji Islands. Two general cruise tracks were used, one by way of the Tokelaus and Swain's Island, and the other by way of Rakahanga and the Danger Islands. Table 11 summarizes the distribution and abundance of Sooty Terns during these trips. The area of coverage was too restricted, and the timing of observations too unevenly spaced to allow more than the following brief summary. Sooty Terns were abundant at all times of the year on and around the Phoenix Islands. Highest densities were recorded from September through February, particularly October to December. An- nual at-sea abundance cycles in this area, however, cannot be evaluated because of the variation in the timing of breeding cycles between the islands, and because of the nearness of these islands to one another and our inability to assign island origins to birds observed at sea. These factors prevented relating a daily at-sea density to a particular island. Also May-September records are few while October- April records are numerous. South of the Phoenix Islands these terns became progressively less abun- 28 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 8* 7* 6* 5* 4* NORTH LATITUDE Daily Observations Avsrage Density 12* 11* 10* 9* 8* NORTH LATITUDE FIGURE 13.—Summary of Sooty Tern densities across the equatorial central Pacific during 1965- 1966. NUMBER 158 29 HOWLAND ISLAND 0 5 UJ UJ -1 I U O(C > mo i^5 If S 3 I i n n •M'-L L iOCCS ta.*W— ill — 525 - 5 5 s * III I 8' K j Diurnal density ^ Nocturnal density Average Miles of Observations per Month Diurnal = 690 Nocturnal 479 FIGURE 14.—Correlation of at-sea densities (within 100 miles o£ Howland) of Sooty Terns with the breeding schedule and population fluctuations of Howland Island. dant, being seen on fewer days as well as in smaller numbers. Movements of banded and streamered birds from this area are summarized in Table 10, Appendix Tables B, C, Figures 8, 10, and 15. These records are discussed under the section dealing with north- central Pacific banding results, and under the dis- cussion of Howland Island in the equatorial central Pacific. EASTERN PACIFIC.—Surveys in the eastern Pacific north of 30° N have been conducted from Decem- ber 1966 through April 1968 off southern Califor- nia and northern Baja California, generally on a semimonthly basis. South of 30°N surveys have been made in cooperation with EASTROPAC. POBSP personnel recorded observations during nine cruises. Three of these ran concurrently in January- March 1967, one in June-July 1967, two concur- rently in August-September 1967, one in October- December 1967, and two concurrently in February- April 1968. The survey pattern was based on north-south cruise tracks along specific longitudes. Two of these tracks (119°W, 112°W) were followed five times each; two (105°W, 98°W) were followed 30 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY •c NUMBER 158 31 TABLE 11.—Distribution and occurrence of Sooty Terns within 100 miles of south- central Pacific islands from March 1964 through February 1967 Area Days observed (No.) Days recorded (No.) Days recorded Average density (BPM) Range of density (BPM) Months of observations Phoenix Islands Tokelau I Rakahanga I. Danger I Swains I. . . . . . Wallis I £. Samoa Horn I Fiji I Total/average . 51 51 100 3.9 0.02-34.6 all except Jun and Aug 20 17 85 0.7 0.0-3.4 all except Jan and May 2 1 - 0 . 3 0.0-0.6 Jun 3 3 - 0.3 0.03-0.7 Mar and Jun 17 13 76 0.1 0.0-1.0 all except Jan, May, and Dec 2 2 - 0 . 6 0.04-1.2 Feb 15 4 27 0.1 0.0-1.1 all except Jan, May, Sep. and Dec 2 2 - 0 . 1 0.02-0.2 Feb 3 3 - 0 . 1 0.01-0.3 Feb 11? % 8? T? 0.0-34.6 all months four times each; one (92°W) was followed twice; and three (126° W, 96°W, 88°W) were followed once. Sooty Terns have never been recorded north of 26°N in the eastern Pacific, and POBSP personnel have not found them north of 22°N. Our data from the eastern Pacific are not complete enough to show much in the way of annual trends. Ob- servations, for example, do not exist for May and December, and are minimal for January and April. Figures 17 through 28 summarize all POBSP records for the eastern Pacific (pp. 34-45). Sooty Terns were generally common (1-5 BPM) in the Equatorial Countercurrent, particularly west of 110°W to 126°W, and along the Mexican coast from Acapulco north to the Gulf of Califor- nia. Densities greater than 5 BPM were recorded on TABLE 12.—Date and location of Sooty Tern densities (BPM) greater than 5.0 in the eastern Pacific Date 2 Feb 67 22 Feb 67 5 Jun 67 7 Jul 67 5 Sep67 9 22 17 18 7 Noon position °38'N,119 °18'N,109 °56'N,102 °38'N,104 °42'N,112 °00'W °17'\V °55'W °48'W °06'W Area Equatorial Counter- current mouth of Gulf of California coast of Mexico coast of Mexico Equatorial Counter- current Density 8.8 7.8 18.5 6.1 9.0 only five days (Table 12). These were also either along the Mexican coast or in the Equatorial Countercurrent. We have never recorded Sooty Terns north of 15°46'N except at the mouth of the Gulf of California where birds have been seen north of 21°49'N. Anthony (1898), Kaeding (1905), Gifford (1913), and McLellen (1926) recorded Sooty Terns as breeding on die Revilla Gigedo Islands (19°N, 111°W) in the northern spring. However, during four days of POBSP observations within 150 miles of these islands (11 February, 20-21 March, 15 September) no Sooty Terns were seen. Brattstrom and Howell (1956) did not record this species there in March or November. Only in February and March were observations made south of 20°S. During these two months Sooty Terns were common (1-5 BPM^ in southern waters from 5°S to 14°S in the more western area (119°W- 126°W), with scattered birds recorded to 19°48'S at 121°3rW. In August, Sooty Terns were likewise common from 5°S to 10°S, the southern limit of our observations. Equatorial currents were probably as influential on Sooty Tern distribution and abundance in the eastern Pacific as they are in the central Pacific. There are, however, several important differences between the two areas. These appear to be signifi- cant in their effect on Sooty Terns. Wyrtki (1966, n.d.) characterizes the Equatorial Countercurrents east of 120°W as clearly developed from May to De- cember and absent from February through April. From May to December, west of 110°W, its bound- SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 11" 10* 9" 7" NORTH LATITUDE 112*through 119* NORTH LATITUDE 88* through 106* FIGURE 16.—Sooty Tern density across the Equatorial Countcrcurrent in the eastern Pacific. aries vary between 4°N to 6°N and 8°N to 12°N, while east of 110°W there is a southward shift so that at the end point the boundaries lie south of 4°N and 10°N. From February to April surface wa- ter flow is to the west and northwest between the South Equatorial and North Equatorial currents. Figure 16 summarizes data from our nine cruises across the Equatorial Countercurrent. The distri- bution and abundance of Sooty Terns appeared to change in response to changes in the Countercur- rent as described by Wyrtki. In both seasons Sooty Terns were found across the entire current area. Density centers, however, differed markedly. During the season when the Countercurrent was not pres- ent, high densities were found only west of 110°W (the two highest densities were at 119°W) and only north of 9°N. (If the Countercurrent were devel- oped, this position would be at its northern bound- ary which is contrary to what would be expected from the Ashmoles' discussion and from the ob- served distribution of central Pacific terns.) Eastern Pacific distribution, however, may be the result of the west and northwest flow developed through this area at this time of year. During the season when the Countercurrent was clearly developed, high densities were mainly at the convergence along the southern border of the Countercurrent (ca. 5°N). It is also pertinent to note that during both seasons highest densities were recorded west of 112° W where the currents are generally stronger and well developed. Sooty Terns appear to be present throughout the year in the eastern Pacific. Our fragmentary data suggest that during the spring (February-April) greatest numbers occur west of 110°W, while dur- ing the fall (August-November) high densities also occur over much of the area east of 110°W. This would be in accord with fall nesting on the Gala- pagos Islands and Clipperton Atoll, and with a westward dispersal at the conclusion of the breed- ing season. Such an hypothesis for breeding stations is consistent with central Pacific Sooty Tern dis- tribution patterns. We would expect to see color- streamered birds if central Pacific birds were mov- ing into the area. Unfortunately, only a few birds have been collected so that the chance of recover- NUMBER 158 33 ing banded birds has been exceedingly small. It is, however, possible that birds from French Poly- nesia enter the area. This is suggested by the large numbers of birds found from 5°S to 15°S, and from 119°W to 126°W in February and March. All traveling flocks observed at this time were heading east. Summary and Conclusions Sooty Terns are abundant and widely dispersed throughout the tropical and subtropical Pacific Ocean. The perimeter of peripheral breeding local- ities marks the normal limits of their pelagic dis- persal. Within this area they may be found over almost any part of the ocean at any time of the year. The occurrence of Sooty Terns beyond the normal limits of their range is generally the result of major climatic disturbances, such as typhoons and cyclones in the western Pacific, and possibly of fluctuations in oceanic currents and water masses. The regularity of stragglers in such areas as Japan is due to the regularity of these disturb- ances. Sooty Tern densities fluctuate widely in both space and time. Factors affecting these densities are complicated, often interacting, and sometimes obscured by the presence of two or more popula- tions which are indistinguishable in the field. The following factors are educed in this investigation, but this list is not exhaustive: Food Availability: Over a greater part of the ocean, Sooty Terns are generally few and scattered, with occasional high densities shifting from area to area in response to an erratic food supply. In such areas, tern densities vary directly with the length of time food is available. In areas where food is regularly available (e.g., the Equatorial Countercurrent), tern densities are uniformly higher. Breeding Island Proximity: During the breeding season Sooty Terns are island-oriented; highest densities generally occur within 25 miles of breed- ing islands. Individual breeding birds, however, may forage up to 300 miles at sea away from breed- ing colonies. Breeding Schedule: At-sea densities vary directly with the breeding cycles on nearby islands; highest at-sea numbers occur at the peaks of the nesting seasons. In the north-central Pacific (Hawaiian- Leewards and Johnston), the at-sea density and island nesting cycles are annual and regular. In the south-central Pacific (Line and Phoenix is- lands), breeding is semiannual or irregular, and at-sea densities may be high at any time depending upon the status of nearby breeding colonies. Post-breeding Dispersal: During the nonbreeding season birds may be rare or absent in some parts of the Pacific. After the young fledge, Sooty Terns become ocean-oriented, and densities near islands decrease; birds appear to remain in the general area of the breeding islands for up to a month be- fore moving to nonbreeding areas. Central Pacific Sooty Terns of all age groups disperse westward; many north-central birds reach the Philippine Sea, which constitutes at least part of their nonbreeding range. Nonbreeding ranges, as well as breeding ranges, of north or 6 lock of about 50 (species?) flock of about 30 ew 1 arge flocks I found in the Mariana, Palau, and Caroline islands 19 May 29 27 Oct 60 29 Oct 60 flock of about 100 wo groups of 50 three groups of 40, 10, and 3 recorded from Siquijor and Sulu Islands 14 Aug 29 30 Jul 29 21 Jul 29 25 Jul 29 24 Mar 29 6 Apr 29 27 Sep 63 26 Sep 63 Hock of about 150-200 (species?) dock of about 58 (species?) several many in flocks .everal (species?) airly common many scattered flocks vast numbers breeding in this area 11 Sep 62 8 Sep 62 20 Aug 61 8 Sep 62 12 Dec 57 22 Aug 61 17 Aug 61 7 Sep 62 26 Nov 28 8 Jul 62 23 Aug 61 29 Nov 28 14 Sep 62 19 Dec 57 14 Feb 63 1 May 60 3 5 ca. 50 8 :> resent 6 3 ca. 200 arger flock far out (species?) 20 ca. 30 fairly numerous 10 one flock 2 7 Source Austin and Kuroda, 1953:450-451 •• •• •• " " " " " " " " " •• " " " " " " Jespersen, 1933:206 .. Brinkley in Bourne and Radford, 1961:25 Mitchell in Bourne and Radford, 1961:25 Dixon and Starrett, 1952:271 Baker, 1951:161 Jespersen, 1933:206 Morzer Bruyns, 1965:63-64 " " " " Delacour and Mayr, 1946:77 Jespersen, 1933:206 " " " •• " " " " " " Mitchell in Boume, 1965:37 Hindwood, et al., 1963:28-30 Norris, 1967:46 " " " " " " Gibson, 1960:18 Norris, 1967:46 " " " »t it »» Jespersen, 1933:206 Norris, 1967:46 " " " Jespersen, 1933:206 Norris, 1967:46 Gibson, 1960:18 Morris in Bourne, 1965:37 King in Bourne, 1964:37 48 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY TABLE A.—Summary of published data on Sooty Tern distribution—Continued Location 29°54'S, 178°30'E 29°56'S, 156°37'E SO°55'S. 155°17'E OS Sydney Lord Howe I. New South Wales New Zealand Near Sydney Sydney Harbor Queenscliff Near Sydney Head Dorrigo North I. S4°S2'S, 172°31'E CENTRAL PACFIC Central Pacific 23°S0'N, 162°W Honolulu Oahu Pearl Harbor 2O°23'N, 158°52'W 20°31'N, WWW Marshalls 7°N, 159°W 7°N, 145°W 7°N, 1S8°W 7°N, 179°E Gilberts 02°15'N, 169°17'W Hull I. 8°40'S, 136°54rW 8°30'S, 156°30'W Marquesas I. to Palmyra I. Marquesas I. SOUTH-CENTRAL PACIFIC 10°08'S. 142°01'W 10o41'S, 172°22'W 11°44'S, 144°10'W 14°39'S, 174°27'W 18°07'S, 179°47rW 18°40'S, 176°21'W 20°57'S, 158°58'W 27°06'S, ffl"41'Vf 29°45'S. 176°57'W 31°35'S, 176°25rW Date 23 Nov 64 25 Feb 29 20 Dec 57 17 Feb 29 Remarks singles and small flocks in water tempera- ture 70° F few present 1 specimen regular breeding cycle beginning in September each year undated breeding on lands May 1892 undated 3 Feb 34 11 Dec 42 25 Jun 50 Feb-Apr late Jul-Aug 30 Jul 61 reported as rare straggler Lord Howe, Norfolk, and the Kermadec is- 1 specimen several specimens 1 immature specimen 1 bird observed 2 cyclone-driven birds, 1 collected 7 records following northerly gales 6 1 bird landed on ship breeding or as having bred on every island group except the New Hebrides and the Solomons 12 Apr 64 24 May 59 undated 27 May 60 26 May 60 13 Jan 60 Oct-Nov 64 Jun 66 Apr 67 5 Nov 60 7 Nov 60 8 Nov 60 3 Nov 60 Nov 64 27 May 59 28 May 59 1 Oct 28 6 May 64 early Dec 55 2 Oct 28 late Nov 55 5 Oct 28 2 Nov 28 6 Oct 28 8 Nov 28 13 Nov 62 8 Dec 57 21 Oct 28 13 Dec 28 14 Dec 28 15 Dec 28 present 50 many groups all around the coast hundreds 5 30 occurred near and between breeding atolls " " " " •• " .. groups of 2 to 200, one group with im- matures present groups of 1 and 10 groups of I, 10, and 3 three groups of 100 20 seen between Makin and Maiana 1 ca. 1000 seen fishing in small groups few large flock over a school of tuna observed daily at sea fairly common abundant in and around these islands few flock of about 10 (species?) still a few (one possible flock of 50) small flock 120 1 few (species?) 2 and 2 1 specimen few Source Edgar, et al., 1965:42 Jespersen, 1933:206 Gibson, 1960:18-19 Jespersen, 1933:206 Hindwood, et al., 1963:30 Goddard and Hindwood, 1951:170 Falla, etal., 1967:165 Goddard and Hindwood, 1951:170 " " " " " " »• ,» •, », " " " " " Falla, etal., 1967:165 » .. » .. Jenkins, 1962:33-34 King, 1967:76 Lamb in Bourne, 1966:33 Peakall. 1960:202 .. King in Bourne, 1964:37 .. ,. Amerson, 1969:302 .. Morzer Bruyns, 1965:63-64 " •• " Amerson, 1969:302 Peakall, 1960:202 " " Jespersen, 1933:206 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:33 King and Pyle, 1957:37 Jespersen, 1933:206 King and Pyle, 1957:37 Jespersen, 1933:206 Worgan in Bourne, 1964:37 Gibson, 1960:18 Jespersen, 1933:206 .. .. ., NUMBER 158 TABLE B.—At-sea sightings of streamered Sooty Terns Date JOHNSTON 1963 5 Aug 1964 5 Mar •• 11 Mar 14 Mai •• • • " 9 Apr 13 Apr 14 Apr 7 May •• •• • • •• 8 May 10 May 15 May " •• •• 7 Jun 8 Jun •• •• » • • •• •• " •• 11 Jun 16 Jun 11 Jul " 5 Aug 6 Aug •• " 8 Aug 10 Aug 11 Aug 12 Aug lime STREAMERED 0704 1040 1110 1148 1400 1607 0659 0713 0719 0736 0837 0930 1431 1751 1520 1810 1630 1335 1002 1026 1146 1530 1600 1218 1428 1205 1315 1423 1603 1636 1713 0622 0720 0735 1151 1154 1157 1300 1304 1547 0714 0824 1345 1420 -• 0700 0702 0928 0933 1640 1650 1050 1250 So. I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 •) 1 1 1 1 :"> 1 4 5 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Behavior flying E flying E feeding not noted flying N not noted flying SE flying NNE flying N flying SSE not noted flying NE flying NE feeding Hying NE feeding • • flying NE not noted flying SE flying E flying SE feeding not noted feeding flying SE flying NNE flying SE flying S flying ENE flying NNW flying ENE flying WSW flying ENE not noted flying NE flying SE flying ENE flying SE flying NE feeding " flying NNW flying N not noted flying SE flying E not noted flying NW not noted N lat. 15°45' 16°43' 16°41' " 16°22' 16°40' 16°57' •• •• •• " 14°07' 16°03' 15°26' 16°20' 17°05' 17°31' 16°54' 16°52' 16°47' 16°20' 16°16' 13°54' 15°36' 16°55' 16°59' 17°04' 17°09' 17°11' 18°05' 17°06' 16°59' •• 16°42' •• 16°36' " 16°07' 15°32' 20° 02' 15°58' 16°05' 18°30' 16°54' 16°42' 16°41' 14°01' 14°26' 16°24' 14°42' W long. 169°19' 169°21' 169°23' 169° 22' 169°21' 169°31' 169°39' 169° 36' • • " 171°49' 171°51' 173°24' 171°37' 171 °20' 169°16' 168° 08' 169° 00' 169° 05' 169° 46' 169°23' 169° 22' 169° 24' 170°02' 169°21' 169°11' 168° 58' 168° 47' 168° 44' 166°28' I68°27' 168° 38' 168°41' 169°19' 169° 20' " 169° 27' 169° 20' 169°57' 169°27' 170° 52' 170° 46' M 165°03' 169°00' 169°23' 169°21' 170° 46' 172°31' 170°51' 173° 57' Miles from origin 55 SSE 9 ESE 8 SE 9 SE 25 SSE 5 S 14 NNW 13 NNW " " 211 SW 144 SW 187 SW 125 WSW 109 WSW 24 NE 90 NE 30 NE 24 NE 16 W 26 SSE 30 SSE 174 S 76 SSW 13 NE 23 NE 36 NE 48 NE 51 NE 177 ENE 63 NE 52 NE 50 NE 11 SE 10 SSE 39 SSE 79 SSW 200 N 91 SW 84 SW •• 278 NE 30 NE 7 SE 7 SE 180 SSW 226 SW 80 SW 287 SW Age adult " " " " " adult '* ** immature adult adult immature 50 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY TABLE B.—At-sea sightings of streamered Sooty Terns—Continued Date 1965 IS Apr 19 Apr •• 20 Apr •• 15 May 21 May 17 Jun •• •• 21 Jun 5 Jul 11 Jul 15 Aug •• •• •• 22 Aug >• " •• •• •• •• " " " 8 Sep •• 10 Sep 1966 31 Jan 6 Mar 8 Mar 1 Apr 2 Apr •• 4 Apr 5 Jun '• •• " Time 1507 1215 1630 0955 1345 1130 1415 0430 1045 » 1710 0956 1710 0740 " 1018 1143 1414 1418 1419 ' 1451 1507 1508 " 1530 1630 1700 1905 0850 1700 1515 1745 0853 0852 0642 1754 0805 1215 1710 1024 1030 1430 0731 0733 0744 0756 0809 0821 0830 0837 0923 1027 1659 1849 1851 No. 2 1 4 10 9 2 3 5 1 17 2 5 12 3 3 11 1 18 3 4 2 Behavior not noted feeding •• •• •• not noted feeding not noted feeding flying S flying NE feeding flying SE flying SE flying NW feeding not noted feeding not noted feeding not noted feeding " •• not noted feeding •• •• •• not noted flying NE flying N flying NE flying W feeding " •• not noted flying NW feeding flying S •• not noted feeding •> " not noted feeding •• flying NE flying E N. lat. 16° 18' 15°37' 16°06' 17°28' 16° 17' 13°32' 18°50' 15°07' 15°22' •• 17°44' 17°07' 15°40' 16°54' " 16° 32' 16°20' 16°43' 16°44' •• 16°46' 16°48' " 16°50' 16°54' 16°56' 17°03' 19°47' 19°15' 16°43' 16°28' 16°34' 11°38' 16°47' 16°43' 15°05' 14°22' 13°40' 16°02' 16°03' 16°28' 16° 18' •• 16°17' 16°16' 16° 15' 16°14' 16°13' 16° 12' I6°08' 16°02' 15°33' 15°23' •• W long. 169°25' 17S°41' 173°O7' 170°Sl' 172°25' 169°49' 170°24' 169° 35' 170°14' 169°53' 168°06' 173° 39' 169°44' 169°34' 169° 30' 169°29' " 169° 25' 169°23' •• " 169°20' 169° 14' 169°12' 169°02' 161 °47' 163° 10' 169°3r 169°39' 170°53' 173°34' 167°21' 169°29' 170°25' 170°40' 171°O3' 171°11' 171°10' 171 °08' 169° 15' •• 169° 17, 169°19' 169°22' 169°23' 169°25' 169°26' 169° 34' 169°45' 170°45' 171°02' 171 °03' Miles from origin 28 S 225 SW 218 WSW 73 NW 172 WSW 195 S 137 NNW 97 S 93 SSW •• 63 NNW 83 NE 247 WSW 16 NW " 13 SSW 25 S 2 S 1 S " 5 E 8 E " 11 ENE 17 ENE 20 NE 32 NE 481 NE 394 NE 2 SSW 19 SSW 80 W 392 SW 124 E 4 SSE 113 SSW 160 SSW 209 SSW 107 SW 106 SW 95 WSW 30 S •• 31 S •> 32 S 33 S 34 S 38 S 45 SSW 101 SW 122 SW •• Age adult " •• immature " adult " immature adult •• " adult •• " •• •• immature adult •• •• •> •• •• •• •• •• •• •• n - •• - adult •• » » •• » •• •• " •• » NUMBER 158 TABLE B.—At-sea Date 1966 10 Sep 3 Dec 1967 8 Jan 12 May 1968 12 Feb Time 1458 1016 1153 1429 1200 HOWLAND STREAMEREG 1966 14 Jul 17 Jul 20 Jul •• " •• •• 21 Jul •• M 14 Aug •• 15 Aug 16 Aug 17 Aug •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• •• 19 Aug 16 Sep 19 Sep •• 20 Sep •• 22 Sep 23 Sep " •• 16 Oct 12 Dec 1967 18 Jan 18 Feb 0832 0845 0846 0830 1017 1144 1617 1724 0936 1645 1649 1010 1025 0845 0930 0649 1659 0923 0948 1015 1044 1059 1117 1135 1204 1320 1330 1415 1440 1500 1515 0850 0808 1035 1425 1522 1543 1736 0430 1040 1710 1015 1652 1153 0836 No. 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 3 1 1 1 3 1 3 1 1 1 3 3 2 1 1 1 sightings of streamered Behavior flying N feeding not noted feeding flying S£ •• flying NW flying NE flying E " flying NW flying S not noted feeding flying W feeding •• •• •• not noted •• •• flying ENE flying NE flying SE feeding flying NE feeding flying S not noted flying S feeding " not noted flying N feeding not noted •• feeding not noted flying SE flying E feeding N lat. 16°42' 18°44' 16°38' 18° 14' 16°35' O°53' 0°54' 0°45' 0°41' 0°24' 0°14' 0°34' 0°41' 0°27' 0°38' 0°31' 0°30' 0°40' 0°34' 0°40' 0°42' 0°45' 0°44' 0°42' 0°40' 0°39' 0°38' 0°S7' 0°34' 0°26' 0°25' 0°22' 0°21' 0°20' 0°19' 1°28' 0°52' 0°29' 0°42' 0°52' " •• 0°48' 0°18' 0°07' l°05' 0°58' 0°45' 0°49' Sooty Terns—Continued W long. 170°13' 164°44' 169°11' 169° 12' 168°35' 176°44' 176°45' 176°31' 176°38' " 176°36' 176°4r 176°40' 176°32' 176° 36' 176°35' 176°28' 176°40' 176°48' 176°47' 176°44' 176°48' 176°52' 176°57' 176°59' 177°O1' 177°04' 177°12' 177°22' 177°23' 177°30' 177°34' 177°37' 177°39' 177°OO' 176°47' 175°51' 176°26' 176°35' 176°37' 176°23' 176°27' 176°01' 176°46' 176°39' 177°35' 176°29' Miles from origin 42 W 299 ENE 19 ESE 89 N 54 E 8 NW 9 NW 7 E 7 S 24 S 34 S 15 SSW 8 SSW 22 SSE 10 SSE 18 S 15 S 14 SSE 12 SW 11 SW 4 SW 12 W 14 WSW 20 WSW 22 WSW 24 WSW 28 WSW 32 WSW 50 WSW 51 WSW 58 WSW 62 WSW 66 WSW 68 WSW 46 NNW 7 NW 52 SE 15 SE 7 NNE 6 N •• 8 S 32 SSE 54 SSE 17 NNW 11 N 56 W 9 E Age " •• " " " " adult " •• •• " •• " " •• •• •• •• " •• " •• adult •• •• •• *• •• " •• •• •• immature adult •• •• •• 51 52 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY TABLE C.—At-sea recoveries of banded Sooty Terns (table based on distance between banding and recovery localities; ? uncertain, - not noted) Original data Date Age Location Date 9 May 66 14 Aug 66 9 Apr 66 21 Jul 66 -• Recovery Age adult " - adult data Sex $ $ - $ Elapsed months 15.2 18.4 14.3 8.7 17.6 0.3 Miles HOWLAND ISLAND 2 Feb 65 adult 1 Feb 65 19 Jul 65 2 Feb 65 12 Jul 66 18 Jul 66 12 Oct 64 2 Feb 65 1 Feb 65 23 Jul 64 12 Jul 66 19 Jul 66 21 Jul 66 17 Aug 66 immature 1 Feb 65 adult 21 Jul 66 9 Oct 64 1 Feb 65 12 Jul 66 2 Feb 65 HULL ISLAND 26 Sep 65 24 Sep 65 immature 25 Sep 65 JOHNSTON ATOLL 8 Jul 66 3 Feb 64 adult 30 Jan 64 8 Jun 64 27 Apr 65 I Aug 63 25 Jul 63 22 Jul 64 II Feb 64 21 Apr 66 LAYSAN ISLAND 9 Aug 65 immature MANANA, OAHU 20 Mar 64 adult 1°OO'N-175°47'W 0oH'N-176°30'W 0°12'N-176°36'W 0°15'N-176°40'W O°17'X-176°3rW 1°17'N-176°34'W O°42'N-176°17'W 0°47'N-176°59'W 0°48'N-176°59'W' l°OrN-176°39'W O°44'N-176°27'VV O°38'N-I76°34'\V O°44'N-176°27'W 0°50'N-176°26'W lear Howland 0o27'S-177o31'W 0°34'N-176°20'W O°O2'S-176°37'\V O°14'N-175°52'W 11°57'N- 16°18'X- I5°44'X- 14°36'N- 18°58'X- 18°49'X- 18°43'X- 14°59'X- 17°42'N- 16°44'N- 175°49'W 172°57'W 172°2O'W 171°03'W 170°16'W 170°24'W 17O°31'W 170°37'W 169°47'W 169°11'W ll°09'N-140°53'W at sea, Hawaiian area 15 Jul 66 17 Jul 66 13 Jul 66 9 Dec 66 22 Apr 67 23 Sep 66 18 Sep 66 19 Sep 66 23 Sep 66 17 Jul 66 17 Jan 67 20 Oct 65 22 Oct 65 17 Oct 65 22 Nov 65 13 Nov 66 20 May 65 18 Apr 65 16 Apr 65 21 May 65 16 Apr 65 20 Apr 65 8 Jan 67 before 6 Dec 65 mid-Oct adult ? adult adult immature adult adult adult 9 immature $ $ 9 adult 0.1 21.1 17.5 17.4 28.5 4.9 9.1 2.1 1.0 19.6 2.1 21.3 15.5 0.2 2S.5 0.8 0.9 0.8 1.9 4.2 15.6 14.6 10.3 0.8 21.7 21.9 8.8 14.3 8.6 3.9 31.0 52 EXE 38 S 35 S 33 S 32 S 28 22 22 21 17 13 12 11 12 5 N ESE W VV W N ESE SSE ESE ENE 1 W 400 390 370 360 460 202 175 158 141 135 132 124 60 18 XW xw NW NW sw wsw wsw svv NNW XX W NNW SW NNW E 1,170 SE 0 to 400 Wedge-tailed Shearwater {Puffinus pacificus)* Warren B. King Introduction The material contained in this report was gath- ered in the course of intensive biological investiga- tions in the central and eastern Pacific by the Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Program (POBSP), Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D. C Hum- phrey (1965) has given a general summary of the activities and objectives of the program, and Gould (pp. 1-5) has discussed the methods and materials and areas of coverage of the program. At-sea work began in 1963 and was concluded in 1969. This report is one of a series of studies of the pelagic distribution of Pacific seabirds. By the end of 1968 POBSP personnel observed 81,740 Wedge-tailed Shearwaters during 2747 days (26,457 hours) and 259,710 miles of observation. The Wedge-tailed Shearwater (Puffinus pacificus) is an abundant, wide-spread species in the tropical and subtropical Pacific and Indian oceans; it may be encountered far from land most of the year. In the central Pacific its population is approximately one-half million birds (Table 13). It also breeds on numerous islands in the western Pacific from the Bonin, Volcano, and Pescadore islands in the north, along the east coast of Australia to Monta- gue Island near Bass Strait in the south-. In the eastern Pacific it breeds only on San Benedicto Is- land of the Revilla Gigedo group. Its marine range is only slightly larger than its breeding range in the Pacific, although in the In- dian Ocean its marine range appears to extend farther north than its breeding range (Bailey, 1968). In the eastern Pacific it has been recorded from Warren B. King, International Council for Bird Preservation, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. Baja California south to the Gulf of Guayaquil, Ecuador. In the western Pacific it has been recorded from the Izu Islands south of Japan to the South China Sea and the Tasman Sea. The northernmost records are a sighting (POBSP. TABLE 13.—Maximum estimates by POBSP (1963-1968) of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters on islands in the central Pacific* Island Kure Midway Pearl and Hermes Reef Lisianski Laysan Gardner Pinnacles French Frigate Shoals Necker Nihoa Islets of the Main Hawaiian group Johnston Christmas Canton Phoenix McKean Taongi Bikar Taka Eniwetok Wake Number 6,250 3,000 22,400 60,000 200,000 100 13,600 2,000 25,000 70,000 2,500 6,000 40 10,000 500 12,000 + 6 12 3 6 • Paper Number 70, Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Pro- gram, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. •Estimates are of birds "using" the islands, including breeding birds, nonbreeders, and, in some cases, chicks. Esti- mates of nocturnal burrowing birds are notoriously inaccu- rate so that many of these estimates may be low by 100 percent or more. On the basis of total number of birds handled in one year during banding operations on islands on which coverage was thorough (Kure, Johnston), roBSP experi- ence indicates that most initial estimates should be doubled or trebled. Above estimates, however, give a good idea of order of magnitude of the populations. 53 54 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Paul Woodward) at latitude 35°26'N, longitude 164°17'W in August 1966 and a typhoon-driven bird found 30 September 1959 in Fukui, Japan, near the Sea of Japan at latitude 36° N (Anonymous, 1960). The southernmost record is a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) band return record from Cook Strait, New Zealand, on 8 November 1965; the light-phase bird had been banded as an adult 19 September 1963 on Johnston Atoll by POBSP per- sonnel. Another Wedge-tailed Shearwater, also light-phase, was reported by Falla (1962) from Makara, Wellington, also in Cook Strait. On tenu- ous grounds Falla assigned this bird to one of the north Pacific light-phase breeding islands, rather than the Shark's Bay, Western Australia, breeding grounds where light-phase birds occur as well. Murphy (1951) recognizes two subspecies, P. p. pacificus Gmelin, an all-dark form from the Kerma- dec Islands, Norfolk Island, and Kandavu Island of the Fiji group, and P. p. chlororhynchus Lesson, a slightly smaller form, from all other islands in the Pacific and Indian oceans. The latter occurs in both light-phase and dark-phase morphs, and oc- casionally in an intermediate form. The light-phase morph predominates in all breeding colonies north of 10°N except the Marianas, where only dark birds occur, and in the Revilla Gigedos. These breeding grounds include: island or group latitude San Benedicto 19° N Main Hawaiians 19°-22°N Northwestern Hawaiians 23°-28°N Johnston Atoll 16°N Northern Marshalls 11°-14°N Bon ins, Volcanos 24°-27°N Pescadores 20 °N longitude light-phase pop- <%) 110°W 33 or less 154°-160°W 97 162°-179°VV 99 + 169°W 95 162°-170°E 93 140°-142°E 99 + 119°E 99? Light-phase birds make up about one percent of the Phoenix Islands' population. Light-phase birds have not been reported in any other breeding col- onies in the south Pacific. The figure of 33 percent light-phase birds for the Revilla Gigedos comes from Murphy's (1951:9) comment that "in certain colonies, as at the Revilla Gigedo Islands, both dark- and white-phase birds are found together in a respective ratio of about two to one." The com- ment was probably paraphrased from Anthony (1898:313), who was speaking of the birds "about" San Benedicto and Socorro Islands, not particu- larly of the birds "on" either island. Anthony's (1900:251) statement that "by far the greater num- ber were in dark plumage," refers to breeding birds on San Benedicto, and Loomis (1918:143) quotes Bunnell's notes which say that "the white-breasted ones were a very small proportion of the total number" just offshore or on the island of San Benedicto. At the risk of reading information into these comments, it would seem that the proportion of light- to dark-phase birds on San Benedicto may be smaller than one to two. BREEDING PHENOLOGY.—The breeding season is from April to November in northern subtropical Pacific breeding localities, and October to May in southern subtropical localities. Birds are most abundant at sea near their breeding areas during these months. When the birds of the year fledge, young and old alike disperse from the general vi- cinity of the breeding islands, so that numbers en- countered nearby at sea are only a small fraction of those seen during the breeding season. The routes of dispersal are not yet known. Birds from tropical Pacific breeding stations are often present near their breeding islands year round, and their breeding cycle may extend beyond the eight months of the subtropical breeders. In the Hawaiian group, Johnston Atoll, and the northern Marshalls, the Wedge-tailed Shearwater breeds synchronously on an annual cycle. Birds ap- pear first on their breeding islands at night in early March. In the Hawaiian group maximum numbers occur in May, although on Johnston Atoll num- bers increase gradually to an August peak. Eggs are laid in mid-June. Nonbreeders visit the islands sporadically and usually account for more than half the population on an island at any given time. Eggs hatch in early August and by mid-August the chicks are left alone in their burrows during the day. By early November neither breeding nor non- breeding adult birds visit the island, and by the middle of November the young have fledged and no birds remain. From September to November large flocks are often encountered off the shore of breeding sites. Birds presumably form such flocks prior to migration. The gonadal development cycle of light-phase birds was determined on the basis of measurements of 75 males collected at sea in all months but Janu- ary and of 79 females from all months but January, October, and November (Figure 29). Gonadal de- NUMBER 158 55 15r E E Ovary length Left testis length • •""" yy Ovary width Left testis width Largest ovum J F M A M J J A S O N FICURF. 29.—Monthly gonad dimensions of light-phase Wedge-tailed Shearwaters collected at sea. velopment apparently begins with the birds' return to the vicinity of their breeding islands and reaches a peak by May, a month before eggs are laid. After May, gonads decrease in size, but the decrease stops between July and October during which gonad sizes hold constant; thereafter they shrink rapidly to minimum size during winter. There is little indi- cation from the data of any distinction between adults and subadults on the basis of gonad size. An exception was that two of four birds collected on the equator in April had gonads very much smaller than the mean dimensions, suggesting they might have been subadults. The other two, and several others taken later in the year south of 10°N latitude where subadults might be expected to be found, showed gonadal development not appreciably dif- ferent from monthly averages. Birds from Christmas Island breed on a schedule similar to that of Hawaiian birds although it is somewhat more prolonged (Schreiber and Ash- mole, 1970), but it is not known if the birds disperse after breeding. In the Phoenix Islands the breeding cycle is an- nual but the peaks are not clearly defined (POBSP) . The cycle is five months ahead of the cycle in the Hawaiian group. Breeding birds arrive at their is- lands in September and eggs are laid in late No- vember or early December. Peak populations are found on the islands at this time, although more than half of the birds present are nonbreeders. Eggs hatch in early February and by March the adults visit the islands only sporadically at night to feed their chicks or to roost. Most adults leave the is- lands in early May, followed by most of the fledged young two weeks later. By early June few birds are left on the islands except small roosting popula- tions which remain during the nonbreeding season. The breeding cycle of San Benedicto Island ap- pears to be roughly synchronous with that of the northwestern Hawaiian group on the basis of the only available information: two egg dates, 31 May and 26 July (Anthony, 1900:252; Loomis, 1918: 142). SUMMARY OF PUBLISHED PELAGIC RECORDS.—The appendix summarizes the status of the Wedge- tailed Shearwater in the Pacific Ocean. Because few observers are familiar with the distinguishing char- acteristics of this species, many of the pelagic rec- ords are ambiguous; they could refer to one or more species that resemble either light- or dark-phase Wedge-tailed Shearwaters. In the eastern Pacific Wedge-tailed Shearwaters have never been identified with certainty south of the Gulf of Guayaquil (latitude 3°S) (Le've'que, 1964b:53-54). They have been reported several times along the Middle American coast from Pan- ama to Mexico near Manzanillo. Murphy's (1958) record of both light- and dark-phase birds off north 56 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY era Baja California in December is exceptional; they have not otherwise been reported north of 21 °N (Loomis, 1918), fully 500 miles farther south. Records from the eastern Pacific have been obtained mainly in the northern spring and fall. Morzer Bruyns (1965) saw Wedge-tailed Shear- waters over the Equatorial Countercurrent across most of the Pacific in November, dark-phase west of the Line Islands, and mixed from there east; King and Pyle (1957) found them in the Counter- current between the Line Islands and Mexico in October. In the southwest Pacific several authors (Jesper- sen, 1933; Fleming, 1950; Gibson, 1960; Mitchell, in Bourne, 1965; Morris, in Bourne, 1965; Norris, 1967) have noted scattered individuals or small groups of dark-phase birds between Samoa and Australia throughout the year. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.—In addition to all the co- operators who have made this paper possible (p. 5) special thanks are due to Gerald A. Sanger and Patrick J. Gould who were closely involved in analyzing the data. The latter was almost solely responsible for the section entitled "Density and Distribution within Equatorial Currents." I am also indebted to William R. P. Bourne, Roger Bailey, and George E. Watson for their criti- cal reading of the manuscript and their many help- ful suggestions and comments. Distribution and Abundance Figure 34-57 (pp. 68-91) show monthly densities of Wedgetailed Shearwaters in the central and east- ern Pacific based on POBSP observations between 1963 and 1968. Densities are expressed in terms of birds per linear mile of observation, and located on the monthly map at the ship's noon position. Areas of similar daily densities are contoured to show the relative abundance of the species in all areas of the Pacific where POBSP observations have been made. In cases where parallel ocean transects were made on cruises spanning two months, the contouring takes into account the distribution and abundance reflected in adjacent areas even though the data came from different months. Because of their geo- graphical and, often, phenological distinctness, light-phase and dark-phase birds are treated sep- arately. DENSITY AND DISTRIBUTION WITHIN EQUATORIAL CURRENTS The Equatorial Countercurrent is an eastward- flowing current, bounded on the south by the west- ward-flowing South Equatorial Current and on the north by the westward-flowing North Equatorial Current or the California Current Extension, de- pending on the longitude. Sverdrup, et al. (1942:709) point out its salient features, i.e., it is a well-developed, northern hemi- spheric phenomenon, whose boundaries fluctuate with the seasons, moving north with the northern summer. Data from the Carnegie Expedition dis- cussed by Sverdrup, et al. (1942:709-711) show that at latitude 140°W the countercurrent lies between 3°N and 10°N. Due to a distinct transverse circu- lation superimposed upon the major flow direction, a divergence occurs at the northern boundary of the countercurrent and at the equator, while a con- vergence occurs at the southern boundary. They speculate, on the basis of the plankton collections of the Carnegie Expedition, that divergences are of high productivity. Similarly, convergences concen- trate plankton and organisms that feed on plank- ton along narrow fronts (Ashmole and Ashmole, 1967). Other authors, e.g., Murphy (1936) and Morzer Bruyns (1965), have noted some of the ef- fects of oceanic currents on density and distribu- tion of birds. In the central Pacific Wedge-tailed Shearwaters may be found throughout the current areas. In general the dark-phase population predominates in the area south of 10°N, the area generally covered by the Equatorial Countercurrent and the South Equatorial Current. The dark-phase population moves north in conjunction with the northward movement of warm waters during the northern summer months. North of the countercurrent, light-phase birds predominate, although small numbers may some- times be encountered as far to the south as the equator or farther. These may represent migrants or nonbreeding visitors since they occur primarily during the nonbreeding period of the light-phase population. CENTRAL PACIFIC.—From January 1964 through February 1967, sixteen cruises were made by the POBSP across these equatorial currents in the area bounded by longitudes 165°W and 180°. Surface 57 15 North Equatorial Current Equatorial Countercurrent Degrees North Latitude FIGURE 30.—Density of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in relation to latitude across the equatorial currents in the central Pacific (165°W to 180°), all months, 1966. (Shaded bars -= dark phase; white bars = light phase.) water temperature ranged from 25.5° to 30.6°C throughout the period of study; the vast majority of samples fall between 27 °C and 30°C. Lowest temperatures were generally found north of the countercurrent and highest temperatures south. Within the countercurrent temperatures remained remarkably constant. Small densities of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were recorded throughout the current area at all times of the year; a few notable concentrations occurred between 4°N and 7°N in winter and spring, and at 9°N in July. A July peak, composed of 99 per- cent dark-phase birds, occurred during the period of northward movement of the dark-phase popu- lation. A concentration in the fall at 15°N can best be explained in terms of the attraction of Johnston Atoll, a nearby breeding site. Unlike Sooty Terns, whose pattern of distribution in the Equatorial Current area does not conform to any boundaries (Gould, p. 32 herein), Wedge-tailed Shearwaters appear to be most abundant within the borders of the Equatorial Countercurrent. This is best exemplified by Figure 30, in which all the data from 1966 are combined. Data from 1966 were used because data were complete enough to permit identification of the countercurrent on the basis of water temperature samples. EASTERN PACIFIC.—In the eastern Pacific the Equatorial Countercurrent is generally well defined east to 90°W longitude from June through Decem- ber, but diffused or absent during the rest of the year. Its southern boundary remains relatively sta- ble at 4°N to 6°N; its northern boundary fluctu- ates between 8°N and 12°N. It is farthest north during the northern summer (Wyrtki, 1966; n.d.). Figure 31 shows densities for six cruises through 58 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 5.0 4.5 4.0 3.5 _» 3.0 8.2.5 5 2.0 1.5 1.0 .5 6.08 15 14 12 10 m 8 7 6 5 Equatorial Countercurrent Degrees North Latitude FIGURE 31.—Density of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in relation to latitude across the Equatorial Countercurrent in the eastern Pacific (97°W to 126°W), 1967. (Shaded bars = dark phase; white bars = light phase.) the area bounded by 97°W and 126°W during 1967. Surface water temperatures show a different pattern for these cruises than for the central Pa- cific cruises. Temperatures remained between 25.5° and 28.8°C in latitudes south to ca. 6°N. At 6°N, temperatures began to drop rapidly; at ca. 2°N readings were between 23.8° and 25.7°C, dropping in one instance to 20.7°C near the equator at 97°W. Both color phases occur within this area, and, al- though the data base is too small to provide a com- plete picture, it appears that light-phase birds (pos- sibly nonbreeding sojourners from the central Pa- cific) predominate in the northern winter, while dark-phase birds (possibly from the Revilla Gigedo population) predominate during the rest of the year. All large concentrations were found between 4°N and 10°N. In February and March highest densities were near 10°N. Due to the unstable con- dition of the countercurrent at this time, its bound- aries cannot be defined clearly. In June and July highest densities were from 4°N to 5°N, corre- sponding fairly closely with the southern boundary of the countercurrent; smaller concentrations were found at 7°N and from 10°N to 11°N, the former being just north of the southern boundary of the countercurrent, and the latter just south of the northern boundary. In the fall (September) only one large concentration was noted, at 8°N, some- what south of the northern boundary of the coun- tercurrent. In the eastern Pacific, especially in the northern summer when the Equatorial Counter- current is strongest, Wedge-tailed Shearwaters NUMBER 158 59 reach highest densities near and within the borders of that current. RANGE OF SEA SURFACE TEMPERATURES AND SALINITIES AT WHICH WEDGE-TAILED SHEARWATERS WERE OBSERVED The Wedge-tailed Shearwater is distributed throughout most of the tropical central and eastern Pacific Ocean, and, thus, it is not surprising to find that the range of sea surface temperatures and salinities at which the species was observed is roughly as broad as the recorded temperatures and salinities of the area. Sea surface temperatures were recorded on a sufficiently large number of cruises to provide a substantial amount of data from which to draw conclusions; salinity determinations were far fewer, and the data are less conclusive. The water samplings within five minutes of the hours of 0800, 1000, 1200, 1400, and 1600 were as- sumed to give a fairly accurate measure of the temperature and salinity for one hour before and one hour after the hours mentioned. All sightings made one hour before to one hour after were as- signed the temperature and salinity values of said hours. Since each sample covers two hours of ob- servation, the ratio of birds to samples divided by 2 yields a bird per hour of observation figure. TEMPERATURE.—Sightings made when no sea surface temperatures were taken, or more than one hour before 0800 or after 1600, account for slightly more than one-half the data. Temperature correla- tions apply to 34,073 of 82,000 Wedge-tailed Shear- waters observed during the study. Table 14 shows the number of birds observed in conjunction with each whole degree of temperature centigrade, the number of water samples at each temperature, and the ratio of birds to samples. Table 14 suggests that Wedge-tailed Shearwaters showed no great sensitivity to temperature as long as it was above 21 °C. The lowest sea temperature at which Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were observed was 15.0°C. Two individuals were seen at this re- markably low temperature; otherwise the lowest temperature was 20.8°C, and the highest was 33.0°C. SALINITY.—Far fewer salinity measurements were made, too few to show anything but the range of salinities over which Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were observed. Table 15 shows the number of birds, TABLE 14.—Relative abundance of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters at various sea surface temperatures Temperature (°C) 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Total Number Number of of birds water samples Birds/Sample 0 13 502 278 5,193* 1,618 11,642 6396 5,579 1,185 1,398 69 34,073 56 66 75 98 133 445 853 900 814 340 276 14 4,070 .00 .20 6.56 2.84 39.05 3.64 13.65 7.33 6.85 3.49 5.07 4.93 'Includes a single sighting of 3500 individuals. This sight- ing is unusually large, and accounts for the inflated birds/ sample figure at 24°C. TABLE 15.—Wedge-tailed Shearwaters observed at various sea surface salinities Surface salinity (parts per thousand) 33.0-33.3. 33.3-33.7.. 33.8-34.1 . 34.2-34.5 34.6-34.9 35.0 + Total Number Number of of birds water samples Birds/Sample 4 18 17 84 158 87 368 4 11 31 46 49 38 179 1.00 1.64 0.55 1.83 3.22 2.29 the number of samples, and the birds per sample in each of six salinity ranges. Table 15 shows a fairly even spread across the recorded salinity range, with a tendency toward greater abundance at salinities 34.6 parts per thousand and above. The lowest re- corded salinity at which Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were seen was 32.60 parts per thousand; the highest was 36.54 parts per thousand. SPECIMEN RECORDS, MOLT, AND BAND RECOVERIES SPECIMEN RECORDS.—The POBSP secured speci- mens of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters at sea in both 60 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 30° N 20° 10° 0° 0° s 180° • • • • • » \ • 170* \ it • T • I- • - • DS • • - r. i • - ! | 160 •A- • : •sir • * • . > 1 • L •k ( 1 | i o 150 1 N it 10* 0* 120 W 12C* s 1 <. 110 > 5,i , \ v S r IK)' H i | s. 00 no V\ 30" 20 FICURE 32.—Distribution of light- and dark- phase Wedge-tailed Shearwater specimen rec- ords: left, in the central Pacific; right, in the eastern Pacific. the central and eastern Pacific. Table 16 lists the numbers of specimens of the two color phases col- lected each month. Figure 32 shows the location; by degree squares, where specimens were obtained; color phases are differentiated. TOPOGRAPHY AND SYNCHRONY OF MOLT.—Pri- mary molt proceeded distally from one locus. It was far more symmetrical than rectrix molt. The pri- maries on either wing were almost invariably at identical stages of growth. Growth differentials of one-half of a feather length were noted rarely. In distal primary molt (primaries 7 to 10) only one feather was replaced at a time. Growth of a distal primary was nearly completed as the next one be- gan to grow. Several inner primaries can be re- placed simultaneously. Rectrix molt was most intense during later pri- mary molt. It was only marginally symmetrical, usually more in the number and spacing of replaced feathers than in their position. For example, rec- trices 2 and 4 might be growing on the left, and rectrices 3 and 5 on the right. Rectrix replacement followed no fixed sequence. Usually one or two, and up to five, of the six rectrices on each side were replaced simultaneously. Contour feather molt probably started at the same time as, but was more protracted than, pri- mary molt. Head and nape feathers were replaced first, followed by scapular and rump feathers. New head and nape feathers of light-phase birds were gray and soft; old ones were browner and coarser. Newly replaced scapulars had conspicuous pale scallops at their tips. These pale scallops were most conspicuous in light-phase birds in December (pre- sumably first-year birds), slightly less so in adults in April. Most December light-phase birds had gray vermiculations on the crissum, flanks, and sides, similar to those of adult Pink-footed Shearwaters NUMBER 158 61 TABLE 16.—Specimens of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters collected by the POBSP each month Area and color phase CENTRAL PACIFIC Light phase Dark phase EASTERN PACIFIC Light phase Dark, phase Total Jan 0 - 3 - _ 3 Feb 3 3 - 1 7 Mar 1 2 3 6 Apr 12 20 - _ 32 May 32 7 - 39 Jun 25 17 1 43 Jul 18 10 - 1 29 Aug 30 2 - 32 Sep 24 10 - 34 Oct 2 5 4 1 12 Nov 1 11 - 12 Dec 16 3 - 19 Total 164 93 8 3 268 (Puffinus creatopus). Such vermiculations were present infrequently in light-phase birds from other months. First-year birds probably retain their juvenal plumage for 15 months. Adults molt primarily dur- ing their nonbreeding season, although replace- ment of contour feathers extends throughout the breeding season. Since adults and subadults are present together on islands, and most likely also at sea, most age-classes were probably sampled in the POBSP collections. Thus, it is likely that molt occurs simultaneously in all age-classes after the first year. SCHEDULE OF MOLT.—Light-phase Birds: No light-phase birds were collected at sea in January. Few were seen in the central Pacific, but they were common in the eastern Pacific. In early February in the eastern Pacific POBSP personnel (Woodward, pers. comm.) reported that they had noticeable gaps in their primaries, indicative of molt of the inner primaries. The three central Pacific speci- mens from February had no molt of remiges, rec- trices, or contour feathers; two had gray vermicula- tions on flanks and abdomen. These three were probably first-year birds with 3-month-old plumage since March and April specimens, presumably adults growing their 9th or 10th primaries, were in the midst of rectrix replacement and had re- placed head, nape, and some scapular contour feathers. Some March specimens collected on the northwestern Hawaiian Islands were completing growth of their 10th primaries. In April seven of twelve specimens taken at sea had completed remex and rectrix molt, but all were still replacing con- tour feathers. In May only one of 32 specimens had not completed flight feather molt, but contour feather molt was continuing in the scapulars and on the rump. No flight feather molt occurred on any bird from June to December. However, all six- teen December specimens had fresh plumage, in- cluding remiges and rectrices with a silvery sheen and prominent white scalloping on scapular and lower back feathers. (The scalloping was noticeable from a considerable distance at sea.) Their remiges had broad vanes and blunt tips with small sharp central points, similar to those of May specimens, indicative of unworn feathers. There was no indi- cation of remex replacement in the small sample of October and November birds, so I conclude that the December birds, which were all from the cen- tral Pacific, were fledglings and that adults and sub- adults had already left that area. Although the date of onset of molt is not known, adults and sub- adults might have already started to molt their worn plumage by December. These December birds were the only ones that followed ships regularly (see "Behavior"). Dark-phase Birds: The molt cycle in dark-phase birds is more complex than it is in light-phase birds because of the geographical and temporal overlap of populations at sea. There was some rec- trix or remex molt in 40 out of 96 birds, and in all months but May. Using the clear-cut molt cycle of the light-phase birds as a model, it is difficult to explain the molt cycles of dark-phase birds. Phoenix Islands' birds lay eggs in November and December; they should start flight-feather molt in May and complete it in October. Many specimens conform to this schedule. Five of 17 June birds were growing primaries 4, 5, or 6; 7 of 10 July birds were grow- ing primaries 6, 7, 8, or 9; several August birds and 7 of 10 September birds were growing primaries 9 62 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY or 10, and all 5 October birds had completed or nearly completed molt. Christmas Island birds lay eggs in June and July. They would be expected to begin molt in Novem- ber and to complete it in April. Seven birds col- lected in November were growing primaries 3 to 7; two January birds were growing primary number 8; 17 of the 20 April birds and all May birds had completed molt of flight feathers. These birds con- form to the Christmas Island schedule. There are still a number of dark-phase specimens that conform to neither of these schedules. The large number of birds molting at all times of the year suggests two explanations: either most birds are from local populations (e.g., Line and Phoenix islands) and are present around their breeding is- lands a greater part of the year and molt is more protracted than in their subtropical, light-phase counterparts, or the central Pacific is invaded by postbreeders from other populations. The two theories are not mutually exclusive. I suspect both are true. BAND RECOVERIES.—Between 1963 and 1969 POBSP personnel banded 75,285 Wedge-tailed Shear- waters, 65,806 in the Hawaiian Islands, Johnston Atoll, and the northern Marshall Islands, and 9,479 in the Line and Phoenix islands. Nineteen banded birds were recovered at sea by August 1969. Three had been banded on Johnston Atoll; the remainder had been banded on islets off the northeast coast of Oahu. The only significant recovery is the southernmost record from Cook Strait, New Zealand, described in the introduction. Recoveries of birds banded on Johnston Atoll were within 300 miles southwest or northwest of Johnston Atoll. Birds banded on islets off Oahu were recovered within 100 miles in all di- rections of Oahu. All recoveries were made between April and October—the breeding season. On 11 October 1964 a bird that had been marked with an orange plastic leg streamer on Johnston Atoll was seen at latitude 9°25'N, longitude 152°55'W, about 1250 miles southeast of its place of marking. Although it is tempting to suggest that this is evidence for migration, individuals doubtless range thousands of miles searching for food, so that this location might well be included within the possible foraging range of the Johnston Atoll population. DISCUSSION In the central Pacific light-phase distribution and abundance at sea were quite evidently tied to the breeding cycle of the birds on the Hawaiian Islands and Johnston Atoll. During the northern winter light-phase bird abundance was lowest and, al- though there was a poorly defined density center at the Equatorial Countercurrent, for the most part the few birds that were recorded were scattered. In February light-phase birds were virtually absent from the central Pacific north of 10°N (7 individ- uals in 4 years). Data from March showed birds re- entering that area, and from April through Novem- ber a typical distribution pattern prevailed with only minor irregularities; maximum densities dur- ing this period were recorded consistently within 100 miles of the breeding islands. In the eastern Pacific the timing was reversed. Light-phase birds were most abundant from Octo- ber to February (a maximum of 10.6 BPM south of Guatemala in February), and least abundant from March to September. Greatest densities were re- corded between 6°N and 12°N, the area of the Equatorial Countercurrent, and the normal light- phase range did not appear to extend very much farther north or south. The northern limit ap- peared to be approximately 25°N latitude. I conclude that the eastern Pacific is a major win- tering ground for light-phase birds from the Ha- waiian group. I suspect they migrate there along the Equatorial Countercurrent and return via the North Equatorial Current. The at-sea distribution and abundance of dark- phase birds cannot be tied as readily to their breed- ing cycles. In the first place the two populations that breed in the central Pacific do so at opposite seasons. (Increasing density in the eastern Pacific concurrent with the beginning of the breeding sea- son on Christmas Island suggests that the bulk of eastern Pacific dark-phase birds in the northern summer do not come from Christmas Island.) Sec- ondly, both populations number in the tens of thousands, rather than hundreds of thousands as does the Hawaiian population. Thirdly, there are many more dark-phase colonies across the Pacific than there are light-phase colonies. Thus, assigning islands of origin to any group of dark-phase birds encountered at sea is, at our present level of knowl- edge, only conjecture. NUMBER 158 Several tendencies in dark-phase distribution are worth noting. The first is the repeated association of high densities with the Equatorial Countercur- rent area, not only in the central Pacific but also in the eastern Pacific. The second is the extent and timing o£ the northward penetration of dark-phase birds. This penetration began in April at the same time that light-phase birds were once again becom- ing numerous to the north. It increased in scope and intensity to a peak in July and August, during which time dark-phase birds were found nearly as far north (to ca. 23°N) as light-phase birds. Num- bers decreased thereafter until there were almost no dark-phase birds to be seen north of 10°N dur- ing December, January, and February. In other words, the distribution and abundance pattern of dark-phase birds north of 10°N in the central Pa- cific paralleled that of light-phase birds. A parallel situation occurs in the Indian Ocean (Bailey, 1968). During the northern winter, the breeding season for Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in the western Indian Ocean, the birds are distributed most abundantly along the Equatorial Countercur- rent. In summer, when the countercurrent weakens or is absent, birds move north to the Bay of Ben- gal and the Arabian Sea in substantial numbers. In the eastern Pacific light-phase and dark-phase birds occupied roughly the same area, but they reached maximum abundance at different times of year. Both phases reached greatest densities between the Equatorial Countercurrent and the coast of Mexico near Manzanillo. Light-phase birds gen- erally were not seen south of 4°N, whereas dark- phase birds were seen occasionally as far south as POBSP observations were made (to latitude 20°S in some months). Light-phase birds were most abun- dant between October and February; dark-phase birds attained highest densities from June to Sep- tember. It is likely that a few birds of both phases, probably nonbreeders, were present throughout the year in the eastern Pacific. The implication of an abundance cycle in the eastern Pacific of dark-phase birds similar to that of light-phase birds, although several months out of phase, is that dark-phase birds from yet unspecified breeding sites perform an annual translongitudinal migration also. Even if all the dark-phase birds en- countered in the eastern Pacific were from the Revilla Gigedos, which is quite unlikely, they must be making an extensive migration, for there are fewer dark-phase birds to be found in the eastern Pacific from October to May than from June to September. Several sources (Jespersen, 1933; Dixon and Star- rett, 1952; MacDonald and Lawford, 1954; Morzer Bruyns, 1965) indicate the presence in the western tropical Pacific between New Guinea and the Mari- anas, and in the Philippine Sea, of large numbers of dark-phase Wedge-tailed Shearwaters from April to October. POBSP personnel saw light-phase birds between the Tokelau and Samoan islands at 12°S latitude in February. Dixon and Starrett (1952) also suggest that light-phase birds are present, at least south of the Marianas, in January and Febru- ary although these may have been any of several other species, especially Streaked Shearwater (Cal- onectris lencomelas). Thus there may be in the western Pacific a situation directly analogous to that of the eastern Pacific in which both phases are present but with abundance peaks in different sea- sons. Behavior FEEDING.—Wedge-tailed Shearwaters have been observed feeding on the surface, under the surface, and in the air. The method most frequently noted by POBSP observers, at least for diurnal flocks, was "contact dipping," to use the terminology of Ash- mole and Ashmole (1967). Second in frequency was "feeding on the surface," third was "air dip- ping," and fourth was "air diving." In contact dipping birds flew close to the sur- face, wings held back as if to hover, sometimes touching the surface with outstretched feet. Head and neck were plunged down several inches into the water. Forward momentum was regained by vigorous wing beats and foot paddling. Usually when a fish was caught it was eaten without inter- rupting flight although birds stopped on the sur- face occasionally, presumably to swallow heavy prey. This was the only method of feeding observed at night (Gould, 1967), although it is likely that feeding on the surface was used too. Feeding on the surface was often accomplished from a sitting position but sometimes a surface dive was employed, although rarely forcefully enough to submerge a bird completely under water. Wing tips and tail usually remained out of water. Air dipping was seen infrequently. It involved 64 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 70 T 1 2 3 5 610 11-25 26-50 51100 101 Number in Sighting FIGURE 33.—Number of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters per sight- ing in a sample of 1000 sightings in which this species was recorded. pursuit of a Hying fish above the surface of the wa- ter, sometimes accompanied by vigorous foot strokes for increased speed. Air dives were rarely observed. They involved a dive into the water "just about like the boobies" (POBSP, Dayle Husted). No further description is available. There were no observations to indicate that birds swim any distance under water, in spite of adapta- tions for this purpose such as laterally compressed tarsi and compact plumage (Kuroda, 1954; Storer, 1960). FLOCKING.—Figure 33 shows the number of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters counted or estimated per sighting in a random sample of 1000 sightings in which the species was observed. A sighting is de- fined here as the observation of one or more birds acting as a unit. Occasionally it was difficult to de- cide whether birds seen at the same time were asso- ciated or not. This was especially true close to breeding areas where streams of birds of several species could be seen coming and going at the same time. Most sightings (66.9%) were of single birds. Progressively fewer sightings were made of larger groupings. Only 0.3 percent of sightings contained 100 or more birds. However, the largest number seen in one sighting was 3500. This was part of a large milling mass of birds near Kaula Rock. Of 70 flocks containing 100 or more Wedge-tailed Shear- waters, the mean number for that species was 307. Fifty out of 70 (71.4%) flocks of more than 100 Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were within one day's travel (100 miles or less) of the Hawaiian Islands. ASSOCIATION WITH OTHER SPECIES.—Casual ob- servations at sea suggest that birds of some species tend to occur individually, others tend to associate frequently with other members of the same species, and still other species tend to occur in mixed- species aggregates. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters usu- ally travel singly or in small groups, but feed most frequently in large mixed-species flocks. Data on association of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in all sightings between 1963 and 1969 were ana- lyzed to determine the relative tendency for the spe- cies to occur alone or in conjunction with other species. Data showed that Wedge-tailed Shearwaters associated with members of other species in 57.8 percent of the sightings, and were alone or with other Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in 42.2 percent of the sightings (Table 17). To understand why more Wedge-tailed Shear- waters were seen in mixed-species aggregates than alone, it is important to look at the behavior of the respective groups. The categories of behavior for which information was recorded systematically in- cluded sitting on the water, feeding, searching, fol- lowing the ship, displaying, parasitism, dispersing, and traveling. The behavior of birds at sea, how- ever, is sometimes difficult to characterize. Search- ing and dispersing are closely related to feeding. Searching implies that a flock of birds has formed and is about to feed when schooling fish break the surface. Dispersing implies that a flock was feeding a short time before observation, but inability to TABLE 17.—Sightings of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters in association with other species and alone Status Associated Unassociated Total Average number Number of Number of of birds per birds sightings sighting 47,276 34,561 81,837 3^25 14,743 17,968 14.66 2.34 4.56 NUMBER 158 65 TABLE 18.—Number and percentage of sightings in which various species were observed feeding with Wedge-tailed Shearwaters (n = 1285) Species Puffinus pacificus (alone) Sterna fuscata Anous stolidus Gygis alba Sula sula Pterodroma externa externa Fregata minor Pterodroma hypoleuca nigripennis Sula dactylatra Puffinus puffinus neweHi Sula leucogaster Puffinus griseus Bulweria bulwerii Pterodroma externa cervicalis Sterna lunata Anous tenuirostris Fregata ariel Pterodroma neglecta Puffinus nativitatis Oceanodroma leucorhoa Stercorarius pomarinus Puffinus carneipes Puffinus Iherminieri Pterodroma alba Phaethon rubricauda Procelsterna cerulea Stercorarius longicaudus Diomedea immutabilis Phaethon lepturus Number Percentage 85 994 241 239 213 192 112 104 90 75 45 43 43 40 31 30 28 26 24 20 17 15 15 13 11 10 8 7 7 6.6 77.4 18.8 18.6 16.6 14.9 8.7 8.1 7.0 5.8 3.5 3.3 3.3 3.1 2.4 2.3 2.2 2.0 1.9 1.6 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.0 0.9 0.8 0.6 03 0.5 find more surfacing fish was resulting in disintegra- tion of the flock. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were not known to display at sea, nor were they subject at sea with any regularity to parasitic attacks by jaegers (Stercorarius spp.), skuas (Catharacta skua), or frigatebirds (Fregata spp.). Wedge-tailed Shearwaters not actively involved in any other behavioral activity were assumed to be traveling. Thus, it is not surprising that in only 2172 sightings (12.1%) was a behavior noted other than that of traveling. Of behavioral categories other than traveling, feeding was probably of greatest significance, be- cause, next to traveling, the greatest number of sightings were of feeding birds (1285 sightings). An additional 295 sightings were noted as searching and 16 were dispersing. Significant interspecific re- lationships can be shown best by analyzing the spe- cies content of the 1285 sightings of feeding birds. I disregarded searching and dispersing birds in this analysis because of the possibility that these behav- iors were misinterpreted by the observers. Table 18 lists the number and percentage of sightings in which various species were in feeding association with Wedge-tailed Shearwaters. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters fed without other species present only 6.6 percent of the time; 93.4 percent of the time they fed in association with other species, especially Sooty Terns (Sterna fuscata). In mixed feeding flocks in the tropical Pacific Ocean, Wedge-tailed Shearwaters and the noddies (Anous spp.) fly lowest, usually no higher than 10 meters above the water. Boobies (Sula spp.) usu- ally fly between 10 and 30 meters and Sooty Terns and White Terns (Gygis alba) fly between 20 and 60 meters above water level. Frigatebirds can be found substantially higher, perhaps as high as 120 or 160 meters. These are the approximate levels at which these species fly during the periods when the schooling fish are not surfacing. The longer the periods between surfacing, the higher the Sooty Terns and frigatebirds tend to fly, and the more dispersed the typical feeding flock becomes. When fish once again break the surface it is difficult for an observer to tell which component of the flock spots them first, but an observer quickly learns to watch for a characteristic flash of white as the Sooty Terns bank from horizontal flight, exposing their white underparts against the sky, in a dive toward the surfacing fish. It is visible to an observer perhaps a mile or more away, appearing like snowflakes danc- ing on the horizon. The presence of frigatebirds over the terns confirms the suspicion that a flock has gathered and is or has been feeding. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters utilize a modified dynamic soaring technique in flight, less efficient than the soaring of albatrosses because of higher wing loading and lower aspect ratio. However, they take advantage of the differentials in windspeed at different elevations over the waves caused by sur- face friction, and are, therefore, more or less tied to the air layer in which windspeed differentials are greatest. Sooty Terns and frigatebirds, on the other hand, either soar statically or propel themselves by constant wingbeats, and are not tied as closely to the surface of the water. Sooty Terns are in a good position to act as the "eyes" of the flock, both because they are high 66 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY above the water and because their greater abun- dance permits a greater area of ocean to be kept under surveillance for surfacing fish. If human ob- servers can take advantage of the Sooty Terns' dives to the surface as an indication of feeding activity, it is not unreasonable to suspect that birds do the same. Although the behavioral pattern of Sooty Terns may bring increased numbers of other spe- cies to the feeding area, competition for food is probably minimal because food is superabundant for the short periods when it is available. The ephemeral nature of the food supply sug- gests that, up to a point, more, rather than fewer, birds help to make the supply of food more readily available. Ashmole (1963, postscript) suggested that although tropical seabirds may be limited in their abundance by the availability of food, their effect on the abundance of the food organisms is probably negligible. This is probably also true in areas of food concentration (for example, in the upwellings of the Peru current, where birds' search efficiencies are undoubtedly much higher than for tropical oceans as a whole), where breeding adap- tations permit more rapid growth of offspring and population sizes commensurate with predictable abundance of food (see Nelson, 1968, for a com- parison of breeding adaptations of boobies within and without such an area of predictable food abun- dance) . Seas surrounding breeding islands in areas without unusual food abundance may support sea- bird concentrations large enough to cause competi- tion for available food resources. In the face of such competition some species, such as Sooty Terns and Wedge-tailed Shearwaters, can, if necessary, exploit seas at greater distances from their breeding islands than can others, e.g., noddies and boobies. Travel- ing greater distances for food places more impor- tance on the role of search time in the species' en- ergy budget than in birds of areas of food abun- dance, and the resulting breeding strategies tend to be more conservative, e.g., fewer offspring, longer incubation stints, and longer fledging periods. Of significance is the relatively low percent of participation in feeding sightings of the Sooty Shearwater Puffinus griseus, Bulwer's Petrel Bul- weria bulwerii, Leach's Petrel Oceanodroma leuco- rhoa, and the two tropicbirds Phaethon spp., all of which are more abundant than is suggested by Table 18. The first species, and its traveling com- panion the Slender-billed Shearwater Puffinus TABLE 19.—Sightings of sitting birds that included Wedge-tailed Shearwaters (n=465) Species Puffinus pacificus (alone) Pterodroma externa Anous stolidus Puffinus puffinus newelli Sula sula Puffinus puffinus auricularis or P. p. opisthomelas Sula leucogaster Puffinus griseus Pterodroma hypoleuca nigripennis. . Sula dactylatra Number Percentage 382 34 9 7 6 4 3 3 3 3 82.2 7.3 1.9 1.5 1.3 0.9 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 tenuirostris, seldom stops to feed in the tropics dur- ing its transequatorial migrations. The other species are all more or less solitary feeders. SITTING ON WATER.—Wedge-tailed Shearwaters frequently sit on the water during the day. Of 465 sightings of sitting birds which included Wedge- tailed Shearwaters, 382 (82.2%) sightings were of Wedge-tailed Shearwaters only. Other species most frequently associated with Wedge-tails were Juan Fernandez Petrels Pterodroma externa externa, and White-necked Petrels P.e. cervicalis. These petrels, not readily distinguished from one another on the water, were frequently seen sitting on the water singly and in rafts up to ten birds during the months of June to October undergoing heavy molt. They were frequently joined by Wedge-tailed Shear- waters. Table 19 gives the frequency with which other species were seen to sit on the water with Wedge-tailed Shearwaters. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters seem to sit on the wa- ter most frequently under two conditions. The first is in association with flocks in which individuals have finished feeding and are resting on the water in small rafts. The second is evidently prior to mi- gration. Rafts of up to 700 or more Wedge-tailed Shearwaters have been seen, mainly near the Ha- waiian Islands in November when the young of the year are fledging; the age-structure of the rafts is not known. FOLLOWING SHIPS.—Wedge-tailed Shearwaters were recorded following ships 20 times. I will omit an analysis of the other species involved in these sightings because of the difficulty in determining if an individual bird was actually following, or if it NUMBER 158 67 passed aft of the ship, turned, and ran with the ship and the other birds for a short while. Also, if the ship provided the stimulus that led the birds to fol- low, then the association of the various species would be purely accidental. There can be no doubt, however, that Wedge- tailed Shearwaters occasionally followed ships for 30 minutes or more. They followed ships most read- ily in November and December in the vicinity of the Hawaiian Islands, and the birds that followed always seemed to have very fresh plumage. They may have been fledglings, attracted to the ship be- cause of food smells emanating from it. Normally Wedge-tailed Shearwaters did not follow ships, al- though they did not seem to avoid them as did some other species, e.g., Sooty and Slender-billed Shearwaters. Summary The Wedge-tailed Shearwater breeds on numer- ous islands in the tropical and subtropical Pacific Ocean. The infrequent sightings of the species at sea belie the fact that it is abundant and wide- spread. Some of its subtropical populations per- form extensive migrations. Birds from the Ha- waiian Islands, for example, probably migrate south to the Equatorial Countercurrent and then east to the coast of Middle America during their nonbreeding season. Molt takes place during the nonbreeding season and is nearly completed when the birds return to the central Pacific to breed. Tropical populations are present at sea near their breeding islands most of the year, and may not mi- grate. Consistently high densities of birds were recorded in the vicinity of the Hawaiian Islands, in the equa- torial current area between latitudes 4°S and 10°N, and off the coasts of Middle America. Light-phase birds were abundant in the central Pacific during the northern summer and all but absent during the northern winter; the cycle of abundance was re- versed in the eastern Pacific. The abundance of dark-phase birds paralleled that of light-phase birds in the central Pacific, but alternated with light- phase birds in the eastern Pacific. Within the equa- torial currents birds were most abundant near the boundaries of the Equatorial Countercurrent. Wedge-tailed Shearwaters are gregarious when feeding, but more solitary when traveling. Three- quarters of the sightings in which this species was noted feeding contained Sooty Terns; Wedge-tailed Shearwaters may rely on the conspicuous diving be- havior of the Sooty Terns to help them locate food. 68 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY * « j£ 5/3 -3 ta il i> 6fi "E £ JZ be \-2 c III ! c o v at i 1c c O .1 — • ^ NUMBER 158 69 o o o o o o o o o o '? o o o \ o o o o o o o oo . §0 . . : be O | | •c 9 60 - 70 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY O O o o X • .3 2 E (Ajj li I fg NUMBER 158 71 II TB-a l l *1 J3 •SP e — o S e •T3 H 72 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY S ' 8 " S3 • 8 - S "8 t a Z5 | o si Js NUMBER 158 73 3 * 2 c 2*2 •si 2 74 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY • • • • • • ' . 8 9o s s S .s i S V5 >-> •a s n 2 §8 l | NUMBER 158 75 . \ \ V.V \ v •' • • • I - 9 t •a * 76 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY >'?* •-• s$ u E 1/5 a. II a. :. o ° "O Si •5 a NUMBER 158 77 Cf'o Is I! ^ o x-y;? J 78 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY O o O K ' ••<# » *' * JL § a 1 II 21 I £' •8 6 5 s 5 NUMBER 158 79 1 .»•?"••% "So 1 -s 1 J l Sri|i •3 ft. Is 80 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY • • • • • • ' • *'' •S 2 e £ 3 "8 c s-'S • s i fl C NUMBER 158 81 o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o O O O o o o sifr 1? I! t * 2 10 c O S o 82 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY ° o o° l o o o ^ NUMBER 158 85 .J ' r3 «i 9-g •a e •S o « £ -3 C 86 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY £ '2 f . ^2 3 l~ 1 i 87 2 "o £ a II 1 I i .2 II c i 3 88 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOCY 2 *S <*'%.* s \\^\\\2 V m* c i s Si e NUMBER 158 89 .5 2 i« I1IE f s 2 90 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY •Jb •sirsT .- t 0 i be o IS u u NUMBER 158 91 \ O O\ o •o o O o ° \v> . «# - *l • ei ^ 1 I* M II Appendix Summary of published data on Wedge-tailed Shearwater distribution Location Date Remarks Source NORTHEAST PACIFIC Vancouver, B. C. EAST-CENTRAL PACIFIC Off N Baja California Off Manzanillo, Mexico 20°59'N, 111°57'W 19°37'N, H1°H'W Rcvilla Gigcdos Rcvilla Gigcdos 16°55'N, 07°23'N to 97°48'W, 112°55'W Off Cape San Lucas. Mexico Off Xayarit, Mexico Off Nicoya Peninsula, Costa Rica 11°N, 90°55'W Off Darien, Panama 10°18'N, 121°04'W Clippcrton 9°46'N, 93°S0'\V 7°58'N, I08°25'W 7°N. 131 °W 7°N, 123°W 7°N, 109°W 7°N, 101°VV 7°N, 93°W W of Panama S of Panama 4°N, 96°30'W 3°24'N, 84°12'W l°40'N. 86°W l°30'N, 108c30'W 0°30'S, 120°W NW coast of South America NW of Galapagos I. Gulf of Guayaquil 6°22'S, 117°O8'W SOUTHEAST PACIFIC 13°34'S, 103°;>9'W 23°28'S, 127O31'W not noted hypothetical, based on 1 specimen, questionable data 16 Dec 56 light and dark seen 24 Oct 55 8 23 Jul 05 a few 2"> Jul 05 common not noted thousands not noted breeds 28 Scp-18 Oct seen daily 05 not noted recorded not noted recorded 8 Fcb 38 3 specimens, 20 miles S of Cabo Blanco 17 Nov 56 many, all light 5 Mar 41 2 specimens at sea 5 km NW of Enscnada, Guayabo 13 Oct 55 came aboard ship not noted 3 specimens, 7 seen in caves and on bank of lagoon 6 Dec 56 seen 27 Oct 55 I 9 Nov 60 25 dark, 1 pale 10 Nov 60 1 dark 12 Xov 60 1 dark, 3 pale 13 Xov 60 2 dark 14 Xov 60 10-20 dark and 10-20 pale not noted seen not noted seen 25 Apr 64 1 of this species or P. natwitatis 23 Nov 58 1 3 Sep 56 3 27 Apr 64 1 of this species or P. natwitatis 29 Apr 64 1 of this species or P. nativitatis not noted occurs regularly 7 Aug 62 1 specimen 14 Mar 62 seen in numbers, light phase 23 Nov 57 1 light, probable 29 Mar 50 2 possibles, dark 9 Jul 48 3 possibles, dark Godfrey, 1966:23 Murphy, 1958:104 King and Pylc, 1957:35 Loomis, 1918:142 Anthony, 1900:250-251 Brattstrom and Howcll, 1956:111-112 Loomis, 1918:142 Blake, 1953:10 Slud, 1964:31 Murphy, 1958:104 Wctmore, 1965:42 King and Pylc, 1957:35 Loomis, 1918:142 Murphy, 1958:104 King and Pylc, 1957:35 Morzcr Bruyns, 1965:58 Harrison in Bourne, 1959:13 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 Leveque, ct al., 1966:84 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 I^veque. et al., 1966:84 Lcvequc, 1964b:53-54 Gibson. 1960:16 Laird, 1951:176-177 Fleming, 1950:175 92 NUMBER 158 93 Summary of published data on Wedge-tailed Shearwater distribution—Continued Location Date Remarks Source NORTHWEST PACIFIC Off Izu I. not noted not uncommon Austin and Kuroda, 1953:305 WEST-CENTRAL PACIFIC Bonin and Volcano I. not noted Marcus Pescadores Pescadores Philippine Sea 15°57'N, 113°12'E Philippines Marianas Marianas Marianas Carolines 7°N, 141°E 7°N, 150°E 7°N, 157°E 7°N, 157°E 10°S, 151°30'E Off S coast of New Guinea New Guinea New Guinea and Celebes Solomons not noted not noted not noted Apr 52 10,15,28 Jan 61 not noted 22 Aug 45 Jan-Fcb 46 not noted not noted 29 Oct 60 30 Oct 60 31 Oct 60 1 Nov 60 4 Oct 63 3 Oct 63 not noted Jul 29 not noted "Comes to land in late Mar. or Apr., some remaining until end of Nov. After breed- ing, a few stray northward to the waters off Japan." may still breed seen in May breeds this species or P. carneipes, sometimes in large numbers probables seen a few stragglers flocks of 21 and 41 (dark-bellied?) 100 miles S\V from Sariguan, Marianas white-bcllicd birds, possibly this species, off southern Marianas breeds Aug breeds tlark phase in numbers up to 10 up to 6 dark at Helen Shoal 1 dark at Ngatik I. 0 dark N of Kusaie I. several 1 1 this species or P. carneipes, very numer- ous from X point of Celebes, easterly toward the waters N of New Guinea breeds King, 1967:118 Cheng, 1955:6 Murphy, 1951:9 MacUonald and Lawford, 1954:19-20 Mitchell »>i Bourne and Radford, 1962:16 Dclacour and Mayr, 1946:21 Dixon and Starrett, 1952:269-270 Baker, 1951:65 Murphy, 1951:2 Morzcr Bruyns, 1965:58 Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Rand and Gilliard, 1967:29 Jespersen, 1933:196 Murphy, 1951:2 SOUTHWEST PACIFIC I7°S, 158°E Near New Caledonia 23°46'S, 151°18'E New Caledonia New Caledonia 26°16'S, 161°24'E 27°3O'S, 154°30'E 30°55'S, 155°17'E lasnian and Coral Seas East Australia, Lord Howe and Norfolk I. Off Sydney, Australia Off Sydney, Australia 37°41'S, 134°E Makara, New Zealand 1 well represented $ probables, dark several, all dark breeds usually 1 or 2 in sight 24 Oct 63 18 Dec 57 16 Nov 61 Nov 28 not noted 19 Dec 57 26 Oct 63 2 20 Dec 57 some in sight all day, once in hundreds Aug 61-Scp 62 numerous dark-phase sightings not noted breeds Sep to Dec 21 Dec 57 seen 27 Oct 63 2 19 Apr 57 1 dark 26 Jan 62 1 specimen, white-breasted Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Gibson, 1960:18 Semple in Bourne and Radford, 1962:16 Jespersen. 1933:1% Delacour, 1966:20 Gibson, 1960:18 Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Gibson, 1960:18-19 Norris, 1967:37-38 Mathcws and Iredale, 1921:26 Gibson, 1960:19 Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Gibson, 1960:12 Falla, 1962:278-279 CENTRAL PACFIC N, E, and W of Hawaiian I. Feb 64-Jun 65 Abundant Mar-Nov, uncommon Dcc-Feb King. 1970:25 94 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Summary of published data on Wedge-tailed Shearwater distribution—Continued Location Hawaiian I. Hawaiian I. Off Pearl Harbor, Oahu 150 to 350 miles WSW of Johnston Atoll Off Oahu Wake 13°S0'N, 180° Marshalls 9°55'N, 164°48'W 9°43'N, lM°5lrW 9°04'N. 143°49'W Christmas I. 7°N, 179°E 7°N, 180° 7°N, 166°W 7°N, 152°W 7°N, 146°W 7°N, 138°W (N of Marquesas ) 6°N, 153°W Jaluit Phoenix 4°-02°30'S, 169°-155°E Marquesas SOUTH-CENTRAL PACIFIC New Hebrides 11°S, 177°W 11°S, W W W Samoa Samoa Tonga 14°30'S, 176°E 14°47'S, 170*35^ Fiji Fiji Tuamotus Henderson 16°S, 178°W 16°09'S, 176°42'E 17°57'S, 169°52'E Society 18°28'S, 172°48'W 19°30'S, 177°3O'E 19°30'S, 178°E 2O°O2'S, 175°01'W Near Papeete, Tahiti Near Fiji 24°S, 166°30'E 25°S, 176°30'E Australs Date 27 Apr 45 28 Apr 45 29 Apr 45 not noted 24 Dec 61 30 Apr 45 24 May 59 not noted 1 May 45 not noted 26 May 59 6 Oct 55 4 Oct 55 not noted 3 Nov 60 4 Nov 60 (E) 4 Nov 60 (W) 6 Nov 60 7 Nov 60 8 Nov 60 9 Dec 63 2 Nov 60 not noted Oct 51 not noted not noted 30 Mar 63 8 May 64 Nov 28 not noted not noted 16 Nov 63 27 Feb 63 not noted Nov 28 not noted not noted 10 May 64 9 Dec 57 10 Dec 57 not noted 6 Dec 57 12 May 64 2 Feb 63 25 Feb 63 28 Nov 57 24 Mar 59 14 May 64 3 Feb 63 not noted Remarks 11 S of Oahu 14 S of Oahu 5 near Johnston Atoll breeds May-Nov 200 light, 3 dark 33 5 migrant (bred formerly) 2 breeds 8 of this species or P. carneipes flock of 20 came aboard ship breeds Feb-Nov two groups of 200 dark 2 dark 2 dark 6 pale 3 dark 110 dark, 1 pale 1 10 dark breeds all months small numbers of this species or P. car- neipes between Niutao Atoll and the Admiralty I. breeds breeds Jan-Jun 3 1 of this species or P. nativitatis several, all dark breeds breeds several 1 in hand breeds several, all dark breeds breeds 1 of this species or P. nativitatis occasional seen breeds small flock, dark birds, 1 light 1 of this species or P. nativitatis I probable 1 in hand dark birds seen, possibly this species seen several 1 probable breeds Source Cogswell, 1946a:47 Cogswell, 1946a:47-48 Cogswell, 1946a:48 Richardson, 1957:16 King in Bourne, 1964:19 Cogswell, 1946a:48 Peakall, 1960:199 King, 1967:111 Cogswell, 1946b:53 Amerson, 1969:295 Peakall. 1960:199 King and Pyle, 1957:35 " " " Schrciber and Ashmole, 1970:368 Mdrzer Bruyns, 1965:58 " " " " " » " " •• " " " •• » Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Mdrzer Bruyns, 1965:58 King, 1967:93 MacDonald and Lawford, 1954:19 Murphy, 1951:2 King, 1967:105 Morris in Bourne, 1965:19 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 Jespersen, 1933:195-196 Murphy, 1951:2 Davidson, 1931:217-218 Mitchell in Bourne, 1965:19 Jenkins in Bourne, 1965:19 Murphy, 1951:2 Jespersen, 1933: 196 Murphy, 1951:2 >. >. Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 Gibson, 1960:18 » » Murphy, 1951:2 Gibson, 1960:17 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 Morris in Bourne, 1965:19 Jenkins in Bourne, 1965:19 Gibson, 1960:17 Dixon in Bourne, 1959:11 Mitchell in Bourne, 1966:19 Morris in Bourne, 1965:19 Mnrnhv IQR1-9 NUMBER 158 95 Summary of published data on Wedge-tailed Shearwater distribution—Continued Location Date Remarks Source 26°15'S, 176°56'W 14 Mar 47 50-60 Fleming, 1950:172 26°28'S, 176°32'W 15 Mar 47 scattered group of 15 " " " 30 °S, 175°30'E 4 Fcb 63 1 probable Morris in Bourne, 1965:19 Kermadecs not noted breeds Oct-early Jun Falla, et al., 1%7:42 Kermadecs not noted breeds Dec-May Sorensen, 1964:70 33°S, 176°30'E 5 Jun 63 2 Morris in Bourne, 1965:19 Black-footed Albatross (Diomedea nigripes)* Gerald A. Sanger Introduction The material contained in this report is a sum- mary of all at-sea observations of the Black-footed Albatross (Diomedea nigripes) by the POBSP in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean. Literature records, scattered northern Pacific POBSP records, and data obtained from POBSP island surveys are included for general background information. Humphrey (1965) gave a general summary of the objectives of the program and Gould summarized the areas surveyed and the methods and materials used in data collection and analysis. The reader is referred to these papers for more details. The Black-footed Albatross is probably the most often seen and best known of the truly pelagic northern Pacific birds. It has been the subject of more papers on distribution and habits at sea than any other northern Pacific seabird. In recent years, intensive research relating to albatross interference with aircraft operation at Midway Atoll has been conducted. While the breeding grounds research has been most fruitful (Rice and Kenyon, 1962a, 1962b; Robbins, 1966), the at-sea studies, because of their general lack of temporal and seasonal scope, have given only general ideas of the overall distribution and ecology. Rice and Kenyon (1962a: 383) conservatively estimated the world's population of Black-foots at 300,000 birds during the period 1956-1958. Rob- bins (1966:9) noted a sharp decrease in the nesting population at Sand Island, Midway Atoll, through 1963, but felt that there was not enough informa- Geiald A. Sanger, National Marine Fisheries Service, North- west Fisheries Center, 2725 Montlake Blvd. East, Seattle, Washington 98112. tion available on prebreeding and older "unem- ployed" ( = not breeding) birds for a direct com- parison with Rice and Kenyon's 1957-1958 popu- lation estimate. BREEDING.—The Black-footed Albatross breeds mainly in the leeward Hawaiian chain (Rice and Kenyon, 1962a). A small colony (ca. 20 birds) exists on Torishima, in the Izu Islands, south of Honshu, Japan (Aronoff, 1960). The leeward Hawaiian Islands support breeding Black-footed Albatross populations as shown in Ta- ble 20. The breeding cycle (see Rice and Kenyon, 1962b) is nearly identical from island to island and from year to year. Table 21 summarizes this infor- mation. Breeding birds begin returning to their islands late in October. Eggs are laid between the middle of November and the first week of Decem- ber; they are incubated for 66 days, and most of the chicks have hatched by the end of January. At TABLE 20.—Largest numbers of breeding Black- footed Albatross populations (all derived from POBSP data except for Kaula, which is from Rice and Kenyon, 1962a: 377) Location Kure Midway Pearl and Hermes Reef Lisianski Laysan French Frigate Shoals Necker Nihoa Kaula Number of birds 1,150" 24.000* 9,000' 4,000b 40,000" 3,100+' 375« 100« 50- • Paper Number 72, Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Pro- gram, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. ' Recorded. b Estimated. 96 NUMBER 158 97 TABLE 21.—Timing of Black-footed Albatross activities at breeding grounds (adapted from Rice and Kenyon, 1962b) Activity Arrival Egg-laying Incubation Hatching Departure of fledged chicks Period 6 Oct-6 Nov 3 Nov-SO Nov peak - 21 Nov x—65.6 days 15 Jan-7 Fcb peak=25-26 Jan Juii-inid-Jul* •Parents cease visiting breeding grounds when chicks are fledged, but no sooner. least one parent is present with the chick continu- ously through mid-March, when the guard state terminates. During April and May breeding birds are mostly at sea and return only briefly to feed fledging young, liy June only young birds are pres- ent all day; breeding adults return only long enough to feed their young. Most young have fledged and departed the islands by the middle of July, and toward the end of July all birds are at sea. SUMMARY OF PUBLISHED PELAGIC OBSERVATIONS. —The Black-footed Albatross is an abundant and commonly seen species throughout much of the northern Pacific Ocean. At sea it ranges from the coasts of China, Japan, and Russia eastward to con- tinental North America, and from the southern Bering Sea and the Gulf of Alaska southward to 18°N off North America, occasionally to 10°N in the central Pacific, and to 19°N off Asia. The appendix summarizes published data on Black-footed Albatross distribution. Papers on ob- servations from the eastern half of the northern Pacific outnumber those on other areas by a wide margin; a few of these papers warrant discussion. McHugh (1955) made a detailed analysis of Black-foot distribution off North America in 1949- 1950. In 1949 a progressive northerly distributional shift occurred in the spring. The population center lay relatively close to shore off southern California in March, close to shore north of San Francisco in April, and off Oregon and Washington in May, when the center showed a tendency to withdraw from the coast and to disperse over a larger area. Summer months generally showed a decrease in number of birds, and a somewhat irregular distri- bution. Birds were present in low to moderate den- sity (x = 11-20 birds/sighting, from stopped ship) in an area off the southern California Channel Is- lands in August, resulting in the highest abun- dance of the year there. In October there was a high overall density of birds, with a broad, heavy concentration some 200 miles off southern Oregon and northern California. By November the popu- lation center had shifted southward far off central California, and overall density had diminished con- siderably. The 1950 distribution patterns were not clear, but the abundance peak for the entire area was in Mardi; there was evidence of a southerly shift of heavy concentrations of Black-foots from southern Oregon-northern California in May, to central California in June. In the period June-September of 1937 and 1938, Black-footed Albatrosses were concentrated in a cold tongue of water off the California Channel Islands (Miller, 1940). There were commonly 12- 15 birds at oceanographic sampling stations in the cold tongue, but never more than five or six at sta- tions outside this area. None were seen in the Santa Barbara channel. Miller (1942) showed that most Black-foots followed his ship for only a few miles. Of 25 birds marked with paint, 12 followed the ship for 20 miles, seven for 30 miles, three for 40 miles, and only one for 60 miles. In 1945 Thompson (1951) observed the distribu- tion of D. nigripes between Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, and San Francisco, California. Most months showed an increase in abundance as the California coast was approached, except in June, when there was fairly even pelagic distribution, and late November, which showed a bimodal distribution with peaks at ca. 125°W and 150°W, and minimums at 140°W and 155°W. There appeared to be an inverse cor- relation between surface water temperatures and albatross numbers. This easterly increase was asso- ciated with passing from the North Pacific Central Water (Sverdrup, et al., 1942) into the California Current between 130°W and 155°W. The maxi- mum number of birds seen at any one time was 45 at 130°W in October. A parallel increase in alba- tross and jellyfish abundance was observed, which Thompson (1951) believed was a similar response of the two organisms to the same environmental conditions. The Black-footed Albatross was the most com- SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY monly seen and abundant species during seven cruises off Washington and Oregon in 1964-1965 (Sanger, 1970). They were present on 94 percent of the 88 days spent in the area and accounted for 53 percent of all birds seen. Maximum abundance and occurrence were in the summer, and minimums were in the winter. Peak abundance occurred in August 1965 when albatrosses were 2.5 times as abundant as in the previous August. Minimum abundance was in January 1965. Generally, num- bers increased with distance from shore, although the maximum number seen at a single sighting (78) occurred just 40 miles off northern Washington in August 1965. Generally there was no difference in abundance or distribution between the areas off Oregon and Washington. For data lumped for all seven cruises there was a general increase in abun- dance with air temperature and surface water temperature (range: 6°-18°C.). There was no ob- served relation between albatross numbers and sur- face salinity, with birds found in salinities ranging from greater than 33 parts per thousand (%«,) far offshore to 15%o just off the mouth of the Columbia River. There appeared to be no relationship be- tween albatross numbers and rate of primary pro- ductivity, although the largest number of birds in a single sighting (78) occurred in water with the high- est primary productivity rate of all cruises. These data have been incorporated with the POBSP records and are included on the distribution maps. The literature suggests that Black-footed Alba- trosses are less abundant, or less frequently encoun- tered, in the western than in the eastern Pacific. For example, Starrett and Dixon (1946) noted a general absence of albatrosses from the southwestern portion of their range between June 1945 and Feb- ruary 1946, and MacDonald and Lawford (1954) noted that flocks of Black-foots were generally smaller in the western Pacific than the eastern Pa- cific in 1951 and 1952. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.—In addition to the many cooperators mentioned by Gould (p. 5 herein), a number of other people gave significant aid with this paper. Warren B. King, Robert L. Pyle, and especially Patrick J. Gould, offered useful advice on early drafts. Elizabeth Anthony and Charles Sklar assisted in analyzing the CalCOFI data, which was made available to the Pacific Program through the generous cooperation of Carl L. Hubbs and Robert L. Wisner of the Scripps Institu- tion of Oceanography. Furthermore, the mass of CalCOFI data, which is the single most intensive pelagic record ever assembled for the species, would not have been possible without the cooperation of the many CalCOFI sea-going personnel who dili- gently recorded the sightings. Among these were Robert Counts, David Kramer, James Thrailkill, and Andrew Vrooman, all of the National Marine Fisheries Service, La Jolla, California. To all of these people I express my sincere appreciation. Distribution and Abundance SPECIMEN RECORDS Table 22 summarizes Black-footed Albatrosses collected at sea by POBSP personnel. Most were from the central Pacific; a few were from the west- ern Aleutians and the coast of southern California. SIGHTING RECORDS Figures 66-77 (pp. 114—125) are monthly maps of the average Black-footed Albatross distribution for January 1964 through November 1967. Relative abundance, i.e., average number of birds per sight- ing for each day, is indicated by different degrees of shading. Because of the ship-following habits of the Black-footed Albatross and a consequent dis- parity in field recording techniques for this species, it was impossible to estimate the actual abundance in the standard units of birds per linear mile of travel. The disparity in field recording techniques was mainly a failure of observers to record the num- ber of birds at set time intervals; some observers recorded hourly counts and others recorded at irregular intervals, or whenever the Black-foot den- sity changed. However, the relative abundance was determined by using a unit of mean number of birds per sighting (BPS) for each day the species was seen, thus eliminating discrepancies in abundance due to variations in recording techniques. Three principal areas received consistently good seasonal coverage of Black-footed Albatross distri- bution: the central Pacific, off the southern Cali- fornia coast to about 126°W, and off the coasts of Washington and northern Oregon to about 140°W. Relative abundance in the former two areas is mu- tually comparable in every way. In the latter area, however, many counts were made from a stopped NUMBER 158 TABLE 22.—Black-footed Albatross specimens collected at sea by POBSP personnel Location 47°18'N,173°13'E 47°03'N, 173°16'E 33°23'N,122°18'W 33°23'N, 122°18'W 21°23'N,167°37'W 20°58'N,158°06'W 20°56'N,158°33'W 20°49'N,158°52'W 20°23'N,161°07'W 19°28'N, 162°11'W 18°2S'N,165O12'W 18°01'N, 166°H'W 17°20'N,164°12'W 16°50'N, 169°50'W 16°38'N, 169°38'W 14°46'N,160°44'W 12°20'N,167°41'W USNM number 503266" 503267" 497772' 497773d 496723 493513 492911 492910 lost 493917 494145 496198 493819 495791 493512 494144 495792 Sex _ - 9 9 9 9 S 9 9 9 9 S 9 $ S 9 Body weight (gm) 3110++ 3110+ + - - 2527 2802 3200 2100 2533 2900+ _ - 2610 - 2857 3000 + 2006 Gonad size (mm) _ - 18 x 8 18 x 8 20 x 10 23 x 15 26 x 17 30 x 14 19 x 11 25 x 17 45 x 35 27 x 5 20 x 4 22 x 25 - 14i/2x7i/2 16 x 6 11 x 6 15 x 10 Date 9 Oct 65 9 Oct 65 21 Jan 67 21 Jan 67 22 May 65 3 Jan 64 3 Dec 63 3 Dec 63 4 Jan 64 4 Feb64 9 Dec 64 9 Dec 64 6 Jan 64 15 Jan 65 12 Feb 64 8 Mar 64 22 May 65 Collector R. DeLong R. DeLong B. Harrington B. Harrington D. H usted - R. Fleet R. Fleet - V. Hoeman R. Standen M. Thompson C. Kepler D. H usted - V. Hoeman R. Merrill 99 * Banded, U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Number 737^*5577 (adult, sex unknown, 8 Nov 63, Green Island, Kure Atoll). b Banded, U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Number 697-73041 1 Banded, U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Number 757-26257 (local, sex unknown, 12 Jun 66, East Island, French Frigate Shoals). d Banded, U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service Number 767-42423 (nestling, sex unknown, 19 Mar 63, Crass Island, Pearl and Hermes Reef). ship, a fact that may make the counts seem large compared to the other areas due to the increased attraction stopped ships have for Black-foots. All mileage figures refer to statute miles. January Distribution (Figure 66): The densest concentration of birds occurred in the central Pa- cific across a broad front at ca. 25°N, between 148°W and 157°W; however, there were no ob- servations along the leeward Hawaiian Islands. Black-foots occurred in most of the area off Cali- fornia farther than 75 miles off the coast, and in areas farther than 100 to 200 miles off the coasts of Oregon and Washington. February Distribution (Figure 67): In the central Pacific, birds were seen in fair numbers as far south as 11°N, 151 °W, although they were peculiarly absent a few longitudinal degrees in either direc- tion. Concentrations were still found across the front at 25°N; no observations were conducted in the Leewards. Scattered birds were seen south to 13°N, 170°W, although there was a conspicuous absence of Black-foots at similar latitudes between 153°W and 168°W. Off California, overall densi- ties decreased from January; a few birds were ob- served within 30 miles of the coast. Scattered birds were seen between northern Washington and 53 °N in the Gulf of Alaska; these sightings apparently represent the northernmost winter records for the species. March Distribution (Figure 68): During March, observations were extended westward along the lee- ward Hawaiian Islands. Correspondingly, ex- tremely dense concentrations of Diomedea nigripes were seen in areas near the breeding islands. A maximum of 56 BPS was seen near Laysan Island. No Black-footed Albatrosses were seen south of 31 °N in the area off California; a few birds were encountered within 25 miles of the coast. No ob- servations were conducted off Washington or Ore- gon. April Distribution (Figure 69): Due to two cruises between Hawaii and North America, cover- 100 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY age this month was quite broad in area, although the Leewards area was not included. A localized concentration of 10-20 BPS was found some 100 miles north of the main Hawaiian Islands, but the bulk of the Black-foot population was seen north of 25°N. A relatively small concentration of birds was centered at 148°W, 28°N, but between here and northeastward to 130°W, distribution was re- markably uniform. Off southern California, overall densities remained essentially unchanged from March; scattered birds were seen within 25 miles of shore. Between the area off southern California and Oregon, distribution is largely speculative, be- cause noon positions were so far apart. However, there apparently was a broad band (5° wide) of 5-10 BPS density off northern California and Ore- gon between ca. 127°W and 132°W, with lesser densities to either side. The densest concentrations this month occurred off Washington and northern Oregon. May Distribution (Figure 70): The most evident feature of May distribution in the central Pacific was the continued northward withdrawal of the population to 20°N. A lone bird was encountered at ca. 13°N. Concentrations were centered at French Frigate Shoals, and some 450 miles northwest of the main Hawaiian Islands. Distribution off California was quite uniform at 2-5 BPS across most of the area. There were no observations off the Washing- ton-Oregon coasts. June Distribution (Figure 71): A continued northward withdrawal of the population in the central Pacific was evident this month; the southern limits were at 21 °N, 160°W, although two widely scattered individuals were seen at the 16°N parallel. The species was observed along the Leewards as far west as Lisianski Island. Off southern Califor- nia, the overall density diminished greatly. A bi- modal distribution was evident off Washington and Oregon, with concentrations of birds found rela- tively close to shore off northern Oregon and 400 miles off northern Washington. July Distribution (Figure 72): The Black-foot population continued to move northward, with 28° N marking the southern range limits. Ten to twenty BPS densities were seen some 1000 miles due west of San Francisco, with an apparent density de- crease toward the southern California coast. A bi- modal distribution was noted off southern Califor- nia. Concentrations of 10 to 20 BPS were seen within 75 miles of the coasts of Washington and Oregon. August Distribution (Figure 73): In the central Pacific, Black-foots were found still farther north than during the previous months. Overall abun- dance off southern California declined slightly. Dio- medea tiigripes was very abundant off the Washing- ton and Oregon coasts; about half of the region was populated with birds in 10 to 20 BPS densities and a general increase in abundance with distance from shore was noted. September Distribution (Figure 74): In the cen- tral Pacific two widely separated individuals were sighted near Midway Atoll and at 04°S0'N, 174°W; the latter sighting is the southern record for the species, excluding the two strays in the southern hemisphere (Oliver, 1955:181). Overall abundance off southern California decreased markedly; a few Black-foots were seen within 20 miles of shore. A region near the western Aleutians was censused this month and low concentrations were encountered over most of the area. There was no observation off the Washington-Oregon coast. October Distribution (Figure 75): Only one Dio- media nigripes was found in the central Pacific this month, near Gardner Pinnacles; however, areal coverage was scanty. Farther north, among and south of the western Aleutians, low densities were still encountered over most of the area. Overall abundance off Washington and Oregon diminished markedly from August, and Diomedea nigripes numbers were distributed erratically in the region off southern California. November Distribution (Figure 76): The species had again returned in some numbers to the central Pacific area, south to 19°N. There was a pro- nounced decrease in overall abundance off Califor- nia, while the region off Washington and Oregon showed an increase in Black-foots between 134°W and 139°W. December Distribution (Figure 77): The popu- lation level in the central Pacific increased to an observed all-time high this month. As would be expected, maximum concentrations were found among the leeward Hawaiian breeding islands. Off California, overall density showed an increase over November, and two days of observations off the Washington-Oregon coast revealed a few birds off Oregon but none within 50 miles of the Washing- ton coast. NUMBER 158 101 - 35' 40° 35° 30° 25° 20° V*' \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ - - 125° ' 1 ' \ \ \\ N\\ V \ \ \ \ \ 1 CAPE MEN0OCIN0 \ " V\ 120° 1 BLACK LOCATION N SAN FRANCISCO N \ N POINT s CONCEPTION • \ ^ \ \ i 115° 110° , . . . . 1 ^% A 1 f\ S\ ^^ • CALCOFI FOOTED ALBATROSS DATA OF BLOCKS (AFTER McHUGH,1955) - N S \ SAN / • DIEGO / . \ X . . . i - 40° - 30" - 25" 125° 120° 115° 110s FIGURE 58.—Location of area blocks for analysis of CalCOFI Black-footed Albatross distribution. BLOCK 10 BLOCK 13 £ 10 J ! J J Z ~ BLOCK 16 y • ,N ? r MJ F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N O J J F M A M J J A S O N D 1951 1952 1953 BLOCK 10 I J BLOCK 13 20-i s BLOCK 16 <20-i 10- ? • . , 1 I *, ? \ J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S 0 N 0 BLOCK 10 a: BLOCK 13 * 10" M t i -V4-* S ^ BLOCK 16 20 f^ i—i—i—r i F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N O J F M A M J J A S O N O 1957 1958 1959 NUMBER 158 103 BAND RETURN INFORMATION Robbins and Rice (pp. 232-271 herein) made a detailed analysis of at-sea band returns of Black- footed and Laysan albatrosses including POBSP rec- ords. No young Black-foots were captured in the leeward Hawaiian Islands during their first winter of life, but some were captured within a couple of hundred miles of both Japan and the United States. As the birds grew older (through their fourth summer), there was an increasing tendency for band recoveries to occur farther north and east in summer, and closer to the Leewards breeding is- lands in winter. Once the birds reached breeding age, there was only a slight tendency for more re- coveries to occur off North America in summer than off Japan. The relative chances of a tagged bird being caught in either area are unknown. There are a number of POBSP band returns from various breeding islands from birds that were originally banded on other breeding islands. Thus, this species exhibits some interisland movement; the individuals involved are probably prebreeders. DISTRIBUTION OFF CALIFORNIA AND BAJA CALIFORNIA, 1951-1959 In 1949, an interagency oceanographic research program known as the California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigations (CalCOFI) "was established as a broad and thoughtful inquiry into the environment and the biology of the California Current system" (Ahlstrom, et al., 1967:5). As a regular part of routine survey cruises, the number of Black-footed Albatrosses congregating around the ships was counted at each sampling station. Black-foot distribution has been analyzed for only the first two years of these data (McHugh, 1955), although the albatross counts continued through April 1959. Data subsequent to 1950 are analyzed and discussed here for the first time. McHugh's (1955) method of analyzing the data was, for the most part, used herein. The survey area was divided into the same series of blocks (Figure 58), and the monthly average of the num- ber of Diomedea nigripes counted at each station «*- FIGURE 59.—Real time graphs of the BPSt for inshore blocks: a, 1951-1953; b, 1954-1956; c, 1957-1959. (Numbers on graphs indicate number of stations contributing to BPSt.) within a block was calculated as mean number of birds per station (BPSt), using the maximum num- ber of birds seen at any one time during a station and including "zero counts." McHugh (1955) dis- cusses the reasons for averaging the counts from stations within the blocks, rather than considering individual counts at each station. An atlas-type presentation of monthly distribution maps such as McHugh (1955) used would be impractical in this paper because of the large amount of data involved. Therefore the blocks were divided into three north- south strips, inshore (blocks 4, 7, 10, etc.), inter- mediate (blocks 5, 8, 11, etc.), and offshore (blocks 6, 9, 12, etc.). The seasonal changes in abundance within individual blocks have been analyzed, as well as changes within the entire strips. SEASONAL CHANGES IN ABUNDANCE WITHIN AND AMONG INDIVIDUAL BLOCKS.—Seasonal fluctuations in birds per station were examined in blocks with the most intensive coverage. These were blocks 10, 13, and 16 in the inshore strip, and 11, 14, and 17 in the intermediate strip. Blocks 12 and 15 in the offshore strip were also considered in this manner because of their proximity to the other blocks, al- though their coverage was poor. Real time graphs of the BPSt in the inshore blocks are presented in Figure 59, in the intermediate blocks in Figure 60, and in the offshore blocks in Figure 61. In the in- shore blocks (10, 13, 16) a north-south density cline is quite evident, as are seasonal cycles in abun- dance, with peak numbers occurring in late spring- early summer, especially in block 10. A study of the intermediate blocks (11, 14, 17) shows that Dio- medea nigripes was generally more abundant there than closer inshore. Also evident during most of the period is a north-south population cline (re- gardless of year or season) and seasonal abundance cycles, with maximum numbers occurring in late spring and early summer. Figure 61 indicates that the highest numbers of Black-footed Albatrosses in the entire area may have occurred farthest off the coast. However, the scanty coverage, both in time and in number of stations, precludes direct com- parisons with the blocks closer to shore. OVERALL DISTRIBUTION AND ABUNDANCE.—Tem- poral changes in albatross abundance within each of the north-south strips are presented as con- toured density real time diagrams (Figure 62) . By simultaneously examining the diagrams for all three strips it is possible to see changes in distribu- 20- lfr o § 0 BLOCK 11 * BLOCK 142O S- 10- S BLOCK 17 « 20- 10- j T M A M j ) A S 6 N 6 j F M A M j j A S 6 N 6 i F M A M i i A S 0 N 0i iJ 1951 1952 19b3 BLOCK 11 J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O H D 20- 10- o £ o BLOCK 11 i 1 1 r—i 1 r £ BLOCK 14 u, BLOCK 17 3 20-. 10- v' . 1 t/\f ^ * * i" i A S 6 N 6 j F M A M j j A S T o N 0 j F M A M j j A S 6 N 6 1957 1958 1959 NUMBER 158 BLOCK 12 105 J F M A M J j A S O N 0 J F M A M J J A S O H D J F M A M J J A S O N D •1951 -1952 -1953 * 1 9 5 4 * 1955 "1956 o l 9 5 « FIGURE 61.—Real time graphs of the BPSt for offshore blocks 1951-1956 and 1958. (Numbers on graphs indicate number of stations contributing to BPSt.) tion and to infer movement among the three areas. There are a number of salient features to the distri- bution and abundance evident in each of the strips. Inshore Strip (upper diagram in Figure 62): Seasonal cycles in abundance are apparent for most years, especially north of Point Conception, Califor- nia. Black-foots occurred in concentrations of 5 to 10 BPSt mostly between April and July; other months they were absent, or present in concentra- tions of 5 BPSt or less. Off southern California they were generally absent most of the year, but a few birds showed up sporadically. The year 1958 was unique in that Black-foots occurred in this area con- tinuously from March through September (except for June), although mostly in densities of 1 BPSt or less. In strong contrast, Black-foots occurred during most months north of Point Conception and off northern Baja California. Concentrations as high as 10-20 BPSt occurred only north of Point Conception; indeed, south of here densities of 5 BPSt or less occurred most of the time. Also quite evident each year was an absence FIGURE 60.—Real time graphs of the BPSt for intermediate* blocks: «, 1951-1953; b, 1954-1956; c, 1957-1959. (Numbers on graphs indicate number of stations contributing to BPSt.) of birds between 24°N and 30°N in late summer or early fall. This could be due to either a northward migration, or a progressive northward withdrawal to seaward from these latitudes. This phenomenon culminated in a complete withdrawal from the in- shore strip in the fall and winter of 1952-1953 and 1955-1956. Intermediate Strip (middle diagram in Figure 62): The most striking feature here is that Black- footed Albatrosses were continuously present in at least part of this zone for the entire 100-month period (no stations were occupied in October and November 1956). There appeared to be a trend for maximum density to occur between April and July, although in 1955 Black-foot densities of 10-20 BPSt lingered until October north of 32°N. Relatively few birds were found in the strip in August through March. Densities of greater than 10 BPSt were rarely encountered south of ca. 32°N; when they did oc- cur, usually as somewhat anomalous groups, it was from June through August (e.g., at 30°N in August 1952 and June-July 1954). Evident in most years in varying degrees was an exodus from, and return to, the area south of 30° N, from late summer to early winter in the same manner as in the inshore strip. This movement generally started in September south of 25° N and progressed northward to 30°N, J F M A W J J A S O M D I F H » H i 1 » j 6 » 6 S l P O t P E R S T A T • E23 ED • • NUMBER 158 107 where it peaked in October or November. In De- cember and January low numbers of Diomedea nigripes returned to the southern end of the strip but another brief evacuation from the southern- most degrees usually followed. This phenomenon occurred every year for which data are available, except 1958-1959. At or south of 25°N anomalous patches of 5-10 Bpst densities frequently occurred from June through August; examples of this were observed in July-August 1953, June 1955, June-July 1956, and June 1957. Offshore Strip (lower diagram, Figure 62): As seen in the figures, coverage in the offshore strip was quite spotty compared with those closer to shore, but a few salient features of distribution and abundance are evident. Densities of more than 20 upst occurred with greater frequency in this strip than in either the inshore or the intermediate zones. There also seems to be a tendency for high densi- ties to occur farther south in this strip than in the other two. These high densities occurred quite er- ratically, and with no apparent evidence of the cy- cles which were displayed in the other two strips. Discussion: South of Point Conception, the rela- tive abundance among the three strips indicates a general increase in abundance with distance from shore, but north of here there is no consistent pat- tern. A more uniform pattern of distribution among the strips is evident, and sometimes there is even a decrease in abundance with distance from shore. Indeed, north of Point Conception, maximum densities among the strips occurred within the in- shore strip in June and/or July of 1952, 1953, 1955, and 1956. ABUNDANCE AT WEATHER STATION Victor Personnel aboard the USCGC Winnebagq kept a record of albatross numbers seen while the ship was positioned at Ocean Weather Station Victor (34°N, 164°E) from 26 February through 19 March 1967. Figure 63 presents the results of this record. The most birds seen at any time during the day (upper graph) ranged from a low of 2 on 17 March to highs FIGURE 62.—Contoured density real time diagrams of BPSt in inshore, intermediate, and offshore blocks: a, 1951-1953; b, 1954-1956; c, 1957-1959. of 31 birds on 1 March and 30 birds on 12 March. There appeared to be a cycle in numbers of birds, changing from low to high numbers at 5-7-day in- tervals. The bottom graph of Figure 63 shows that the maximum number of birds usually occurred in the afternoon (1600), but never occurred in the morning (0800). Analysis of Distribution GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS Two major trends in the distribution of Black- footed Albatrosses are evident. First, there is a ma- jor latitudinal population shift coincident with the breeding season, i.e., the birds are in the southern part of their pelagic range in winter (breeding sea- son), and in the northern part of their range in summer (Figure 64). This is especially evident in the central Pacific. However, because there is con- siderable spatial overlap between the two ranges, and some birds are well north as early as April and as late as October, there are Black-foots throughout most of the absolute range at any given time of the year. Secondly, the evidence suggests that this spe- cies is predominantly an eastern Pacific bird, al- though a part of the population regularly occurs west of 180°. For example, the numbers of birds seen in single sightings in the northeastern Pacific are far in excess of similar counts for the north- western Pacific. Examples of this are: 70 birds 40 miles off San Francisco Bay (McHugh, 1950); 125 birds some 1000 miles southwest of San Francisco, and 53 Black-foots 465 miles off Oregon (Yocom, 1947), 78 birds 40 miles off northern Washington (Sanger, 1970); and 100 Black-footed Albatrosses at Unimak Pass in the Aleutians (ca. 165°W, 54°N) (Arnold, 1948). Although similar counts for the western Pacific are scarce, those available show far lower numbers; Kuroda (1955) saw a maximum of 11 birds 240 miles east of Hokkaido during his sum- mer observations, and Wilhoft (1961) had a maxi- mum cumulative daily total of only 70 birds, some 100 miles northwest of Luzon in the Philippines. Furthermore, a general scarcity of Black-foots has been noted in the western Pacific at various seasons (Starrett and Dixon, 1946; Aronoff, 1960). Trans- Pacific observations (MacDonald and Lawford, 1954; Nakamura, 1963) have revealed generally more Black-foots in the eastern Pacific than in the west 108 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 30 25 20 15 10 (A) Birds seen at . . . . 0800hours — 1200 hours — —1600 hours 26 27 28 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 February March 1967 FIGURE 63.—Fluctuation in Black-footed Albatross numbers at Ocean Weather Station Victor (WOCN. 164°00'E). Seasonal Variation in the Range of Black-Footed Albatross E D Summer (July) £Z2 Winter (February) HOE 130 150 170 170 150 130 110 FIGURE 64.—Seasonal variation in the range of the Black-footed Albatross. TON (although Austin and Kuroda [1953:299-300] stated that this albatross is common off Japan from April to November, and Hamilton [1958] observed that in June 1955 they were more abundant between Japan and 180° than east of there). Perhaps the most convincing evidence that the majority of the population prefers eastern Pacific waters is ob- tained from banding studies. Robbins and Rice (pp. 237-238) reveal that band recoveries of pre- breeding young showed a marked tendency to occur in the eastern half of the Pacific in all seasons, as did those for adults during winter. In summer, how- ever, band recoveries of adults occurred with nearly equal frequency off North America and Asia. The relative chances for recovering banded birds in these two areas of the Pacific are unknown. SEASONAL AND MONTHLY VARIATIONS Starting in late fall, adult birds begin arriving at the breeding grounds. This would explain, at least in part, the sharp reduction in the number of Black-foots off Washington and Oregon between August and October. The regular late summer-early fall reduction in numbers off southern California and Baja California may be partly due to adult birds leaving for the breeding islands. Except for copulation, breeding activities do not require the simultaneous presence of both parents. "Incubation spans" range up to 18 days, and "guard spans" last about 21/2 days (Rice and Kenyon, 1962b). When the guard stage ends in late February, both parents leave the island, returning only briefly to feed the 110 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY fledging young. Thus, even during the breeding season, about half of the breeding birds are at sea. It is uncertain how far parents range from breed- ing sites, but they probably remain within 1500 to 2000 miles. Evidence to this effect is a dramatic buildup at sea during the breeding season in areas near the main Hawaiian Islands, some 1500 miles east and southeast of the major breeding areas on the Leewards. Robbins and Rice (Figure 148) indicate a host of band returns of adult birds from December through March between 155°E and 170°W, along the latitude of 30°N, and very few elsewhere. This further suggests the tendency for adults to range as indicated above. The Black-foots that occur off Washington, Oregon, and southern California in winter are probably largely nonbreed- ing immatures, but it is physically possible for the parents to range for food as far away from the breeding grounds as the North American Pacific Coast and return to the breeding grounds within two to three weeks. Although parent birds are gathering food for the young, and presumably for themselves, they appar- ently exist under a progressive nutritional deficit during the breeding season. Frings and Frings (1961) noted that the weight of adult Black-footed Albatrosses decreased by about 8 percent over a two- week period in early egg-laying and nesting stages, presumably because of a reduction in heavy fat de- posits which birds have prior to that time. Woodward (POBSP) shows a dramatic decrease in the number of nonbreeding Black-foots during March and April on Kure Atoll. By late February most breeders are away from the atoll most of the time. The general exodus of birds from breeding is- lands which takes place in March and April may explain the regular April-May ingression of birds into the area off California as noted in the Cal- COFI data. McHugh's (1955) 1949 distribution data certainly suggest a northeastward movement away from the breeding grounds, followed by, and coincident with, a northward movement paralleling the coast. The timing of this movement corresponds to the subsequent CalCOFI data reported here. After the young albatrosses are fledged in early July, the adults stay away from the breeding grounds permanently and disperse throughout their range. Their distribution is probably governed by the distribution of food organisms, concentrations of which, at least in the case of immature birds, are possibly found only by random searching. Overall movements, as indicated earlier in the literature review, show that some birds are in the area of the Aleutians as early as May (Gabrielson and Lincoln, 1959:74), and as late as November (Kenyon, 1950). There seems to be no clear-cut trend in the winter movements in the far northeast Pacific. Rice and Kenyon (1962a) estimated that about 14 percent of the Black-foot population (one- and two-year-old birds) winter at sea. DISTRIBUTION IN RELATION TO THE ENVIRONMENT CURRENTS AND WATER MASSES.—The southern limits of Black-foot distribution generally coincide with the southwestern sweep of the California Cur- rent in the eastern Pacific Ocean off Baja Califor- nia and the North Equatorial Current in the cen- tral Pacific Ocean. Although there are few data available for the western Pacific it seems likely that Black-foots usually do not range south or west of the North Pacific or the Kuroshio Currents, which may explain the scarcity of birds reported by Star- rett and Dixon (1946). La Touche (1934) and Cheng (1955) both stated that this species occurs off China. It is common in the Bering Sea in sum- mer, considerably north of the major northerly currents, the West Wind Drift and the Alaskan Stream. In winter the species apparently does not range very far north of the Kuroshio-Oyashio con- vergence in the northwest Pacific, nor of the sub- arctic current (ca. 50°-55°N) in the northeastern Pacific. Thompson (1951) found that Black-foots tended to be more abundant in the California Current off California than in eastern North Pacific Central Water. Within the California Current, Miller (1942) found Black-foots concentrated within "tongues" of cold water off the southern California Channel Islands. Sverdrup, et al. (1942) explain that these tongues are caused by intense upwelling of deep water along the coast which are swept south- ward along the surface by the California Current. The point of upwelling in Miller's description would have been at Point Conception, California. Reid, et al. (1958:30) note that upwelling along the North American coast is seasonal, being "strongest off Baja California in April and May, off southern and central California in May and June, NUMBER 158 111 off northern California in June and July, and off Oregon in August." Thus, while the initial increase in abundance of Black-foots close to the central California coast (north of Point Conception) is cor- related with the departure of adults and nonbreed- ing birds from the breeding islands in March and April, it seems quite possible that this high density of Black-foots is prolonged by the enriching process of upwelling in May and June. Further, the de- crease in upwelling off the central California coast in July might well be a factor in the reduction in Black-foot numbers usually noted at this time. Farther north off Oregon, upwelling also occurs close to the coast in August, and Black-footed Alba- trosses are apparently concentrated there then (Gerard Bertrand [Oregon State University], pers. comm.). The large concentrations of birds found by Yocom (1947) are well within the California Cur- rent, but the observed abundance was probably dis- torted by the fact that his ship spent several days in the same location, thus creating a strong attrac- tion factor. Sanger (1970) observed a concentration of 78 Black-footed Albatrosses relatively close to shore over the continental shelf in August 1965, but over an 18-month period there was a general increase in abundance with increasing distance from shore; however, observations in nearshore areas may have been inadequate for a direct comparison with off- shore data. P. W. Martin (1942) implied an abun- dance of Black-foots off British Columbia in sum- mer over offshore banks. The large concentration of birds observed in Unimak Pass in the Aleutians (Arnold, 1948) could well have been coincident with local island-induced upwelling or tidal currents. In the western Pacific, Kuroda (1955) saw his highest numbers of Diomedea nigripes in the coastal waters off Honshu, approximately west of the Kuroshio- Oyashio convergence, in June and July. SURFACE WATER TEMPERATURE.—There has been much discussion on the relationship between Black- footed Albatross distribution and surface water tem- peratures. Kuroda (1955) considered the species to be warm water adapted in his study of the birds be- tween Japan and the western Bering Sea. Thomp- son (1951) observed a seeming inverse correlation between temperature (mostly 15°-25°C) and alba- tross numbers between Oahu and California. Hamilton (1958), Wilhoft (1961), and Nakamura (1963) all present temperature data which are in- conclusive. In oceanic waters off Washington and Oregon, relatively high surface water temperatures (range over 18-month period, ca. 6°-17°C) were associated with relatively large numbers of Black- foots, and low temperatures were associated with small numbers (Sanger, 1970). In the central Pa- cific near the main Hawaiian Islands, King (1970: 91) observed Black-foots in low densities when sur- face water temperatures were greater than 23°C (range of ca. 22°-27°C). The POBSP data correlating water temperature and albatross occurrence show no clear-cut trends for individual months; sample sizes (number of days of observation) are often small and the data are therefore insufficient to present graphically. In most months the data apparently simply reflect the range of surface temperatures encountered on the cruises. The only month that indicates a trend at all is March, which shows an inverse correlation between Black-foot numbers and water tempera- tures from 20° to 28°C. This is in line with tem- perature data of King (1970) and Sanger (1970), which suggest that the species is most often found in relationship to surface water temperatures rang- ing from ca. 14° to 22°C. A detailed analysis of the relationship of alba- tross abundance and water temperatures in the CalCOFI area is beyond the scope of this paper; however, a few brief generalizations can be made. Ten-meter water temperatures were obtained at the same time the albatross counts were made (Cali- fornia Marine Research Committee, 1963). The warmest temperatures generally occurred off south- ern California and Baja California in September and October, followed by rapid cooling through March. Off southern Baja California (ca. 26°30'N in the inshore strip), the 10-year mean October IO- meter temperature was 23°C; it can reasonably be assumed that the surface temperature was warmer by a few, perhaps several, degrees. Thus, the usual fall evacuation by Black-foots from the zone south of 30°N in the inshore and intermediate strips may have been the result of a negative reaction by the birds to increased water temperatures. Similarly, the fact that the birds consistently reentered this zone in winter may have been a result of cooling water temperatures. Just off Point Conception (CalCOFI station 80.60), the coldest 10-meter tem- peratures occurred between February and May (10- year mean ca. 12.5°C), and the warmest from Au- 112 120 140 160 180 160 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 120 100 80 120 140 FICURF. 65.—The area bounded by the surface isotherms of 14° and 22°C (after Muromtsev. 1958). gust through October (10-year mean ca. 17.5°C). The peak Black-foot numbers occur just north of here as the water temperature is warming (in June), although the entire annual range of temperatures is within the "preferred" temperature range noted above. The apparent disparity in abundance of the Black-footed Albatross between the western Pacific (fewer birds) and the eastern Pacific (more birds) may possibly be explained by the species' apparent preference for a certain range of surface water tem- peratures. It was noted above that Black-foots were most often found within a surface temperature range of ca. 14° to 22°C. Assuming that the species disperses randomly within, and actively associates with, waters in this temperature range, one would expect to find more birds in the eastern Pacific than in the western Pacific. Figure 65, the average sum- mer surface temperature in the North Pacific (after Muromtzev, 1958), shows that the region encom- passed by the isotherms of 14° and 22°C is more than two times as large east of 170°W than west of that meridian. Thus, if the Black-foot indeed does actively associate within a 14° to 22°C surface wa- ter temperature range, one would expect most of the population to be found in the eastern north Pacific. The absolute range of surface water temperature in which this species has been observed is from 3.4°C in the Gulf of Alaska in March 1967 (Uni- versity of Washington data), to 30°C in the western Central Pacific in August 1960 (Wilhoft, 1961). SURFACE SALINITY.—King (1970) observed an ap- parent direct relationship between Black-foot num- bers and surface salinity in the central Pacific (within a range of ca. 33.5%, to 35.0%,). He felt, however, that this resulted from the fact that, within his study area, the species' geographic range occurred north of waters with a lower surface salin- ity. Off the Washington and Oregon coasts there was no observable relationship between Black-foot numbers and surface salinity (Sanger, 1970), al- though Black-foots were occasionally found in sa- linities far below normal sea water salinities (e.g., 14.98%.). AIR TEMPERATURE.—Air temperatures are closely correlated with ambient surface water temperatures in the ocean. One would expect, therefore, to find similar relationships between Black-foot numbers and these two parameters, and this indeed is the case. King (1970:89) observed a pronounced inverse correlation between air temperatures and Black- foot numbers from 16° through 29°C. Few birds were seen at temperatures warmer than 22°C, and none above 27 °C. Sanger (1970) noted a direct re- lationship between air temperature and Black-foot abundance within a range of 7° to 18°C, and Kuroda (1960) believed that within an overall range of 7.0° to 22.5°C the species preferred air temperatures from 17° to 22.5°C. NUMBER 158 WEATHER CONSIDERATIONS.—Wind is probably the most significant feature of the weather affecting albatross distribution. Since albatrosses are depend- ent upon the wind for mobility, it stands to reason that they would avoid, or be found in lesser num- bers in, areas with wind velocities insufficient or marginal to maintain their sailing flight. The aver- age wind velocity decreases as the equator is ap- proached and the doldrum wind conditions are en- countered; this fact no doubt plays a significant role in limiting the southern distribution of the Black- footed Albatross. High winds apparently have little or no adverse effect on the Black-foot, since the species has been noted sailing in winds as high as 113 70 knots (80 MPH) with no apparent ill effects (Sanger, 1970). Addendum After this paper was written in 1968, the impor- tant paper of V. P. Shuntov (1968) came to my at- tention. It is in general agreement with the findings reported here that the Black-footed Albatross is pri- marily a species of the eastern north Pacific, but with some of the population occurring in the west- ern part. Shuntov indicates the Black-foot ranges in summer and autumn into the Sea of Okhotsk and north into the western Bering Sea to the Gulf of Anadyr, but not as far south in winter as our rec- ords in the central Pacific indicate. 114 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 115 .£ > 1 I > > Observer R.C. Miller* unknown " CM. Love " • • • • " •* " G.H. Allen CM. Love " " H.Jackson G.H.Allen unknown '• CM. Love P. McCrery H. Jackson P. McCrery G.H.Allen P. McCrery E. Linger R. Rubinstein P. McCrery R. Rubinstein P. McCrery R. Rubinstein E. Linger P. McCrery R. Rubinstein E. Linger P. McCrery R. Rubinstein E. Linger Remarks letter of 21 Jan 66 to Sanger Operation NORPAC i . • • bird stayed with drifting ship for 7.5 hours I.G.Y. Expedition " " " " " " " " " " " " •• " •• " " " " " " " " in the central Pacific, but the species was still com- mon in the Leewards. In 13 days of observations off southern California, Laysans were seen on only two days. A single bird was recorded as close as 200 miles off the Washington coast, but most were west of 140°W. In the Gulf of Alaska (1956) the species was seen as far north as 59°34'N, this apparently being the northernmost record for the species. June Distribution (Figure 86): Laysans were com- mon in relatively low densities (less than 3.2 BPS) in the Leewards, but were not seen in the remainder of the central Pacific. None were observed off south- ern California, and one was seen in the Gulf of Alaska (1956). July Distribution (Figure 87): Our records show only one sighting in the entire Pacific this month, at 26°15'N, 174°00'W near Lisianski Island. August Distribution (Figure 88): In the central Pacific there were but two birds sighted in the Lee- wards (near Pearl and Hermes Reef), and two more at 35°N. None were seen off southern California and only one was observed off Washington, about 750 miles off the coast. In the Aleutians (1957), Lay- sans were common just south of the islands be- tween longitudes 171°W and 173°E. Two were noted one day in the southern Bering Sea at ca. 52°40'N, 180°. NUMBER 158 133 TABLE 27.—Miscellaneous sight records of Laysan Albatrosses from the eastern North Pacific, (observers, except one, from University of Washington) —continued Date Location No. of birds Observer Remarks 25 Aug 57 13 Sep 57 14 Sep 57 2 Apr 57 3 Apr 57 13 Jan 61 16 Jan 61 27 Jan 62 10 Oct 62 1 Mar 63 1 Mar 63 9 Mar 63 11 Mar 63 15 Oct 66 15 Oct 66 16 Oct 66 16 Oct 66 18 Oct 66 19 Oct 66 20 Oct 66 23 Oct 66 24 Oct 66 24 Oct 66 26 Oct 66 27 Oct 66 30 Oct 66 13 Nov 66 14 Nov 66 19 Dec 66 21 Dec 66 27 Sep 67 29 Sep 67 29 Sep 67 5 Oct 67 6 Oct 67 7 Nov 67 51°02'N, 52°58'N, 51°53'N, 55°30'N, 54°20'N, '48°10'N, 46°22'N. 46O41'N, 42°21'N, 48°14'N, 48°13'N, 45°34'N, 44°16'N, 47°04'N, 46°53'N. 47°OO'N, 47°OO'N, 47°OO'N, 47°OO'N, 46°55'N, 46°55'N. 47°OO'N. 47°OO'N. 47°OO'N, 47°00'N. 47°3O'N, 48°00'N, 47°45'N, 48°10'N, 46°03'N, 53°S0'N, 52°3O'N, 52°07'N, 50°00'N, 47°33'N, 48°25'N, 171°45'W 15O°34'W 150°42'W 139°0O'W 135°OO'W 126°42'W 129°30'W 126°40'W 125°25'W 126°46'W 127°45'W 129°30'W 127°24'W 130°08'W 13O°31'W 132°1O'W 132°OO'W 132°00'W 132°OO'W 132°12'W 132°OO'W 132°03'W 132°0O'W 132°00'W 132°00'W 129°45'W 131°52'W 131°55'W 125°41'W 126°4O'W 162°00'W "l60°00'W 159°2O'W 137°OO'W 133°OO'W 129°18'W P. McCrery E. Linger unknown CM. Love K. Light wood CM. Love J. Nickerson R. Robeck D. Armand J. Nickerson D. Armand R. Robeck D. Armand R. Robeck D. Armand V. Wyatt J. Nickerson V. Wyatt ca. 35 mi off Cape Alava, Washington •California Academy of Sciences. September Distribution (Figure 89): None were seen in the central Pacific or off southern Califor- nia; one was seen some 35 miles off central Cali- fornia (Robert C. Miller, California Academy of Sciences, pers. comm.). The species was common in the western Aleutians and in the western Gulf of Alaska (1955, 1957). October Distribution (Figure 90): None were seen in the central Pacific nor off southern Califor- nia again this month. Off Washington and Oregon, however, Laysans were common in densities of up to 4.0 BPS. One was noted 75 miles off Washington, but most were much farther offshore. South of the western Aleutians, they were common and ex- tremely abundant. A center of abundance was noted at ca. 45°N, 173°E, where densities of 20 and 30 BPS were recorded on two consecutive days. These are high records for pelagic areas away from breeding islands. November Distribution (Figure 91): One bird was observed in the central Pacific near Kaula Rock (21°45'N, 160°30'W), but no surveys were con- ducted in the Leewards. Single birds were seen on three days off southern California and the species was common to abundant to 138°W in areas far- ther than 150 miles off the Washington and Oregon coasts. December Distribution (Figure 92): Laysan Alba- 134 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY trosses were abundant (up to 10.0 BPS) in the west- ern Leewards, but only scattered sightings were made south to 13°37'N in the central Pacific. Only on 3 out of 33 days were they seen off southern California. Off Washington and Oregon, single birds were noted on two out of an unspecified num- ber of days; one was a scant 35 miles off Cape Alava, Washington. ANNUAL PELAGIC CYCLE The appearance of Laysan Albatrosses in pelagic areas of the central Pacific in late November cor- responds to their arrival on the breeding islands. Numbers increase at sea around the breeding is- lands in December and scattered birds are recorded to almost the southern limits of their central Pa- cific range. From December through May they are seen, though uncommonly, in pelagic areas south to 13°N, with February being the month of peak abundance south of 20°N and the month of most southerly penetration. Birds begin to leave the cen- tral Pacific in May and by July and August there is only an occasional bird seen in the northern Leewards. They are unrecorded in September and October. This seasonal shift in distribution is il- lustrated in Figure 78. It can be seen that this north-south shifting of birds is synchronized across the central and eastern Pacific. The northern range limits also retreat southward in winter, but this is neither as pronounced nor as well documented as it is in the central Pacific. The occurrence of Laysan Albatrosses in the Gulf of Alaska also appears to be cyclic, with spring be- ing the season of maximum abundance and north- ward penetration. A few birds occur in the southern part during winter. As spring approaches they move northward and by May can be found in the north- ernmost part of the Gulf. As summer approaches, they move westward out of the Gulf, and are found with any regularity only west of 160°W; most of , the population apparently occurs west of 180°. Thus, the westward movement out of the Gulf of Alaska corresponds to the late spring movement away from British Columbia, Washington, and Oregon (Sanger, 1970). ABUNDANCE AT WEATHER STATION Victor Figure 79 presents counts of Laysan Albatrosses made by personnel of the USCGC Winnebago at Ocean Station Victor (34°N, 164°E), from 26 February through 19 March 1967. The maximum number of birds seen at any time during the day (upper graph) ranged from none on 17 March to a high of 27 on 15 March. Most counts revealed no more than 14 birds. The maximum number of birds during the day usually occurred in the after- noon (1600), although the high counts were in the morning on three days. This suggests that Laysans were less inclined toward a regular daily activity cycle than Black-footed Albatrosses, who never dis- played maximum numbers in the morning in the same area. BAND RETURN INFORMATION Routine monitoring of banded birds during sur- veys of the breeding colonies on the leeward Ha- waiian Islands has documented numerous inter- island movements of Laysans. Most of these involve birds moving the short distance between Kure and Midway Atoll, or between Kure and other Leeward locations. Only one bird has been recaptured on land away from the breeding islands. This speci- men, banded as an adult on Kure Island, was re- covered on Mejit Island (ca. 10°30'N, 171°00'E), Marshall Islands, on 20 May 1965 (Amerson, 1969: 293), but must be regarded as a stray in this extra- limital location. This represents the southernmost specimen record for this species. The POBSP Laysan Albatross band returns are be- ing integrated with those of the U.S. Fish and Wild- life Service (Robbins and Rice, p. 234, herein). Pertinent highlights of this information are sum- marized here. Recoveries of subadult birds (through the fifth year of life) suggest that they are more in- clined to be scattered longitudinally than adult birds, but most recoveries were west of 180°. More than half of the summer adult recoveries occurred between 170°E and 180°, in and just south of the western Aleutian Islands. Almost all of the summer adult recoveries were from north of 40°N between Japan and the Aleutians. In winter, the adult re- coveries were mainly south of 40°N, scattered be- tween Honshu, Japan, and Midway Atoll. Analysis of Distribution GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS Two major trends are apparent in the gross dis- tribution of the Laysan which are similar to those NUMBER 158 135 45 40 - 30 - 25 30 25 - 20 - 15 - 10 - • - - 1 1 4 4 4 4 If 1 \l •+- Southern Distribution -*- \ U Point 1 jJIPlllIJi )|[| / ~ x -<— Southern Observational -*- , v Limit ' x ' X ' X ' X 1 1 1 * 1 1 1 l' 1 1 J F M A M J J A S O N O Months EASTERN PACIFIC - - pr \ \y Point \ Vagrant Sightings 171°F • 163°33'W ' N-«-Southern Observational ' v Limit 1 X / x 1 1 1 1 l/ 1 >l 1 1 1 1 V 1 J F M A M J J A S O N Months CENTRAL PACIFIC FIGURE 78.—Seasonal and latitudinal shifting of Laysan Albatrosses in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean. 136 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Birds seen at ••••0800 hours 1200 hours — -1600 hours 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1726 27 28 1 February 18 19 KK.IRE 79.—Counts of Laysan Albatrosses made by personnel of the USCGC Winnebago at Ocean Weather Station Victor (34°\, 164°E) 26 February through 19 March 1967. Seasonal Variation in the Range of Laysan Albatross E 3 Summer (August) EZ3 Winter (February-March) 72 Spring-Gulf of Alaska •£23 Area of apparent non- breeding concentrations no E 130 ISO 170 170 ISO 130 110 FIGURE 80.—Seasonal variation in the range of the Laysan Albatross. of the Black-footed Albatross. First, there is a ma- jor latitudinal population shift concurrent with the winter breeding season (Figure 80). In sum- mer, they are fairly far north in the Pacific, appar- ently concentrated off the Kuriles and in the Aleu- tian Islands. During the winter breeding season, their range shifts considerably farther south (to 13°N). Rare birds have been seen at 11°N (King, 1970:9) and 8°30'N (Thompson, 1951) in the cen- tral Pacific Ocean. The second major distributional feature is that the Laysan is predominantly a west- ern and central north Pacific species, in contrast to the Black-footed Albatross which has a more even or eastern distribution. The movements of breeding adults and older im- matures are directed toward the breeding grounds in late fall, and away from the breeding grounds and toward feeding areas early the following sum- mer. Moreover, about half of the breeding birds are away from the breeding grounds at any given time during the breeding season; indeed, the recovery of a breeding bird over 2000 miles away 23 days after being banded on its nest shows that breeding birds can range well away from the breeding grounds (Kenyon and Rice, 1958). Curiously, the breeding season range is much broader than that of the nonbreeding season. In winter, Laysans are un- common to common off North America from north- ern Baja California to southern British Colum- bia, and off Japan as far south as Kyushu. These 138 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY birds are no doubt mostly prebreeding immatures, but probably include some adult breeders. Kenyon and Rice (1958) demonstrated the amazing ability of this species to cover vast distances in relatively short periods of time, despite adverse weather con- ditions. Banding returns indicate that the postbreeding dispersal of adults and fledged young takes them northwestward from the breeding grounds. POBSP sightings for September and October 1964-1965 in- dicate that maximum numbers of Laysans may oc- cur in the Aleutians in late summer and early fall. Therefore, the occurrence of Laysans off Japan in summer may be because of a curvilinear migration route to the Aleutians. DISTRIBUTION IN RELATION TO THE ENVIRONMENT CURRENTS AND WATER MASSES.—As in the case of the Black-footed Albatross, the gross distribution of the Laysan Albatross (Figure 80) is similar to the distribution of certain major currents and water masses. Winter distribution seems generally to par- allel the circulation of the north Pacific cyclonic currents, but individuals wander north of the West Wind Drift and south into the Equatorial Counter- current. Concentrations of birds in summer are ap- parently mostly within the western Subarctic and Alaskan Gyres, and north of the West Wind Drift (see Dodimead, et al., 1963, for descriptions of these currents and water masses). Summer distribution seems to conform to the Kurilo-Aleutian surface water mass (Muromtzev, 1958:248) with some birds being found in the western part of the "Alaska Bay ( = Gulf) surface water." Distribution off Japan (Kuroda, 1960; Robbins and Rice, pp. 236-237, herein) relates well to the Kuroshio-Oyashio con- vergence, with no birds being found in the warm Kuroshio Current in summer. SURFACE WATER TEMPERATURE.—The maximum surface water temperature tolerated by most of the population seems to be about 21° to 24°C (70°-75°F) in the central Pacific in winter. In sum- mer, individuals occur as far south as 35°N, where the surface temperature would again be in the 21° to 24°C range (Muromtzev, 1958, fig. 112). How- ever, the surface water temperatures in the western Aleutians, where most of the population appar- ently summers, is moderately cold, about 8° to 10°C (Muromtzev, 1958, fig. 112). Kuroda (1960) suggested that the Laysan is the most cold-adapted albatross in northwest Pacific waters. When the Laysan occurs off Washington and Oregon in win- ter, the surface water temperature generally ranges from 8° to 10°C. Within an observed annual range of about 7° to 17°C in this area, Laysans were found to occur most often in relatively low tem- peratures, and only three times (all during the same cruise) in water warmer than 14°C (Sanger, 1970). King (1970) noted that albatrosses (both Laysan and Black-foot) were seldom found in water warmer than 23°C in a survey area east and south- east of the main Hawaiian Islands (the data from which are included in this report). As long as the birds are within their physiological temperature tolerances, distribution will probably be dictated by the distribution of preferred food organisms and not by water temperature per se. AIR TEMPERATURE.—The limits of the Laysan's range seem to parallel the isotherms of about 5° and 24°C regardless of season. The 24°C (75°F) isotherm lies at about 20°N latitude in March and at about 40° N latitude in August in the central Pacific (U.S. Navy, 1956). Both of these latitudes ap- pear to be the southerly limits of most of the Lay- san population during the respective seasons (see Figures 81-92). The temperature tolerance of this species is conjectural at this point, but the species has been seen in temperatures ranging from 4.8°C in the Gulf of Alaska in February 1967 to as high as ca. 26°C in the central Pacific (King, 1970:89). Kuroda (1960) observed that Laysan Albatrosses preferred 13° to 15°C temperatures within a range of 6.2° to 22.5°C in the summer in northwest Pa- cific waters. In waters off Washington and Oregon, Laysans were encountered most often when the air temperature was less than 10°C in an annual range of 6.6° to 18.0°C (Sanger, 1970). SURFACE SALINITY.—The distribution of Laysans indicates that they occur in waters with moderate to high salinities, and only rarely in low salinity water (less than 32.5-33.0%o). The surface salinity in areas of Laysan Albatross concentrations, i.e., west of 180° and north of 40°N, generally ranges from 33-34%o (Muromtzev, 1958:374). Seasonal data from off Washington and Oregon show that, in- deed, Laysans may avoid relatively low salinity water (Sanger, 1970). In summer, when Laysans are well away from the coast, salinity of less than 32.5%o (resulting from runoff from the Columbia NUMBER 158 139 River) has been traced westward to nearly 132°W off Oregon (Budinger, et al., 1964:52). Coinci- dentally, there is no such offshore area of low surface salinity in the northwest Pacific. In winter, prevail- ing south and southwesterly winds off the Washing- ton-Oregon coasts tend to hold river runoff within a relatively few miles of the coast (Budinger, et al., 1964:69), allowing a maximum eastward invasion of oceanic water toward the coast via the California Current. It is at this time that maximum abun- dance of Laysan Albatrosses occurs in the area and they occur closest to shore (see Figures 81, 91). In the central Pacific, albatrosses tended to be found in higher salinity water within a range of 33.9%o to 35.2%o (King, 1970:96). WEATHER CONSIDERATIONS.—As in the case of Black-footed Albatrosses (see p. 113), wind is probably the most significant feature of the weather affecting Laysan distribution. The doldrum wind conditions no doubt play a significant role in limit- ing the southern distribution of the Laysan Alba- tross. Addendum After this paper was completed in 1968, two im- portant papers on the pelagic distribution of Lay- san Albatrosses were published, those of V. P. Shuntov (1968) and Fisher and Fisher (1972). Gen- erally, these authors indicate the same distribution patterns reported here, but with certain notable exceptions. Shuntov, using sightings at sea, has Laysans rang- ing much farther north in winter than our data indicate, to about 59°N in the Gulf of Alaska, and to about 55° N in the western Bering Sea. Also, con- trary to our sightings and those in the literature, Shuntov has Laysans ranging south to only about 21 °N in the central Pacific. In summer, he shows Laysans ranging well into the Sea of Okhotsk and north in the western Bering Sea to the Gulf of Anadyr. The Fishers' paper is based on 109 captures at sea of birds banded on Midway Island and most of the sightings noted in the literature; omitted for unknown reasons are Sanger's (1970) records off Washington and Oregon. These omissions cast some doubt on the validity of the graphs (Fisher and Fisher, 1972: figs. 3, 5, 7) portraying average monthly longitudinal and latitudinal movements, as does the lack of statistical treatment of the data in the graphs. The inclusion of standard deviations of the means shown in the Fishers' figures 3 and 5 would have given an idea of how representative the means really are. Puzzling is the contention (Fisher and Fisher, 1972:8) for "a probable similarity in the distribution of tunas and albatrosses in the North Pacific. . . ." The facts are that tuna range far south of the southern limit of the Lay- san's range (cf., Rothschild and Uchida, 1968), and that Laysans range far north of the northern limits of tuna distribution. The northern part of the tuna range and the southern part of the Lay- san's range merely overlap. Fisher and Fisher's (1972:16) curious reference to Seckel's (1970) dis- cussion of weather-sea surface interactions in the area from 0° to 35°N, and 130°W to 170°W, for documenting "turbulence and many eddies be- tween 35° and 40°N and 140° to 160°E," and their erroneous view that warm oceanic waters have low salinity (Fisher and Fisher, 1972:17, 23), suggests that more rigor might have been applied in dis- cussing oceanographic matters. The question raised by the authors of whether their data reflected the distribution of albatrosses or of persons recapturing albatrosses never was convincingly answered, espe- cially in view of the disparity in the distribution of albatrosses and tuna (and therefore tuna fishermen). Longline tuna fishing is by far the most susceptible means of capturing albatrosses at sea because the birds actively go after the baited hooks. These and other flaws notwithstanding, the Fishers have pre- sented an important, useful document, all the more so because they have given evidence for differences in the at-sea distribution of young and adult Lay- san Albatrosses. 140 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 141 53* *S 142 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY z ' 2 " NUMBER 158 143 a. < 144 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 145 146 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 147 148 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 149 z ' 2 " 150 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY NUMBER 158 151 Appendix Summary of published data on Laysan Albatross distribution location Date Remarks Source NORTHEAST PACIFIC Various sites in the May-Oct Aleutians, three Gulf of Alaska sightings 230 mi £ Kodiak I., IS Oct 48 Alaska Various sites in Aleutians Jun, Jul 90 mi S of Aleutians at 28 Mar 51 49°51'N, 178°22'W Off Vancouver I. 25 Dec 52 10 Dec 53 Off Washington, Oregon 24-27 Fcb 58 and Vancouver I. Off Washington and May 64-Nov 65 Oregon 100 mi off Washington Fcb 51 to Oahu 50°N, 173°W 23 Scp 54 48°N, 150°W to 30 mi NW of Farallon I. 47°15'N, 126°45'W Along 47° Nat 155° and 178°W 45°36'N, 124°S6'W 45°14'N, 127°31'W 44°45'N, 132°00'W 44°10'N,135°45'W 44°10'N, 132° W 41 °N. 137°30'W- 24°30'N, 155°W 40°32'N, 138°17'W 39°40'N, 139°W 37°37'N, 124°53'W 30 Nov-6 Dec 48 1 Dec 45 Aug 59 1 Oct 63 16 Mar 63 16 Dec 63 15 Dec 63 30 Nov 45 16-20 Jan 60 29 Nov 45 29 Nov 45 25 Jan 45 EAST-CENTRAL PACIFIC North America when not breeding Within 45 mi of central Feb-Mar 58 California coast California, far offshore Oct-Apr from Cape Mendocino to San Nicolas I. possible confusion of early records with Short-tailed Albatross individual followed ship for several hours; ship's captain quoted as often seeing Laysans in same area sight and specimen records; possibility of several Short-tailed Albatross sightings being Laysans 1, apparently the northernmost record for the central North Pacific at this early date 2 at 48°N, 133°W, was closest sighting to North America 3 at 49°N, 133°W, were the most teen off North America at this latitude; generally scarcer in NE Pacific than NW Pacific 6 sightings of 1-3 individuals, 60-100 mi off northern Washington and southern Vancouver I. comprehensive seasonal data; see text herein seen less often and in fewer numbers than Black-footed Albatross 12 this date; place was maximum for general area; seen north of 52 °N several times seen every day during this period; 1 collected 40 mi off northern Califor- nia 1 155°W, apparently near eastern limits of summer range 1 2 1 1 2 "Two or three were always present" only southern range limits, i.e, Baja California, specifically mentioned 11 sightings 8 Feb-29 Mar as close as 18 mi offshore rare or casual visitant; specimen col- lected San Nicolas Murie, 1959:39-40 Kenyon. 1950:100 Gabrielson and Lincoln, 1959:75 MacDonald and Lawford. 1954:16 Poole. 1966:71-72 Sanger, 1965:1-2 Sangcr, 1970:342-343, 349-352 MacDonald and Lawford, 1954:15-16 Poole, 1966:71-72 Kenyon. 1950:100 Thompson, 1951:234 Nakamura, 1963:239-245 Sanger, 1965:1-2 Thompson, 1951:234 Agnew, J. H. in Bourne, 1961:12 Thompson, 1951:234 Vaurie, 1965:19 Holmes, 1964:302-303 Grinnell and Miller, 1944:41 NUMBER 158 153 Summary of published data on Laysan Albatross distribution—Continued Location Date Remarks Source Baja California to Oregon Feb-Apr 49 no dateSan Geronimo, Cuadalupe and San Martin, Baja California 34°N, 131°30'W 17 Mar 45 31 °47'N-35°3rN, within 31 Mar-5Apr 100-300 mi of shore 31°45'N, 129°W NORTHWEST PACIFIC SE of Kamchatka Penin- sula 49 26 Mar 60 16Aug? 45ON,155°E 22 Oct 53 Off Pacific coast of Hon- early spring- shu and Hokkaido late autumn Off Hokkaido, Kuriles, Jun,Jul54 and Kamchatka 40°N, from 165°E to 172°W Coastal Honshu, Japan, from ca. 35 °N to 38°30'N Off Japan 36°N, 141°E Off Japan 35°37'N, 142°59'E Off Japan 34°56'N, 157°OO'E 30°N, 154°E 29°N, 146°E CENTRAL PACIFIC 33°N, 166°E-23°30'N, 162°W 26°S0'N,151°3O'W 22°N, 170°W N, S, and E of Hawaii 17°44'N,159°56rW 17°3O'N,171°2O'W 8°S0'N,163°35'W 6-8Jun55 Dec 62 Apr, May 51 10Jun53 apparently May 51 not specified 22Aug60 Mar 61 22 Mar 60 9-12 Apr 61 12 Apr 60 Mar 61 1964-1965 22 May 59 22 Apr 45 1 Feb45 several sightings by people on oceano- graphic cruises; unspecified positions and numbers formerly fairly common but not re- cently seen McHugh, 1950:153-154 Friedmann, et al., 1950:15 2 stayed near the stopped ship for most Yocom, 1947:510 of one day; crew members saw other white-bodied albatrosses in the area prior to 1945 scattered singles and doubles 1 1 obtained in Kamchatka waters 25, maximum number seen at single sighting; generally more common in western Pacific than other areas regular and not uncommon visitor; not as plentiful as Black-foot maximum number 14 ca. 240 mi S southern tip Kamchatka; other sight- ings mostly scattered singles; none seen in western Bering Sea; suggested temperature preference is 7°-8°C maximum numbers (2.5 per hr) seen at 180° second in abundance only to Rissa tri- dactyla; winter banding returns for coastal Japan; suggests wintering birds are nonbreeding young more common here at this time than in NE Pacific in previous February 6, closest sighting to land during 5 trans-Pacific trips westernmost and southernmost position at which sighted suggests main summer range off Japan as N of 40°N; main winter range S of 35°N (quoted by Kuroda, 1963:234) only time species seen during 36 days at sea, including 2 days off southern and central Japan 1 1 regular occurrence in area implied McHugh, 1950:153-154 Agnew, J. H. in Bourne, 1961:12 Dementev and Gladkov, 1951:347 Poole, 1966:72 Austin and Kuroda, 1953:300 Kuroda, 1955:292 Hamilton, 1958:160-162 Kuroda, 1963:234 MacDonald and Lawford, 1954:16 Poole, 1966:71-72 MacDonald and Lawford, 1954:16 Yamashina, 1942:247 [in Japanese] Wilhoft, 1961:260 Nakamura, 1963:241-243 Mitchell, J. B. in Bourne, 1961:12 Lamb, K.D.A. in Bourne, 1961:12 2 Agnew, J. H. in Bourne, 1961:12 1 Nakamura, 1963:241-243 see text herein King, 1970:9 1, apparently southernmost record for Peakall, 1960:199 month 3 Thompson, 1951:234 1, southernmost record for species " " " The Storm Petrels (Hydrobatidae) Richard S. Crossin Introduction The family Hydrobatidae consists of a group of morphologically similar species distributed over most of the pelagic waters of the earth. At least 15 species and a variable number of subspecies (de- pending upon the reviewer) are found in the areas of the Pacific Ocean covered in the present work. Many of these species are included in the genus Oceanodroma which contains groups of sibling spe- cies, often only separable with some difficulty in the hand, and presenting considerable problems to the observer in the field. The pelagic ranges, as well as other aspects of the life histories of most of the Pacific forms, are little known; for some species even the breeding grounds are unknown. Austin (1952) discusses the taxonomy and breeding stations of most north Pacific species but deals little with pelagic distribution or other aspects. Palmer (1962) covers those hydrobatids that occur in North Amer- ican waters, but the pelagic distribution maps are inadequate. In many cases lack of knowledge of pelagic distribution of a species is admitted by placing a large question mark in an area. For other species range maps are presented with little or no information given as to the type of records (speci- mens, sightings) used to determine the distribution area shown. Murphy (1936) discusses the forms found in waters off the South American continent, as well as many species found to the north. Despite the considerable ornithological work since these vol- umes were written, there has been little or no new information gained regarding many species of hydrobatids considered therein. Richard S. Crossin, Neotropical Ornithological Foundation, J719 North Huachuca, Tucson, Arizona 85705. * Paper Number 84, Pacific Ocean Biological Survey Pro- gram, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 20560. The major reason for lack of positive knowledge regarding Pacific Ocean hydrobatids is the logistics problem with which the student of these seabirds must contend; the Pacific is a vast area where ports are few and far between, and shipping is primarily restricted to large commercial or military vessels. Harrison (1962) had a rather exceptional oppor- tunity of making seabird observations while aboard Royal Navy ships. King and Pyle (1957), Szijj (1967), and others have gained information while on trans-Pacific research cruises. The unique op- portunities of consistent area observation available to the Smithsonian Institution's Pacific Ocean Bio- logical Survey Program (POBSP) during the course of field work from 1963 to 1968 have added a wealth of new information not only on Pacific hydrobatids, but on Pacific seabirds in general. In this paper I shall not attempt to summarize all information available from other sources on the forms of hydrobatids under consideration. Rather I shall present the recently acquired POBSP data, with inclusion of previous data only when it seems necessary for cogency. The POBSP data on Pacific hydrobatids covers essentially four categories: (1) pelagic distribution, (2) breeding biology, (3) molt, (4) taxonomy. As might be expected, unequal amounts of information in these categories were acquired for the various species concerned. These data are presented in the species accounts. Throughout the course of POBSP studies, a variety of vessels were utilized: United States Department of Interior, Bureau of Commercial Fisheries ships; United States Navy vessels; Scripps Institution of Oceanography research vessels; United States Coast Guard ships; leased fishing ships; and others. POBSP observers normally worked in rotating two-man teams who were on watch constantly during day- light hours and occasionally at night. On cruises 154 NUMBER 158 155 with only a single POBSP observer aboard, he usu- ally observed from dawn to dark with intermittent breaks. All bird sightings were recorded with ac- companying pertinent data. The recording of time of day at each sighting permitted interpolation of latitude and longitude positions from the ships' cruise charts. Weather and oceanographic condi- tions were coupled to each sighting when possible, and all information was later transferred to mag- netic tape from which rapid summations of data for single species or species groups could be drawn for analysis. For a more comprehensive view of the Automatic Data Processing program, see King, Wat- son, and Gould (1967). As field work was performed for the most part on a year-round basis, migrational patterns, seasonal movements, and other factors can be analyzed to determine variations present in sea- sonal timing and areas utilized by the various spe- cies concerned. During the course of POBSP activities some 12,574 observations covering 27,140 individ- uals of the family Hydrobatidae were recorded. Regular and periodic surveys of islands used for nesting within the area of investigation allow for a more complete understanding of the pelagic obser- vations. Specimen collecting accompanied pelagic observations whenever feasible. Artificial oil slicks (see Murphy, 1936:8) were often put out specifically to attract hydrobatids. During the course of the study 650 specimens of 11 hydrobatid species were collected. Most speci- mens collected and observations made were of the various subspecies of the Leach's Storm Petrel (Oceanodroma leucorhoa). The means, with stand- ard errors and standard deviations, are given in Appendix Tables A to E for all standard measure- ments of the POBSP specimens of leucorhoa races, as well as of other species. All wing measurements are of the chord. In comparing chord measurements with measurements of the flattened wing on storm petrels, I find extremely little difference between the two. AREA COVERED BY POBSP.—Gould (Figure 1) shows the approximate outlines of the areas sur- veyed during all POBSP cruises from August 1963 through April 1968. All portions of those areas were not comparably surveyed in regard to total coverage or to time of year. Without question, certain areas received consistent and by far more regular cover- age than other areas, which were surveyed only once or very irregularly. By and large, the area surveyed falls into two major regions: the central Pacific and the central eastern Pacific (hereafter referred to as the eastern Pacific). The former was surveyed almost constantly from 1963 to 1967. The latter was surveyed intensively during 1967 and 1968. Inter- mittent cruises were also run in the Alaskan area. FIELD IDENTIFICATION.—As a group, the various white-rumped and dark-rumped storm petrels in the Pacific present as great an identification prob- lem to the field worker as any two groups of sibling species known. I have no doubt that each species has its peculiar identifying characters and that un- der ideal conditions most individuals might be properly identified to species, but sightings in the field are seldom under ideal conditions. In fact, it is unusual when weather, lighting, distance and other factors are satisfactory for positive identifica- tion. Most sightings are assigned to species only by inference and deduction. In 1965 Wilson's Storm Petrels (Oceanites ocean- icus), a totally unexpected species, were collected for the first time in the central Pacific. No doubt some were seen during late 1963 and 1964, but were erroneously recorded as Leach's (Oceanodroma leu- corhoa) or Harcourt's Storm Petrels (Oceanodroma castro). Continued collecting after 1965 with the re- sultant procurement of scattered specimens of Wil- son's, plus a detailed survey of migration in the central Pacific (Huber, 1971) have shown that these birds apparently move through the Pacific (Mar- shall Islands area, at least) in considerable numbers, and are scattered throughout the central Pacific in small numbers during the migratory period. Any purely visual identification made of storm petrels in an unknown area is, in my opinion, speculative. In the central Pacific, identification problems were greatest for Leach's, Harcourt's, and Wilson's Storm Petrels, all white-rumped forms. The latter two were present in fewer numbers than Leach's. Random collecting performed throughout the area allowed for a fairly good estimate of the percentage of each species present. In the eastern Pacific the situation was consid- erably different in that both white-rumped and dark-rumped forms were present. Although more species were involved, the majority of these were sufficiently diverse to allow reasonably accurate field identification. General collecting proved even more fruitful here than in the central Pacific, as certain forms, such as the two races of the Gala- 156 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 120° 110° 100° 90° FIGURE 93.—POBSP sightings and specimens of Pelagodroma marina. 10 70° pagos Storm Petrel (Oceanodroma tethys), are read- ily separable in the hand. Thus in a situation such as this, the ideal is realized in that a collected speci- men not only provides positive identification of the species, molt, food, and gonadal information, but allows for designation of the at-sea range of a spe- cific geographic race. Hence, despite the problems connected with field identification of hydrobatids, observations made during the POBSP surveys can be discussed with a considerable degree of assurance for the following reasons: (1) the observers concerned had an extra- ordinary opportunity to gain experience in field identification during extensive periods of work at sea under every conceivable condition, and (2) most at-sea observations were backed by random collecting; this constant procurement of specimens throughout various areas provided a constant check on visual observations. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.—The following made impor- tant observations and collected field data pertinent to hydrobatids during the program; without their contributions, this paper could not have been writ- ten: A. Binion Amerson, Jr., Richard D. Chandler, Roger B. Clapp, Robert L. DeLong, Patrick J. Gould, C. Douglas Hackman, Brian A. Harrington, Lawrence N. Huber, Dayle N. Husted, Warren B. King, Horace Loftin, Max C. Thompson, and Paul W. Woodward. (For a more complete listing of POBSP personnel and objectives of the Pacific Pro- gram, see Gould, pp. 1-5, herein.) I also wish to thank the following individuals who aided the writing of this paper in their respec- tive ways. Philip S. Humphrey, as Principal Investi- gator of the Pacific Program, offered valuable ad- vice and encouraged the writing of the present work. Dean Amadon of the American Museum of Natural History in New York and Joseph R. Jehl, Jr., of the San Diego Natural History Museum made available the hydrobatid specimens in their charge. Carl L. Hubbs of Scripps Institution of Oceanography generously offered me the use of his field notes and preliminary consolidated data on hydrobatids from the eastern Pacific islands, espe- NUMBER 158 157 FIGURE 94.—POBSP sightings of Oceanodroma furcata. (Breeding localities are largely from Palmer, 1962). daily Guadalupe. Oliver L. Austin, Jr., reviewed the manuscript and offered valuable suggestions. Ralph Browning donated his time and effort to performing much of the tedious work of measuring specimens. Anne K. Poulson prepared the illustra- tions. Pelagodroma marina (Latham) WHITE-FACED STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—Most POBSP pelagic rec- ords of this basically southern hemisphere hydro- batid are from west of the Galapagos Islands. Prac- tically all sightings fall within a triangular area with points at 5°N, 112°W; 8°S, 112°W, and 3°S, 100°W (Figure 93). Two adult females were col- lected by the POBSP on 24 August 1967 at 6°19'S, 111°55'W. Three other specimens taken in the east- ern Pacific (two near the Galapagos, one near Ecua- dor) are mentioned in Murphy (1936:768). LeVeque, et al. (1966) report a specimen collected in Septem- ber 1930 about 100 miles southwest of the Gala- pagos, and two sightings in August 1960 and seven sightings in July 1961 about halfway between the Ecuadorian mainland and the Galapagos. The similarity of south Atlantic (Tristan da 158 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Cunha Islands) and south Pacific (Australia-New Zealand) subspecies makes it difficult to assign ori- gin to specimens collected near the Galapagos. Murphy (1936:768), while implying that some form of this species was probably resident in the eastern Pacific, left the question of origin open. Most likely these eastern Pacific records pertain to members of the Australian-New Zealand populations, which migrate to the South American coast and follow the Peru Current north and west through the Galapa- gos region. The large number of records west of the Galapagos in August and September (84% and 14%, respectively, of total POBSP sightings for those months) indicate a buildup prior to the return to the Australian-New Zealand breeding grounds where egg-laying takes place in late October. The condition of our August specimens (in terminating stages of complete molt and with moderate fat) is in accord with the condition of other procellarii- forms prior to a prebreeding migration. Murphy (1936) and Palmer (1962) summarize the known biology of the species. Oceanodroma furcata (Gmelin) FORK-TAILED STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—This species was ob- served commonly on all POBSP cruises in the central and eastern Pacific north of 40°N (Figure 94). A region of high density off the California coast be- tween 31 °N and 36°N probably consists of birds from the northern California or Oregon popula- tions. An obvious straggler was observed on 22 February 1968 feeding on refuse behind a ship in the company of several Black Storm Petrels (Ocean- odroma melania) near the southern tip of Baja California. POBSP collected only a few specimens of nominate O. f. furcata near the Aleutian Islands; thus most of our pelagic sightings are not referable to race. Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa (Vieillot) LEACH'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The nominate race of Leach's Storm Petrel is distributed in its at-sea range over much of the Pacific Ocean with a de- cided center of abundance in the central Pacific. Measurements of normally used characters of all specimens collected (Figure 95) in this area are com- pared with known breeding O. I. leucorhoa from the Alaskan area in Appendix Table B. It can easily be seen that central Pacific birds fall well within the range for nominate leucorhoa. As a whole, the specimens are comparable both in meas- urements and other more subtle morphological characters with nominate leucorhoa from the breeding grounds. However, because of the diffi- culty involved in separating nominate leucorhoa from O. I. beali, the presence of a small percentage of the latter in the central Pacific is not to be ex- cluded. Oceanodroma I. leucorhoa attains greatest winter densities in a broad belt along the equator. Num- bers drop rapidly to the south, and south of 12°S only an occasional individual is sighted. Waters to the north of this equatorial high-density area pre- sent problems of seasonal density specification. High density in small sectors north of the equa- torial complex is probably due to several factors, among which are local, temporary, high concentra- tions of food. Additionally, late fall and early spring migrants may tend to mass at certain points in the northern sector of the wintering grounds be- fore moving on south or north, as the case may be. Birds are found throughout the central Pacific win- tering grounds throughout the year, with decided buildups of wintering birds as would be expected (compare Figure 96 "Summer" with Figure 97 "Winter"). The number of summering birds is considerable, but their age status is uncertain. In the Atlantic population of the nominate race, birds presum- ably do not breed until three years of age, but two- year old birds may return to the colony during the breeding season (Wilbur, 1969). Wilbur (1969) im- plies that first-year birds might fly over the colony without entering it; he apparently has no positive evidence for this in the form of banded birds. Huntington (pers. comra.) informed me that of eleven breeding birds banded as nestlings, the youngest were four years old; of thirteen banded birds mist-netted over the colony, breeding status unknown, the youngest were three years old. There may be considerable individual variation among one- and two-year old birds in regard to their re- turn to the breeding colony. The only other explanation for the large num- ber of birds that summer in the central Pacific is NUMBER 158 159 180 FIGURE 95.—Localities of collected specimens of Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa in the central Pacific. that for some reason, some adults do not return to the breeding colony every year. Both Huntington (1963) and Wilbur (1969) record that approxi- mately 50 percent of birds banded while nesting one year are found nesting the following year. Un- less we assume some birds were missed in the study plots or had moved elsewhere, this seems to be an exceptionally high mortality rate. Possibly some adults that successfully raise a chick one year do not return to the breeding grounds the following year. The migrational pattern of nominate leucorhoa is largely obscured by the high densities of sum- 160 170 W 160' SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 150° 140° . 150° 140° FICURE 96.—Summer densities (May, June, July, August) of Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa. NUMBER 158 161 160 E 170 180" 170 W 160 150 140° o —130 20' 10" 20 Birds per square mile .01 -.10 if!-11--20 •1.21 + 20 10° ,20 140°160° 170 180 170 160° 150° FIGURE 97.—Winter densities (November, December, January, February) of Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa. mering birds, and is more readily ascertained by field observations of flocking birds rather than by actual increases or decreases in recorded density. The spring migration north begins in March and probably occurs sporadically throughout April, since April densities in the central Pacific are still far greater than in mid-summer when most breed- ing birds are on the breeding grounds. The fall mi- gration south is also largely obscured by summer- ing birds, but definite density increases are noted southward to the high-density equatorial center as early as September. At this time of year breeding birds would still be expected on the breeding grounds or at least in more northerly latitudes. These early fall buildups in the equatorial area may either be of birds that have experienced nest- ing failures, and thus have left the breeding grounds earlier than the successful breeders, or of prebreeders that have spent the summer farther north and have returned to more southerly latitudes for the winter. As it is virtually impossible to dis- tinguish immature prebreeders from adult breed- ing birds when the latter's gonads are in a winter quiescent stage, collected specimens from these sea- 162 20 10° s 10" 130 110° SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 100° 90 "140° 1 bird 5 birds 30" Islobela I., A - Galapagos j Islands 10" 120° 10° no 100° 90° FIGURE 98.—Localities of collected specimens of Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa in the eastern Pacific Ocean. NUMBER 158 163 sons do not lend information as to their recent breeding activities. Movements and distribution of the nominate race throughout the eastern Pacific are less clear because of the difficulty of separating individuals from the abundant O. I. beali, which winters promi- nently along the western American coast. A few specimens from the eastern Pacific are clearly refer- able to nominate leucorhoa by their greater size; collecting localities of these are shown in Figure 98. Aside from POBSP specimens, Loomis (1918:182) mentions three specimens collected south of the Galapagos Islands whose measurements indicate their allocation to the nominate race. Palmer (1962: 227) mentions examples of the nominate form taken off the coast of Ecuador. Comparatively, the num- bers of these eastern representatives are low and the equatorial high-density area between 170°W and 175°E is, if not the center of winter abun- dance, one of the most important of such centers. TAXONOMY.—Considerable taxonomic work was performed on available POBSP specimens during the course of this study in the hope that the ability to distinguish races of at-sea collected specimens would allow for a clearer picture of their respective at-sea ranges. In some cases this was possible, but many individuals cannot be designated unconditionally to a particular race. Concerning the Pacific races of Leach's, Austin (1952:400) stated: "On dimensions alone these are all weak races. Despite significant differences between the means of some characters, fewer than half the individuals of many of the recognized subspecies are distinguishable." Despite the recently collected large series of most of the races concerned, we are no better off in regard to solving these problems. Austin's (1952) arrange- ment of the various Pacific subspecies of Oceano- droma leucorhoa is followed here. The unusual situation concerning O. I. socorroensis at Guada- lupe Island and the possible need for revision of the taxonomy of that population is discussed be- yond. In working with fresh series of recently molted birds of all populations, I find that little signifi- cance can be attached to the oft-mentioned char- acter of a lead bloom to the plumage of the north- ern races, which is supposedly most prominent in nominate leucorhoa. All races in very fresh plum- age show this particular bloom but with consid- erable individual variation, and this particular cast is lost quite rapidly, both in living birds and in museum specimens. Freshly molted series of either O. I. chapmani or O. /. socorroensis show this char- acter as prominently as newly molted nominate leucorhoa from the Alaskan area, although the overall plumage is admittedly considerably darker in the southern races. Juvenile socorroensis from Guadalupe are especially prone to show this par- ticular character, but drastic differences exist be- tween new and old plumage. When the plumage is several months old the entire feather coat in all races is of a washed-out brown hue in addition to its ragged condition, with hardly a trace of the rich charcoal present in new featheration. Body contour feathers, as well as flight feathers, are badly worn at the end of a plumage sequence. Of the flight feathers, primaries appear to take the most wear. In contour feathers, those about the head and neck appear most subject to wear and at the beginning of a new molt sequence these are often no more than ragged portions of the original appendages. Only in the case of exceptionally large individ- uals of O. I. leucorhoa, and exceptionally small in- dividuals of O. I. socorroensis, can birds of the leu- corhoa complex be segregated with any degree of certainty. As is evident from the measurements in Appendix Table B, nominate leucorhoa from the Alaskan area is the largest of all races. While the average individual of the nominate race has a gen- erally more massive bill, this subtle difference is useful only in direct comparison of specimens, and does not lend itself meaningfully to mensural appli- cation. MOLT.—Members of the nominate race of Leach's that enter the central and eastern Pacific from northern breeding grounds, as well as year-round semipermanent residents there (nonbreeders), are already undergoing a pronounced primary molt by July. This continues in some individuals through- out the fall and winter (to December or even later). In a large percentage of birds the entire primary molt has been accomplished by November, and in exceptional individuals by October (Figure 99). For many others this molt may not terminate until April. It cannot be determined whether individuals finishing primary molt from, say, February through April, are birds that have a very prolonged cycle or whether they are individuals that began molt very late in the year. Primary molt can be clearly ascer- tained and follows a set pattern of replacement of 164 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 100 90 80 70- 60- 5 50 s. 40 30 20 10 July N=6 I I Old 3 Molting Non-molting FIGURE 99.—Seasonal molt stages in Oceanodroma leucorhoa leucorhoa. The percentages of new, growing, and old primaries and rectrices are calculated from direct count of all birds in each respective sample; narrow portion of bar equals nonmolting percentage of sample, wide portion of bar equals molting percentage of sample, (n = sample size.) new feathers from the innermost to the outermost primaries with corresponding feather pair members of each wing coincident or very closely attuned. Most individuals of chapmani and socorroensis, re- turning to the breeding islands, were in terminal stages or had very recently completed a body and primary molt. Some individuals were still growing the outermost (tenth) primary as defeatheration of NUMBER 158 165 the brood patch and gonadal enlargement were oc- curring. We took no specimens of either beali or leucorhoa on any breeding grounds except for willetti ( = beali) on the Coronados Islands. Rectrix molt, like the preceding, is already well along in our July sample of O. I. leucorhoa, and is for all practical purposes, finished by November. Only a few isolated individuals show any evidence of rectrix molt during the period from January through May. There seems to be no set pattern of rectrix molt except that opposite members of a pair of tail feathers are generally molted at the same, or at nearly the same time. Investigation of the molt pattern of the second- ary feathers was less satisfactory because of the dif- ficulty of working with study skins in these small, long-winged birds. In general, it appears that the outer secondaries begin to molt at about the time the first primaries shed, and molt then proceeds progressively toward the body. Secondary molt is closely parallel to primary molt and is usually ter- minated before the last primary has finished grow- ing. Extensive body molt of the contour feathers in the nominate race begins in November and is ap- parent in a decreasingly smaller number of indi- viduals through April. Body molt is generally dis- tributed over most of the body; the crown and throat regions and the primary and greater coverts are the last areas to replace feathers. The various races of Leach's show certain variations in molt pat- terns. No doubt much of the variation in molt between individuals of the nominate race can be attributed to differences between juvenile, immature, and adult breeding birds. However, I cannot satisfactor- ily separate immature birds from adults on the wintering grounds after the latter's gonads have regressed, except for truly adult females, which form only a small part of our sample. The more extensive lighter margins of the coverts and the scapulars, and the wrinkling of the nostril area in study skins, which are supposed to be good charac- ters for separating juvenile birds from older indi- viduals, are not positive determinants and at any rate these differences disappear within the first year of life. Hence, the monthly samples shown in the molt graphs are unquestionably made up of a va- riety of age classes. Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali Emerson BEAL'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—Our at-sea observations, backed by routine collecting of specimens through- out the eastern Pacific (Figure 100), have deter- mined that O. I. beali winters throughout a broad area south of the breeding grounds from north- central California (northern limit of recurrent POBSP cruises) to at least 20°S. South of 10°S de- creasingly lower densities are recorded. Within this extensive area the distributional picture is some- what confused because of the admixture of certain other white-rumped forms, such as a scattering of identifiable nominate leucorhoa, O. I. socorroensis and two races of Galapagos Storm Petrels (O. tethys tethys and O. t. kelsalli). Nevertheless dense winter- ing populations of beali are found off both central and southern California and throughout a broad area from ca. 26°N to ca. 8°S, between 90°W and 120°W (Figure 101). Although not readily apparent from the density distribution maps, these are the areas most heavily surveyed by the POBSP. Hence, as is often the case, graphic display of geographical distribution of an organism more often tends to show distribution of the researcher rather than of the organism. The POBSP has not surveyed to the west or south of the areas involved in EASTROPAC cruises. Our summer cruises in the eastern Pacific only extend to ca. 5°S; densities of O. I. beali are fairly high to that point (Figure 102). It may be noted that the density figures in the O. I. beali pelagic distribution charts are consid- erably higher than those for O. I. leucorhoa in the central Pacific. Despite the fact that more forms are involved in the eastern area, actual eastern Pacific densities for all races of leucorhoa are roughly three times greater than those recorded in the cen- tral Pacific. Since the magnitude of observations under varying conditions in both areas would elimi- nate, or render insignificant, any temporary varia- tions in the data gathering, the differences in density consistently recorded between these two areas must be regarded as real. TAXONOMY.—Austin (1952) synonymizes both O. I. beldingi from the northern California coast, and O. /. willetti from the Coronados Islands, with O. I. beali. Hence, O. I. beali applies to all Leach's Storm Petrels breeding along the North American west coast from extreme southeastern Alaska to the 166 130 W 20 10 130e SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 100° 90° . • 1 bird • 5 birds 40 30° l.abela I.. ' Galapagos Islands 120° 110° 100° FIGURE 100.—Localities of collected specimens of Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali. 10" 10 90° 20 - 130 20 70" FIGURE 101.—Winter densities (November, December, January, February, March) of Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali. 168 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 13C w 70" 0 50 10° 0° Birds per square mile .01 .20 40- 30 130° 120° 110° 100° 90° 80° FIGURE 102.—Summer densities (May, June, July, August) of Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali. Coronados Islands* just south of the United States- Mexican border. Although this eliminates the con- fusion involved in attempting to recognize more than one form along the United States west coast, many individuals in this complex cannot be dis- tinguished from nominate leucorhoa to the north; a considerable number of individuals from the Coronados population cannot be distinguished from either dark-rumped O. I. chapmani from the San Benitos Islands (along the west-central coast NUMBER 158 169 •o I FHUJRE 103.—Seasonal molt stages in Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali. (See Figure 99 for explana- tion of symbols.) of Baja California), or O. I. socorroensis of Guada- lupe Island. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—A number of authors record the nesting of O. I. beali along the western North American coast; among these are Grinnell and Daggett (1903), Willett (1915), Howell (1920), Bailey (1927), E. W. Martin (1938), and Campbell and Stirling (1968). The consensus of these reports is that beali nests from at least April through Sep- tember. Eggs are recorded from June to August, and young from July to September. An exception- ally early record of the Coronados Island popula- tion ( = willetti of the 1957 A.O.U. Check-list) is that of a three-quarter grown downy young taken 27 Ap- ril 1929 (specimen in the San Diego Natural His- tory Museum). Other specimens from the Corona- dos in that institution were collected between 6 July and 5 September. A few of the September birds are small downy young that probably would not have left the island until October. The POBSP captured three dark-rumped birds of the Coronados population in a mist net on the night of 30 June 1968 on Center Island. No nests were found; the population at that time could not have exceeded 100 birds. MOLT.—The molt sequence of O. I. beali is graphically demonstrated in Figure 103. From our collected samples, beali appears to have a larger percentage of individuals undergoing primary molt during the prebreeding months (February-May) than O. I. leucorhoa. Fall primary molt (probably concerned with immatures) is terminated more rapidly than in O. I. leucorhoa. Rectrix and body molt are basically the same in beali and nominate leucorhoa. Oceanodroma leucorhoa chapmani Berlepsch CHAPMAN'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The pelagic distribution of this form is little known, and POBSP surveys have not been informative. Although the race is charac- terized by the fact that all members have a dark rump, its presence at sea is difficult to determine because it is indistinguishable from dark-rumped birds of both the Coronados and Guadalupe Island populations present in the same area. Although we have a considerable number of sightings of dark- rumped birds from both the northern cruise areas and the southern EASTROPAC areas, it is impossible to assign racial designation to these sightings. An admixture of collected specimens of dark-rumped, intermediate, and white-rumped birds of small size from the eastern Pacific are in most cases definitely assignable to socorroensis. It is not possible by measurements to separate definitely all dark-rumped socorroensis from chapmani. We have collected few, if any, chapmani at sea. On the basis of the 170 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY limited number of small, dark-rumped specimens taken, however, it may be that this race winters much closer to the coast than do beali, leucorhoa, or socorroensis. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—This dark-rumped form of Leach's breeds predominantly or exclusively on the San Benitos Islands off west-central Baja California. During a POBSP survey of these islands from 26 to 29 April 1968, birds were plentiful on all three islands. At that time they were calling from the air, as well as occupying empty burrows and cavities among the rocks. No eggs were found. Several adults were discovered fatally impaled upon the spines of the rampant cholla cactus (Opuntia sp.). A later June survey noted 14 such individuals on one slope. During a 25 to 27 June 1968 survey, most birds were still calling from empty nest sites; some 20 percent of the population were on fresh to heavily incubated eggs, but no chicks were found. The birds occupy every feasible habitat on the islands for nesting, with possibly the talus slopes and rocky areas preferred. In these habitats they are in com- petition for nest sites with the Black Storm Petrel and Least Storm Petrel (Halocyptena microsoma). Some chapmani used abandoned Cassin's Auklet (Ptychoramphus aleutica) burrows, but a number were noted digging their own burrows. DeLong (POBSP) records that "despite the apparent weakness of the bony structure of the legs, they dig with great fervor and make the soil fairly fly." The species' nocturnal and secretive nesting habits make it extremely difficult to arrive at more than a rough estimate of the population size. For the June 1968 survey this was set at 50,000 birds for the island group. Oceanodroma leucorhoa socorroensis Townsend SOCORRO STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—O. I. socorroensis were found at sea as far north as 35°N and south to 10°N. A considerable number of specimens were taken southeast of the breeding island of Guada- lupe. As socorroensis cannot be distinguished in the field with any degree of certainty, all records are based on collected specimens (Figure 104). In late February 1968 near 10°N, and between 100°W and 110°W, sizeable concentrations of socorroensis were recorded in mixed flocks composed of Oceanodroma tethys tethys, Oceanodroma leucorhoa beali, and a few large specimens that are best referable to O. I. leucorhoa. No socorroensis were collected below 10°N, although extensive collecting was done throughout the cruise in these longitudes to 20°S. The western limits of the pelagic distribution are unknown. From our evidence, apparently socor- roensis does not range as widely from the breeding grounds, nor as far from the coast, as do beali or leucorhoa. TAXONOMY.—This race is the smallest and most variable in rump color of all forms of leucorhoa in the Pacific. The characters of greatest use in sep- arating this from other races are wing and bill length, and the overall slightness of the bill. Weights, when available, are also useful in dem- onstrating the small size. A series of 109 POBSP specimens from the summer breeding population show a range of wing length from 135 mm to 150 mm with a mean of 141.89. Austin (1952) records 25 socorroensis with wing length ranging from 141 mm to 157 mm, and with a mean of 148.8 ± .88. Another series of winter breeding birds composed of POBSP specimens as well as specimens from the San Diego Natural History Museum contains 19 males with a wing length range of 141 mm to 150 mm, and 18 females with a range of 140 mm to 147 mm. With this overall range of from 140 mm to 150 mm for both sexes (although close to the 135 mm to 150 mm range for summer socorroensis) the winter birds tend to be slightly larger, although there is complete over- lap between winter and summer birds. Considering all birds of both winter and summer populations from a sample of 146 birds, the range is 135 mm to 150 mm. This large sample should totally blan- ket Austin's sample of 25 birds, but his series shows considerably larger measurements in both range and mean. His sample apparently contains both winter and summer Guadalupe birds and also ap- parent stragglers (probably of O. I. beali) taken off- shore Guadalupe. For example, several obvious beali (by their worn plumage and measurements) taken offshore in winter were found in the series of socorroensis in the San Diego Museum. The winter breeding population on Guadalupe of slightly larger birds is in need of considerable investigation. If this population is sufficiently dif- ferent to warrant subspecific recognition, the ap- propriate name would be Oceanodroma leucorhoa NUMBER 158 171 130° W no" N 20 10 100 -140° • 1 Bird Breeding locality 30" 10 130 120 110 100 FIGLRE 104.—Localities of collected specimens of Oceanodroma leucorhoa socorroensis. kaedingi. For convenience, I will refer to the win- ing population, socorroensis. Besides their slightly ter breeding birds as "kaedingi" to differentiate larger size, kaedingi are, in part, further distin- them from the currently recognized summer breed- guishable from socorroensis by rump color. All 37 172 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY FIGURE 105.—Variation in rump color of Oceanodroma leucorhoa socorroensis from Guadalupe Island. winter-breeding kaedingi examined are white- rumped, the amount of white ranging from 2 through 4 on a scale of 0 to 5 measuring the amount of white in the rump. The series of 37 showed the following scale figures: 2 (14%), 3 (40%); interme- diates between 3 and 4 (11%); and 4 (35%). Thus an average bird of this population would have rump color of slightly over 3, about comparable to that of O. I. beali. Summer socorroensis, on the other hand, have rump color ranging from cate- gories 0 through 5, or from pure dark to pure white rumps (Figure 105). Austin's (1952:401) state- ment characterizing rump color of socorroensis, "rump patch variable, almost always with some white, but never as much as in typical beali," is not quite true. As discussed in the breeding biology section, 90 percent of the birds breeding on Islote Negro in June 1968 had pure dark rumps. Con- versely certain individuals taken off Islote Afuera have a pure white rump; even the feather shafts are white (as in Oceanodroma castro), a condition that rarely occurs in any race of leucorhoa. Obviously these differences between socorroensis and kaedingi are insufficient to permit racial designation of most individuals taken away from the breeding island, so at present it is useless to attempt to recognize these two populations as taxonomically distinct. These differences, however, are neither more nor less than those displayed by most named subspecies of leucorhoa. A small- to average-sized O. I. chap- mani from the San Benitos Islands would be in- distinguishable from a dark-rumped socorroensis from Guadalupe Island, as would a large chapmani be indistinguishable from a dark-rumped "willetti" (=beali) from the Coronados. Unfortunately we are dealing with populations that show few external morphological differences. Nevertheless the winter breeding population at Guadalupe, whether it is recognized as a distinct race or not, undoubtedly differs physiologically from the summer popula- tion. Despite equalizing ocean temperatures, Guada- lupe is at a fairly high northern latitude (29°N) with a considerable difference between summer and winter temperatures. The possibility exists that food items available to the young in the surround- ing waters differ considerably between winter and summer. To my knowledge kaedingi is the only hydrobatid (besides Oceanodroma tristrami) in the northern hemisphere that nests in the northern winter. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—Oceanodroma leucorhoa so- corroensis breeds only on Guadalupe Island, some 200 miles west of Baja California, Mexico. The POBSP surveys, as well as numerous surveys by Carl NUMBER 158 173 Hubbs of Scripps Institution of Oceanography and other parties, have shown that at least the bulk of the storm petrel population is now restricted to breeding on tiny offshore islets free of introduced predators. The two best surveyed among these islets are Islote Negro and Islote Afuera near the Mexi- can settlement at the southern tip of the main island. We have indirect evidence that a sizeable population may still breed on the main island proper, but the actual nesting area has not been discovered. This race of Leach's has presented some of the most puzzling problems of all forms studied. Be- tween 22 and 23 June 1968 the populations on both Islote Negro and Islote Afuera were surveyed. On Islote Negro the estimated population of sev- eral thousand birds, judged by several hundred handled at the nest sites, was composed almost without exception of dark-rumped birds. On Islote Afuera, only about a mile and a half away, we estimated more than 90 percent of the population were white-rumped. There appeared to be no mor- phological difference except rump color between the two populations. This was inferred not only from living birds, but from the series of skins col- lected at the time. Vocalization recordings of in- dividuals from both populations were taken, but these have not yet been analyzed. Suffice to say that the field workers could discern no differences in the calls of the two populations. To complicate mat- ters even more, a series of about 50 birds collected aboard ship on the night of 28 June immediately off the southeast coast approximately 10 miles from these islets, contained individuals with every con- ceivable rump color from white through completely dark. Many of these were not in breeding condition, but a considerable number of birds with interme- diate-colored rumps had heavily vascularized brood patches, indicating that eggs or young were already present. Had these birds been part of the popula- tions on either Islote Negro or Afuera, it seems cer- tain that they would have been noticed. Hence, this population was suspected of nesting somewhere on the main island. Huber spent about eight hours about the cliffs and among the pines on 29 June, but found no breeding storm petrels. No explanation is offered regarding the allo- patric distribution on adjacent islets of these popu- lations. That chance would be operative in segre- gating these color morphs appears to be a mathe- matical improbability, especially in view of the number of individuals involved. The total exclu- sion of an influx of birds of opposing rump colors can hardly be plausible. For the present, this con- fusing issue must await a more detailed study. The nesting stages of the populations on these islets on 22 and 23 June 1968 were as follows: Islote Negro: The summer breeding population on Islote Negro was estimated to be about 4000 birds. Storm petrels were found nesting over the entire islet, but definite concentrations were found wherever large masses of volcanic rocks were pres- ent, these apparently being the most favored sites. Lesser numbers were found nesting in soil burrows, excavated by Black-vented Shearwaters (Puffinus puffinus opisthomelas) or Cassin's Auklets, and un- der dense mats of plant material. The storm petrels themselves also excavated a considerable number of burrows in the hard-packed soil. The tiny en- trance holes to many extensive burrows indicated that only storm petrels could have dug them. Varying amounts of plant material in the form of seed pods or dried stems (usually of the intro- duced ice plant, Mesembryanthemum sp.) were used for nest linings. Nests in rocky areas usually had very little nest lining, the eggs being deposited on the sparse soil or on the rocks in some cases. The population on Islote Negro at this time was ap- proaching its egg-laying peak with an estimated 20 percent of the nests containing fresh eggs. Only a single egg out of about 30 examined showed ad- vanced incubation. The majority of the popula- tion appeared to be paired with completed or par- tially completed nest sites. An occasional fresh egg was found lying on the ground outside nest cavities. These were presum- ably inadvertently kicked out by the shearwaters or murrelets, both of which utilized the larger nooks, and rock or soil crevices. Many old storm petrel eggs, presumably of the winter breeding popula- tion, were noted in and about active nest sites. It appeared that the two populations frequently uti- lized the same nest sites. This seems reasonable, as practically every good nest site was occupied by the summer breeders. Birds vocalized continuously through the night, with a calling frenzy shortly after full dark. Most birds called from burrows; a few called on the wing. All birds examined (a minimum of 500) on Islote 174 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Negro had dark rumps. The most white noted on any bird was a few feathers at the sides of the rump. In these individuals the feathers were more gray than glaringly white. Islote Afuera: Islote Afuera supported about 25 percent fewer birds than Islote Negro. The nesting cycle was roughly in the same stage, with a some- what higher percentage of nests with eggs. This may have been due to the considerably less nest construction necessary, as the vast majority of birds on Islote Afuera occupied natural pockets and crev- ices in the lava rock instead of excavating burrows in the sparse soil. At least 90 percent of the birds on Islote Afuera were white-rumped. Other than rump color, no differences could be detected between the popula- tions of the two islets. Except for the following rec- ords of immatures, we have few data pertaining to later aspects of the breeding season of O. I. socor- roensis. Huey (1930) records a juvenile with con- siderable down still adhering to the plumage that came aboard ship about a mile off Guadalupe on the evening of 27 September 1929, and another with completely downy underparts that came aboard ship 28 September, 26 miles north of Guadalupe. The POBSP found flying young with down on ven- tral regions sitting around burrows at night on 21 October 1967 on Islote Negro. The latest date for young of this population is a male juvenile with completely downy underside that flew aboard a ship off northeast anchorage, Guadalupe, on 12 November 1954. The three specimens mentioned above are in the San Diego Museum of Natural History. From the above records it can be surmised that young socorroensis leave the islands through- out the fall and hence overlap with the winter breeding population, at least from September through November. Measurements of a series of 20 eggs of the sum- mer breeding populations of Islotes Negro and Afuera are given in Table 28. Eggs of socorroensis are white with a wreath of fine reddish brown dots about the large end. The small size of socorroensis is reflected in the egg dimensions when compared to those of other races of Leach's Storm Petrel. WINTER BREEDING POPULATION (O. /. kaedingi Anthony).—More confusing is the status of the winter breeding population that arrives on the same islets before all the summer breeders leave (see Hubbs, 1960). No POBSP survey was made during TABLE 28.—Egg measurements of three subspecies of Leach's Storm Petrel (Oceanodroma leucorhoa) (data for O. I. leucorhoa and O. I. beali are from Palmer, 1962) Measurement Length with SD (n = 20) Breadth with SD (n = 20) O. /. leucorhoa O. I. beali O. I. socorroensis (Bay of Fundy) (NW U. S. coast) (Guadalupe Island) 3S.01±l.06 23.58 ±0.57 S1.46±1.S1 23.21 ±0.78 29.76 ±0.72 22.19 ±0.74 the height of the breeding season of kaedingi, and we have few specifics pertaining to its cycle. It ap- parently begins coming to the islets in August, and thus at least a portion of the two populations over- lap, as not all the summer breeders have left the is- lets by this time. On 21 October 1967 on Islote Negro, three pairs were noted during a mid-day survey of the islet. Approximately 30 minutes after sundown birds began appearing, and within an hour an estimated 100 birds were calling from the air and about 400 from rock crevices and burrows. Previous mention is made of socorroensis juveniles recorded at this time. Specimens of juvenile kaedingi in the San Diego Museum of Natural History indicate the extent of the breeding season. J. R. Henderson took a three- quarters downy young from a burrow on 31 Janu- ary 1950 and Carl Hubbs collected similarly sized young under a boulder on Islote Afuera on 11 Feb- ruary 1957. A juvenile with completely downy belly was taken aboard ship by Hubbs at northeast anchorage on 1 March 1965. A POBSP survey found on Islote Negro on 29 April 1967 one large juvenile with down on the venter. It apparently represented the last of the 1966-1967 winter season kaedingi. The June 1968 POBSP survey found about ten fully feathered chick mummies on Islote Afuera (presum- ably birds of the winter breeding population). Only one of these had a dark rump. All previously col- lected winter birds were white-rumped. The conditions that cause two or more popula- tions of the same species, or of different species, to utilize the same geographical area for nesting at different times of year appear to be the presence of vast uniform feeding grounds, coupled with very limited land space for breeding. Much the same NUMBER 158 175 100 90- 80 70 60- c » 50- £. 40- 30- 20- 10- New YZAGr I I Old olting Non-molting FICURE 106.—Seasonal molt stages in Oceanodroma leucorhoa socorroensis. (See Figure 99 for explanation of symbols.) situation occurs at islands across the equatorial Pacific where two or more colonies of the same species breed on the same island at different times of the year. This is most noticeable in the Phoenix and Line groups with the Sooty Terns (Sterna fuscata) because the colonies are exceedingly large. However, species that are found breeding all months of the year, yet with a known changeover of marked individuals (such as the White Tern, Gygis alba) must be doing the same thing, only in a less dramatic way. How these species arrive at such "shift-work" utilization of an island is little known, but the factors bringing about such a situa- tion are obvious. Aside from a shortage of actual physical space on these small islands, and the pos- sibility of insufficient food in the surrounding wa- ters to support the entire population at any one time of year, the social stresses between individuals would prohibit reproduction if all birds were to occupy the same area at one time. MOLT.—Our samples, except for late summer, are too small and disjunct in regard to time of year to be especially meaningful. Data are graphically demonstrated in Figure 106. For the most part, molt sequence closely parallels that of O. I. beali. PREDATION.—Aside from the ever-present danger to storm petrels posed by the Western Gull' (Larus occidentalis) (primarily avoided by the strictly noc- turnal habits of the hydrobatids), Burrowing Owls (Speolyto cunicularia) appeared to be the greatest threat to these small Procellariiformes. In order to study predation, numerous remains of owl-eaten storm petrels were collected on Islote Negro during the April 1968 survey and again during the June 1968 visit. Although little of quantitative value can be determined from this study because of the wind- scattered remains, etc., predation was considerable. In April 1967 a downy young storm petrel was found, partially eaten, at the end of a burrow, indi- cating the possibility that the small owls may enter occupied storm petrel burrows and attack the young. At least one pair of owls each were noted on 176 130'V 120 110 100 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 90° 80° 130° 120 110° 100° 90° 80° FIGURE 107.—POBSP s ightings of Oceanodroma homochroa. Islote Negro and Islote Afuera. During June 1968 the owls were largely feeding upon downy young Xantus' Murrelets (Endomychura hypoleuca), which were hatching in great numbers and trying to make their way to water. Oceanodroma homochroa (Coues) ASHY STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The POBSP records of this species are few, with low numbers of scattered sightings from ca. 7°N to 47°N; all sightings are along the western North American coast (Figure 107). The most pelagic sightings are of two birds near 13°N about 480 miles from the coast. The only concentration we recorded was off the Baja California coast between 28°N and 29°N during August 1967. Uncertainty concerning the pelagic range of this species results primarily from difficulties in sep- NUMBER 158 177 arating it in the field from closely similar dark- rumped Oceanodroma leucorhoa races such as O. I. chapmani, O. I. socorroensis and O. I. willetti (— O. I. beali). It probably occurs in rather low numbers compared with its closely allied forms. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—A POBSP survey around San Miguel Island in the Channel Islands off the Cali- fornia coast 14 and 15 May 1968, found small num- bers of birds on both Castle Rock and Prince Islet, all in empty nest cavities in rock crevices among a colony of Cassin's Auklets. Flight calls of the storm petrels were heard shortly after full dark, but it was impossible to make an estimate of the population size because of the din of surf and calling auklets. The few birds examined at this time had bare or defeathering brood patches. On another survey of San Miguel from 28 May to 7 June 1968, birds were still courting; one egg each was found on Castle Rock and Prince Islet. The maximum estimate at that time was 100 birds for the San Miguel population. A bright moon at the time seemed to retard the arrival of the birds on the islets and reduced their activity. Perhaps the Western Gulls take advantage of the moonlight to prey upon these petrels as the Great Black-backed Gulls (Larus marinus) and Herring Gulls (L. argen- tatus) prey upon Leach's Petrels in the Bay of Fundy (Gross, 1935). Gross notes that on moonlit nights very little storm petrel activity occurs. In the Coronados Islands Joseph Jehl of the San Diego Natural History Museum collected a few Ashy Storm Petrels in a mist net on Center Island the night of 17 May 1968, but POBSP recorded none during a 30 June to 1 July 1968 visit. No evidence of nesting was found on either visit; apparently very few individuals utilize the Coronados. Orr (1944) gives an excellent summary of what little is known of the breeding biology of this species along the California coast. From a series of 20 birds collected at San Miguel Island, two show considerable amounts of whitish feathers at the sides of the rumps. This is interest- ing, not only from the standpoint of the relation- ship of homochroa to leucorhoa, but from the fact that selection for dark rumps seem to have affected all hydrobatid forms along the middle western North American coast (an area of excessively high gull predation?). Oceanodroma castro (Harcourt) HARCOURT'S (or MADEIRAN) STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The pelagic range of Harcourt's Storm Petrel in the Pacific is rather ex- tensive, as indicated in Figures 108 and 109. The sightings recorded probably represent only a small fraction of the actual birds seen, as those shown represent only sightings considered positive. The more extensively white rump of Harcourt's as op- posed to Leach's could often be used to separate these two forms at close range, but undoubtedly the majority of birds of this species were recorded by POBSP personnel only as "unidentified white- rumped storm petrel." Despite the difficulty of dis- tinguishing Harcourt's from other white-rumped forms (especially Leach's and Wilson's), specimens of Harcourt's collected at various points through- out the pelagic range lend credibility to the obser- vations. In the central Pacific birds were recorded com- monly south and southwest of the Hawaiian Is- lands to 4°S, with one sighting south of 8°S. Birds were also common to the west and northwest of the Hawaiian Islands and it is likely that the species ranges beyond the boundaries shown in the north- west sector as birds were observed practically to the limits of POBSP cruises in that area. Although it can- not be determined from the collected specimens, central Pacific records probably represent birds from the Hawaiian population (dubiously distinc- tive O. c. cryptoleucura). Harcourt's distribution in the eastern Pacific is even more extensive than that recorded in the cen- tral Pacific. Sightings were recorded from near Panama west to 120°W and from 25°N to south of 13°S. While it might be logical to assume that east- ern Pacific records are attributable to the Gala- pagos Islands population, we cannot, in fact, assign origin to them. The species obviously ranges so widely at sea that sightings at any point could be of birds from any one of the Pacific breeding sta- tions. Three specimens taken near the Galapagos are most probably referable to the breeding race of that island group (O. c. "bangsi"), but as Austin (1952) demonstrates, none of the named Pacific sub- species of this form are separable. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—The available breeding data for this species are summarized by Palmer (1962). The POBSP was unable to add further information of its breeding status in the Hawaiian Islands. NUMBER 158 179 130 W • 1 bird • 5 birds O Specimens collected 20 130° 120° 110° 100° 90° 80° FIGURE 109.—I»OBSP sightings and specimens of Oceanodroma castro in the eastern Pacific. court's Storm Petrel during a day of collecting on 25 June 1966 just off Kauai Island near the Waimea Canyon area, where I saw a considerable number of birds and collected one specimen, a female with ovary enlarging, but not yet in breeding condition. Birds appeared to be both going to and leaving the island throughout the day, but we could not ap- proach the shoreline closely enough to determine if the birds went to land. The population on Kauai, as judged by the number of specimens and sight- ings, cannot be large. MOLT.—The data from the ten specimens col- lected by POBSP are given in Figure 110. Briefly, our May and June birds collected in the central Pacific, as well as March birds collected near the Galapagos, are in new plumage without molt except for ter- minal stages in the rectrices of the May birds. Octo- ber and November central Pacific birds are in inter- mediate primary and body molt with very worn, but unmolting, rectrices. Oddly enough, a Gala- pagos bird collected in late July is in exactly the same stage of primary molt as two November speci- mens from the central Pacific. Oceanodroma tethys (Bonaparte) GALAPAGOS STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The Galapagos Storm 20 130° 120° 110° 100° 90° 80° FIGURE 109.—I»OBSP sightings and specimens of Oceanodroma castro in the eastern Pacific. court's Storm Petrel during a day of collecting on 25 June 1966 just off Kauai Island near the Waimea Canyon area, where I saw a considerable number of birds and collected one specimen, a female with ovary enlarging, but not yet in breeding condition. Birds appeared to be both going to and leaving the island throughout the day, but we could not ap- proach the shoreline closely enough to determine if the birds went to land. The population on Kauai, as judged by the number of specimens and sight- ings, cannot be large. MOLT.—The data from the ten specimens col- lected by POBSP are given in Figure 110. Briefly, our May and June birds collected in the central Pacific, as well as March birds collected near the Galapagos, are in new plumage without molt except for ter- minal stages in the rectrices of the May birds. Octo- ber and November central Pacific birds are in inter- mediate primary and body molt with very worn, but unmolting, rectrices. Oddly enough, a Gala- pagos bird collected in late July is in exactly the same stage of primary molt as two November speci- mens from the central Pacific. Oceanodroma tethys (Bonaparte) GALAPAGOS STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The Galapagos Storm 180 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY October - November N--3 New 1223Growing L .J Old 1H3 Molting on-molting FIGURE 110.—Seasonal molt stages in Oceanodroma castro. (See Figure 99 for explanation of symbols.) Petrel is one of the few white-rumped species in the Pacific that can be identified with a fair degree of certainty under most field conditions. The ex- tremely large, prominent, wedge-shaped white rump, and alternately fluttering and bouncy flight are good characters for distinguishing most individ- uals from Oceanodroma lencorhoa, the species reg- ularly recorded with O. tethys over much of the latter's pelagic range. When I first encountered tethys at sea, and l>efore I learned some of its more subtle characters, I had difficulty making on-the- spot distinctions between it and equally small, ex- ceptionally white-rumped O. I. socorroensis. Part of this difficulty arose from the fact that both forms were in extremely ragged plumage at the time. It may be noted that specimens of both races of O. tethys had medium-gray oil (uropygial) glands, as opposed to the creamy white oil glands of all races of O. leucorhoa and of O. castro. Supposedly, the nominate race (O. /. tethys) breeds in the Galapagos from April through Sep- tember^). The POBSP pelagic specimens of this race are confined to August 1967 and March and April 1968. During the latter period concentrations were especially prominent in a broad band along the equator from about 3°N to 2°S between longitudes 97°W and 105°W. August specimens were taken at 12°N, 120°W. A June specimen in the San Diego Natural History Museum was taken at 15°N, 101 °W. Huey (1952) reports a specimen taken by J. R. Pemberton in March 1938 at Roca Partida in the Revilla Gigedo Islands south-southwest of Baja NUMBER 15* 181 130° W 120 1.01 + Specimens collected O. tethys tethys • lb ird • 5 birds O. tethys kelsctlli ¥• 120 110 100 90 FIGURE 111.—I*>BSP sightings and specimens of Oceanodroma tethys. 80 70 California (ca. 19°N). In this same publication Huey reports a male of this race in nonbreeding condition (testes 3 x 2 mm) taken from a colony of Oceanodroma leucorhoa kaedingi on Guadalupe Island off Baja California in January 1950. The bird was found in a nest cavity with a downy young kaedingi. For whatever reason the bird came to the island, Hubbs (1960) is incorrect in regarding this as constituting a breeding record for the Galapagos Storm Petrel at Guadalupe. I have examined this specimen at San Diego and, except for a short, heavy bill and slightly small wing for O. t. tethys, it corresponds well to that form. This locality, at roughly 29°N, apparently marks the northern limit for the nominate race. The second-named form of this species, O. tethys kelsalli (Lowe), breeds on the Pescadores and San Gallan Islands off the coast of Peru. Northernmost POBSP records of this race are of two individuals collected on 6 August 1967 at 23°03'N, 118°24'W. Moffitt (1938) reports 12 specimens collected at 22°30'N, 112°39'W on 22 July 1905 and another specimen taken at 16°45'N, 110°28'W on 22 Sep- tember 1933. These birds had traversed northward through most of the recorded pelagic range of the nominate race. Our pelagic sight records (Figure SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Primary Rectrix 1 March-2 April N=36 Body Primary Rectrix 11 August Body New E22 Growing C H Old I Molting FIGURE 112.—Seasonal molt stages in Oceanodroma tethys tethys. (See Figure 99 for explanation of symbols.) I l l) cannot be qualified to race as the two named forms are separable only on mensural differences. The pelagic ranges of the two races show consid- erable sympatry. Other POBSP specimens of O. /. kelsalli were col- lected in the Gulf of Panama during August 1968 and June and August 1969. Large numbers of O. tethys were observed in the gulf from August through November 1968 and June through August 1969. Although only a relatively few specimens were collected, all are definitely referable to O. t. kelsalli. On this basis, it is reasonable to assume that most Gulf of Panama wintering O. tethys are of the race kelsalli. From November on, tethys is absent from the Panama gulf waters, when it is ap- parently replaced by the Black Storm Petrel and the Least Storm Petrel. MOLT.—Considerable variation in molt is dis- played in two series of O. t. tethys collected at sea. A series of 36 taken between 1 March and 2 April falls essentially into two categories: 1. Molting: As shown in Figure 112, 44 percent of the birds in this sample are molting in both pri- maries and rectrices. There was no exact correlation in the progress of molt between these two plumage areas. A few birds still molting the primaries had completed their rectrix molt and vice versa. Hence, although only 44 percent of the sample is involved in each case, the total number of individuals con- cerned in these combined categories equaled 50 percent of the sample. In practically every case, pri- mary and/or rectrix molt was accompanied by body molt. 2. Nonmolting: The remainder of the sample NUMBER 158 183 (50%) not in primary or rectrix molt, was, for the most part, in old, but relatively unworn plumage, indicating that molt had occurred within the previ- ous few months. Definition of plumage condition in rectrices or remiges of birds not in molt is some- what subjective. When molting, a distinction is easily made between new and old feathers, pri- marily because the feathers being replaced are obvi- ously old and show considerable wear and discolor- ation. The majority of birds in both molting and non- molting categories were adults, judging by gonadal condition. None was in breeding condition, al- though several may well be considered either to have begun gonadal enlargement or retrogression. The nominate race of O. tethys is supposed to have a complete postbreeding molt from July through October (Murphy, 1936:730). It appears from our sample that the duration of the molt cycle is much more extensive. If tethys has a molt cycle similar to races of O. leucorhoa, a large number of birds would be expected to terminate a molt just prior to the advent of a breeding cycle. The small series of five birds collected in August are all in finishing stages of complete molt, or in very new plumage. A combination of immatures and adults is represented, judging by gonads. This series substantiates Murphy's (1936:730) statement concerning a postbreeding molt from July through October, but half of the large series taken in March and April certainly do not correspond to this pat- tern. Obviously we need to know the ages and times of breeding cycles of individual birds before it will be possible to draw conclusions concerning the molt cycle of the species. Oceanodroma hornbyi (Gray) HORNBY'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The few POBSP records of sightings and specimens of this southern hemi- sphere hydrobatid were recorded in August 1967 in the Peru Current southeast of the Galapagos Is- lands along the South American coast (Figure 113). Three specimens taken at 3°38'S, 87°01'W were adult females with medium fat, ovaries between 3 and 5 mm, granular. I have no data for a fourth specimen taken south of the above area at 9°29'S, 82°05'W. Murphy (1936:741-743) limits the species to the Peru Current roughly between Valparaiso, Chile, and the equator. The breeding grounds of O. hornbyi are still im- precisely known, but Johnson (1965:108) cites four points of evidence that strongly indicate it nests inland along the Chilean and Peruvian coasts. These are summarized as follows: (1) In 1894, Dr. Darapsky found a fully grown immature specimen (with patches of down still adhering) in a hole in the hills of the coast ranges of the port of Taltal, in the southern Antofagasta Province (specimen in the National Museum of Santiago). (2) In 1923, Wetzel found mummified nestlings in holes in the canyon of the Loa River at the point where it crosses the nitrate desert inland from Tocopilla. (3) Another mummified specimen was found in De- cember 1923 in the nitrate fields of Santa Luisa de Taltal, 30 miles from the coast at an altitude of 5000 feet. (4) The Koepckes took several specimens at night in the streets of Lima, Peru. Some of these had abundant down patches on the abdomen. Oceanodroma melania (Bonaparte) BLACK STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—Abundant observations of this species were made on POBSP cruises along the western American coast from about 38°N to the equator. Sightings below the equator (to 7°S) were few, as were those in the extreme northern sector and at extreme distances from the coast (Figure 114). There was a pronounced movement into the Gulf of Panama during November, which presum- ably indicates a southward movement after the breeding season. The species was common in the gulf area until June, during which time the Least Storm Petrel was also abundant. Most sightings along the California coast are summer records, but a few birds were recorded above 34 °N in Decem- ber. At sea the Black Storm Petrel is a swift flyer. During collecting activities off the Baja California coast, the birds appeared to have no problem in outdistancing our skiff, which was moving at an estimated 25 knots. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—Coronados Islands: During a POBSP survey on 1 and 2 May 1968, Black Storm Petrels began coming in over the cove on North Island precisely at full dark. Their appearance was in exact correlation with the termination of West- ern Gull movements and one may be certain that 184 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 100 W 80° 20' N ltf 10' S 20' 70° . 20 • lbird O specimen collected 100 90 FIGURE 113.—POBSP sightings and specimens of Oceanodroma hornbyi. the timing of these activities is not coincidental. Storm petrel aerial movements and vocalizations were most intense during the first few hours after dark and had essentially stopped by midnight. An increase in flying birds was noted near the beach at about 0100; this possibly represented birds leaving the island. Two characteristic calls were noted: an aerial call described by most field workers as "puck, puckaroo," and a variable "twitter" uttered only from nest cavities. This latter call may continue for many minutes. The nest sites on North Island were invariably in deep recesses under large boulders NUMBER 158 185 130 W • 1 bird • 10 birds • 20 birds f Breeding localiti 110" 100° 90° FICURE 114.—POBSP sightings of Oceanodroma melania. that prevented investigating the nests in most cases. A few such large "fortresses" harbored more than one pair. The four to six nests that could be exam- ined at this time contained both members of the pair, but none had eggs or young. Individuals taken in a mist net had bare or defeathering brood patches. During a visit on 30 June 1968, a few birds were noted on Center Island and a chick, estimated to be only a few days old, was found on North Is- land. In the San Diego Natural History Museum a series of downy nestlings, ranging in size from small to large, are recorded from the Coronados from 13 August to 5 September. San Benitos Islands: On a POBSP survey from 26 to 29 April 1968, these petrels were noted coming in over the islands at night, with a peak of aerial movements and vocalizations during the first three hours of darkness. Little activity was noted for the remainder of the night. No evidence of nesting was recorded at that time. During a survey from 25 to 27 June 1968, a sample of nest sites examined showed that birds were on fresh- to medium-incu- bated eggs, with a few individuals still calling from as yet empty nest cavities. The preferred nesting sites of this species seemed to be under large boul- ders on talus slopes. In some cases Least Storm 186 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY Petrels were found nesting in the same burrows with the Blacks. The Black Storm Petrels were found on all three islands in the San Benitos group, with greatest densities on West Island. A popula- tion estimate for the island group at that time was 10,000+ birds. A prime mortality factor was the abundant cholla cacti throughout the nesting area. Birds flying about in the dark were often impaled upon the spines; on one slope several Black Storm Petrels were found dead in this manner (see com- parable data on Oceanodroma leucorhoa chap- mani). 120 W ' 1 bird • 5 birds • 10 birds O specimen collected 20 120 20 110 100' 70° FIGURE 115.—POBSP sightings and specimens of Oceanodroma markhami. NUMBER 158 187 Oceanodroma markhami (Salvin) MARKHAM'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—Most POBSP pelagic sightings of this species are in August and Septem- ber along a broad equatorial front from the South American coast west through the Galapagos area to 105°W (Figure 115). A group of more northerly sightings off the coast of Baja California may well represent erroneous identifications attributable to the very similar Oceanodroma melania. I doubt if the two species can be distinguished in the field, and melania would certainly be the more expected form in these northern waters. It may be noted, however, that Murphy (1936:740) cites Loomis (1918:174) as having recorded markhami at 13° 28'N, 108°52'W, and just south of Cocos Island, 5°33'N, 87°00'W. Two specimens were collected by POBSP along the South American coast. Both in- dividuals taken on 6 August 1967 at 00°18'N, 81° 51'W were females with small gonads (and oviducts never used), light fat and heavy contour molt. The breeding grounds of this species are still un- known. Murphy (1936:739) records several females with fully formed eggs in the oviducts taken by Rollo Beck in early June, 75 to 80 kilometers off the Peruvian coast. He further states that the only islands off the Peruvian coast not thoroughly in- vestigated were the Hormigas de Afuera, which because of their exceedingly low elevation seemed a doubtful nesting site. He suggests the possibility of their nesting inland in the Andes. Johnson (1965:107) notes that Carlos Reed collected a speci- men on 1 December off Antofagasta, Chile (23°S) that still had traces of down on the head and ab- domen. He also records an immature specimen with abundant down on the breast and abdomen taken between Pica and Matilla, some 30 miles inland from the port of Iquique, Chile. Oceanodroma tristrami Salvin SOOTY STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The POBSP pelagic sight- ings of this species are from various positions around the Hawaiian Islands, with concentrations near the Hawaiian Leewards (breeding sites), as would be expected (Figure 116). A disjunct, high-density con- centration was also recorded between 44°N and 45°N near 173°W. The latter records may pertain to tristrami populations from the Bonin or Izu islands, or possibly to Oceanodroma matsudairae from the Bonin Islands. It is extremely doubtful if tristrami could be differentiated from O. matsu- dairae in the field. No specimens are available to clarify which of the two species were seen here, but even if specimens were available, distinctions could not be made between the Hawaiian and Bonin Is- land populations of O. tristrami. BREEDING BIOLOGY.—Sooty Storm Petrels have a disjunct breeding distribution, with populations at Torishima in the southern Izu Islands (Austin, 1952), the Bonin Islands, and the Hawaiian Lee- wards. The specific localities in the Leewards are Laysan, Pearl and Hermes Reef, and Midway. Rich- ardson (1957:19) mentions the possibility of their breeding on Necker but gives no details. Bryan and Green way (1944:96) record the species on Nihoa. Clapp and Woodward (1968:10) report recent POBSP records on Kure Atoll and French Frigate Shoals. The latter cite the collection of three speci- mens with definitely enlarged gonads on Kure (one each on 1 January 1964, 1 March 1965, and 12 De- cember 1965). The January 1964 bird was one of two observed digging a burrow. Two other birds were observed digging a burrow on 2 April 1964, and one examined in the field between 30 Decem- ber 1966 and 5 January 1967 had a completely bare brood patch. Others were seen on Kure between November and January during the years 1963 to 1967. Three specimens collected 1 to 3 January 1967 have greatly enlarged gonads. On 14 March 1967, one very small downy chick and another about three-quarters grown were found in shallow burrows under the grass on Whale-Skate Island, French Frigate Shoals. Amerson noted a fledgling here in early June 1967. I believe it very likely that the species will eventually be found nesting on Lisianski Island, which has an extensive habitat comparable to that which supports a sizable popu- lation on Laysan. From this latter island POBSP col- lected three specimens on 22 October 1966 with considerably enlarged gonads. Willett (1919) re- ports egg-laying on Laysan from 1 to 15 January. Inadequate POBSP winter surveys in the Leewards, plus the very secretive nature of this storm petrel on the breeding grounds, make it difficult to obtain a clear picture of the breeding cycle. From available data it appears that the species is to be found on 188 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO ZOOLOGY 170 E 180 170 W 160 150 40" N 30" 20 10 • 1 bird • 5 birds •10 birds ^f breeding localities 40 30 20 10" 170' 180* 170* 160' 150 FIGURE 116.—POBSP sightings of Oceanodroma tristrami. NUMBER 158 189 120 W 120 110 100 90 FIGURE 117.—POBSP sightings of Halocyptena microsoma. 70 the breeding grounds during an extended period from at least October to May. Apparently Decem- ber and January are peak egg-laying months; both young and adults are gone from the islands by mid- May. Halocyptena microsoma Coues LEAST STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—At sea this species is usually distinguishable from other dark-rumped forms by its tiny size. Although it is normally a more coastal form, it was sighted by the POBSP as far as 600 miles off the Mexican mainland. Large num- bers are found in the Gulf of Panama during the winter months (December to April). There appears to be replacement between this species and Oceano- droma tethys in the Gulf of Panama. Oceanodroma tethys is very abundant from June to November, but completely disappears in the latter month when H. microsoma begins showing up in numbers. A small number of Black Storm Petrels are, how- ever, present during the time the Least is abundant. Other than the concentrations in the Gulf of Pana- ma, the majority of POBSP sightings of the Least Storm Petrel was along the coast of Baja California and the Mexican mainland (Figure 117). BREEDING BIOLOGY.—The Least Storm Petrel breeds on the San Benitos Islands and on various other islands in the Gulf of California. During a POBSP survey of the San Benitos on 28 April 1968, the only Least noted was one that came aboard ship offshore. During the 25 to 27 June 1968 survey here, Leasts were abundant on all three islands of the group. Nesting was primarily restricted to rock outcrops and talus slopes, and nests were invariably in rock crevices. Occasionally more than one pair were found in suitable cavities and some birds were nesting in the same cavities with the much larger Black Storm Petrels. A few eggs of the Least were found, but most of the birds in June were still in early stages of nest site selection and courting. An 190 SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS 1O ZOOLOGY estimate for Halocyptena during the June survey was ca. 15,000 birds for the island group. As men- tioned in the sections on O. melania and O. I. chap- man i, Halocyptena were adversely affected by the abundant cholla cacti on the islands and several birds were found impaled on the spines. On islands in the Gulf of California, the Least Storm Petrel is frequently mentioned as nesting in association with the fishing bat (Pizonyx vivesi). Maya (1969), who studied this bat in the Gulf, felt that a lizard (Cnemidophorus sp.) preyed upon the young storm petrels and that the lizards were less prone to inhabit cavities where the bats lived. On Isla Partida (in the northern part of the Gulf of California) R. D. Ohmart (pers. comm.) saw no predation by the lizards on very small storm petrel chicks left unattended by their parents during the daytime. Once after removing an adult storm petrel from its nest, he saw a large scorpion carry away the egg. Ohmart did not feel that the presence of the bat offered any particular advantage to the pet- rel. It appeared to him that the Least and Black Storm Petrels and the fishing bat clumped to avoid excessive heat and gulls, and possibly to gain in relative humidity. Both eggs and small downy chicks of the Least Storm Petrel were found on Isla Partida from 12 to 21 June 1968. Nests were be- neath rocks on the ground or in cavities among rock piles. Oceanites oceanicus (Kuhl) WILSON'S STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The POBSP pelagic rec- ords indicate extremely widespread distribution of this species in the Pacific, with two decided centers of abundance (Figures 118 and 119). The equatorial central Pacific records are practically all confined to October and November; all are of adults with somewhat enlarged gonads and very heavy fat, and in all probability represent birds returning to the Antarctic breeding grounds. An April specimen from this area is probably a straggler from an ap- parent postbreeding migration that moves north through the Marshall Islands in the spring (Huber, 1971). Our surveys give no clue to northward extent of this movement, nor to the distribution or activi- ties of the birds between April and October. Large numbers are recorded in the Peru Current along the northwestern coast of South America dur- ing August. A fair number of stragglers are re- corded throughout the eastern Pacific to at least 31°N. In view of this, the various coastal California records in August (1910, 1935, and 1959) summar- ized by Nisbet and McCaskie (1960:141) seem not too unusual considering the species' wide dispersal. It should be emphasized that the POBSP sight rec- ords shown are only those of fairly positive nature; undoubtedly many more birds were observed which were recorded only as "unidentified white-rumped storm petrel." Oceanites gracilis (Elliot) GRACEFUL STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—Most POBSP sightings of this species were during September near the Gala- pagos Islands. Other cruises were run about the islands during other times of the year, especially March and April, and relatively few birds were seen. Most of our September sightings were within a hundred miles of the Galapagos (Figure 120). Loomis (1918:181) states that "they were never ob- served far from land, the greatest distance being about 50 nautical miles." Murphy (1936) has no record of its breeding, but it has been taken just offshore of several of the Galapagos Islands and un- questionably breeds there. The race O. g. galapagoensis obviously restricts itself to the cold waters of the Peru Current just to the west of the Galapagos. The nominate race O. g. gracilis appears to be restricted to the Peru Current between Valparaiso, Chile, and Santa Elena, Ecua- dor (Murphy, 1936). Fregetta grallaria (Vieillot) WHITE-BELLIED STORM PETREL PELAGIC DISTRIBUTION.—The primary distribu- tion of this species in the area covered by POBSP was along 85°W from 06°S to 15°S. Two scattered sightings were recorded at 09°45'S, 117°43'W, and 02°17'N, 104°W (Figure 121). Murphy (1936:762) recorded that R. Beck took a specimen of Fregetta grallaria titan at 04°20'S, NUMBER 158 191 50° N 170 E 170°W 160 ISO'o 50 40 20 10 • 1 bird • 5 birds O 1 specimen collected 40° 20 10 10 150°17