JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH, VOL. 109, E07005, doi:10.1029/2003JE002155, 2004 Aeolian sediment transport pathways and aerodynamics at troughs on Mars Mary C. Bourke' School of Geography and the Environment, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom Joanna E. Bullard Department of Geography, Loughborough University, Loughborough, United Kingdom Olivier S. Bamouin-Jha Applied Physics Laboratory, Johns Hopkins University, Laurel, Maryland, USA Received 14 July 2003; revised 4 February 2004; accepted 2 April 2004; published 13 July 2004. [i] Interaction between wind regimes and topography can give rise to complex suites of aeolian landforms. This paper considers aeolian sediment associated with troughs on Mars and identifies a wider range of deposit types than has previously been documented. These include wind streaks, falling dunes, "lateral" dunes, barchan dunes, linear dunes, transverse ridges, sand ramps, climbing dunes, sand streamers, and sand patches. The sediment incorporated into these deposits is supplied by wind streaks and ambient Planitia sources as well as originating within the trough itself, notably from the frough walls and floor. There is also transmission of sediment between dunes. The flow dynamics which account for the disfribution of aeolian sediment have been modeled using two-dimensional computational fluid dynamics. The model predicts flow separation on the upwind side of the trough followed by reattachment and acceleration at the downwind margin. The inferred patterns of sediment transport compare well with the distribution of aeolian forms. Model data indicate an increase of wind velocity by ~30% at the downwind trough margin. This suggests that the threshold wind speed necessary for sand mobilization on Mars will be more frequently met in these inclined locations. INDEX TERMS: 1815 Hydrology: Erosion and sedimentation; 1824 Hydrology: Geomorphology (1625); KEYWORDS: Trough, aeolian, dune, MOC, MOLA, computational fluid dynamic modeling Citation: Bourke, M. C, J. E. Bullard, and O. S. Bamouin-Jha (2004), Aeolian sediment transport pathways and aerodynamics at troughs on Mars, J. Geophys. Res., 109, E07005, doi:10.1029/2003JE002155. 1. Introduction associated with troughs and valleys on Mars, despite the .-,.???, ,. ^ ? ^ ? ,, . potential for significant infilling and burial of fluvial fea- [2] A sigmticant proportion o? the surtace oi Mars is i, ., <-, u ?* i/-^ ri,/ir^\- u ^u ai. '-^ , . ? ,. ,. ? r .? r . tures. Mars Orbital Camera (MOC) images snow that there IS covered m aeolian deposits. Surtace sediment trequently u A e ^ u A e 4. u {^ J, ,? ? , , , ? , J:- ^ , ? ? , an abundance o? transverse bed torms on trough iloors forms distinct morphological featoes such as mantles, wmd ^^^?.^ andEdgett, 2001] but other within-valley dune forms streaks, dunes and a variety ot sand sheet-like deposits , * u -J ^i- j A? n c ^u i * * r? , ,, ,??, X,, , ,???, .?, , have not been identitied. Valleys on Earth are known to act \ureetey andIversen, ?9o5; Ihomas et at., 1999\. Aimough , ., J- <. ? j i- u rr , mo^ ? , ,; , ,. , ,? ,. -, \, , , both as sediment sources in dune iields \Lancaster, 19?6; wmd-erodible sediment potentially exists over the whole ,^ ,, ? , ?, ,. ,noT ur ^e\o^^ A ? * , ^ ,, . ,,?_?-, ? ? , , Mabbutt and Wooding, 1983; Wasson, 19?41 and as inter- planet, the mai or concentration 01 dunes IS in vast sand seas , " ? i " ui i ? * *? A- * iu r^y ^^ \ -1 ? i:?^o,^/^/^,^, 2 ccptors Or siuks blockmg or truncating sediment path- 01 the northern hemisphere covering an area ot 680,000 km , ? ^ A- ^t. i. ^ A ,. ? , ? \ i^^^n T? 1 1 ? ways. In previous studies, the approach to determine [Lancaster and Greeley, 1990]. Elsewhere, they occur m ^^^.^^^^ ^^ ^^^ ^^^ ^^^ ^.^^ ^^^ ^^^^ local concentrations oiten trapped by topographic teatures i u i ? i r^ J , ; inam T7 ^ A- I, r? , , , ,^o^ .? 1- 1 i^^m T. ? global m scale ?Anderson et at., 1999]. Few studies have [Greeley and Iversen, 1985; Malm et al., 1998]. It is ? A ^u t A^ I TU . ^^ ^ ,,,,,, , ? , . ? , locused on the landiorm scale. There are some exceptions, important to understand the extent to which geological , ,, i *i, * u -A 4.-c A * A C ^A A- . ^ J, , r, ? , ,? -, ,, , , , notably work that has identiiied crater dune iields as sedi- signatures oi past tluvial activity on Mars have been mod- , r j^irirj,, inm ZTJ ^, J ?J- 1 rr, , , ,, , , ^?? r 1- i:- mcut sourccs tor wind streaks [Edgett, 2002; Edgett and itied. To date, there has been little locus on aeolian teatures ,^ ,. r.^?^r, T? . ; mon *i, ? ^- c c Mahn, 2000; Thomas et ai, 1981], the association ot sen- like features with the elongation of barchan horns [Lee and ?-, Thomas, 1995 ; Tsoar et al., 1979] and links between barchan Now at Planetary Science Institute, Tucson, Arizona, USA. ., . ? n t. j. vr^ ^ ^ i '^r\r\-^-i ' and transverse dunes m Proctor crater [/^e?to? ei a/., 2003]. Copynght 2004 by the American Geophysical Union. t^] Topography affects both wind velocity and direction. 0l48-0227/04/2003JE002l55$09.00 Sediment transport and erosion may increase as wind veloc- E07005 1 of 16 E07005 BOURKE ET AL.: SEDIMENT TRANSPORT AND AERODYNAMICS ON MARS E07005 ities increase on the windward side of topographic features such as hills and valleys [Greeley et al, 2002] while zones of flow separation on the downwind side may be areas of preferential deposition [Wiggs et ai, 2002]. Wind flow patterns predicted by general circulation models for Mars and Earth generally correlate with the location and orienta- tion of aeolian deposits [Anderson et al., 1999; Blumberg and Greeley, 1996]. Research on the interactions between synoptic-scale wind flow and trough topography on Earth suggests that the presence of troughs will initiate not only a within-trough wind regime, but also may affect the strength and orientation of wind on the adjacent surface [Bullard et al, 2000; Slerputowski et al, 1995]. This, in turn, may affect the location of aeolian deposits [Wiggs et al, 2002]. [4] We use the term trough to include all linear negative relief topography. The results reported here are valid for fluvial valleys, Chaos regions, Chasma etc., and are partly applicable to escarpments. However, the specific geological history will determine the sediment type and availability, which in turn will influence the potential assemblage of aeolian forms. Another influence will be the presence of niveo-aeolian deposits. In polar deserts on Earth, sand dunes may have permafrost cores and/or contain sand layers inter- bedded with snow and ice [Calkin and Rutford, 1974; McKenna Neumann, 2004; Steidtmann, 1973]. We are investigating the potential for niveo-aeolian dune deposits on Mars in ongoing research [e.g., Bourke et al, 2004]. [5] This paper focuses on the interaction between trough topography and aeolian sediment on Mars. Using detailed observations from narrow and wide-angle MOC images of troughs in Syrtis Major (and elsewhere), the effects of the interaction between regional-scale wind patterns and trough topography on aeolian depositional forms are described. We highlight the range of dunes found within the trough, suggest potential sediment sources and consider the role of the trough as a temporary sediment sink and/or store. Using work that has been undertaken on valley-wind interaction on Earth [Wiggs et al, 2002], a preliminary 2-D model is developed to investigate similar interactions under Martian conditions. We suggest that, through its impact on aeolian sediment transport pathways, the trough provides an important link (source/sink) for exchange of sediment between different aeolian forms and different parts of the surface. A conceptual model is presented illustrating the sediment transport continuum between the trough and the aeolian features both within and adjacent to it. 2. Study Area [6] Syrtis Major is one of the most prominent Early Hesperian (~3.6 Gy) volcanic complexes on Mars. The gently sloping (~0.13?) lava plains are estimated to be between 0.5 and 1 km thick [Hiesinger and Head, 2004]. Syrtis Major is a low-albedo (0.15) and high thermal inertia (average 312.53 J m~^ K~' s~''^) [Fergason and Christensen, 2002] region on Mars. Recent Thermal Emis- sion Spectrometer (TES) data indicate the northern region of Syrtis Major to be predominantly basaltic [Bandfield et al, 2000], specifically comprising feldspar and high calcium Pyroxene [Mustard and Cooper, 2002]. The principal surface types of the region include the following terrain components: old cratered, knobby, locally grooved, etched. pitted, polygonal terrain in craters, cratered and smooth terrain superimposed with dunes [Hiesinger and Head, 2004]. [7] At a regional scale, Syrtis Major is dominated by easterly winds. This is inferred from the orientation of wind streaks which are aligned between 260? and 280? (Figure 1). Amus Vallis, located in northern Syrtis Major, is a sinuous, slot-like trough (Figures 1-3). It has a northeast- southwest orientation and crosses the east to west aeolian sediment transport path, as indicate by wind streak direc- tion. Amus Vallis is 200 km long and centered on 14.1?N 289.5?W sloping gently down to the north (Figure 4b). Other significant regional features include impact craters, troughs, wrinkle ridges, lava flow fronts and dark and bright wind streaks (Figure 1). The origin of the trough is unknown; however proximity to the Nili Patera caldera to the south suggests that it is likely to be a lava channel. A series of (sub) horizontal beds exposed in the trough wall may be lava deposits. The presence of an inner channel (Figure 3) suggests that Amus Vallis may have been subject to low-viscosity fluid erosion, perhaps water released through geothermal activity. 3. Results 3.1. Trough Morphometry [8] The MOC and MOLA data indicate that the trough has an average width of 775 m and a relative depth of ~90 m. The high-resolution MOC images show the trough to be sinuous, with well-developed convex and concave bends (Figure 3). The absence of craters on the trough floor indicates that it may be significantly younger than the surrounding Planitia surface on which a number of degraded craters are visible, although, craters may have been buried by trough floor aggradation. The MOLA profile indicates a sharp break of slope between the trough and Planitia surface that is sufficient to initiate flow separation at the upwind trough wall (Figure 4d). 3.2. Aeolian Deposits on the Planitia Surface [9] We have based our observations primarily on a high- resolution (2.95 m/pixel) MOC image that reveals a 4.6 km length of Amus Vallis in Syrtis Major (Figure 3). Two types of aeolian deposits are identified on the Planitia surface, wind streaks and drift deposits, and are described below. 3.2.1. Wind Streaks [10] Wind streaks are identified by variations in albedo and take the form of dark, bright and mixed tone streaks that generally form in association with topographic obstacles such as troughs and craters [Thomas et al, 1981]. In Figure 1, a series of bright and dark albedo markings extend from positive and negative topographic features (craters, ridges, and troughs). The east to west trend of these wind streaks (270?) correlates with global climate model predic- tions of regional wind directions [Greeley et al, 1992]. Using the classification of Thomas et al [1981], the streaks are identified as type I bright (b) and dark (d) wind streaks and are parallel and fan-shaped. Type I (d) streaks occur on the outer margins of approximately 30% of the bright streaks in Figure 1. High-albedo markings have been interpreted as global dust storm fallout deposits in protected wind-shadow zones [e.g., Veverka etal, 1981]. Dark albedo 2 of 16 E07005 BOURKE ET AL.: SEDIMENT TRANSPORT AND AERODYNAMICS ON MARS E07005 Figure 1. Amosaic of MOC wide-angle images: (bottom) E16-01895,12.3?N, 290.12?W, 259.9 m/pixel, (middle) E16-00806, 14.17?N, 289.2rw, 261.13 m/pixel, and (top) E16-00279, 15.28?N, 288.75?W, 261.42 m/pixel. Amus Vallis extends from the lower left. The location of MOC narrow-angle images (see Figure 2) is also shown. Arrows indicate examples where dark (black arrow) and bright (white arrow) streaks extend from trough; j: wind streak crosses trough; k: wind streak extending from crater does not appear to cross trough. 3 of 16 E07005 BOURKE ET AL.: SEDIMENT TRANSPORT AND AERODYNAMICS ON MARS E07005 markings can form by the deposition or erosion of sediment [Edgett, 2002; Thomas et al, 1981]. Both bright and dark albedo markings feed into and extend from Amus Vallis (Figures 1 and 2). On the downwind side the bright streaks are similar to the coalesced individual bright streaks reported by Thomas et al. [1981]. The dark areas extending from the trough are assumed to be coalesced dark wind streaks. Dark streaks emanating from troughs have not previously been reported. We suggest that the classification of Thomas et al [1981] be expanded to include these dark albedo features (Type II (d)). Most of the bright and dark albedo markings are discontinuous across the trough (Figure 1) suggesting a change in streak composition. The details of the relatively high-albedo markings are seen on the MOC image (e.g., Figure 3) and are identified as drift deposits. Some low-albedo areas are also depositional (see Figure 2 a). 3.2.2. Drift Deposits [n] Drift deposits are accumulations of wind blown particles not organized into bed forms [Greeley et al, 2002]. The relatively high-albedo area on the downwind side of Amus Vallis (Figure 3) appears to be a thin, discontinuous, sediment sheet and the dark albedo area upwind appears devoid of (relatively high-albedo) sediment at this resolution. The intensity of brightness on the down- wind trough margin varies (Figure 3), and areas with higher albedo are inferred to be concentrations of aeolian sediment. We infer two types: sand patches and sand streamers (Figure 3). Sand patches are irregularly shaped areas, the largest measuring 1.7 km^. Some appear to be trapped in topographic lows such as degraded impact craters (Figure 3). Sand streamers are narrow, slightly sinuous and sometimes discontinuous. They have an average width of 12 m and are of variable length (100-400 m). The two types of deposit appear to be linked and streamers frequently feed into and extend from patches. Lancaster [1996] suggests that sand patches are initiated in a zone of spatially and temporally fluctuating winds and disperse as surface roughness increases and sand supply is reduced. [12] We do not know the thickness of sand streamers on Mars but suggest that they are thin. On Earth, a 7 km long, 0.5 km wide streamer has a maximum depth of 2.5 m [Schaber and Breed, 1999], and smaller ones are known to Figure 2. Subset of MOC narrow-angle images showing sections of Amus Vallis (for location, see Figure 1). From north to south: (a) E16-00278, 15.3TN, 289.15?W, 4.67 m/pixel, (b) E22-01045, 14.69?N, 289.4rW, 6.2 m/ pixel, (c) El 1-00553, 14.37?N, 289.44?W, 6.21 m/pixel, (d) E16-00805, 14.9?N, 289.61?W, 4.66 m/pixel, (e) M03- 07414, 13.97?N, 289.97?W, 2.94 m/pixel, (f) E23-01150, 13.5?N, 290.012?W, 4.65 m/pixel, (g) same as Figure 2f, (h) E18-01455, 12.98?N, 290.08?W, 6.2 m/pixel, and (i) E16-01845, 12.32?N, 290.51?W, 6.19 m/pixel. The lateral dune is visible on the east side of Amus Vallis in all images. The dune is estimated to extend continuously >165 km. Small-scale (500-800 m wide) low-albedo streaks extend westward from the trough. Many are associated with cross-trough extensions of the lateral dune (dark arrows). This illustrates a cross-trough sediment transport pathway from the lateral dune to the dark depositional streaks. 4 of 16 E07005 BOURKE ET AL.: SEDIMENT TRANSPORT AND AERODYNAMICS ON MARS E07005 Figure 3. Geomoiphic map of aeolian features and MOC image of Amus Vallis (for location, see Figures 1 and 2e). (a) A large lateral dune extends along the eastern trough wall, (b) Transverse aeolian ridges are aligned along the trough floor, and (c) hypothesized sand ramps climb up the western trough wall, (d) Drift deposits: (i) sand streamers and (ii) sand patches. White arrow indicates western margin of an inner channel, the eastern boundary of which is buried by the lateral dune. Note the contrasting albedo on the east and west of the trough. MOC image (M03-07414), 13.97?N, 289.97?W, 2.95 m/pixel. be significantly thinner. On Earth, sinuous sand streamers have been described as areas where through?ow dominates over accumulation and are consequently areas of the highest rates of transport [Thomas, 1997]. The albedo of these streamers and patches is similar to the distal portion of some bright wind streaks and similar sediment texture and processes may be found in those locations. [n] Greeley et al. [2002] documented small-scale aeolian deposits at the Mars Pathfinder landing site (MPL). The features include small-scale (<5 m) dunes (whalebacks, transverse: barchan, barchanoid), normal ripples, megarip- ples and surface lag deposits. We do not have the resolution to determine the presence of these features at Amus Vallis, but it is possible that the patches and streamers we identify 5 of 16 E07005 BOURKE ET AL.: SEDIMENT TRANSPORT AND AERODYNAMICS ON MARS E07005 15.0 Distance (km) 0 10 20 30 40 50 70.0 70.2 70 4 70 6 70.8 71,0 Longitude 1400 c 1300 .O 1200 13 1100 ? 1000 LU 900 800 700 Orbit 19251 60 40 Distance (km) 1200-) 5 1100- LU 1000 -50 m i m Orbit 19251 B ' 1 1 1 1 r- f 70 65 60 Distance (l